Menu
Four Brothers Pizza
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Amenia

Four Brothers Pizza

★★★★ 4.3 · 0 reseñas

Four Brothers Pizza in Amenia offers a welcoming and casual dining experience for lunch and dinner. Known for its fast service and friendly staff, the restaurant provides a comfortable atmosphere for everyone, with wheelchair accessibility throughout. Customers rave about the div...

Four Brothers Pizza

Pizza · Amenia

4.3 · 478 reviews Google

Deals available

Be flexible, save more

Be flexible, save more

fourbrothersrestaurants.com

About Four Brothers Pizza

Four Brothers Pizza in Amenia offers a welcoming and casual dining experience for lunch and dinner. Known for its fast service and friendly staff, the restaurant provides a comfortable atmosphere for everyone, with wheelchair accessibility throughout. Customers rave about the diverse menu, highlight...

Four Brothers Pizza in Amenia offers a welcoming and casual dining experience for lunch and dinner. Known for its fast service and friendly staff, the restaurant provides a comfortable atmosphere for everyone, with wheelchair accessibility throughout. Customers rave about the diverse menu, highlighting dishes like the chicken broccoli Alfredo pasta and fresh salads. Beyond pizza, appetizers like mozzarella sticks and buffalo wings are popular choices. For those with a sweet tooth, the custard ice cream soft serve is a must-try. Unique features include outdoor seating, takeout, and dine-in options. In addition to the great food and service, Four Brothers Pizza is a local favorite because of its proximity to a drive-in theater and mini golf.

What Customers Say About Four Brothers Pizza

Four Brothers Pizza in Amenia is a family-friendly spot known for its great service and fun atmosphere, including a drive-in area. Customers rave about the lobster roll, salads, and chicken broccoli Alfredo. Some find the prices high for the food quality.

Popular Dishes

Lobster Roll Greek salad chicken broccoli Alfredo pasta buffalo wings mozzarella sticks pizza (6)

Best For

Families Groups Casual

Tip: The "Drive In" area is great for little ones and very family friendly.

Features

📶 WiFi 🌳 Outdoor 🅿️ Parking Accessible 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner 🥗 Vegetarian Coffee
🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy 👨‍👩‍👧 Family 👥 Groups

What to see nearby

Immaculate Conception Church
A 370m

Immaculate Conception Church

edificio

View details
Beth David Synagogue
Heritage
A 410m

Beth David Synagogue

sinagoga

View details
Beekman Park
A 643m

Beekman Park

parque

View details

Data from Wikidata

Explore the area around Four Brothers Pizza

Four Brothers Pizza is located in Amenia, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.

Historical Heritage

  • Beth David Synagogue (A 410m) — reform synagogue in Amenia, New York (state), US Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos

Parks & Gardens

  • Beekman Park (A 643m) — park in New York, United States of America

Other Points of Interest

  • Immaculate Conception Church (A 370m) — Roman Catholic parish church in Amenia, Dutchess County, New York City

Data from Wikidata

Frequently asked questions about Four Brothers Pizza

Four Brothers Pizza is located at 4957 NY-22, Amenia, NY 12501, Amenia.
Near Four Brothers Pizza you can find points of interest such as Immaculate Conception Church, Beth David Synagogue, Beekman Park.
Four Brothers Pizza offers pizza cuisine.
Four Brothers Pizza has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.
Four Brothers Pizza offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway.
The most recommended dishes at Four Brothers Pizza based on customer reviews are: Lobster Roll, Greek salad, chicken broccoli Alfredo pasta, buffalo wings, mozzarella sticks.
Four Brothers Pizza is ideal for families, groups, casual dining.
Four Brothers Pizza in Amenia is a family-friendly spot known for its great service and fun atmosphere, including a drive-in area. Customers rave about the lobster roll, salads, and chicken broccoli Alfredo. Some find the prices high for the food quality.
The "Drive In" area is great for little ones and very family friendly.
478
Reviews

Four Brothers Pizza Amenia Reviews

4.3
478
5★
58%
4★
23%
3★
10%
2★
5%
1★
5%
Reviews (21)
K
K. D. (Reader)

Came here a ton as a kid, came back now and I'm so glad I did. Excellent good food, perfect atmosphere. So glad I could bring my son here too!

Phil Womble
Phil Womble

I lived in Armenia, New York in fall of 1997To spring of 2002 and this pizza place was absolutely the best pizza place in the entire state of New York hands-down four brothers kudos 100% all the way best Best pizza best pasta best salad best everything you can ask with this restaurant someday I hope to go back and reunite and have this food all over again

Carla Avila
Carla Avila

The food was delicious, the ambiance and service was great. It was a group of 17 of us (kids and adults) they were very accommodating and attentive.

Lisa Molloy
Lisa Molloy

I lived in Amenia 25 years ago and dined here back then. Anytime I am in the area I stop in. The service is pleasant and fast, food is always very good and the prices are reasonable.

Maureen Hart
Maureen Hart

Everything was absolutely amazing. One of my new favs for suuuure!! Food, service.. nailed it all and we ordered many different dishes 10/10 would recommend. Also has a drive in theater and mini golf so we’ll be back again.

maria Gentile
maria Gentile

loved it the STAFF is outstanding!!! Super Friendly and very helpful..we had a big group and all needed separate checks because it was a wk trip.. The Staff never complained or even reacted remotely negative. Staff gets 5 stars.. we ate there twice in one week..great food especially the Greek options

Kateri Event and Wedding
Kateri Event and Wedding

We stopped in on a hot summer day for their famous custard ice cream soft serve. The swirl was amazing! We often ask for their salads to go to add to our dinners. The salads are just so fresh and delicious. We love the Greek salad with cheese and banana peppers.

Yusuf Yassin
Yusuf Yassin

We kicked things off with the buffalo wings, mozzarella sticks, calamari, and hummus. Everything was pretty solid, especially the mozzarella sticks. The pizza was a bit of a letdown compared to the rest, but still decent. The burgers were really solid, the Philly cheesesteak was delicious, and the chicken wrap was also a hit. Service was amazing, especially considering we were a big group. Shoutout to our waitress for handling everything so smoothly and making us feel well taken care of. Overall, great variety, good food, and a great time.

Huanchong Wang
Huanchong Wang

Just great food. Probably the best chicken broccoli Alfredo pasta I’ve ever had. Chicken is tender and juicy. Broccoli is cooked just right and still maintained the fresh green color. The Alfredo sauce is creamy but not too greasy which is fantastic. Environment is beautiful and service is excellent. Not too busy during the lunch hour. Definitely will come back again.

Sammi Harper
Sammi Harper

Sat outside on the patio it was so beautiful and there is a drive in movie that has all kinds of cool stuff you can take pics with. The good was amazing and service was excellent would definitely go back.

Rich Clark
Rich Clark

Had a great experience and loved their Lobster Roll !! The "Drive In" area is great for little ones. Very family friendly...you can even rent out one of their Airstreams for the night !!

Carmen Gonzalez
Carmen Gonzalez

Me and my Mom went in on a Sat night around 8:00 on our way home from NY. There were only a couple of other patrons there. You seat yourself, I grabbed a window seat. The waitress came right away with the menus and drink order. We ordered a small veggie pizza. The pizza was yummy. I had to flag down the waitress for a refill of soda and extra napkins, which I should've of had to, as she only had 1 other table. Nice atmosphere, except the fake hanging plants those definitely should be taken down. I noticed they have a small private dining area right as you walk in to the left, and they also have a drive in movie area in mid-winter months. I will definitely be back when in the neighborhood again.

Aniko Magyar
Aniko Magyar

Unbeatable food at unbeatable prices! Friendly staff (mostly young local trainees with about two senior waiters thrown in). Bathroom small but spotless. The venue has a welcoming, homely feeling, and can accommodate larger parties. The vestibule has several local announcements posted, and there are local newspapers/publications for pick-up. There are about four beers on tap, and several on bottle. Prepared foodstuffs are retailed by the cash register. Outside there is ample private parking, and a drop-box for donated clothing.

Froggy “Froggy” Jen
Froggy “Froggy” Jen

Always a fun place to grab a bite. We ate inside as it was a bit too warm to sit outside, but the outside area is really cute! I had the lobster roll, and it was delicious! Worth every penny!

Jane Ahmon
Jane Ahmon

Great izza restaraunt that I went with a group of people. Had a custom pizza with pepperoni, sausages, onions, and peppers. It was thick, juicy, and lots of flavour. Was great quality and definitely filling for the price of $16. The service was great, friendly, and never lacking, and the atmosphere looked old style unique, tropical, and lively. Absolutely bumped up the experience. However, I would prefer on having glasses instead of paper cups to make it more of a restaurant and the pizza could have had more pepperoni, plus it was very similar to store bought. Yet I do recommend this place for a casual stop.

Jacqueline Chen
Jacqueline Chen

Excellent crispy base pie style pizza. Dough was soft and crust was crispy. Great pizza with fresh ingredients. The lasagna was satisfying and tasty. Didn’t have much meat but the rich cheesy sauce made up for it. The lasagna sheets were somewhat thick. Overall a nice friendly place for a Friday evening meal. Warm, helpful staff.

Emeline Chatelot
Emeline Chatelot

Every Sunday night, I eat pizza, it’s my moment ! Although, your pizza dough was looking than cookie.. However, I loved the place and the atmosphere ! I will come back for the place, not for your pizza !

Thomas Armstrong
Thomas Armstrong

The place is cute. Has a good atmosphere and lots to do. Food is okay, service is good. However, $75 for burgers and shakes for four people is legitimately insane. There are several high class restaurants within a few minutes of this place that you can enjoy a five star meal for that price. If you’re okay with paying 75 bucks for fast food then you will enjoy the experience.

Brandon Newkirk
Brandon Newkirk

Dropping my daughter off at camp and stopped for local quick bite and found this place. Basic food nothing special but nothing “bad”. Restaurant depot food warmed up. Pizza was fresh but was not a fan of the sauce but the crust was nice a soft texture wise. Quick and easy but not worth price.

Christopher Chapman
Christopher Chapman

I’m only given two stars because the service from the young ladies working there was amazing but this looks like a frozen chicken patty cut in half with 1/2 piece of cheese and a half of a tablespoon of red sauce. This is the most pathetic disgusting Chicken Parmesan I’ve ever ever had, this place should bit be called. Pizzeria if this is what they’re gonna sell, I got better Chicken Parms back at school…. FYI… I wouldn’t eat frozen chicken patties, especially not for $18 with the tip. This went straight in the garbage.

Armando Flores
Armando Flores

I’m disappointed I order a gyro and the lettuce was bad I call back and I let them know, they tell me they going to do something. I send some pictures to never here back

Sign in to leave a review

Sign in
👑 Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Explore Your Area

More restaurants in Amenia →
📸

80 Photos

Explore Four Brothers Pizza's photos

Four Brothers Pizza
Four Brothers Pizza
Four Brothers Pizza
Four Brothers Pizza
Four Brothers Pizza
+75 More
📍

About Four Brothers Pizza

How to get there

4957 NY-22, Amenia, NY 12501

Loading map...
Four Brothers Pizza
Tap for directions

Highlights

Good Rating
4.3/5 stars
💬
Many Reviews
478 reviews
💰
Moderate Price
Price level
👨‍🍳
pizza
Cuisine type

Services

🍽️ Lunch
🍾 Dinner
Coffee
🍰 Desserts
🥗 Vegetarian Options
🥡 Takeout
🍴 Dine-in

Dining Options

🍽️ Dine In
🥡 Takeout

Restaurant Info

Status
Verified by owner
🕐 Hours Today
11AM-9PM
Rating
4.3/5
💬 Reviews
478
💰 Price Level
$$
⏱️ Typical Visit
People typically spend 45 min to 1.5 hr here
📞 Phone
+1 845-373-8178
🌐 Website
fourbrothersrestaurants.com
📋 Menu
View Menu

Amenities

📶 Free WiFi
🅿️ Parking
🌿 Outdoor Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
🚻 Restroom
💳 Credit Cards
📱 Mobile Payments
🏘️

The Neighborhood

Location

4957 NY-22, Amenia, NY 12501

📍 Explore the Neighborhood

Weather
17°
Weather updated hourly · Jobs and events refreshed daily
Immaculate Conception Church

Roman Catholic parish church in Amenia, Dutchess County, New York City

A 370m
Beth David Synagogue Heritage

reform synagogue in Amenia, New York (state), US

A 410m
Beekman Park

park in New York, United States of America

A 643m
🎮

Gaming

🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!

Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Four Brothers Pizza and other restaurants

🎮

Earn Points at Four Brothers Pizza!

Play Find Me and redeem rewards here

Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Four Brothers Pizza

🏆 Rewards at Four Brothers Pizza

💰

10% Discount

At Four Brothers Pizza

1000 pts
Available
🍽️

Free Appetizer

On your next visit

2500 pts
Limited
👑

VIP Table

Premium experience

5000 pts
Exclusive

to redeem rewards and earn points

📋 How Do Rewards Work?

1

Play Find Me

Every 100 score points = 1 reward point

2

Collect Points

Workers earn 2x points per game

3

Redeem Rewards

Discounts, free food and VIP experiences

Call
Leave a Review on Google
👑

Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Sign in & Play

Check your email!

No password needed — we'll email you a link

We sent you an access link

Check your spam folder if you don't see it