keith drucker

A truly amazing experience starting with a generous and thoughtful host who seated us shortly after arriving for a 630 Saturday night reservation, to great tasting perfectly dressed appetizers and dinners, and culminating with an amazing peanut butter cake desert. The old fashions were the best we’ve had and the bill was extremely reasonable. Thanks for an enjoyable delicious dinner.

Alex L

We were greeted by the owner and we felt super welcome. The atmosphere is amazing! The food is spectacular and the service is top notch. Highly recommend. Will be back soon.

Robert Flannigan

All very good! Service, atmosphere, food quality and value. I'll be back.

Bob Barzyk

We had dinner at the bar on a Tuesday around 6pm and it had a really nice vibe. Everyone was friendly and was having a good time. Bartenders were great, too.

Jessica Price

A beautiful restaurant and bar. Nice atmosphere, really liked the color schemes. I'm tired of battery operated flames, and was impressed by their hurricane candles. We both ordered from the prix fixe menu, and both meals were plentiful portions of quality food.

June Stoyer

Great place to have lunch or grab a cocktail. The pre-fix menu has a decent selection and good value for the money. Our waitress was friendly. The service about average. It's a nice place to catch up with friends or date night. Was fairly crowded for lunch. Get there early.

+4

Robert LoCascio

Wow - the food has been amazing. We have recently been going here during lunch. The lunch specials are top notch, food quality is excellent and price is fair. (Although it was lunch time we tested the beer tap - also very good). Staff is friendly, and the space very clean. Try the new outdoor space they recently added. also, parking in the back. COVID restrictions: No problem. everyone wearing masks and proper social distancing.

Went there for dinner with another couple. Reservations were definitely needed and we were seated right away. The place was packed and very loud. Service was not the best but I don't know if that was do to the place being so crowded. The food was excellent but again it was so loud that it was difficult to carry on any conversation. I would still recommend it.

Good food and drink. Service for our large party was not the best. Maybe just a bad day

Jason Corelli

Good food with a warm atmosphere. Staff were all friendly and attentive. Looking forward to going back.

Paul Kuba

Food was really good. We had my sons 18th birthday party there. Service was incredible, didn't have to ask for anything those ladies work hard. Thank You all ...

Laura Br NY

Abysmal parking situation. Very nice main dining room for family gatherings. I attended a baby shower upstairs. Only one server working entire party, so patience was needed! Very weird bathroom placement; right behind hostess station. Only two stalls for entire restaurant. Not at all wheelchair friendly. Salmon made my stomach a bit queasy for remainder of day.

Thomas Robinson

My wife and I have been going to the Wantagh inn for many years . We have been going there for Thanksgiving also with our family for many years . I recently made reservations for Christmas Eve dinner for 4 people with no issues. I called today 11/29/2025 to add 2 extra people for the same time as the original reservation. I was told that they could not make the adjustment for that time I would have to come much later that evening . Told the gentleman that that was to late could he please squeeze us in for the original time slot. I said we are talking about 2 extra people it wasn’t like a lot . Told me it was not possible. I guess be a good returning customer does not mean much . Very disappointed will not be bringing my family to this restaurant anymore.

VLOGS. Johnny

I went to Wantagh Inn recently and had one of the worst experiences I’ve ever had at a bar. The owner came up to me — clearly drunk, barely able to stand — and randomly asked for my ID. I handed it to him without any issue, and even though I am 21, he told me I had to leave. The bouncer, who hadn’t checked anyone’s ID at the door, looked at mine under a light and said, “This looks good to me, it’s real.” Even he admitted my ID was fine, but then said, “If the owner wants you to leave, you gotta go.” Meanwhile, none of the 10 people I was with were asked for ID at all. The whole situation was unprofessional and embarrassing, especially since I hadn’t done anything wrong. I’ll definitely never go back. I’d much rather give my business to Mulcahy’s — better atmosphere, better staff, and a place that actually treats paying customers with respect.