Jersey Mike's Subs
Sandwich · Amarillo
Deals available
Be flexible, save more
Be flexible, save more
About Jersey Mike's Subs
¡Bienvenidos a Jersey Mike's Subs en Amarillo! Directamente desde Nueva Jersey, os traemos nuestros famosos subs jumbo, rebosantes de los mejores embutidos y los ingredientes más frescos. Con cada bocado, experimentareis el sabor auténtico de la costa este y la calidad que nos distingue. ¡Os esperam...
¡Bienvenidos a Jersey Mike's Subs en Amarillo! Directamente desde Nueva Jersey, os traemos nuestros famosos subs jumbo, rebosantes de los mejores embutidos y los ingredientes más frescos. Con cada bocado, experimentareis el sabor auténtico de la costa este y la calidad que nos distingue. ¡Os esperamos para compartir una experiencia deliciosa e informal!
What Customers Say About Jersey Mike's Subs
Jersey Mike's in Amarillo receives high praise for its friendly and helpful staff, with several reviewers specifically mentioning employees like Alisha and Alexa. The Chicken Portabella sandwich is a standout favorite. However, some customers have reported long wait times, rude service, and issues with order accuracy.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Visit during non-peak hours to avoid long wait times and ensure a smoother experience. Be sure to double-check your order for accuracy before leaving.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Jersey Mike's Subs
Jersey Mike's Subs is located in Amarillo, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Religious Buildings
- St. Andrews Episcopal Church (A 693m) — church building at 1601 S. Georgia St. Amarillo, Texas
Parks & Gardens
- Austin Park (A 916m) — park in Potter County, Texas, United States of America
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Jersey Mike's Subs
Jersey Mike's Subs Amarillo Reviews
Went in for a quick lunch while in town on business. Great service on a busy lunch hour! Would stop in again.
Holy hell! BEST SUBS I'VE EVER HAD!! We ordered two giants not knowing what we were doing and went full on MIKES WAY, annnnnnd uh it was amazing. The bread is so delicious, and the way the make everything is just on point. I used to think Jimmy John's was amazing, Nope! They have been replaced. This place is like gourmet subs. I had lunch, AND DINNER!!
Went in for a quick lunch while in town on business. Great service on a busy lunch hour! Would stop in again.
Holy hell! BEST SUBS I'VE EVER HAD!! We ordered two giants not knowing what we were doing and went full on MIKES WAY, annnnnnd uh it was amazing. The bread is so delicious, and the way the make everything is just on point. I used to think Jimmy John's was amazing, Nope! They have been replaced. This place is like gourmet subs. I had lunch, AND DINNER!!
Subs here freaking fantastic. The employees there are nice Kind and helpful. And I don't think it's the employees problemMainly because of the process of making the subs. But we did wait in line with only about 5 people for about 20 minutes. It's just a little longer than I'm always expecting when I go in. Other than that small problem everything else is fine every sandwich I've ever had there is always fantastic
Absolutely love this place…the food is amazing but the customer service is on another level. Everyone is always friendly and courteous no matter what. The number one reason I go there as often as I do is because of the quality of employees that work there. So many people are rude and just want to throw your order together but at this store you know they want to make sure you are happy and satisfied. Whoever is hiring these folks, they deserve a raise bc they make me feel like they actually appreciate me coming in. 10/10 would recommend!
Alexa was absolutely amazing ! Her customer service and attitude was great and she is an awesome leader ! My sub was neat , and a treat ! Thank you !
Alisha was absolutely amazing ! Her customer service was top tier and i will be visiting again soon ! Thank you !
Hadn’t been there in forever! Staff so hopeful and friendly to everyone that walked in literally all smiles! Good environment!
I doordashed JM's for Lunch today after seeing all the positive reviews on Doordash. After just one bite I understood all the hype. The Chicken Portabella sandwich might be my favorite sandwich of all time now. The meat was cooked to perfection and the mushrooms were really savory. I was so impressed. I'm planning on becoming a regular.
Alisha was absolutely amazing ! Her customer service was top tier and i will be visiting again soon ! Thank you !
Alexa was absolutely amazing ! Her customer service and attitude was great and she is an awesome leader ! My sub was neat , and a treat ! Thank you !
Hadn’t been there in forever! Staff so hopeful and friendly to everyone that walked in literally all smiles! Good environment!
I doordashed JM's for Lunch today after seeing all the positive reviews on Doordash. After just one bite I understood all the hype. The Chicken Portabella sandwich might be my favorite sandwich of all time now. The meat was cooked to perfection and the mushrooms were really savory. I was so impressed. I'm planning on becoming a regular.
Subs here freaking fantastic. The employees there are nice Kind and helpful. And I don't think it's the employees problemMainly because of the process of making the subs. But we did wait in line with only about 5 people for about 20 minutes. It's just a little longer than I'm always expecting when I go in. Other than that small problem everything else is fine every sandwich I've ever had there is always fantastic
Absolutely love this place…the food is amazing but the customer service is on another level. Everyone is always friendly and courteous no matter what. The number one reason I go there as often as I do is because of the quality of employees that work there. So many people are rude and just want to throw your order together but at this store you know they want to make sure you are happy and satisfied. Whoever is hiring these folks, they deserve a raise bc they make me feel like they actually appreciate me coming in. 10/10 would recommend!
It was my first visit o Jersey Mike's. The sandwiches were good. The service was good. That said, I doubt I will go back because there is no drive thru, and the parking is atrocious!
It was my first visit o Jersey Mike's. The sandwiches were good. The service was good. That said, I doubt I will go back because there is no drive thru, and the parking is atrocious!
I have always enjoyed Jersey Mike’s but here lately it’s hit or miss on if they get my sandwich right. I always get the grilled veggie wrap. My last visit last week the wrap was cold and the cheese wasn’t melted. I went back in and they redid it. But I could hear the lady making comments to another worker. The staff has always been friendly but they need to be trained how to make the grilled veggie wraps. I’m not sure if I’ll go back. To pay over $9 for a sandwich is a lot and I would expect it to be made correctly. Thank you
Got the sandwich quick, but the girl in the front kept getting my order wrong. They can work on better customer service. It was least busiest place Jerseys Mike I have ever been to and the only one was never greeted “good bye” or “thank you”. I guess I’m used to the Jersey Mikes in Greater Houston
The soda machine was uncarbonated,it was not on my 2025 bucket list to have a flat ass Pepsi
I took my granddaughter due to a young man behind the counter telling inappropriate stories and talking extremely rudely to not only the customers but his coworkers. He was the bigger young man who looked no older than 18. I hope he learns to do better. I love the food but can not tolerate this.
Ordered online, wasn't ready when I arrived. I waited for at least 10 min, watched about 7 other customers walk in and grab thier food. One customer even had 2 sandwiches made right there. Then the employee said " Are you still waiting on your order". Dude fr? Yeah I'm waiting on my food.
I just left Jersey Mike’s 10/18/2025 at 1230pm and didn’t even receive my order I witnessed two young gentleman employees leaving at the same time the area was a mess pregnant lady was very rude to me.. will not go back
walked in with my service dog the workers didn’t even ask if she was a service animal or not they just told us we couldn’t be in there. when we said she was a service animals they all rolled their eyes and started whispering to each other so we left, what disgusting behavior.
Long wait during lunch rush due to staff being more interested in visiting with each other than working. Staff also acted as if I was invisible and were extremely rude and reluctant to serve me. Store was also not wheelchair user friendly with multiple necessary items out of reach.
Jshawn was the manager this entire experience was caused from and not fixed. Worst customer service and management I've ever experienced. I found hair in my sandwich , and then on top of it I asked for rosemary bread and was given white bread instead. Because of having to get to work and in a rush and far away at the time I found the hair and noticed bread was wrong on the road. I was not able to turn around to go get fixed right away. I called in and the manager argued with me about it all and said he was not going to fix it because he said someone else had called in the week prior and he thought I was the same person, he also said that the cook wore a hair net. I went back the same night to ask for my refund completely cause from the management i definitely would never get a sandwich from a place i was disrescpected at. When i went back 3 hours later after work to get my refund or see how the manager response would be, i saw a cook without a hair net . And the same manager argued with me again and told me he was not going to give me my refund even though i found hair in my food and wrong bread. The manager cursed me out and was loud mouthing me in person and as well On the phone and in front of other customers. How he got a management position I have no idea. He is piss poor horrible manager. The worst part is. This was my first experience ever going to a jersey Mike's. I saw my coworker with some food from there and he gave me a recommendation. As a railroader I am we eat out all the time. I definitely do not recommend this location if you do eat jerseys. This was horrible. This could have been such an easy fix , but poor management skills cause it to be the worst experience over a freaking sandwich. It's just a damn sandwich .
Pregnant employee is a moody woman. She is rude to employees infront of customers
Was very disappointed with their service. Me and my mom both ordered gluten free and ended up waiting over half an hour to receive our food. The staff was rude and one even bumped into me and said nothing, they also refused to let us customize our sandwiches. Very disappointed with the overall experience.
Pregnant employee is a moody woman. She is rude to employees infront of customers
I just left Jersey Mike’s 10/18/2025 at 1230pm and didn’t even receive my order I witnessed two young gentleman employees leaving at the same time the area was a mess pregnant lady was very rude to me.. will not go back
The soda machine was uncarbonated,it was not on my 2025 bucket list to have a flat ass Pepsi
go to chick-fil-a, they know how to train their employees to have customers and can speak.
I’m out of town at work my girlfriend went to get a sandwich employee being a weirdo calling her babe. Get your priorities right.
walked in with my service dog the workers didn’t even ask if she was a service animal or not they just told us we couldn’t be in there. when we said she was a service animals they all rolled their eyes and started whispering to each other so we left, what disgusting behavior.
I took my granddaughter due to a young man behind the counter telling inappropriate stories and talking extremely rudely to not only the customers but his coworkers. He was the bigger young man who looked no older than 18. I hope he learns to do better. I love the food but can not tolerate this.
Long wait during lunch rush due to staff being more interested in visiting with each other than working. Staff also acted as if I was invisible and were extremely rude and reluctant to serve me. Store was also not wheelchair user friendly with multiple necessary items out of reach.
Ordered online, wasn't ready when I arrived. I waited for at least 10 min, watched about 7 other customers walk in and grab thier food. One customer even had 2 sandwiches made right there. Then the employee said " Are you still waiting on your order". Dude fr? Yeah I'm waiting on my food.
Was very disappointed with their service. Me and my mom both ordered gluten free and ended up waiting over half an hour to receive our food. The staff was rude and one even bumped into me and said nothing, they also refused to let us customize our sandwiches. Very disappointed with the overall experience.
Jshawn was the manager this entire experience was caused from and not fixed. Worst customer service and management I've ever experienced. I found hair in my sandwich , and then on top of it I asked for rosemary bread and was given white bread instead. Because of having to get to work and in a rush and far away at the time I found the hair and noticed bread was wrong on the road. I was not able to turn around to go get fixed right away. I called in and the manager argued with me about it all and said he was not going to fix it because he said someone else had called in the week prior and he thought I was the same person, he also said that the cook wore a hair net. I went back the same night to ask for my refund completely cause from the management i definitely would never get a sandwich from a place i was disrescpected at. When i went back 3 hours later after work to get my refund or see how the manager response would be, i saw a cook without a hair net . And the same manager argued with me again and told me he was not going to give me my refund even though i found hair in my food and wrong bread. The manager cursed me out and was loud mouthing me in person and as well On the phone and in front of other customers. How he got a management position I have no idea. He is piss poor horrible manager. The worst part is. This was my first experience ever going to a jersey Mike's. I saw my coworker with some food from there and he gave me a recommendation. As a railroader I am we eat out all the time. I definitely do not recommend this location if you do eat jerseys. This was horrible. This could have been such an easy fix , but poor management skills cause it to be the worst experience over a freaking sandwich. It's just a damn sandwich .
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Big Jim's Pizza Co.
Ichiban
Marhaba Restaurant
El Tejavan
Chicken Salad Chick
Jimmy's Egg
Five Guys
Palace Coffee
Texas Roadhouse
Popeyes
Gallery
No photos available
Photos will appear here when synced from Google Places
About Jersey Mike's Subs
How to get there
2311 S Georgia St, Amarillo, TX 79109
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
2311 S Georgia St, Amarillo, TX 79109
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Upcoming Events
Amarillo Sod Poodles vs. Northwest Arkansas Naturals
21 May 2026, 19:05
Hodgetown
Amarillo Sod Poodles vs. Northwest Arkansas Naturals
23 May 2026, 19:05
Hodgetown
Amarillo Sod Poodles vs. Northwest Arkansas Naturals
24 May 2026, 13:05
Hodgetown
Amarillo Sod Poodles vs. Tulsa Drillers
02 Jun. 2026, 19:05
Hodgetown
church building at 1601 S. Georgia St. Amarillo, Texas
park in Potter County, Texas, United States of America
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Jersey Mike's Subs and other restaurants
Earn Points at Jersey Mike's Subs!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Jersey Mike's Subs
🏆 Rewards at Jersey Mike's Subs
10% Discount
At Jersey Mike's Subs
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu