Sam Cooch

We will definitely be coming back here again! You really need to make a reservation. We turned up without a reservation and waited 10 minutes and were given a table. I think if you do make a reservation turn up on time otherwise you'll lose the table. The service was a little slow but service was excellent. The food was definitely the best we've had in years. The lamb was cooked to perfection and was delicious with the gorgonzola sauce. Everything tasted amazing.

Lily E W

Cozy and delicious! I loved the stuffed artichoke and the pork chops. The cooking was excellent. The meat was browned just right with crisp seasoning on the surface and the side vegetables and potatoes were sauteed perfectly.

SUSAN LATCHFORD

The food was amazing and each course was served within a reasonable amount of time, never felt rushed and never had to wait for staff. It was a really nice night out. Only thing (and I didn't take any star away for it) is it's not really geared for parties of two, you can't make a reservation unless it's four or more and there's only a couple of two person tables. They'll set you at a four person if there is not a reservation, but we found that all four seaters were booked. We'll definitely go again, but next time we'll bring friends :)

Susan Bruno

Absolutely Delicious! Best stuffed artichoke I have ever had. Cozy atmosphere, attentive staff and a perfect menu for all tastes. It's our go to restaurant most weekends. The BYOB is the icing on the cake. It makes it so affordable. We have yet to find a place that compares.

Ryan Mulkeen

Absolutely delicious! Best stuffed artichoke I've ever had. Great cozy atmosphere. Staff is very attentive. BYOB is excellent so you don't break the bank going out for a nice dinner.

Ray Strilec

Hidden behind/beneath Kinnelon Country Liquors. San Giorgio's has really great Italian food, which makes this place quite popular among the locals. It is BYOB so the liquor store above the restaurant is very convenient. It is usually very busy on the weekends. They do not accept reservations for parties of two, three or more, only. It's worth the wait. I've never had a bad meal here. They have your traditional Italian dishes, have a great steak, fresh seafood, veal chops and nice pasta dishes. Don't go if you are in a rush. It's slow paced dining and when they're busy, the kitchen can take a little longer.

Great hearty authentic Italian food. Small and reservations are a must. BYOB and foods pair well with your better stock. Can be loud and tables are small but the food is well worth it.

Kylie Danielle

This has been my family's go to local Italian spot for years. The food is consistently good, the prices are so reasonable, the staff is friendly and it's a BYOB. My fiancé had the potato crusted chicken and it was AMAZING! He gets it every time and it never disappoints. We tried the crab cake special and it was delicious. Large chunks of fresh crab, a honey mustard drizzle and it was not loaded with breadcrumbs. This time I was disappointed when I ordered my entree. I ordered the Veal a la Tony and the cheese was not melted completely on top and the chicken was not hot. I asked for it with spinach and they didn't add the spinach, no big deal, but it was on our check. I was also sad to see that they no longer give you the bruschetta with the bread, but I understand if they are trying to cut cost. Definitely a must try!

Joan McHugh

The food was okay, not great. Wait staff not terribly friendly.and the owner made no acknowledgement of our leaving. within a yard of us walking out. Two of us were celebrating our birthday and the waitress could barely mumble a " happy birthday." We won't be returning.

Robert Kerner

Italian restaurant in the lower level of another building (seen on Google Street view). Small, dated interior with a lot of drapery separating the small seating area from the service areas and toilets. The food was adequate but most notable the service. The wait staff seem visibly annoyed to take our order (party of 10). Exactly 60 minute wait for the appetizers to arrive. Portions are large and the food tasty but nearly 3 hours for a meal is a lot to ask of customers.

Cutie0615 L

I’ve been coming to this restaurant for the past eight years and it has been excellent however tonight is a different situation. I ordered for pick up and I ordered shrimp with penne vodka and it was 20.95 and I was given three shrimp and the vodka sauce was very bland. I also had the stuffed artichoke which is usually amazing and it was undercooked and the juice was very bland as well. I called the restaurant to let them know and all they could say to me is they will tell the cook and that is it. They did not offer me A discount to come back or a coupon for next time. I am very disappointed and I will not be coming back as there are too many great restaurants around the area that would have treated their customers better in a similar situation.