Subway
Sandwich · Hancock
About Subway
Subway in Hancock offers a casual and convenient dining experience with a focus on customizable sandwiches and salads. We provide a variety of health-conscious options to suit your preferences. Open daily from 9AM to 9PM, we offer dine-in, takeout, and delivery services. Whether you're looking for a...
Subway in Hancock offers a casual and convenient dining experience with a focus on customizable sandwiches and salads. We provide a variety of health-conscious options to suit your preferences. Open daily from 9AM to 9PM, we offer dine-in, takeout, and delivery services. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch, a satisfying dinner, or a solo meal, we're here to serve you. Our location is wheelchair accessible, featuring accessible entrances, parking, restrooms, and seating. We also offer coffee to complete your meal. With a 3.9-star rating from 40 reviews, we strive to provide quality and convenience to our customers.
What Customers Say About Subway
This Subway gets high marks for friendly and professional service, with specific praise for employees like Kelly and Natalie. Customers appreciate the cleanliness and fresh food. However, some reviews mention understaffing, limited menu options, and inconsistent food quality.
Best For
Tip: If you're passing through, it's a good place for a quick stop, but be aware that they may be understaffed or have limited options.
Features
Frequently asked questions about Subway
Subway Hancock Reviews
I've eaten Subway sandwiches for many moons and all over the world. I did a pit stop in a Hancock, New York to charge my car on the way to Buffalo. Kelly made the best subway sandwich I've had in a very very long time. I did my usual cold cut combo and she was very generous with the toppings and made it like you see in the commercials. If Subway HD or her boss reads this, take care of her. She takes care of your business. 5 Stars.
*Great Food* *Friendly Staff* *Awesome Hygiene* They washed their hands and put on a new pair of food handling gloves in-between different customers, that's the reason I am writing this review and giving them a well deserved 5 star rating 👍🏼
I've eaten Subway sandwiches for many moons and all over the world. I did a pit stop in a Hancock, New York to charge my car on the way to Buffalo. Kelly made the best subway sandwich I've had in a very very long time. I did my usual cold cut combo and she was very generous with the toppings and made it like you see in the commercials. If Subway HD or her boss reads this, take care of her. She takes care of your business. 5 Stars.
*Great Food* *Friendly Staff* *Awesome Hygiene* They washed their hands and put on a new pair of food handling gloves in-between different customers, that's the reason I am writing this review and giving them a well deserved 5 star rating 👍🏼
The employees were nice and polite and the food was great.
The subway was closed when we came here due to being understaffed. Great place to stop along the way if you need a break.
Quickly made our group's orders. Was very professional!
Absolutely delicious sandwich every time!
Pretty good for gas station
Love it very nice place net and clean
Good spot for a quick lunch
People are friendly and always prompt
I wish I knew the gentleman's name that made our sub, what a gem! We were traveling home on 8/8/25 and needed gas and decided to grab a sub too. This guy was so friendly and charismatic! Made us a delicious sub and I tod him he has missed his calling, he should be working a blackjack table in Vegas!
man i just wanted to say Ms. Natalie is astounding. i love the customer service she provides and is always positive towards me and my brothers everytime we come in. whoever is in charge PLEASE give her a promotion. we need more workers like her.
I love Kelly. She is the best sandwich artist I have ever had the pleasure of working with. I will be back for more sandwiches here!
I wish I knew the gentleman's name that made our sub, what a gem! We were traveling home on 8/8/25 and needed gas and decided to grab a sub too. This guy was so friendly and charismatic! Made us a delicious sub and I tod him he has missed his calling, he should be working a blackjack table in Vegas!
man i just wanted to say Ms. Natalie is astounding. i love the customer service she provides and is always positive towards me and my brothers everytime we come in. whoever is in charge PLEASE give her a promotion. we need more workers like her.
I love Kelly. She is the best sandwich artist I have ever had the pleasure of working with. I will be back for more sandwiches here!
Pretty good for gas station
The employees were nice and polite and the food was great.
Absolutely delicious sandwich every time!
The subway was closed when we came here due to being understaffed. Great place to stop along the way if you need a break.
Love it very nice place net and clean
Good spot for a quick lunch
Quickly made our group's orders. Was very professional!
People are friendly and always prompt
Friendly staff and clean Subway area in a gas station. Only complaint was there were just 4 slices of turkey breast on a 6 inch sub.
Friendly staff and clean Subway area in a gas station. Only complaint was there were just 4 slices of turkey breast on a 6 inch sub.
It's a smaller spot, so If you bring a huge group they will kind of panic because they are not use to it. The actual food was meh everything was moved to one half of the sandwich so it was a pain to eat. Overall need some food there you go, just dont get your hopes up.
It's a smaller spot, so If you bring a huge group they will kind of panic because they are not use to it. The actual food was meh everything was moved to one half of the sandwich so it was a pain to eat. Overall need some food there you go, just dont get your hopes up.
Food was cold and the didn’t even have half the things I ordered. Embarrassing
Food was cold and the didn’t even have half the things I ordered. Embarrassing
Tom from subway gave us nothing but attitude, he had a problem because we didn’t know what was on the Italian subs. Than he threw a fit because we asked for mayo because he ran out and had to go in the back and get some more mayo.
Subway is understaffed & have no breads, veggies So on 45 mins drive in next city there is another subway, try that
Yuck worst subway ever and rude service.. nothing nice here try the next exit..
It’s a gas station and Subs Smelled like gasoline!
Subway is understaffed & have no breads, veggies So on 45 mins drive in next city there is another subway, try that
It’s a gas station and Subs Smelled like gasoline!
Tom from subway gave us nothing but attitude, he had a problem because we didn’t know what was on the Italian subs. Than he threw a fit because we asked for mayo because he ran out and had to go in the back and get some more mayo.
Yuck worst subway ever and rude service.. nothing nice here try the next exit..
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
No se encontraron idiomas
Explore Your Area
China City
Hamden Inn
Soda Jerks
Sloan's New York Grill
Old Bat Factory
Magro's Pizzeria
Panera Bread
STAR MIX GRILL restaurant
Peppino’s in Callicoon
Jumbo Jumbo Asian Cafe
Gallery
No photos available
Photos will appear here when synced from Google Places
About Subway
How to get there
494 W Main St, Hancock, NY 13783
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
494 W Main St, Hancock, NY 13783
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Subway and other restaurants
Earn Points at Subway!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Subway
🏆 Rewards at Subway
10% Discount
At Subway
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu