Chinedu Ernesto

Paneantico is a hidden gem in the heart of Brooklyn, offering an unparalleled experience that captures the essence of classic bakeries. From the moment you walk in, the irresistible aroma invites you to a haven of freshly baked pastries, bread, and bagels. The friendly staff adds a warm touch, guiding you through a wide array of delectable options. The bagels tasting freshly made, paired with the finest cream cheese and toppings, create a taste sensation. This establishment outshines its unnamed competitor across the street, providing a nostalgic journey to the heart of old-style Brooklyn bakeries where quality and a friendly smile take precedence. Paneantico is a true classic, a testament to the authenticity of Brooklyn's culinary charm.

+7

Eric Jankstrom

One of the best Italian spots in the city. Incredible sandwiches, like about 75 choices. No joke. Great hot food and the best rice balls in NYC. And they have a huge selection of bakery items, cakes, cookies coffees. Don’t miss this spot.

Great to finally discover this gem in my old neighborhood. The recommendation for the blueberry cheesecake was spot on!! Best cheesecake I have ever had!! And the heros are very meaty and filling.

EATWITHEMNYC

Old-school Italian charm right in Bay Ridge Peaneantico Bakery gives all the cozy café vibes -- great service, delicious food, and even better prices. Lunch for two under $40? Proof you don't need to spend a lot for a solid meal.

Steven Nechamkin

The bakery/cafe is located in the Bay Ridge section of Brooklyn. They have tables for dining in. Breakfast options include beverages, omelets, pancakes and sandwiches. Lunches and dinners are available and include various salads, appetizers and pizza. The bakery has a nice variety of bagels, bread, cookies, cakes and pastries. I ordered a layer cake with oreo cookies on top that was very good. Friendly and helpful staff.

Jamila Yassine

This place has a lovely atmosphere, making it a great spot to catch up with friends. The staff is friendly and welcoming. However, if you’re a coffee enthusiast like me, who enjoys a strong, bold cup, you might find their coffee and espresso drinks a bit lacking. While the flavors are pleasant, they don’t quite pack that sharp punch that some coffee lovers crave. Overall, it’s a nice place to unwind with good company, but if you’re after a robust coffee fix, it might not fully satisfy.

Frugal Cyclist

Really enjoyed our visit here after cycling 40 miles with a buddy on Shore Rd. The cafe is bustling with energy. The staff seem very happy as are the customers. 😊😊 Excellent selection of pastries, breads, & desserts. 👍👍 A few things really stand out: 1) the coffee bar is top notch 2) great vibes & service 3) outdoor seating 4) reasonable prices 5) breakfast menu Surprisingly, this is one of the few bakeries that does NOT offer self seating. Waitress told us table service only after we sat outside for 15 minutes. 3.75% service fee for credit cards. Overall, it’s a wonderful neighborhood bakery cafe.

+46

CRISPYKARTEL

I do like that the bagels are big, although didn’t like my bacon cooked with the eggs, I prefer my bacon crispy. But for a $12 bagel sandwich, it just didn’t taste like it. I don’t even think they added any salt to the eggs. It tasted kind of bland. I do however like that they had outdoor seating, and it looked like a cool place, with a lot of baked goods. If I’m ever in the area I’d be open to trying their food again, I just thought for a cafe that they would have good breakfast sandwiches.

anthony tanico

This had to have been the worst experience. I have ever had eating out. I'm, I do not recommend anyone going here unless you're gonna order online for grubhub, because it seems like that's where all their priority is focused, not on the people that actually come in. My God I come in there and I'm waiting almost 2030 minutes for my food after ordering it and then it comes with only one of the items and my other person I was with. Couldn't have theirs, and it still wasn't ready. And then on top of that, I take a bite into it hard old, dry.Clearly this place isn't practicing anything of fresh food.Because this was one of the worst experiences i've ever had.I do not recommend anyone going in there at all.Because if you want go in there so someone else can get their food before you even though you've been sitting in there for an hour or so like this is unacceptable for a place to practice this kind of service

Caterina P

Was very disappointed with the pastries we chose. A slice each of Tiramisu Cheesecake and Carrot Cake. They were both equally stale, and cream was not creamy at all. Texture of the cakes were dry and crumbly. Why were they even in the display case in that condition? Of course....they were pretty to look at....but appearances are deceiving. Paid $10.00 with tip...but I was too embarrassed to ask for a refund. I made sure I let the workers know how inedible they were. Returned everything back to them...including the bag and box they put them in. That's why I gave 1 star....they packaged them up accordingly with utensils and napkins. We even sat outside on this beautiful, sunny day. ..and quickly returned after one bite. Not a good experience at all... First and last time for us.

Thomas Padula

My wife and I were drinking coffee and walking by Paneantico when we decided to stop in to get a few things..We bought some bread and said let's get a large Lobster Tail to split....Wow..I knew it was going to be bad before I even tasted it...The little dollop of cream with the cherry on top was HARD AS A ROCK..Then when I cut it open the cream inside was like Philadelphia Cream Cheese and SOUR...This pastry had to be sitting there for days..or atleast I hope it was because if that was fresh, you need to check all your pastries. If I would have bought a box of these I would have been pissed. You people need to check the QUALITY of your products. You can't sell products that are not fresh.