CR Walters

Our family had an excellent experience dining at George Martin's. Reservations are definitely necessary. The appetizers and entrees were all delicious and beautifully presented. The dining room was cozy and relaxing. There is also outdoor dining available.

Lindsay Johnson

This steakhouse is a perfect combination of fun and family. You feel like you are family with the warm and welcoming atmosphere and the live music and staff make everything the most fun dining experience! I would dine here every day if possible. Not enough great things to say about them! 💕

Chris Lek

Me and my girl both love coming here for special occasions. The steak and seafood never fails, the drinks are always on point… the atmosphere is always top notch with live music every time we’ve been here. Super cool "speak easy” house vibe, with impeccable service. Oh and the bread… it’s a steak house with the best damn bread & butter on the planet!… I could easily, just eat that and the steak and consider it an amazing meal!🤌

Andy Selden

The only place I’ll eat steak, it’s that good! Everything there is absolutely delicious! We dine there for all special occasions.

+1

Danielle Dody

Always an outstanding experience from the greetings at the door to the excellent bartenders and the professional friendly severs. Then of course we cannot forget the food. The steaks are always too notch and cooked to perfection. Who doesn’t love staring a meal with a popover. Special thank you to Suzanne and Jordan at the bar. They made our visit extra special! The music was terrific too. A one man performance was the perfect touch to a perfect evening.

Blanca

We haven't been here in some time. Reservations are not easy to come by unless you book weeks in advance. We shared the (deconstructed) Caesar salad, 2 petite filet mignons with mushroom bordelaise sauce & parmesan french fries. Brought our own bottle of Caymus for a $25 corkage fee. Christa, our server was very attentive despite it being very busy. The restaurant was at capacity as expected for a Saturday night & tables were were quickly reset. Bar was very crowded too. Live music contributed to the overall atmosphere

Rene Z

What an amazing place with great atmosphere, friendly staff and food to die for! I had such a wonderful experience here and it's the first time I was able to enjoy a steak dinner since the pandemic started. I'm not fully comfortable eating indoors yet but this place offers great outside seating options that are extremely comfortable. Our waiter Phil was the best at making sure our time was enjoyable and did a great job at describing everything and making sure we were fully taken care of. The food here is out of this world! Everything was prepared as expected and portions are more than enough. On top of all that, the prices were more than reasonable for the type of food you're getting and location. Location is in the middle of a residential part of LI which made it unique on its own and added to the charm of this place. If you're ever in the area and in the mood for great steak, I can't recommend this place enough!

+1

The side dishes, macaroni and cheese, shrimp, and salad were just ok considering the exorbitant prices charged. The porterhouse steak was ok again with $150.00 price tag.

Mr. Thomas

We eat here a lot and just had 14 for dinner in back room. Only complaint I have is that last visit. The pork belly was salty, tough and basically crap. I don't know what happened because service and food is always top notch. Oh yeah, the rice with my sea bass special was inedible because the reduction sauce was soaked up by it and densely sour and bitter. Those are my only complaints in numerous visits and really just a shout out for you to take a closer look. This is the best restaurant in the area that I know of. It blows Tellers out of the water. Ample room to enjoy your meal unlike the clown car seating at Tellers.

Mel C

I have no idea how this place has such raving reviews. I had to try it because I been to all the other amazing steakhouses Long Island has to offer. It was meh. Yea the steak was good but that’s about it. The sides and apps were meh and the atmosphere was not my style at all. Back to insignia and tellers for me

It had been many years since we had last dined at George Martin’s Strip Steak, so we were genuinely looking forward to returning. We went last evening with another couple expecting a great night out, but unfortunately were extremely disappointed with the food, service, and overall atmosphere. We were seated in a very small room with four tables packed tightly together, which made the space feel cramped and uncomfortable; far from the upscale dining experience the restaurant presents itself to be. We waited a full 20 minutes before anyone came to take our drink order. The restaurant was clearly busy and appeared to be short staffed, and unfortunately the service throughout the evening remained slow and inattentive. We understand that the restaurant is expensive and that everything is à la carte, we knew that going in and have no issue paying for quality. However, the food simply did not deliver. At that price point, you expect exceptional meals, and unfortunately that was not the case. The dishes were underwhelming and not at all worth the cost. Very disappointing experience overall. I think it goes without saying that we will not be back.

Charles Mitchell

My wife and I looked forward to celebrating our anniversary at George Martin Stripsteak, but we're very disappointed. My request for a table in the "fireplace dining room" was not written down when I made my reservation and we ended up binge seated in the back under the sloped roof that proved to be very noisy. My wife ordered a NY strip for ,$65 that had a bland taste. I ordered stuffed shrimp that cost $65

Virginia

I took my family for dinner tonight at Strip Steak steakhouse, in Great River. I purchased a $100 e-gift card for my husband last Christmas, which I printed on my computer. When it came time to pay the bill, the waitress said my e- gift card did not have a code they needed. I asked to see the manager and Liz Malfa (the owner) came to speak with me. I explained with tears in my eyes, that I had bought the card for my husband last Christmas and we never got to use it because he suddenly became sick and passed in June. She didn’t want to hear it and said without the code she couldn’t accept it. I asked for the check and after much discussion, she said she would only take $50 off the check. When I didn’t respond she said, “Well do you want it or not?” Ms. Malfa’s said it with such an attitude that my 18 year old grandson wanted to know what was with her nasty attitude. I questioned her again, why if she could take off $50 , why couldn’t she take off the $100 I had paid for the e-card? She just said she wouldn’t! Long story short, she left a very sad, bad taste in my families mouths, plus she kept my $50, from the $100 I paid for the gift card. On another note the pictures on the walls of the restaurant with all the naked woman are definitely pornography and definitely not artistic. I was surprised a woman who owns this restaurant, would want such degrading pictures of women in her restaurant!! I guess this particular woman has no heart and bad taste in art!