Menu
Tato's Pizza
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Tato's Pizza
Photos

Tato's Pizza

Pizza · Brooklyn

Experience Brooklyn's best pizza, crafted with love in our cozy heartland

4.2 · 166 reviews Google

About Tato's Pizza

Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 8409 18th Ave #2910, Tato's Pizza offers an authentic and memorable dining experience. Our small, cozy space is a testament to our commitment to community and tradition, reflecting the vibrant spirit of Brooklyn itself. We serve up classic and innovative pizzas, c...

Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 8409 18th Ave #2910, Tato's Pizza offers an authentic and memorable dining experience. Our small, cozy space is a testament to our commitment to community and tradition, reflecting the vibrant spirit of Brooklyn itself. We serve up classic and innovative pizzas, crafted with the finest ingredients sourced from local suppliers. With a dedicated team passionate about pizza-making, we ensure every bite is both delicious and satisfying. Enjoy a variety of dining options, from quick bites to leisurely meals, all while savoring our unique blend of flavors and warm hospitality. Come taste the difference at Tato's Pizza where tradition meets innovation.

What Customers Say About Tato's Pizza

Tato's Pizza is known for its affordable and tasty pizza, especially the $10 large pie. Customers praise the fresh ingredients and quick service. Some note inconsistent service and the cash-only policy as drawbacks.

Popular Dishes

pizza (15) cheese pizza spaghetti & meatball plates Beef patty

Best For

Locals Quick Bite Casual

Tip: Come prepared with cash, as Tato's Pizza does not accept debit or credit card payments.

Features

🚗 Delivery Accessible 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner Coffee
🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy 👥 Groups

What to see nearby

New Utrecht Reformed Church
Heritage
A 63m

New Utrecht Reformed Church

iglesia

View details
Garibaldi Playground
A 137m

Garibaldi Playground

parque

View details
Milestone Park
A 231m

Milestone Park

parque

View details
Benson Playground
A 620m

Benson Playground

parque

View details

Data from Wikidata

Explore the area around Tato's Pizza

Tato's Pizza is located in Brooklyn, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.

Historical Heritage

  • New Utrecht Reformed Church (A 63m) — church building in Brooklyn, United States of America Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos

Parks & Gardens

  • Garibaldi Playground (A 137m) — park in Kings County, New York, United States of America
  • Milestone Park (A 231m) — park in the United States of America
  • Benson Playground (A 620m) — park in the United States of America

Data from Wikidata

Frequently asked questions about Tato's Pizza

Tato's Pizza is located at 8409 18th Ave #2910, Brooklyn, NY 11214, Brooklyn.
Near Tato's Pizza you can find points of interest such as New Utrecht Reformed Church, Garibaldi Playground, Milestone Park, Benson Playground.
Tato's Pizza offers pizza cuisine.
Tato's Pizza has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.
Tato's Pizza offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway, delivery.
The most recommended dishes at Tato's Pizza based on customer reviews are: pizza, cheese pizza, spaghetti & meatball plates, Beef patty.
Tato's Pizza is ideal for locals, quick bites, casual dining.
Tato's Pizza is known for its affordable and tasty pizza, especially the $10 large pie. Customers praise the fresh ingredients and quick service. Some note inconsistent service and the cash-only policy as drawbacks.
Come prepared with cash, as Tato's Pizza does not accept debit or credit card payments.
166
Reviews

Tato's Pizza Brooklyn Reviews

4.2
166
5★
61%
4★
19%
3★
8%
2★
3%
1★
8%
Reviews (40)
B
Blue Dragon Animates Main

I’ve been coming to this place for a while, its pizza is the best I have ever had. The pizza is made fast and it’s cheap. ($3 for each normal slice and $4 for toppings)

D
Dan Gibson

I'm a big fan. The pizza was outstanding. I had a pie that was every bit as good as the famous spot on Ave J. Only here I didn't have to wait two hours and pay $30 for a pie. That alone is worth 5 stars. I didn't have cash on me and the ATM was doing some software update. The guy behind the counter let me use Chase quick pay and hooked me up with some killer garlic knots. I would come back for the knots alone but damn if I didn't love the pizza also. Keep up the great work.

A
Alain Ravelo

Good is great. Better than any pizza shop in the area. They remodeled or in the process but pizza still good. Prices went up but still fair

R
Riarianyc LAU

Love their pizza here. Best pizzeria in the town. We came here couple times from manhattan. The pizza dough is good. Tasty and fresh ingredients. Great service. Strongly recommend.

S
Shavkat Burhanov

Really good pizza been buying for here quite sometime tastes really good recommend to you guys

Blue Dragon Animates Main
Blue Dragon Animates Main

I’ve been coming to this place for a while, its pizza is the best I have ever had. The pizza is made fast and it’s cheap. ($3 for each normal slice and $4 for toppings)

Shavkat Burhanov
Shavkat Burhanov

Really good pizza been buying for here quite sometime tastes really good recommend to you guys

Savita Crump
Savita Crump

Their pizza is good and always fresh. Also affordable. Just wish they would accept debit or credit card payments. Cash only here.

Riarianyc LAU
Riarianyc LAU

Love their pizza here. Best pizzeria in the town. We came here couple times from manhattan. The pizza dough is good. Tasty and fresh ingredients. Great service. Strongly recommend.

Dan Gibson
Dan Gibson

I'm a big fan. The pizza was outstanding. I had a pie that was every bit as good as the famous spot on Ave J. Only here I didn't have to wait two hours and pay $30 for a pie. That alone is worth 5 stars. I didn't have cash on me and the ATM was doing some software update. The guy behind the counter let me use Chase quick pay and hooked me up with some killer garlic knots. I would come back for the knots alone but damn if I didn't love the pizza also. Keep up the great work.

Alain Ravelo
Alain Ravelo

Good is great. Better than any pizza shop in the area. They remodeled or in the process but pizza still good. Prices went up but still fair

H
Han 漢 H

Can’t complain for the price. Definitely better that supermarket pre-made frozen pizza 🍕

Han 漢 H
Han 漢 H

Can’t complain for the price. Definitely better that supermarket pre-made frozen pizza 🍕

V
Vincent Gulizio

I have stopped in here a couple of times. Both times, pizza was good and people behind the counter were friendly. Good stop.

A
A T

Had to change the 5 star, they fell off, pizza is mediocre but slightly above average. Just cheap, fast, mid eats. not bad

i
insertcoolname

I give a four stars because of the nostalgia, I used to go here all the time; it's a good place fairly cheap.. of course you're going to get the kid running with stolen goods other than that it's a really good place.

M
Mark Kessel

Good tasting pizza, $10 medium pie, usually quick, but the service can be indifferent at times. The salad posted on the board was not for sale, unless I talked to the “guy” out on the sidewalk who apparently runs a separate kitchen. I’m still a bit puzzled, but the pizza is good and affordable.

j
john doe

Decent prices for decent pizza, especially the 10 bucks for a pie, I hope they never increase the price for that. Most people go there for that price special. Probably a bit too much sauce and not enough cheese but still good enough.

M
Mr. Shillington

Always good to find a spot that can't serve a decent slice of pizza. Of all the pizza joints in the area, this taste the best to me. I have tried any other items on the menu yet but I am looking forward to it.

A
ANDRE VALLE

Pizza is good and very cheap for the pie 10 dollars large !!! Now where else you can find this the service is nice and the guys are cool it’s decent pizza you cant get mad

E
Eric Chan

Decent pizza slices and rolls. Fair place.

Eric Chan
Eric Chan

Decent pizza slices and rolls. Fair place.

insertcoolname
insertcoolname

I give a four stars because of the nostalgia, I used to go here all the time; it's a good place fairly cheap.. of course you're going to get the kid running with stolen goods other than that it's a really good place.

ANDRE VALLE
ANDRE VALLE

Pizza is good and very cheap for the pie 10 dollars large !!! Now where else you can find this the service is nice and the guys are cool it’s decent pizza you cant get mad

john doe
john doe

Decent prices for decent pizza, especially the 10 bucks for a pie, I hope they never increase the price for that. Most people go there for that price special. Probably a bit too much sauce and not enough cheese but still good enough.

Mark Kessel
Mark Kessel

Good tasting pizza, $10 medium pie, usually quick, but the service can be indifferent at times. The salad posted on the board was not for sale, unless I talked to the “guy” out on the sidewalk who apparently runs a separate kitchen. I’m still a bit puzzled, but the pizza is good and affordable.

Mr. Shillington
Mr. Shillington

Always good to find a spot that can't serve a decent slice of pizza. Of all the pizza joints in the area, this taste the best to me. I have tried any other items on the menu yet but I am looking forward to it.

J
Jen L

Got a regular cheese pizza and it was overly salty. The pizza is okay. I remember it used to taste better but now the quality seems different. I like the thinness of it but the saltiness and cheese threw me off.

Jen L
Jen L

Got a regular cheese pizza and it was overly salty. The pizza is okay. I remember it used to taste better but now the quality seems different. I like the thinness of it but the saltiness and cheese threw me off.

S
Sandra Pellegrini

They got my order wrong, then had a nasty attitude! Too many good places around to go back and spend my hard earned money! It cost nothing to be nice!

Sandra Pellegrini
Sandra Pellegrini

They got my order wrong, then had a nasty attitude! Too many good places around to go back and spend my hard earned money! It cost nothing to be nice!

B
Bing Lin

The tomato sauce is bland and the crust is solid like the dough is not proof properly. the size of a slices are generous.

Bing Lin
Bing Lin

The tomato sauce is bland and the crust is solid like the dough is not proof properly. the size of a slices are generous.

Ralph P
Ralph P

Go to one of the thousand other pizza places in the area. Square slice had brittle, dried out crust, crappy sauce and cheese. Could have gotten better in a school cafeteria. Beef patty tasted like the frozen stuff you'd get anywhere else.

S
Sayda Velasquez

This how messy it was, 20$ for stomach ache no thanks just buy some papá johns for less smh

Sayda Velasquez
Sayda Velasquez

This how messy it was, 20$ for stomach ache no thanks just buy some papá johns for less smh

M
Marjona Ulmasuva

Horrible place to eat food, service was not the best they got my order rong and when I told them they had a attitude and refused to chang it ,not even clean and tables still had trash from other people . pizza was to grease, I do not recommend this place just go somewhere els

F
Fidela Collins

Horrible, ordered 2 spaghetti & meatball plates to go. Looked wonderful added extra meat had lots of mozzarella cheese on top (didn't even know they put mozzarella cheese on top)... Tipped the guy $3 dollars before leaving.... Got it home to feed to my son's both plates had absolutely no sauce... None white plain ... With old meat balls all covered by a bunch of mozzarella cheese no wonder why they put cheese on top because they new it was old with mo sauce !!! & To think I asked the guy are meatballs and spaghetti a good choice... If I could attach the picture to show all SMH Then I call and the guy answering the phone says he don't work in the kitchen ... what off to the side two feet from him so people can't see what's being prepared ?? And then has the nerve to ask so do you want to come back for the sauce??? AWFUL...& They knew and covered it up with mozarella!!!

Marjona Ulmasuva
Marjona Ulmasuva

Horrible place to eat food, service was not the best they got my order rong and when I told them they had a attitude and refused to chang it ,not even clean and tables still had trash from other people . pizza was to grease, I do not recommend this place just go somewhere els

Fidela Collins
Fidela Collins

Horrible, ordered 2 spaghetti & meatball plates to go. Looked wonderful added extra meat had lots of mozzarella cheese on top (didn't even know they put mozzarella cheese on top)... Tipped the guy $3 dollars before leaving.... Got it home to feed to my son's both plates had absolutely no sauce... None white plain ... With old meat balls all covered by a bunch of mozzarella cheese no wonder why they put cheese on top because they new it was old with mo sauce !!! & To think I asked the guy are meatballs and spaghetti a good choice... If I could attach the picture to show all SMH Then I call and the guy answering the phone says he don't work in the kitchen ... what off to the side two feet from him so people can't see what's being prepared ?? And then has the nerve to ask so do you want to come back for the sauce??? AWFUL...& They knew and covered it up with mozarella!!!

Sign in to leave a review

Sign in
👑 Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Explore Your Area

More restaurants in Brooklyn →
📸

1 Photos

Explore Tato's Pizza's photos

Tato's Pizza
📍

About Tato's Pizza

How to get there

8409 18th Ave #2910, Brooklyn, NY 11214

Loading map...
Tato's Pizza
Tap for directions

Highlights

Good Rating
4.2/5 stars
💬
Many Reviews
166 reviews
💰
Budget Friendly
Price level
👨‍🍳
pizza
Cuisine type

Services

🍽️ Lunch
🍾 Dinner
Coffee
🥡 Takeout
🚚 Delivery
🍴 Dine-in

Dining Options

🍽️ Dine In
🥡 Takeout
🚚 Delivery

Restaurant Info

🕐 Hours Today
11AM-11PM
Rating
4.2/5
💬 Reviews
166
💰 Price Level
$
📞 Phone
+1 718-621-3300

Amenities

Wheelchair Accessible
🚻 Restroom
💳 Credit Cards
🏘️

The Neighborhood

New Utrecht Reformed Church Heritage

church building in Brooklyn, United States of America

A 63m
Garibaldi Playground

park in Kings County, New York, United States of America

A 137m
Milestone Park

park in the United States of America

A 231m
Benson Playground

park in the United States of America

A 620m
🎮

Gaming

🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!

Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Tato's Pizza and other restaurants

🎮

Earn Points at Tato's Pizza!

Play Find Me and redeem rewards here

Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Tato's Pizza

🏆 Rewards at Tato's Pizza

💰

10% Discount

At Tato's Pizza

1000 pts
Available
🍽️

Free Appetizer

On your next visit

2500 pts
Limited
👑

VIP Table

Premium experience

5000 pts
Exclusive

to redeem rewards and earn points

📋 How Do Rewards Work?

1

Play Find Me

Every 100 score points = 1 reward point

2

Collect Points

Workers earn 2x points per game

3

Redeem Rewards

Discounts, free food and VIP experiences

Call
Leave a Review on Google
👑

Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Sign in & Play

Check your email!

No password needed — we'll email you a link

We sent you an access link

Check your spam folder if you don't see it