Michael Highman

I was inspired to write a review because of the recent email blast. If you're reading PizWiz reviews and are in need of additional verification other than a 4.7 rating with over 650 reviews, you need to sit down and have a look in the mirror about why you are so concerned about ordering a pizza. This place is very good. They're funny. I order a vegan custom pie and my spouse orders a regular roni without sauce. They're consistently great. Also, the seitan wings are awesome. I'm glad they stopped that short jaunt with gardein or whatever. When UPS doesn't deliver the seitan wings I get the fries instead, which are also great. I have the bluey shirt and the Kathy with a C shirt. My spouse has the Brokeback Mountain shirt and also Kathy with a C. Parking is incredible when you drive a FIAT 500, which I do. Goodbye.

Sue Mussaw

Absolutely the best pizza I’ve ever had. I actually prefer just the original roni because it’s soooooo delicious and a classic but it’s all good there. You’ll be wanting more after you try it! If you can snag a chocolate chip cookie, they are worth having too!

darrin fratus

This place is amazing. I usually prefer a new york style slice but these guys blew my mind . We drove over an hour to try these guys and we will most definitely be back.

Alicia

Great atmosphere, regular pizza is delicious. The vegan aioli sauce was delicious, the vegan pizza was mediocre, wet and lacked seasoning. I love pizza wizard the vegan pizza could use a bit more TLC maybe some garlic onion powder and sea salt. I would reccomend their non vegan items. The bread is absolutely delicious and buttery

+2

Jill O

I found this hole in the wall while Doordashing for others. It's a bit off the restaurant path, but WELL worth going to. D-elicious! Deep dish pizzas in NY, and they are done right! I love their twist of putting the sauce on top as it keeps the yummy bread from getting soggy. Their red sauce, btw, is amazing. I'm pretty sure it could go on anything alone, but when added to their fresh ingredients, it is perfection. Try them out if you haven't. I guarantee you won't be disappointed.

+1

Lisa Mistretta

The Sum Buck pizza is amazing! The crust is divine. The kale wasn't bitter and the bacon wasn't too salty. The ricotta cream was really pleasant. I personally wouldn't get the shwarma dry rub again because it was a little stronger than I expected. But I'm sure their other wing flavors are good. The actual chicken tasted good.

Eddie J

Pizza wizard is great! One of my favorite pizza places to go to when visiting Rochester! The dough is cooked to perfection, with a crisp bite for the crust! The sauce is out of this world and it’s extremely filling! Had this with some wings and had an amazing experience! Love this place and would recommend this to anyone!

+1

Cindy Carpenter

I love pizza and since pizza wizard was voted number one I need to check out the hype. It didn’t disappoint it IS one of the best pizzas I’ve tasted in a long time. The sauce is very flavorful and the chunks of artichokes & mushroom…A#1. My pizza which was the thin slice option had mushroom, artichokes, sausage, chicken,and garlic all on red sauce base. I also tried the wings medium. The wings were meaty and well sauced. No blue cheese or ranch included which was a little disappointing. Over all I’ll be trying some more combinations. And also their square pizzas.

Corey Newell

Detroit style pizza with a little creative flare! Gotta love this joint! The creativity, the flare, the passion. The pizza is always great. The service is exceptional and it’s just one of the coolest, most original and unique pizza joints to visit in ROC! Be a Pizza Wizard and stop in there today!

Carl

My wife and I stopped in here for lunch as she wanted to try a new pizza place. This place is cool. It has the high ceilings and the exposed duct work and feels comfortable. We went to the counter and saw the special. 2 slices and a soda (or Genny) for 8.50. Sounds perfect to try a place out. I ordered 2 pepperoni sausage and hot peppers slices and my wife ordered a pepperoni sausage and bacon slice and a garlic ricotta slice. You pay, they give you a number to put on your table, they heat up the slices an and bring them to your table. In about 3-5 minutes you have your slices. These are about as good as deep dish get. The outside was crispy with the “burnt cheese” on the outside crusts with the sauce on top of the pizza. Crispy outside, tender inside, and left me wanting another slice. I fought of that urge but I pondered it for some time. They have an area in the back with a cooler and cups for water and things like extra Parmesan cheese and hot sauce if you desire it. I like hot sauces and tried the Zebs St Louis style and it was awesome. Like a combination of a slightly spicy Jamaican Jerk seasoning. I ordered some on Amazon after I tried it. We left saying that was good pizza and next time we will order a whole pie and try it steaming hot out of the oven!

+3

F Backus

Loved the personal panned pizza. The red sauce is rich. The wings are the best I’ve had since moving here 3 years ago. The service was spot on. They provided suggestions. We loved the atmosphere. They played great music. Looking forward to my next visit.

+2

The food was great, the service was great. The portion sizes were unfortunately really small for the price. The pizzas are 4 deep dish pieces, and the pieces are about the same size as the Little Caesars deep dish pieces (so the whole pizza is about half as big as a Little Caesars deep dish, which is 8 pieces). I have nothing against high quality coming with a higher price, I was just caught off guard with the price-to-portion ratio. This could probably be made more obvious with some decent signage. No hate, just a heads up that it's a little pricey.

Devang Parikh

Simply the best pizza place for Vegan or vegitarian in Rochester NY

+5

Morgan Kreifels

Top pizza on my list for the price and the amount of goods on the pizza. The special pizzas available have more unique options than most pizza shops. The crust is so fluffy with a crispy outer edge. The inside was clean and plenty of seating. Only probably was that I ordered in advanced and the order still came out 15 minutes after the order time. Highly recommend this place. I did not try out the gluten free options yet.

The pizza was “fine”. We ordered two orders of wings: one chicken wings and one seitan wings. First, we ordered blue cheese sauce with both wings but they only gave us one. The worse thing though is that the seitan wings were visibly overcooked to the point that any self-respecting person ought to have been ashamed to serve them (basically shriveled black husks). Sure enough, on biting into them they were disgusting burnt lumps and inedible.