Jude Jhons

I recommended this great Restaurant. Great flavors and fair costs considering the serving size. The dishes and employee courtesy were remarkable. Great cooking paired with unique menu selections. The menu items seem tasty before trying.

Beth Shelburne

Delicious, fresh, authentic, friendly and not too expensive. This spot in Harlem is a gem. SO much better than any other pizza in this area. This is true Neapolitan style pizza. *chef's kiss*

Maxine Gerardo

Great service and cute atmosphere. The pizza is amazing!!!!! Best pizza in harlem and possibly in the city. Wish they had liquor too though! Only beer and wine. Good wine though!

Anthony M

Fantastic spot in East Harlem! The space is super clean, the food quality is great, and the service is excellent. We had it on our list for a while, and we are very happy we finally went. 4 stagioni was absolutely delicious. Definitely will return!

Pablo Barajas

Fantastic spot in East Harlem! The space is super clean, the food quality is a solid 10/10, and the service is excellent. We had it on our list for a while, and we are very happy we finally went

Inga Marie

Delicious pizza, fantastic service & wonderful ambiance. Such a wonderful spot — our new go-to for delicious pizza and good vibes.

Syed Ashrafulla

The best pizza place in New York City. I recommend any of the pizzas. Don't change any of them. What you'll get is a Neapolitan pizza where the dough is light and chewy. There is enough sauce to get the full tomato and herb taste without overpowering. I suspect they are reducing and rehydrating to create the deeper tomato sweetness. The toppings are all very fresh and the right amount for each pizza. At this point I've had half of their pizzas and a calzone. All were excellent. Also make sure you peruse the beer menu. The price is justified; basically you're getting craft Italian beer.

Bandee YI

Great Italian food. It was my first time trying authentic Italian food and it was better than I thought. The good focuses on the natural flavor of ingredients, so you will taste what you see. In overall, it seems like not much of seasoning was used, which I liked. Not greasy, fresh and light flavor, so even I could finish one pizza by myself. You will not get tired of pizza. The dough was also really good. Chewy but not hard. If you are used to New York pizza style or salty food with lot of seasonings, this pizza could be bland to you, but I actually liked this kinds of style. I got Verdure with Soppierssata added. I really enjoyed it and recommend it!

+1

Danqing Wang

The pizza here is SO AMAZING. Their chocolate tartufo dessert is the most perfect blend of creamy gelato and chocolate crunch. I’d definitely be returning for more.

gigi jaime

From the pizzas to the service 10/10. Pizzas were amazing and the chickpeas salad really good. The spicy oil wasn’t spicy but that’s ok.

+9

Natalie

I’ve lived in Harlem for a few years now and I am so mad I didn’t try this place before. It was SO good. All the pizzas we tried were absolutely delicious and fresh. The service was quick (even when the place was packed) and we were surprised at how fast our pizzas came out. The Capricciosa and Aglio/olio were my favorite. We also shared a salad that was really good. Now that I know about this gem I will come back. The servers were really nice and the prices unbeatable.

+15

Andi Shahu

LOVED this place. The pizza was fantastic (much better than most neopolitan places in the US, though the pizzas are a bit more busy ingredient/topping-wise than your usual neopolitan pizza), had a great salad. I loved that they had a bunch of imported Italian beer, most of which I’d never even heard of before but was really fun to try. The tiramisu was amazing - tasted truly homemade with actual mascorpone, lady fingers, and the right amount of coffee and cocoa powder. And the lemon sorbetto was surprisingly great and came served in an actual lemon!! Will def go back. One of my favorite discoveries in NYC.

+1

Jack Lawson

Sottocasa is one of the best pizza places in all of NY. If you’re worried that a trip to Harlem is “too far” you should reconsider. It doesn’t matter what pizza you order, you will enjoy it. Everything is delicious! The staff are friendly, the vibe is lovely, and the food is delicious! They have an extensive craft beer list and the beer bottle come out in a bucket of ice. Overall it’s an incredible place and needs to be highlighted because it’s too good not to share with others! Will be back 100%

+25

Pizza unlike other pizza available. The Napoli - yum delish. Im in a manual wheelchair and they do everything to ensure I enjoy the evening.

pizza unlike other pizza available. The Napoli - yum delish. Im in a manual wheelchair and they do everything to ensure I enjoy the evening.

This is the best gluten free pizza I've had anywhere. I haven't been to Italy but have had GF pizza all over the US (SF, NYC, Chicago, Vegas) and this beats everything! \n\nAnd even more proo…

This is the best gluten free pizza I've had anywhere. I haven't been to Italy but have had GF pizza all over the US (SF, NYC, Chicago, Vegas) and this beats everything! \n\nAnd even more proof, m…

Absolutely delicious, and super fast pizza and service, at a beautiful location. I can't speak to any of the pizza's other than the Marinara here (only vegan option) but it was absolutely delicious…

Sottocasa continues to be our favorite neighborhood pizza spot. Incredibly friendly with pies that do not disappoint. Chewy, flavorful crusts with nice beers.\n\nOur favorites are the 4 Formaggi an…

Great Italian pizza and salads... other items as well.\nRelaxing environment.\nGood vibes.\nThe owners are AMAZING humans who actually CARE about delivering quality food and service.\nAND, they hav…

Great Italian pizza and salads... other items as well.\nRelaxing environment.\nGood vibes.\nThe owners are AMAZING humans who actually CARE about delivering quality food and service.\nAND, they hav…

I have been here with no reservation the place was pretty busy. The pizza is delicious . service is great too . And the restaurant look really nice. I will definitely return to this place

I have been here with no reservation the place was pretty busy. The pizza is delicious . Service is great too . And the restaurant look really nice. I will definitely return to this place

Soo good! Taste just like Italy!! Great place to bring your family. Fantastic service with a friendly and homey atmosphere.

This is a great little gem in Harlem serving up Neapolitan style pizza. Service is very quick and the interior is beautiful. Makes for an intimate night with friends or a romantic date. They have g…

Sottocasa is so delicious. Not only do they have fantastic pizza, but their drinks are great as well. I love Belgian beers and decided to try one of the specialty imported Italian ones. I was surpr…

We are a family of 4 that were super lucky to stumble on this gem in the heart of Harlem on the last night of our 5 day tour to New York. The food was excellent and the service super. The atmospher…

We are a family of 4 that were super lucky to stumble on this gem in the heart of Harlem on the last night of our 5 day tour to New York. The food was excellent and the service super. The atmospher…

This was real Italian pizza. I live in the UK so I do not have the chance to enjoy real pizza, this place served the best pizza. This was a cosy restaurant with a friendly Italian feel, the manager w…

This was real Italian pizza. I live in the UK so I do not have the chance to enjoy real pizza, this place served the best pizza. This was a cosy restaurant with a friendly Italian feel, the man…

We were staying in an AirBNB in Harlem and this restaurant was within walking distance. How fortunate! This little gem of a restaurant offered delicious pizza and Italian apps. The wait staff wa…

This pizzeria (Sottocasa Pizzeria) is amazing. They serve really tasty pizza's with diverse toppings where you can chose from. The setting is cozy and the ambiance is beautiful. The staff is very p…

This pizzeria serves tasty Neapolitan pizza with diverse toppings in a cozy setting. The staff is friendly, and the Ceci salad and leopard pizza are outstanding. The skilled pizzaioli ensure a clea…

was great was here with a reunion of my old friends and the pizza and wine were outstanding. One of the best pizzas in New York and that says something.

This pizzeria has no competition, a unique flavor! Of all the ones that I have tried, I prefer this one, its atmosphere, the service and its food, everything is first class.

This pizzeria has no competition, a unique flavor! Of all the ones that I have tried, I prefer this one, its atmosphere, the service and its food, everything is first class.

One of the best spot in the City for the real Italian pizza. Staff is always very kind, and food delicious. Also very good choice of wine! Definitely a must go!

It’s good, but not sure if it’s worth the hype. I think it would be great if their tomato sauce had more robust flavor

This is a popular and high-quality spot, but for someone looking for non-dairy/vegan options, it is disappointing. I ordered the marinara pizza, which was listed as vegan and I was thinking that it would have non-dairy cheese and be a proper vegan pizza. But instead, it was just a pizza crust with tomato sauce and no cheese or anything else. To me that seemed like a lazy way to do it, as if it’s not possible to acquire vegan cheese of which there are many choices. Other than that, there is just one other item on the menu, a salad, that doesn’t have dairy or meat. For people who don’t care about this, however, I think this is a great place to get a very tasty and somewhat large individual pizza with a variety of topping options.

Ramseen Evazians

Good service. Good pizza. Nice sauce and crust..maybe slightly overcooked...But the BIG miss was our pizza came almost at room temperature...even though the place was not too busy. 😕

Friend: let's grab pizza at one of my favorite go to spots\n\nOfc I'm happy to oblige and luckily I went with my friend or else I would have easily missed it. The pizzeria is tucked amongst a row of …

Friend: let's grab pizza at one of my favorite go to spots\n\nOfc I'm happy to oblige and luckily I went with my friend or else I would have easily missed it. The pizzeria is tucked amongst a row o…

And time and again, this is a wonderful place to grab a delicious bite. So far, none of the choices have gone wrong, and one leaves with a great deal of satisfaction.\n\nPREVIOUS REVIEW:\nSmall and s…

This pizza went straight in the trash. The worst pizza I've had in New York. I got a margarita pie. It was soggy, bland, and cold. The tomato sauce has no seasoning and was a little frothy (weird).…

The pies were absolutely amazing!!!! One of the best pizza spots in Harlem. The Tartufata is mouthwatering. I'm ordering it again! The margherita is delicious but it's your classic. Friendly and ef…

Pros \nCute & cozy restaurant \nBrightly decorated \nPays homage to Harlem \nStaple in neighborhood \nFamily friendly \nConvenient location \nBar area \nAttentive staff \nDraft beers \nImpressive s…

The atmosphere was laid-back, perfect for a quick meal. The pizza was decent but didn’t blow us away. It was a bit greasy for our taste. Overall, it’s a fine spot if you’re craving pizza, but it’s …

The atmosphere was laid-back, perfect for a quick meal. The pizza was decent but didn’t blow us away. It was a bit greasy for our taste. Overall, it’s a fine spot if you’re craving pizza, but it’…

The atmosphere was laid-back, perfect for a quick meal. The pizza was decent but didn’t blow us away. It was a bit greasy for our taste. Overall, it’s a fine spot if you’re craving pizza, but it’s no…

Very family friendly, laid back with authentic Italian food, neapolitan pizzas and Laura Pizza were the best. Been twice and loved it, can’t wait to go back

Amazing pizza. The tough part is they won't take reservations even for families with small kids. Makes it really hard when we know we don't want to wait for dinner standing around with kids. Would …

J K

Had a very unpleasant and disappointing experience with the owners of this restaurant. I arrived right at opening, around 5:00 p.m when the place was nearly empty. I politely asked if the chef could wear gloves while preparing my pizza, since I have Celiac’s disease. I fully understand that cross-contact is possible in a pizza restaurant, but given that it was the very start of service with few customers, I didn’t think this would be an unreasonable request. The response I received was cold. The man who I have a hunch was the owner, told me they DON’T use gloves and that he’d “only do it this once.” His presumed wife chimed in from the background in an equally nasty tone. You would have thought I was asking for free food here. Asking for gloves shouldn’t be treated as an inconvenience, it’s a basic request for health and safety for someone with a Gluten allergy. But here’s the reality. Owning a restaurant is a privilege, not a right. Success depends on respect for the very customers who keep your doors open. Gluten-free options or not, I will never be returning. Edit: I was presumptuous to assume it was your wife. I was in error. My apologies on that. The interaction was in 2024. Further details are not even necessary. You having a defensive position by assuming the costumer is either lying or is reviewing the wrong establishment tells me all I need to know about your level of accountability and your capacity for constructive criticism.