Vlad V Kilmor

One of the best spots ever, I make it a goal to introduce my business partners and friends to this yummy 🤤 gem 💎, the staff are all friendly and welcoming. Food is off the chart 📈 and very affordable, fresh made to order.

Chris Romero

Tucked away in Peekskill, NY this sandwich shop has just enough selection to more than satisfy your deli desires. This trip I ordered the Chili Crisp Turkey - something about that bite into the soft ciabatta with just a little spicy crunch from the chili mayo and slices of turkey make it so satisfying. I also ordered the one and only ODB Roast Beef (a family favorite) - something about the combo roast beef and Swiss that is elevated with the rosemary garlic mayo! But did someone also say bacon? The bacon jam topping literally makes you chew slower to savor that flavor. And these are just 2 of the selections at Benny's - but whatever sandwich desire, you will be able to find something to satisfy. Anything from tuna, other traditional deli meats and of course a crispy chicken - a cluckin' good sandwich with hot honey. As always, staff is super friendly and chill! I appreciate the vibe they bring...thank you all. So either finish up 2025 with one of the best sandwiches in the area or put it on your resolution list for 2026...you can thank me later!

John Flynn

I recently discovered Benny's and a bit depressed I was late to the game. A great sandwich shop. To date I have had the Chilii Turkey, Thai Fried Chicken, and the Chimi Chimi Roast Beef. All are excellent. The Thai Fried Chicken would be best when you can sit down and enjoy it. Cool chip selection and beverages. Counter folks are super friendly as well. Sandwiches are like $15 but are built to share. Great place I will frequently visit now.

Easily the best sandwich spot in Westchester. Every sandwich is a thoughtful mix of flavors and textures that rival traditional sandwich fare. The rotating specials are killer, the staples are amazing, and the crew is fantastic. The only reason they have lost best of Westchester is because they don't waste loads of money buying ads in Westchester magazine. As someone who worked in an establishment that wins best of Westchester every year I can tell you this.

Had to leave due to an emergency 20 min before they closed but they told us they would hold onto our food till we got back. Arrived after closing time and even gave us free banana pudding. Just wanted to say from the bottom of my heart thank you guys. We hadnt ate all day and you guys came in clutch 🙏🫡 I WOULD RECOMMEND THIS SPOT

Looks like a converted house into a sandwich shop. Bit hard to find. Thank God for google maps. Don't let that discourage you. The sandwiches are all made and prepare in a timely manner. One hero sandwich can feed two people. Soda, chip. Ready to go. No place to really to sit and eat. Take out only. The console TV reminds me of the 80's living room. The owner says check on line for the menu because it changes. You will spend anywhere from 15 to 25 dollars between drinks and chips. Enjoy the food.

+4

This place is absolutely amazing! Quincy is very friendly and always seems to have it under control no matter how many people are in there. The sandwiches are exactly how you would want; large and delicious. The only place that justifies their prices for the food quality and service. Their menu is fresh and different than just your regular average ham and cheese. The homemade sauces and spreads they use, the types of cheeses and combinations make all their sandwiches unique. Would recommend this place to anyone and everyone. 10/10 Favorite spot in Peekskill and around

I had a sandwich from Benny's for the first time today about 10 minutes ago. I have to say by far the best chicken sandwich I've had in all of westchester / Putnam / and dutchess county chicken was crispy and not dry at all the pickle paired perfectly with it. The toasted bun was amazing. I highly recommend the southern fried chicken sandwich

Croton Tapsmith

The best sandwiches around. Clearly, there is a passion and careful thought put into flavor combinations. Go get some and tell em The Tapsmith sent ya!

Mara

best sandwiches I have had in ages. shared the rachel and the chili crisp turkey and both were delicious and super different. great service. would highly recommend

Ethan M. Dropkin

I got the Sky-high Veggie Stack with non-vegan mayo and it was both some of the best prepared tofu I’ve ever had and one of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had. The ambiance was very comfy and charming, the staff was friendly and efficient, overall a spectacular experience. Do not miss this spot!

L G24

Amazingly friendly staff amazingly delicious sandwiches with a great view of the Hudson River. I truly recommend I drove by. Didn't even know it was there and the food was great. Something I will definitely come to eat again and again and again cuz that's how good it was. Please stop by it's actually really good

Selena Rook McMahan

This sandwich place is so awesome. Really carefully crafted sandwiches. Such tasty combinations and a very fun atmosphere. We regularly drive 45min out of our way just to get a Benny's sandwich.

Vivian Nicastro

The sandwiches are BANGIN’. You can’t go wrong…they are so good. I loved the chili crisp turkey, but I was fortunate enough to try a bite of the buffalo chicken…10/10. They’ve got a fun selection of offerings to browse while you wait on your sandwiches, plus you can get lost in the VCR tapes rolling on the old TV. The sandwiches aren’t cheap - I got lunch for 5-6 of us and spent over $120, but you get what you pay for. It’s clear they put a lot of effort into their product. Plus, you can get a punch card to earn a free sammy. 😎

Corinne Cordts

Love the sandwiches here but they do need some quality control on their desserts. They have me a burnt chocolate chip cookie last time. I could have burnt a cookie myself if I wanted the taste of coal chocolate lol. But also, partially my fault for not checking the bag before I left.

Doug Brown

Believe the hype. I'm an always looking for a 'good deli, good lunch sandwich guy'. Tried BBB one day. Ordered The Rachel turkey sandwich. One of the best turkey sandwiches I've ever had. Another day had the Bear Mountain roast beef. Sandwiches are great, delicious! Service is excellent and the vibe is good. Always treated with friendliness and a smile by the deli staff. Highly recommend.