Shayna Siegel

The music is always fun, the atmosphere is always adorable, the drinks are always perfect, and the pies are EXQUISITE. I’m making it my goal to try every single flavor by the end of the semester. Every bite is worth it and the passion put into making the pies is so apparent. Pictured is the guava mascarpone pie and some matcha, and both were insanely good.

Stanley Louis

Petee Cafe was an amazing experience! The staff truly understands what they're doing and they were extremely friendly. While I wasn't a big fan of the pecan pie, my girlfriend had the cheese cake pie and it was fantastic. So just choose the flavor you think you'll enjoy. This place is a hidden gem in Brooklyn and I highly recommend it.

Sarah Watanabe

This is a very cute place and there is SO MUCH PIE!!! We specifically skipped dessert at brunch to come here to get pie - between 4 of us we split 2 pieces that were delicious. I also got a chai latte which was good. In the back they have a little outdoor patio with some greenery and various tables and chairs - enough for a slow weekend but not enough if they place is hopping. This is good because it would prevent overcrowding in the back and really allow you to enjoy the space. The staff was friendly and the bathroom was pretty adorable and clean.

+5

Kurt Anderson

Five stars for the pie, atmosphere, and service. We had a great time. This little shops is a hidden gem. It's so cute inside, plenty of seating. An outdoor patio with seats in the back. Lots of gold flourishes everywhere. The pie is displayed on a classic bar. The pie was delicious. My kids loved it. We will be back soon!

+1

Elisabeth Hediger

This place has the best key lime pie! It was especially good paired with the hot jasmine green tea. The interior is fairly large and has an outdoor patio in the back as well. Would be a great place to bring a large group of friends and get dessert!

Tim Valshtein

I love it here. The pie is 6 dollars a slice, so by no means is the place affordable. Have, as far as pie goes -- it's worth every penny. Delicate and buttery crust, flavors to satisfy any palette, and in a perfectly cute size. The cafe itself is very charming. Good to work, but on weekends laptops are confined to outside or at the counter. Coffee is great and bottomless!! Definitely recommend hangin' out here on a lazy afternoon sometime.

+1

Solongo E

It's such a cute little pie spot! I wish I had big enough stomach to try all their pies! I only got to try their blueberry pie and hope to come back for more. I love the interior, plants and vibe of this place. Perfect place to catch up with a friend or two. They have a patio for the sunny warm days too.

Bought the wild Maine blueberry pie for $45. Like many have said, the pie and filling is not sweet so that's a plus for me. You can taste the original flavor of the blueberries in the paste. I found the pie to be too savory for me, not sure if that's from the butter.

Chelsi

Love their pies, perfect crust, however… Tonight, my friends and I felt for a treat and decided to order in from Petee’s. Tell me why I opened the bag (didn’t even open the container) and 1/3 of my slice is missing 😒Why would you sell a pie slice that’s not whole?! I obviously can’t eat the rest because what if I just got someone’s half eaten pie…? This is weird man, just don’t sell the slice.

A L

3.14.23 - stopped in for 3.14 pi day and had the Apple Crumb and Lemon Mirengue, both of which were really good; I think I liked the meringue the most. We also got a 12 oz drip, which was pretty good. The staff was kind and attentive while the shop had two tables that can seat parties of 2 and 4. There are also banquettes with cushions, but it's better used in conjunction with the existing tables. If anyone is wondering, the B54 stops within 2 minute walking distance going both ways.

H H

I feel like at this point most restaurants and cafes need to have their delivery games down. While i love the pie here they often get my orders wrong when I use uber eats. Today I ordered three slices and a whole pie which came out to around $100. They instead sent four slices. Clearly a oversight that can be corrected easily but now I am holding the bag & I have to call uber eats to get a refund issued because of the cafe’s mistake. But their pie is so good.

Thomas Carpenito

I was promised freshly baked pies. We arrived at 11AM (when the google page says they open) to a sign saying they have a slow opening and open at 11:30AM. When we went in, I got a plastic container with a day old pie in it and a lousy cappuccino. If i wanted old pie in plastic id go to the supermarket. The cashier told another customer that she just put the pies in… Are we to wait until 1PM two hours after opening to get fresh pies. Sorry just disappointed, the pictures informed me of something else.

Nene

Update: 11.14.22, there is no longer a way to call and speak to someone about the pies or ingredients that are in the pies, you are constantly redirected and robots text you. These pies are okay (Myrtle location). I walked in one day smelling lots of butter and was able to get a pecan pie. It was gud my favs include: 🔸Black bottom almond 🔸Banana pudding 🔸Honey butter pecan 🔸 Coconut (idk the name) - I will say, I wish the crust was a little thicker but still gud.