Eat'sa Pizza

Great little spot right on Main Street. I'm from Buffalo and don't get out this way that much but happened to be and found myself needing a quick lunch. Cozy, old school looking inside with great prices, 2 slices and a soda for just 8 bucks! Can't beat it. Friendly young gent at the counter, and the pizza was really great, a good balance of sauce and cheese, and very flavorful! Would definitely stop by again!

Amazing food super chill guy and service was very fast

Jayram Mercado

It was amazing. The pizza was beautifully crafted by the hands of an angle. Every bite had a great amount of sauce and cheese. There was just enough pizza grease that it help it go down your throat nice and easy. It was incredible.

Vincent Miranda-Johengen

Amazing food super chill guy and service was very fast

Aaron Krygier

Great little spot right on Main Street. I'm from Buffalo and don't get out this way that much but happened to be and found myself needing a quick lunch. Cozy, old school looking inside with great prices, 2 slices and a soda for just 8 bucks! Can't beat it. Friendly young gent at the counter, and the pizza was really great, a good balance of sauce and cheese, and very flavorful! Would definitely stop by again!

Daelyne Leschuk-Scott

My family has eaten here since the 80's. It is THE pizza spot!! Love, love, love!!

Gabriel Vigliotti

In town from Ohio and decided to order their pizza since it’s right by where we’re staying. The pizza is delicious and the employees are super friendly. We highly recommend grabbing a bite to eat here if you’re in the area.

Marika Morris

Super great service and the pizza and wings were phenomenal! We were drawn in by the clever name while we were driving to Zoar valley. We stopped in on our way home and we will definitely stop in again!

A H

First gluten free sub I've ever liked. Working in Rochester and drove over to see a friend. Now they're gonna think I really like them if I drive the hour and a half again this week, but it'll mostly be to get another sub.

FN Greatness

Carnival pizza was exceptional. Chicken fingers and regular pizza was good as well. There was only women working and they were killing it on a Bills playoff night. Great food and service.

Great subs, good pizza. My wife was pleasantly surprised with the quality of their gluten free rolls - sure looked like real bread to me. And steak subs actually have real steak, not that shaved steakum stuff. I've only had their pizza slices for lunch, so it's kind of unfair to judge a pizza that way, but it's pretty good.

Small town pizza. Good food. Pizza by the slice and regular lunch specials. They usually have a few different types of pizza by the slices in the display. Very good subs. If your in the area you can’t go wrong here

Matthew Carlacci

Small town pizza. Good food. Pizza by the slice and regular lunch specials. They usually have a few different types of pizza by the slices in the display. Very good subs. If your in the area you can’t go wrong here

Michael K

Great subs, good pizza. My wife was pleasantly surprised with the quality of their gluten free rolls - sure looked like real bread to me. And steak subs actually have real steak, not that shaved steakum stuff. I've only had their pizza slices for lunch, so it's kind of unfair to judge a pizza that way, but it's pretty good.

Calzone was good. Packed with a lot of ingredients. Making fresh mushrooms, and onions not being cooked all the way. Small corner was super doughy and not cooked. Had to cook it a bit more..

The pizza has always been wonderful over the last 40+ years! It's one of the best and I make a point to get pizza when I return to Eden visiting. 5 stars on pizza! However, the buffalo wings USED to be fantastic. I would order extra to bring back to the Hudson Valley...these last couple of visits the wings were over cooked, no sauce even on the wings and the carrots/celery is old and brown! Pay attention kids who work there! Put a hairnet on so your dark colored hair won't get in my wings. Pay attention with the orders! I spent over $75 for my pizza and wings...so utterly disappointed. Won't go back again when I'm in town. Used to be the best. Get your act together and make the fantastic wings you used to make!!

Got a couple slices a little while before closing. Not impressed. Slices were still cold. Crust was hard as a rock!

Mr. Buttons

Got a couple slices a little while before closing. Not impressed. Slices were still cold. Crust was hard as a rock!

Sarah S

The pizza has always been wonderful over the last 40+ years! It's one of the best and I make a point to get pizza when I return to Eden visiting. 5 stars on pizza! However, the buffalo wings USED to be fantastic. I would order extra to bring back to the Hudson Valley...these last couple of visits the wings were over cooked, no sauce even on the wings and the carrots/celery is old and brown! Pay attention kids who work there! Put a hairnet on so your dark colored hair won't get in my wings. Pay attention with the orders! I spent over $75 for my pizza and wings...so utterly disappointed. Won't go back again when I'm in town. Used to be the best. Get your act together and make the fantastic wings you used to make!!

Tara Christian

Calzone was good. Packed with a lot of ingredients. Making fresh mushrooms, and onions not being cooked all the way. Small corner was super doughy and not cooked. Had to cook it a bit more..

Wow. WAY overpriced! There are amazing pizza places in Buffalo that don't charge as much! There is no menu on their website which leaves you guessing, they charge $39 for a white pizza, and do not deliver .with 2 extras, my pizza came to $50(sheet) that is ridiculous for a tiny place. Food is good, however I can't afford it.

Allkreatures

Wow. WAY overpriced! There are amazing pizza places in Buffalo that don't charge as much! There is no menu on their website which leaves you guessing, they charge $39 for a white pizza, and do not deliver .with 2 extras, my pizza came to $50(sheet) that is ridiculous for a tiny place. Food is good, however I can't afford it.

Do NOT order the gluten free pizza. My fiance was given a normal pizza instead and has been sick for 3 days now, going on 4. He typically has no problems with cross contamination and just thought it was really good crust until the stomach cramps kicked in. Now he's been in immense pain for days. Why bother offering a gluten free option if you aren't going to serve it? Do better.

I haven't had a pizza sub in many years. That being said it was nothing even remotely as I remember them to be. The worst part is the overabundance of sauce. Overall, I wouldn't order it again.

Called at 8:17 on a Sunday ask for a steak hoagie and was told kitchen was closed because they were closing in a half hour must be they already cleaned up and want to leave early

I ordered a pizza and 30 wings. When I got home and opened the pizza, I didn't ordered spinich on my pizza!! I ordered cheese, onion, mushroom, sweet peppers on my pizza. Don't like spinich. Well they did make me the correct pizza and my husband picked it up on his way home. Needless to say, I ordered from there cause of the .75 cent wings. Well I will never order from there again!! I wished I ordered it from Eden Seafood. I never had problems from Eden Sesfood. Like I said, the only reason I ordered from eat'sa pizza cause of .75 cent wings. The pizza was horrible and the wings were over cooked at eat'sa pizza!! Never again. I will continue to order my food from Eden Seafood cause I never had a problem with their take out food.

Larry D

Called at 8:17 on a Sunday ask for a steak hoagie and was told kitchen was closed because they were closing in a half hour must be they already cleaned up and want to leave early

Vicki Arthur

I ordered a pizza and 30 wings. When I got home and opened the pizza, I didn't ordered spinich on my pizza!! I ordered cheese, onion, mushroom, sweet peppers on my pizza. Don't like spinich. Well they did make me the correct pizza and my husband picked it up on his way home. Needless to say, I ordered from there cause of the .75 cent wings. Well I will never order from there again!! I wished I ordered it from Eden Seafood. I never had problems from Eden Sesfood. Like I said, the only reason I ordered from eat'sa pizza cause of .75 cent wings. The pizza was horrible and the wings were over cooked at eat'sa pizza!! Never again. I will continue to order my food from Eden Seafood cause I never had a problem with their take out food.

Michael Mackey

I haven't had a pizza sub in many years. That being said it was nothing even remotely as I remember them to be. The worst part is the overabundance of sauce. Overall, I wouldn't order it again.

Sara Clark

Do NOT order the gluten free pizza. My fiance was given a normal pizza instead and has been sick for 3 days now, going on 4. He typically has no problems with cross contamination and just thought it was really good crust until the stomach cramps kicked in. Now he's been in immense pain for days. Why bother offering a gluten free option if you aren't going to serve it? Do better.