Matthew Andrychuk

After 45 years , still best pie in city! All fresh ingredients. Worth it.

Satya Devi

Such good pizza, it reminded me of my grandmother's. Had a wonderful chat with the owner who has the same accent as my grandmother did so that was also very heart warming. Will definitely order again next time we are in Rochester.

Alicia Healey

This is a classic case of 'do not judge a book by it's cover.' You might miss it while driving by, but Nino's pizzeria is a hidden gem in Rochester. 💎 Their pizza is fresh and delicious, with the sauce being the star - it's absolutely delicious! 🍕 Their fries are also tasty! Highly recommend! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Hannah Maier

Best pizza in Rochester. You’re going to order for pickup(that’s your only option), the owner is going to make the pizza the same way he has for the past 40 years, when it’s done he’s going to walk it to you and show you the pizza for approval before payment. This is how it’s done. It’s delicious, the toppings are under the cheese sometimes so don’t be worried, crust is fluffy and thick-ish but you can order thin crust if you want. It’s amazing.

Theresa Kusak-Smith

Nino’s Sicilian pizza is the real deal! I swear it was a 10 lb pizza loaded with toppings and cheese. Crust was crispy on the out side - fresh and light on the inside. Best pizza ever!

+1

Oblitus Angelus

Very good pizza. I tried the Sicilian round pizza. Was surprised how good it was. Very good price as well. Sauce maybe a little thick but still good. Decent amount of cheese as well. What really stood out was how fresh the bread was. Like fresh baked bread from Italian bakeries in NYC growing up.Very soft on the inside and crispy on the outside. I'd definitely recommend trying this place out. I'll be back to try a regular pie soon.

Edward Horeth

This review is based only on the quality of the pizza. There are no frills or extras at this place, but if you like Sicilian style pizza then your going to love this place.

Alicia Cardinell

Surprisingly delicious. The place certainly looks like it has been open for 50 years. The sauce on the pizza was killer though! Definitely up there for one of the best pizzas in Rochester.

John King

This is hands down the most incredible pizza in Monroe County, possibly all of nys.... I drive a half hour to pick it up. I would drive a day or two if I had to. I added a little cheese my girlfriend had grated but it is far from necessary. I always get Italian Sausage, Prosciutto, fresh onion, fresh garlic, fresh jalapenos, grated locatelli cheese and Mozzarella

Olivia Shamon

Very unique style of pizza for the area. Delicious fluffy, crunchy crust, incredibly flavorful sauce, and lots of fresh toppings. They use home made sausage and it's so good! I was very pleased with the price, quality of ingredients, and friendly staff.

Mike Foell (Blancohammer)

Food was really good pizza crust was soft and amazing! Sauce was sweet side but not to over whelming. Talked to the owner and he was a very nice man, talked about his pizza shop and starting a pizza shop.

Aupair with Anh Pham

A small to-go pizza place. Parking is on street. There are 2 tables indoors if you want to eat in. The man who helped taking my order was friendly. I ordered a small sicilian. Pizza took about 15 minutes. The dough was very soft and good. Wish the sauce has a but more flavor. Price is very reasonable

+1

Erin Leigh

We were very excited to try this place due to the great reviews, unfortunately we did not have a good experience. Immediately upon opening the pizza box we could smell something pungent. We tried to overlook this thinking that it may just be the cardboard, however, the pizza wasn’t any better. There was a strange smell, it was dry with very minimal sauce, all of the cheese on the “extra large pizza” was on one side, and we ended up throwing most of it away. The wings were not much better.