Dominic's Delicatessen

Great breakfast sandwich and nice place with quirky features. Super friendly service! Edit: Had lunch today - Special #5 was great!

Great little spot with really good breakfast and lunch options, and super friendly people

Best deli in town 100%. They stuff their sandwiches with meat and high quality ingredients. Absolutely delicious and great prices!

RF

So, so, so good. We're from the midwest, and I was looking for a good deli while we were in NY. Picked this one based on the reviews, and it did not disappoint. The sandwiches are packed with meat and flavor, love the thinly sliced lettuce on a sandwich, and the bread is just so good. Everyone who works there is so friendly, too. Small deli with only counter seating on the side, but it's a huge sandwich for a great price and it's so worth it.

David Garcia

Cozy atmosphere with delicious home style sandwiches. The staff is extremely friendly and attentive to customers.

K D

Very cozy local deli I’ve been meaning to try for years. Got a chicken cutlet sub but was able to customize it. Large delicious portion with very quality ingredients. I’ll definitely be back!

T Stuart

Absolutely awesome! After delicious breakfast sandwiches two days in a row, today was travel home day. The bagel was excellent and the cream cheese was generously slathered! We also got sandwiches for the road ... 😲 OMG!!! They were huge!!! Fed us for lunch and dinner when we got home. The turkey was tasty but the Roast beef - recommended! Highly recommend you drop by for a bite. Virginia will take care of you!

michael shanker

Best Old School Wedges around. I love there Food & The Staff. Potato salad if great! Get a reality TV show while you wait ! They aim to entertain!

Jackie Ratner

Don't judge a book by its cover, lesson for me today. When I walked in, I thought I was in a place that was maybe going out of business. The deli counter didn't have the usual display of foods, cold salads etc, you see in a deli. The chest freezer was basically empty. A friendly guy took my order for a grilled chicken salad and I had low expectations. A friendly lady chatted with me and rang up the order. It's actually a BEAUTIFUL salad with gorgeous fresh ingredients, very high quality, perfect portion size for 1 person. At under $10 it's a great deal. I shouldn't have been so quick to judge by appearance!

Matt Capone (matcpn)

Tourist to the area, wanted to try a New York bagel and a New York deli so I knocked them both out in one go here. Felt like an authentic experience. Delicious, cheap prices, quality, pretty quick. Highly recommended

Matt Brown

Love at first bite! If you’re reading this review, don’t hesitate and just go. I got the number 5 and It was more than I could ask for. There’s even a deli within walking distance from me and I won’t even look at it anymore after eating here. They even modified my sandwich because they ran out of ingredients and I still enjoyed it.

Ben Treder

Legit one of the best sandwich shops I've been to. Everything is on point, their signature sandwiches are creative, but also familiar. A must stop in Tarrytown.

Cori James

Absolutely phenomenal! Massive portions and great quality food! This is quickly becoming our go-to deli!

Ryan Raaum

Great breakfast sandwich and nice place with quirky features. Super friendly service! Edit: Had lunch today - Special #5 was great!

AJ Eschle

Great little spot with really good breakfast and lunch options, and super friendly people

Joe E

Best deli in town 100%. They stuff their sandwiches with meat and high quality ingredients. Absolutely delicious and great prices!

This little deli is amazing. The owner (I am assuming that's who he was) literally cuts the meat after you place the order. He does so right in front of you which was an experience in itself! The quality of the cold cuts are the best I have had, like ever. I ordered an Italian sub and it was a mile high with meat, toppings, and cheese. Every single bite was bursting with flavor. The most amazing part of this deli, in my opinion, is the music they play. They even have a massive vinyl collection. I live about 40 minutes away but this will definitely be my new go to anytime I am on that side of the Tappan Zee.

This place has everything you want and its home made- excellent sandwiches, salads and coffee. With the best music playing in the background - The rummer is they are closing - I really hope thats not true

Place is old school. I had the #3 sandwich special. It may be one of the best sandwiches ive ever had. Will be back!

I was looking for a good sandwich as one does. A challenge, in this world, where so much is considered a cheap commodity. But on walking into Dominic‘s, it felt like I was at my sandwich home. They listened to what I wanted, and went to work. They had beautiful classic music playing from a nice corner for while I waited, a set of vinyls to pursue. More locals came in, building my excitement as it was clear this shop had roots with the locals. And then my sandwich was ready. A turkey club on a roll. All the fixings. Wrapped up. Warm. It felt like I was being handed a freshly swaddled baby. That fresh newborn smell of bread, bacon, turkey all mingling. And it delivered.

This is the best deli in town. If you’re looking for a true New York deli, Dominic is the place to go.

We arrived in Tarrytown for another reason, and thankfully, our initial plan fell through because we discovered this incredible spot! We almost missed it, but decided to grab a sandwich to enjoy by the water. The customer service was exceptional — genuinely friendly, and they recommended some wonderful, freshly made options from their own kitchen. The background music was lovely (they even sell LPs!), and you could tell it's a popular place by the steady stream of warmly welcomed regular customers. And the sandwiches? Delish! We tried the #3 and #5, and both were absolutely excellent. We're already planning our return trip to Tarrytown just for these. Recommend you give it a try.

One of the great gems of Tarrytown! Best deli sandwich around. Excellent value for the money

Tiesha Thomas

This little deli is amazing. The owner (I am assuming that's who he was) literally cuts the meat after you place the order. He does so right in front of you which was an experience in itself! The quality of the cold cuts are the best I have had, like ever. I ordered an Italian sub and it was a mile high with meat, toppings, and cheese. Every single bite was bursting with flavor. The most amazing part of this deli, in my opinion, is the music they play. They even have a massive vinyl collection. I live about 40 minutes away but this will definitely be my new go to anytime I am on that side of the Tappan Zee.

Hays Westbrook

This is the best deli in town. If you’re looking for a true New York deli, Dominic is the place to go.

Donald Kostik

Place is old school. I had the #3 sandwich special. It may be one of the best sandwiches ive ever had. Will be back!

Mike

One of the great gems of Tarrytown! Best deli sandwich around. Excellent value for the money

Tky Jake4

We arrived in Tarrytown for another reason, and thankfully, our initial plan fell through because we discovered this incredible spot! We almost missed it, but decided to grab a sandwich to enjoy by the water. The customer service was exceptional — genuinely friendly, and they recommended some wonderful, freshly made options from their own kitchen. The background music was lovely (they even sell LPs!), and you could tell it's a popular place by the steady stream of warmly welcomed regular customers. And the sandwiches? Delish! We tried the #3 and #5, and both were absolutely excellent. We're already planning our return trip to Tarrytown just for these. Recommend you give it a try.

Michael Smith

I was looking for a good sandwich as one does. A challenge, in this world, where so much is considered a cheap commodity. But on walking into Dominic‘s, it felt like I was at my sandwich home. They listened to what I wanted, and went to work. They had beautiful classic music playing from a nice corner for while I waited, a set of vinyls to pursue. More locals came in, building my excitement as it was clear this shop had roots with the locals. And then my sandwich was ready. A turkey club on a roll. All the fixings. Wrapped up. Warm. It felt like I was being handed a freshly swaddled baby. That fresh newborn smell of bread, bacon, turkey all mingling. And it delivered.

Ja War

Super nice people! It's what a "typical" deli would look like to me in my head. Hubby & I shared a turkey & Swiss with garlic aioli on a roll. It was ridiculously stuffed with turkey! Sooo good. But the best thing was the coleslaw; literally the best I've ever tasted: not too sweet, with a little tang supporting role. I totally hate carrots but I didn't even taste them. I wanted to ask for the recipe, but it's probably a family secret one, which is totally understandable. Great stuff!