Andrew Bauer

I stumbled over this sandwich shop after I had a craving for a hot sandwich and man did it not disappoint! I got a philly cheesesteak and it was honestly second to some I’ve had in Philadelphia! The team members were super welcoming and efficient in preparing the sandwiches. I’ll definitely be coming back for more!

Matthew Schermer

We stopped in here after a morning at the Children's Museum. The atmosphere leaves a little bit to be desired but the food more than makes up for it. We got the chopped cheese, South of the border and og BLT and all of them were excellent. They were very generous with the bacon on the OG BLT, the chipotle chicken had just the right amount of spice and the chopped cheese had a ton of flavor. It definitely felt like a New York deli. The service was friendly as well. They messed up my daughter's grilled cheese so they remade it really quick and even gave us the extra. We ate later and I couldn't even figure out what they messed up on. This place is definitely worth checking out.

Nicole Miller

This deli takes you back to the bodegas in New York! The food is excellent and the cooks take pride in fixing your meal how you want it. The employees are down to earth and don’t mind assisting you with your decisions! I also love the fresh ingredients and verify of chips and drinks! Stop by and get a taste of New York!

+1

Dave Donahue

Forgot to take a picture as the chopped cheese was so delicious, I didn’t think until it was gone. The workers were very nice, and wrapped my sandwich very securely to go with no leaks. I will definitely return!

Jay D

First time trying this place, and I always like me a good chopped cheese. This spot definitely did not disappoint! The cashier was cool when I ordered chill dude. I got the combo with fries, and everything here is made to order. My food came out hot and hit the spot for the money I spent. I’d for sure come back again real good chopped cheese, y’all. We got New York in Indianapolis with this one!

Carly Downs

The food is 10/10. They make it fresh, so it's hot when you get it and not sitting in a warmer. This is going to be my new favorite breakfast sandwich spot! Waffle fries were amazing too!! I've actually been wanting to try this place for so long but was hesitant because of the Boar's Head recall last year. Definitely don't let that stop you from trying this place!!! The food is safe to eat, the place is clean, and they have signage posted addressing the recall and their commitment to food safety. The employees were very patient, nice, and helpful. I can see why this place has great reviews! definitely will be back!

Haley Logan

I work a few blocks away, and there are not a ton of lunch options in this vicinity. I've fallen victim to paying door dash delivery fees in time of need because the thought of crossing over Fall Creek or braving Keystone during lunch hour terrifies me. Today I decided to walk over to the NY Gourmet Deli, and omgggg wish I'd done this sooner. The gentleman working the cabinet was so kind, greeted everyone who walked in, and answered my questions as a newbie. I settled on the OG BLT Combo, which comes with crinkle fries (they ask if you'd like seasoning salt added), and a canned drink. It cost about $14, and came with enough food for two meals. The food was so good, everything tasted fresh and I will be back!

Muted Xpressions

Bomb! That's what I have to say about this place, amazing. I don't think highly of too many places here in Indianapolis but I'll tell you one thing the chopped cheese sandwich and number 45 which is a chopped cheese mixed with a Philly cheese steak, can't miss. I usually like to try things when they are piping hot, fresh to order, the first time my husband went I was able to try it immediately and I knew that it was a banger. The second time he went, picked it up and brought it home, it was still warm. I love the wedges, and while I don't eat pork my husband enjoyed the hot Italian sandwich, his only wishes that there were more mayo. The bread was nice and soft and just flavorful overall.

+2

Sweets

Very clean and the services were great. The food was made to order and it was so delicious. I got loaded chicken fries and a grill cheese. I know what a combination but the grill cheese was for my son. But it was sooooo good.

coleman Hawkins

The double cheeseburger with bacon is 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 The restaurant is clean and everything is fresh. They aren't hiding anything. You can see them cook and the food is all in view. They don't advertise, just word of mouth. Trust me, It's Gooood!!!!!!! They'll be long lines soon.

+6

William Chesak

Such a great addition to the neighborhood. Friendly staff. They had a ton of orders coming in and were handling them well. Chip selection is legit, even some ones I have not seen before at other spots. Got a chopped cheese and Italian with tots. Great sandwiches that I’ll soon order again. Plenty of other options and all the Boar’s Head meat and cheese you can stand.

Zachariah Haske

This new location is right in our neighborhood and we are so excited to welcome them! They were kind when we walked in, gave us a menu to look at and take home. They mentioned they will have a phone line set up soon to call in orders ahead. Food was out quick, hot, fresh and super tasty! No tables or seating to wait at yet - but it didn’t take long. We will definitely be back soon!

+1

Kierra Santillan

Amazing service and delicious food made to order. We got the chopped cheese, Philly cheesesteak and loaded fries, and they all hit the spot! Only complaint— the lettuce and tomato were too sparse to taste on our sandwiches. Outside of that, we loved it and will definitely be returning!