Jordon

I was treated really well here. It’s a charming restaurant. The food is really good. I’m not used to New York pricing so the food was $40 for their popular plate and a dessert.

Ron M

An excellent Mediterranean restaurant. Their in-house baked pitas are to die for. The Hummus and Babaganous were quite good as was the falafel. My favorite dish on our first visit was the lamb adana kabob. They also have wonderful smoothies. The service was great and the staff was very helpful. We will certainly return and would not hesitate to recommend Tutt Heights Cafe to anyone seeking a quality Mediterranean eatery.

+6

Şeyda Bora Benzer

This restaurant was amazing! The lentil soup was absolutely delicious, just like the authentic Turkish style we’re used to. We also ordered 5 cold mezes and they were also delicious. We had a really great time here. Thanks a lot!

Tanveer Kaur

Food was excellent . Nice hospitality.. lamabajin pizza was yummy must try dish.

+1

Holly Ainsworth

Food and service were both amazing! The workers were kind and accommodating to our group, and the food was fresh and delicious. Highly recommend checking this restaurant out if you are in the area!

DJKingMagneto #1

The food is good , a bit pricey , but good. Now the 1 major problem is the Pita Bread , It's like Rubber , the reason maybe cause over kneading the dough and or not Baking it properly. Reason I Avoid The Pita Bread , Cause Who wants to Chew on Something Rubbery. So until the Pita Bread Is Baked Properly , 4 Stars , when Pita Bread Bake The Right Way , then I Give 5 Stars. Respectfully. 🕊️

Graham Short

Close but off the beaten path so nice place to grab some food and drinks. The server was lovely. The food was great and well priced. Sat outside, there are a few tables on the street and enjoyed the sunshine. The falafel plata was delicious

+28

Tiffany Chen

I enjoyed having the lamb kebab. The meat was a little dry and salty on it's own but eaten together with all the other parts of the meal tasted great. The pita bread is honestly the best part, they do it really well. Owner was really nice and accommodating to allergies.

Hsin Yi Wei

We placed an order via Grubhub from Tutt Cafe and picked up at assigned time. The order process was not smooth because it got canceled and duplicated when we were picking up our order. The staff was friendly but not familiar with the issues caused by Grubhub which was frustrating. It was fixed in the end by Grubhub but was time-consuming. We had their Green Pitza, Leg of Lamb Plate and Baklava. The food was decent especially the leg of lamb. The lamb was cooked properly with no gamey taste even my husband who hates lamb finished his plate. We were disappointed with their baklava which was not the best in our experience and the filling was way too little.

Timothy R

Run of the mill mediterranean restaurant plus pizza for the locals. One person was working the front section and a little overwhelmed. Nice enough guy, but it's too busy to keep up any service. Try the Loomi, it's excellent! Nothing stellar about the food or the presentation. The fresh pita was a nice addition, and the rice was good as well. The lamb was fresh enough, but a little overcooked and not seasoned as much as I'm used to when I'm in the Middle East. The flat wide skewer normally used for an Adana kebab was absent, so I got a round hotdog lamb stick. Fair enough, just different. The mixed salad had hardly any dressing, if any. At least it was fresh and diced small. The mixed appetizer was a small portion and not worth the price to me. The onion chickpea side was a new one and not that appealing. I'm guessing that it is sumac on the pickled beats? I'm being a little rough on this restaurant, but I expected better in NYC. Comparing it to every other Middle Eastern restaurant in the US only, I probably should give it 2.5 stars. Would I return? No Is it worth a stop? Meh...