Rick Garcia

Brooklyn Pizzeria is amazing. It is by far the best pizza in our area. The owner, Sam, is one of my favorite people. His high quality level of service and attention to detail is second to none. Their pizza is outstanding and it is right on the same level as the famous pies in New York. Brooklyn Pizzeria is simply the best and I can’t wait until our next order.

Pablo Lopez

Step into this pizzeria and instantly feel like you've been transported to the streets of New York. The aroma of fresh, bubbling cheese and the sound of pizzas being tossed in the air create an authentic and inviting atmosphere. The pizza here is nothing short of amazing. The thin, crispy crust is the perfect base for the savory tomato sauce and generous toppings. Each bite bursts with flavor, and you can tell that the ingredients are of the highest quality. The classic New York-style slices were a true delight, and the specialty pizzas offered a creative twist on the traditional favorites. The authenticity of the pizzeria is not just about the food, but also about the experience. The staff is friendly, the service is prompt, and the ambiance is casual and welcoming. It truly feels like a neighborhood pizzeria in the heart of Richmond, but with the genuine spirit of New York. If you're a pizza enthusiast or simply someone who appreciates a delicious, authentic dining experience, this pizzeria is a must-visit. Whether dining in or ordering for takeout, the experience is sure to leave you craving more. This spot has truly brought the essence of New York's pizza scene to Richmond, and I can't wait to return for another slice!

Deflection Mode

I thoroughly enjoyed my calzone there. It had the perfect amount of cheese inside it. Also the breading was crispy and delicious. I will definitely return and try other dishes and their pizza too.

Jamie Jimenez

The pizza was good, great flavor. Would have liked a crisper crust. The garlic knots were very moist with a weird taste. We will be back but without the garlic knots.

Griswald Schwille

I love this place. They make consistently great pizza and always offer friendly service. Thank you to the person who delivered to our place Monday after 7pm for knocking pleasantly. It usually makes me jump when someone aggressively pounds on the door, and they were patient while we herded the dog to the next room. They delivered faster than expected.

Tommy Ly

Solid NY style pizza. Dough is thin and has a nice chew to it. I love that the “edge crust” is also thin; sauce and cheese are tasty too. My only criticism is it needs to be cooked longer so the cheese gets to a nice brown, charred color. But that’s a me thing because I like my pizza that way, nicely charred. If you like it that way too, ask for well done. Will be back!

Ordered online for pickup around 9:00 PM. The ordering process was simple and the website worked smoothly. Parking was easy with plenty of spots right out front, which makes quick pickup convenient. According to my significant other who went inside to grab the order, the restaurant wasn’t busy at the time. The cashier was friendly and the food was ready on time. Food Ordered -Large Pepperoni Pizza This one was the clear winner of the night. The kids demolished it. -Special Brooklyn Pizza (added pineapple) Rating: 3/5 The pizza was loaded with toppings and had good variety on it. The downside was several bites had a burnt taste. Buffalo Wings – 10 count (requested extra sauce) Rating: 2/5 The wings were actually a good size, Unfortunately they came out pretty dry, and the buffalo sauce was almost nonexistent even though extra sauce was requested. Garlic Bread Rating: 2/5 The texture was soft and easy to bite into, which was good, but again there was a burnt taste. The garlic flavor was there, but the burnt taste took away from it. Overall Thoughts 3-stars. Pepperoni pizza saved the night. Some items had a burnt taste and the wings needed more sauce. Not bad, not amazing, just a decent quick pizza pickup spot.

Alexander Kacer

Spoke with Nate on the phone on my pick up order, he was great. I assumed they have been burned too many times because they insisted I paid over the phone. No biggie. Ordered a cheese and a signature pizza, neither were impressive. Undercooked and very doughy, just my opinion. Ordered cheesy bread, this was the biggest let down, it was two pieces of bread fused together by cheese, not crunchy or cut, just two pieces of loaf bread very doughy, maybe microwaved? . Wife got eggplant parm. She enjoyed it. Sub- Par pizza.

K B.

Despite the beer on the menu & the Anheuser Busch neon sign they do NOT have beer on premise. They lost their license. So we were off to a bad start. We ordered 3 pizzas for our group & then ordered garlic knots. After that order the kid at the counter said oh they're free with 2 pies and since you ordered 3, you're good. That would have been good to know before because we almost paid for them. The garlic knots were not very warm when they arrived & were strangely moist & dense. On to the pizza.... I have read other reviews & I highly doubt that anyone who was really from NYC, let alone Brooklyn, would compare this place to authentic Brooklyn PIzza. This may be "New York Style" pizza, but the real thing is far superior to this. The pizzas were all undercooked and the dough was lacking in flavor. The pepperonis were a bit random, so you got some slices with little to no meat on them. The Marguarite pie was odd. I suspect the tomatoes were added later or they were very cold when they were added, because they were cold on top of the pie & they often just fell off. The crust was as soft as a fajita and didn't have that crisp crust that easily folds in half, like a real NYC slice of pizza would have. We were told by the kids at the counter that the manager was from Brooklyn, NY and when we asked to see him, they said he was out doing deliveries. With all those kids working there, you'd think the manager would be there on site managing. I'm eager to hear what part of Brooklyn he's from because it ain't Bensonhurst or Bay Ridge! I'll give it 2 stars because the kids at the counter were respectful & helpful and you could eat this if you were hungry enough, but ot loses 3 stars for fraudlent advertising of authentic Brooklyn pizza and for on premise beer. So i say...... Fuggedaboutit!

Riley Copper

They don’t care about customers, the food was disgusting. I would not have paid $44 for the burnt food they served us, but they were unwilling to fix the issue even though my friend had an allergy. She couldn’t eat the pizza and the calzones are normally good, was splitting it with a friend of mine and couldn’t eat it. Wish this place was better, my friend talked it up so much, and was a huge let down. We won’t be coming here anymore.

Luis Leal

Poor service to a friend of mine, food was awful. They burnt the calzone, not even sure why they would serve it to a guest. Very disappointing this place is normally good. Service has gone down hill over the five years I’ve been in the area

Paige Kuebler

Poor service ordered over the phone asked for no olives and brought it home to find olives. I am allergic and can’t have them won’t be coming here again and will make sure to let others know you all handle customers poorly. I would have gladly brought the pizza back whole and have you remake it, but now I know you can’t serve customers and fix your mistakes. Record your phone calls. I always order no olives at any pizza place otherwise I need an EpiPen. Girl over the phone was not helpful, and didn’t even offer to have me speak with a manager to solve the situation. At the end of the day don’t order over the phone. Also burnt the calzone