Caribbean Fiesta
Jamaican · New York
Deals available
Be flexible, save more
Be flexible, save more
About Caribbean Fiesta
At Caribbean Fiesta, we're proud to serve up delicious comfort food with a Caribbean twist. Our friendly vendors and servers will make you feel at home, while our extensive menu features a wide variety of dishes to suit every taste and craving. From jerk chicken and oxtail to macaroni and shrimp lom...
At Caribbean Fiesta, we're proud to serve up delicious comfort food with a Caribbean twist. Our friendly vendors and servers will make you feel at home, while our extensive menu features a wide variety of dishes to suit every taste and craving. From jerk chicken and oxtail to macaroni and shrimp lomein, our flavors are bold and authentic. We're also happy to accommodate solo diners, coffee lovers, and those looking for healthy options or quick bites. Whether you're in the mood for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, we've got you covered. Come taste the difference at Caribbean Fiesta, where great food meets warm hospitality.
What Customers Say About Caribbean Fiesta
Caribbean Fiesta is praised for its authentic Caribbean/Soul Food, especially the flavorful oxtails and jerk chicken. Customers consistently highlight the friendly staff and generous portions. It's primarily a takeout spot, and can get crowded during lunch.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Arrive early for lunch, as popular dishes sell out quickly. Be prepared for a crowded space with limited seating, as it's primarily a takeout establishment.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Caribbean Fiesta
Caribbean Fiesta is located in New York, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Historical Heritage
- St. Cecilia's Church and Convent (A 275m) — church building in Manhattan, United States of America Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
Religious Buildings
- Church of the Holy Agony (A 538m) — church building in Manhattan, United States of America
- Primera Iglesia Hispana Metodista Unida (A 653m) — church building and religious congregation in East Harlem, Manhattan, New York, United States
- Edith Fabbri House (A 749m) — church building in Manhattan, United States of America
- Islamic Cultural Center of New York (A 840m) — mosque and cultural center in New York City
- St. Lucy's Church (A 858m) — church in Manhattan, New York City
Parks & Gardens
- Peter Minuit Playground (A 348m) — park in Manhattan, New York City, United States of America
- Blake Hobbs Park (A 680m) — park in the United States of America
- Metro North Community Gardens (A 757m) — park in the United States of America
- Monterey Public Garden (A 768m) — park in Manhattan, New York City, United States of America
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Caribbean Fiesta
Caribbean Fiesta New York Reviews
Good food
Nice
Great place
Muy bueno
Excelente
There jerk chicken taste really good Actually on point
Very good fried chicken
Great oxtail, great for lunch!
Great lunch spot
great buffet style spot
Delicious, quick, affordable
Yummy
Food is delicious
Food is fantastic. You take what you need. Friendly people.
Loved it. A wonderful array of tasty food.
The food was awesome and the customer service was great.
Excellent service, and hope other customers wil get to and experience theur friendly service
The food was delicious I won't forget
Food is great they always aim to please
A hidden gem. Super fresh and budget friendly place. Great Customer Service. Highly recommended if you are in the area but most of the displayed food finishes between 3-4 pm.
Amazing find, rare is the occasion when you find a place like this. A large selection of everything from salads & macaroni to oxtail & chicken. everything you could possibly be in the mood for. The pictures speak for themselves, so I walked in a little early & they were still setting up. Everything I had was perfectly seasoned & tasted as it should.
A hidden gem. Super fresh and budget friendly place. Great Customer Service. Highly recommended if you are in the area but most of the displayed food finishes between 3-4 pm.
Amazing find, rare is the occasion when you find a place like this. A large selection of everything from salads & macaroni to oxtail & chicken. everything you could possibly be in the mood for. The pictures speak for themselves, so I walked in a little early & they were still setting up. Everything I had was perfectly seasoned & tasted as it should.
As others have said, great food and friendly staff. Jerk, curry, and fried chicken are all great. I also got some other stuff I didn't recognize and those were tasty too Friendly staff too.
This is a great place to eat. Vendors are friendly and food is really good. The jerk chicken was my favorite (really hot, yes!) and the rice is soft, well cooked. They also have a variety of salad mix. The potato salad was really good. I'm not a fish eater but even the seafood smell good. Price is reasonable, I think it's 9$ a pound but less money if the weight is less. It's definitely worth it.
Great spot for lunch or dinner. Always hits the spot.
The food is amazing. Usually fresh and hot. There is a variety of foods they serve and offer. Lunch time food typically comes out around 10 to 11. I eat here all the time, never had a problem. Be sure to arrived early for lunch becuz the food goes quickly. This place is typically crowded and popular. Enjoy, great for grab and go not enough space to stay and eat.
This is place is authentic Caribbean food! Loved it and lots of spices. I stopped by when I was in the area and picked up jerk chicken, oxtail, mac and cheese, plantains and green was great! Highly recommend! The staff are friendly too.
Delicious!! Oxtail, curry chicken, red beans & rice, shrimp lomein w/veggies. OMG! CAN'T wait for breakfast. They serve acki&cod fish plain or w/okra & steamed dumplings! The servers & clientel were nice. Take out & pick up only.
Food was delicious and the man on the phone was so nice!! The oxtails were full of flavor. Excited to frequent here often!
Delicious food and friendly staff. Vegan options available.
The cooks are "real Jamaicans" so the food is authentic Carribean/Soul Food. It's a bit small and cramped inside; no place to sit & eat. Use this place for takeout
Incredible food, will be ordering from here again. The goat curry really does it for me.
Halal jerk chicken, great choice, great prices and the owner is very nice
Great spot for lunch or dinner. Always hits the spot.
As others have said, great food and friendly staff. Jerk, curry, and fried chicken are all great. I also got some other stuff I didn't recognize and those were tasty too Friendly staff too.
Delicious food and friendly staff. Vegan options available.
This is a great place to eat. Vendors are friendly and food is really good. The jerk chicken was my favorite (really hot, yes!) and the rice is soft, well cooked. They also have a variety of salad mix. The potato salad was really good. I'm not a fish eater but even the seafood smell good. Price is reasonable, I think it's 9$ a pound but less money if the weight is less. It's definitely worth it.
Halal jerk chicken, great choice, great prices and the owner is very nice
Incredible food, will be ordering from here again. The goat curry really does it for me.
Food was delicious and the man on the phone was so nice!! The oxtails were full of flavor. Excited to frequent here often!
Delicious!! Oxtail, curry chicken, red beans & rice, shrimp lomein w/veggies. OMG! CAN'T wait for breakfast. They serve acki&cod fish plain or w/okra & steamed dumplings! The servers & clientel were nice. Take out & pick up only.
This is place is authentic Caribbean food! Loved it and lots of spices. I stopped by when I was in the area and picked up jerk chicken, oxtail, mac and cheese, plantains and green was great! Highly recommend! The staff are friendly too.
The food is amazing. Usually fresh and hot. There is a variety of foods they serve and offer. Lunch time food typically comes out around 10 to 11. I eat here all the time, never had a problem. Be sure to arrived early for lunch becuz the food goes quickly. This place is typically crowded and popular. Enjoy, great for grab and go not enough space to stay and eat.
The cooks are "real Jamaicans" so the food is authentic Carribean/Soul Food. It's a bit small and cramped inside; no place to sit & eat. Use this place for takeout
Food was good
Very good
Good food
Love the food and services
All type of food, burgers, pizza, cheese steak. Good food
Little spot on Madison Ave in Harlem! The food was really good but the Mac and cheese could have been better! The jerk chicken was on point for me. The man gave good service!
Little spot on Madison Ave in Harlem! The food was really good but the Mac and cheese could have been better! The jerk chicken was on point for me. The man gave good service!
food is delicious but i think they could use less oil to make their food -- it would definitely taste better also v suprised they dont make their own hot sauce - overall great food and a good foundation but if they wanted to double their visitors they would do the above, along with reducing the price by lb slightly.^
Best to get there early. Lunch time can be very busy. The later it gets - you may not get any food. Food is usually fresh but sometimes not hot. Luke warm food is not a great look when you're hungry. No bathroom for customers, and very little seating.
Happen to do my usual Google food search and came upon this diamond in the rough. Not sure how long you guys have been in business but I'm hoping the quality of your food stays the same.
I walked passed here coming from Hospital and the Aroma brought me in. Food Tastes Good and Prices are Awesome..
Good checkout lines not long and they have the things i want or need decent price.
food is delicious but i think they could use less oil to make their food -- it would definitely taste better also v suprised they dont make their own hot sauce - overall great food and a good foundation but if they wanted to double their visitors they would do the above, along with reducing the price by lb slightly.^
Best to get there early. Lunch time can be very busy. The later it gets - you may not get any food. Food is usually fresh but sometimes not hot. Luke warm food is not a great look when you're hungry. No bathroom for customers, and very little seating.
Happen to do my usual Google food search and came upon this diamond in the rough. Not sure how long you guys have been in business but I'm hoping the quality of your food stays the same.
I walked passed here coming from Hospital and the Aroma brought me in. Food Tastes Good and Prices are Awesome..
Needs a upgrade that's all.
$1 Pizza is good.
It's ok
Was give wrong order to far to go and return no phone
The place has closed ?
The place has closed ?
Was looking for something around the conservatory to grab and go for a picnic lunch. Based on the reviews, we were looking forward to it. Haven’t had Caribbean in a while and we’re craving some decent oxtail. The setup is very simple with a bunch of trays of food and all the classics, including beef patties. Was also surprised to see they have pizza on the menu. We picked up some rice, oxtail, mac n cheese, turkey(?) wing and stewed beef. If you get more than $11.95pp, they throw in a free soda. Service was fine, nothing expected since he just waited behind the counter and rung us up. The food itself tasted ok. Could have been a bit hotter. Biggest reason for the low scores was that the oxtail had hairs in it. Was pretty unsettling after the 3rd hair and no longer felt like a coincidence.
Why you stealing?
Restaurant closed way earlier than posted. Did not inform of store hours online. Waste of time.
just came into this place to a couple of slices of pizza today, , well these slices were awful , stale and salty as hell, from the first bite you new these was yesterdays pizza, not fresh made today, plus the guy at the counter is a thief, stole money from by not giving me the correct change back, he folded a couple bills in half and made it look like i was getting the correct change back, i work for the hospital near there and telling every one not not buy from there any more
just came into this place to a couple of slices of pizza today, , well these slices were awful , stale and salty as hell, from the first bite you new these was yesterdays pizza, not fresh made today, plus the guy at the counter is a thief, stole money from by not giving me the correct change back, he folded a couple bills in half and made it look like i was getting the correct change back, i work for the hospital near there and telling every one not not buy from there any more
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
3 Photos
Explore Caribbean Fiesta's photos
About Caribbean Fiesta
How to get there
1544 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10029
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
1544 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10029
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
church building in Manhattan, United States of America
park in Manhattan, New York City, United States of America
church building in Manhattan, United States of America
church building and religious congregation in East Harlem, Manhattan, New York, United States
park in the United States of America
church building in Manhattan, United States of America
park in the United States of America
park in Manhattan, New York City, United States of America
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Caribbean Fiesta and other restaurants
Earn Points at Caribbean Fiesta!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Caribbean Fiesta
🏆 Rewards at Caribbean Fiesta
10% Discount
At Caribbean Fiesta
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu