New York Pizzeria

Name: New York Pizzeria
Address: 68 Main St, Fort Plain, NY 13339, Fort Plain, NY, 13339, US
Telephone: +15189932232
Price range: €€
Rating: 4.6

Pizza · Fort Plain

4.6 · 361 reviews Google

New York Pizzeria

Your name

Your phone

Your email

We'll send your confirmation and prize here

Date & Time

Party size

Special requests

Free for you. The reward awaits you at the restaurant.

Reservation received!

About New York Pizzeria

En New York Pizzeria, te invitamos a disfrutar del auténtico sabor de la pizza al horno de ladrillo, elaborada con ingredientes frescos y de la mejor calidad. Además de nuestras deliciosas pizzas, encontrarás una selección de sopas, sándwiches y pastas para complacer a todos los paladares. Con un ambiente acogedor y un servicio atento, queremos que te sientas como en casa mientras disfrutas de una experiencia culinaria única en Fort Plain.

What Customers Say About New York Pizzeria

New York Pizzeria in Fort Plain is highly praised for its authentic NY-style pizza, friendly staff, and clean atmosphere. Customers rave about the pizza's flavor and quality, with many comparing it favorably to NYC pizza. The subs and wings also receive positive mentions.

Popular Dishes

pizza (15) garlic knots wings (3) subs Philly cheesesteak

Best For

Families Casual Quick Bite Locals Tourists

Tip: Try the pizza by the slice for a quick and satisfying meal. Be aware that they close relatively early at 8pm.

Features

🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery ♿ Accessible 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner

🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy 🤫 Quiet ✨ Trendy 👥 Groups

Frequently asked questions about New York Pizzeria

New York Pizzeria is located at 68 Main St, Fort Plain, NY 13339, Fort Plain.

New York Pizzeria offers pizza cuisine.

New York Pizzeria has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.

New York Pizzeria offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway, delivery.

The most recommended dishes at New York Pizzeria based on customer reviews are: pizza, garlic knots, wings, subs, Philly cheesesteak.

New York Pizzeria is ideal for families, casual dining, quick bites, locals, tourists.

Try the pizza by the slice for a quick and satisfying meal. Be aware that they close relatively early at 8pm.

361

Reviews

New York Pizzeria Fort Plain Reviews

4.6

361

5★

77%

4★

14%

3★

2★

1★

Reviews (21)

Jess Ehm

Good pizza! Friendly service! Clean restaurant!

Emily Collinsworth

Stopped on a road trip and was pleasantly surprised. Pizza by the slice and baked to perfection. Chewy yet crispy crust, perfect cheese amount, and a variety of options. Good value, too!

Mariah Kraham

Wonderful small Pizza shop! Wonderful slices and the staff were wonderful. Great place to take our Family, we will definitely return!

Maurice Blibaum

Awesome NY style pizza, wings and heros. Friendly staff and great atmosphere. Wouldn't hesitate to eat here again!

Beth Carle

Such good pizza! Order at the counter, find a seat & they bring your food to you. Family owned & operated. Very happy, neighborhood atmosphere. Loved it!

charles pullan

Very friendly, prompt service in a clean updated setting. The sauce that came with the garlic knots was top notch and the Philly cheesesteak was a solid 8 out of ten

Kai Ravencourt

We just moved to NY a few months ago! We haven’t found a great pizza place until now!! We don’t live too far from here and decided to give it a try!! Everyone in the family was satisfied!! You have been deemed our pizza place of choice for pizza nights!! Thank you all for being so kind and working fast to ensure I have my food ready for pick up!! ❤️❤️

David Kroop

I had a whole mushroom pizza with friends while staying at the Haslett House across the street from the restaurant. The pizza is New York City style. I am from New York City, and I can testify that this is as good as any pizza you will get there. The owners are very nice and friendly, and the there are comfortable tables for dining inside. All and all, a wonderful find.

Craig

I’m from New York City and I will tell you this is by far the best pizza I’ve ever had in upstate New York from Syracuse to Albany Rochester Buffalo. Nothing compares to Fort Wayne, New York pizzeria!

Joshua Cruz

New York Pizzeria has the perfect balance between welcoming and convenient. The open, well-lit ambiance makes it an ideal place for families to gather or for a quick, casual bite. Which is what I did on my trip around the area. As for the pizza itself—delicious! The cheese was nicely melted, creating that perfect gooey texture, and the sauce had just the right touch of tang to it. While I personally prefer a crispier crust, the flavors and quality of ingredients made up for it. This place is definitely worth a visit!

A V

First, Excellent boneless wings! Ordered the Hot and BBQ. Good quality chicken and plenty of sauce. Pizza was also good. Super friendly staff! Also, unlike many of the other pizza places in Canjo and Johnstown the food was ready ON TIME in just 15 minutes!

Monster Snow

Whenever my husband and I pick up our order, I personally feel that wave of care of the owner, the camaraderie amongst the staff, and the culture of Italy shared with us. My tummy is happy with every bite, and I will never forget the first time I tasted the garlic knots, which I must say, is an essential add on to any order you place. Thank you New York Pizzeria! •^_^•

Dannielle Parker

They have best subs and rolls ever. The gentle toast of the sub roll, is perfection. The house dressing is out of this world. I drive from Saratoga Springs, roughly 1 hrs and 15 minutes one way just for my favorite sub. The staff is exceptional. Best little place ever. P.S. The pizza is Phenomenal as well.......

Adam Hovak

Stopped in on the way through fort plain on route 5s, and we’re glad we did. We had a large Pepperoni, peppers and sausage pizza and it was excellent. FYI - A large was about 16” round, with 8 decent size slices and we found that reasonable for 3 guys, since we also got some garlic knots. It’s loud when you call, but the food is worth stopping in

Benny Goldstein

Absolutely fantastic! New York Pizza has truly mastered the art of crafting mouthwatering slices. From the generous toppings to the perfect blend of cheeses, every bite is a delightful explosion of flavor. The crust strikes the perfect balance between chewy and crispy, transporting me straight to the streets of New York. The impeccable service and speedy delivery only add to the overall excellent experience. If you're searching for authentic, delectable pizza, look no further than New York Pizza!

Judi A

We loved it. We stopped by to get slices, but it smelled so good we got the large cheese pie, wings, and garlic knots. Everything was great, and the place is super clean. Our first impression is a total thumbs up for this small town pizzaria.

Tasha

Pizza was cooked perfectly & had amazing flavor. Highly recommend.

Cindy C

I'm originally from Queens NY and this is the closet to NYC pizza. I've had upstate. I'm glad this place is there, the flavors are authentic NYC. This place is a hidden gem 💎 Absolutely delicious!

Joe Masucci

In the area for work and was recommended by a local to try "Frank's" pizza. Nice place. Clean. I had a fresh pepperoni slice right out of the oven and also tried a Sicilian slice that was setting out already. Both served hot. Great taste! I would never have imagined such good pie so far from civilization. The owners are from Italy so I am told and they looked it. Highly recommend this place. A bit higher priced than most places but you get what you pay for and this is worth it. Can't wait for work to send me out that way again!