New York Deli Cafe & Pizza
Fast food · New York
About New York Deli Cafe & Pizza
Welcome to New York Deli Cafe & Pizza, a beloved local spot in New York dedicated to serving fresh, made-to-order comfort food. Our authentic deli features famous bagels and savory sandwiches that consistently delight both locals and travelers. Guests praise our friendly, consistent service and warm...
Welcome to New York Deli Cafe & Pizza, a beloved local spot in New York dedicated to serving fresh, made-to-order comfort food. Our authentic deli features famous bagels and savory sandwiches that consistently delight both locals and travelers. Guests praise our friendly, consistent service and warm atmosphere, noting how we treat every visitor like a regular. Whether you enjoy our signature pizza, fresh orange juice, or a simple breakfast tea, our team ensures a welcoming experience. Conveniently located with wheelchair accessibility and quick visit options, we offer reasonable prices and modern payment methods. Stop by for a taste of true New York hospitality where excellent food and genuine care come together perfectly.
What Customers Say About New York Deli Cafe & Pizza
New York Deli Cafe & Pizza is praised for its friendly staff, fresh food, and reasonable prices. Customers rave about the bagels, sandwiches, and pizza. Some negative reviews mention issues with food quality and cleanliness.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: The staff is very friendly and helpful, making it a welcoming place for both locals and tourists. Locals know it for the best bagels in town.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around New York Deli Cafe & Pizza
New York Deli Cafe & Pizza is located in New York, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Historical Heritage
- Church of Sweden in New York (A 238m) — Church of Sweden Abroad denomination Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
- Grand Central Terminal (A 253m) — estación de ferrocarril de Nueva York Hito histórico nacional
Museums
- New York Transit Museum (Grand Central Terminal annex) (A 266m)
Religious Buildings
- Fifth Church of Christ, Scientist (A 218m) — church building in Manhattan, United States of America
- Temple Emanu-El (A 247m) — former synagogue in New York City (1868-1927)
- Holy Trinity Episcopal Church (Manhattan) (A 260m) — Episcopal church building in Yorkville, Manhattan, United States of America
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about New York Deli Cafe & Pizza
New York Deli Cafe & Pizza New York Reviews
Locals already know, try out this authentic NYC Deli for the best bagels in town. By the second morning they remembered us and treated us like regulars. Bagels are fantastic and the Bacon, Egg, & Cheese on an Everything is NYC perfection.
Service was great. Alen was friendly and helpy I had high hopes on my new york bagel experience. No disappointments, it was great! ¹¹
Great quality food.The service is extraordinary 😍 Turkish coffee is excellent You can find a lot of high quality products that is impossible to find somewhere else
Lots of selection with bagels, salads, fresh fruit and pizza. I opted for the pizza slice and it was really nice. Will visit again for breakfast and try the bagels.
Had the Chicken roll it's really good. One of the best I've ever had!
It was best fresh juice in NYC
Locals already know, try out this authentic NYC Deli for the best bagels in town. By the second morning they remembered us and treated us like regulars. Bagels are fantastic and the Bacon, Egg, & Cheese on an Everything is NYC perfection.
Service was great. Alen was friendly and helpy I had high hopes on my new york bagel experience. No disappointments, it was great! ¹¹
Great quality food.The service is extraordinary 😍 Turkish coffee is excellent You can find a lot of high quality products that is impossible to find somewhere else
Lots of selection with bagels, salads, fresh fruit and pizza. I opted for the pizza slice and it was really nice. Will visit again for breakfast and try the bagels.
Had the Chicken roll it's really good. One of the best I've ever had!
We wanted to get a good sandwich before a matinee Broadway show and this part of town is kind of a desert for good food. We walked a few blocks east and glad we did. Delicious bagel sandwiches. Exactly what we wanted. Also got a “sunshine” fresh-squeezed juice with citrus, carrot, and ginger. Recommend!
It was our first time in NYC and didn’t know where to get good food. I’d recommend this place to anyone local or traveling. Everything is fresh and made to order. Super friendly staff.
These guys made me a fresh orange juice near closing time. They insisted, even though they had to clean the juicer to do so. It brought me back to life and I enjoyed the rest of my evening in beautiful NYC. Thank you very much!
Here it’s worth stopping by — the staff is very friendly, the food is fresh and tasty, and the prices are reasonable. I think this is the best place to try pizza in all of New York.
I came to New York all the way from abroad, and I have to say this deli made me feel right at home. The food is excellent, but what really impressed me was the team. Sandra, Jana, Samy, and Fabiola were absolutely amazing — so kind, helpful, and welcoming. They not only served me great food but also helped me feel comfortable and settle in during my visit. Truly the best team, thank you for making my New York experience even more special!
This spot gets the basics right. I enjoyed every bite. Customers make reservations necessary. The staff excel at service consistency. The area showcases this standout place.
Very friendly staff! Delicious bagels. Nice relaxed atmosphere. Definitely recommend for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Or just a snack.
Great place! Very nice and helpful staff. We had a tasty sandwich and salad, lovely and fresh. The tea was the best, just plain breakfast tea but the best we've had in NYC!
Here it’s worth stopping by — the staff is very friendly, the food is fresh and tasty, and the prices are reasonable. I think this is the best place to try pizza in all of New York.
Very friendly staff! Delicious bagels. Nice relaxed atmosphere. Definitely recommend for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Or just a snack.
It was our first time in NYC and didn’t know where to get good food. I’d recommend this place to anyone local or traveling. Everything is fresh and made to order. Super friendly staff.
This spot gets the basics right. I enjoyed every bite. Customers make reservations necessary. The staff excel at service consistency. The area showcases this standout place.
These guys made me a fresh orange juice near closing time. They insisted, even though they had to clean the juicer to do so. It brought me back to life and I enjoyed the rest of my evening in beautiful NYC. Thank you very much!
I came to New York all the way from abroad, and I have to say this deli made me feel right at home. The food is excellent, but what really impressed me was the team. Sandra, Jana, Samy, and Fabiola were absolutely amazing — so kind, helpful, and welcoming. They not only served me great food but also helped me feel comfortable and settle in during my visit. Truly the best team, thank you for making my New York experience even more special!
Great place! Very nice and helpful staff. We had a tasty sandwich and salad, lovely and fresh. The tea was the best, just plain breakfast tea but the best we've had in NYC!
The blonde lady cashier was very nice. She was sweet and polite which is hard to find nowadays in Manhattan! Will come back for sure. Amazing place great atmosphere 5/5
We were walking home today after lunch and passed by this deli and decided to stop in and check it out. In the middle of the block on Madison between 45 and 46th streets. A few tables on the left by the front windows. Pastries and coffee on the left of the long counter. Deli stuff in the middle and pizza etc on the right. Several coolers full of a good variety of drinks. We bought a bottle of water to start and then a good cup of strong coffee. Service guy was very helpful and efficient. Quick service. Good experience.
A conveniently located cafe with all classic deli stuff but overpriced coffee. I feel like smth was ofwith their roast. Surprisingly , a croissant and almond croissant are same price, which is a good value considering the size. A few tables next to window make it a good place for an early casual meeting before work. The service could be faster.
We were walking home today after lunch and passed by this deli and decided to stop in and check it out. In the middle of the block on Madison between 45 and 46th streets. A few tables on the left by the front windows. Pastries and coffee on the left of the long counter. Deli stuff in the middle and pizza etc on the right. Several coolers full of a good variety of drinks. We bought a bottle of water to start and then a good cup of strong coffee. Service guy was very helpful and efficient. Quick service. Good experience.
A conveniently located cafe with all classic deli stuff but overpriced coffee. I feel like smth was ofwith their roast. Surprisingly , a croissant and almond croissant are same price, which is a good value considering the size. A few tables next to window make it a good place for an early casual meeting before work. The service could be faster.
Tried the Detroit style pizza. Not the best, yes it's rectangular but is more similar to pizza served in school cafeteria than real Detrot style. It's also overpriced at nearly $11. Skip the pizza here and just hit a $1.50 slice shop, they are better.
Tried the Detroit style pizza. Not the best, yes it's rectangular but is more similar to pizza served in school cafeteria than real Detrot style. It's also overpriced at nearly $11. Skip the pizza here and just hit a $1.50 slice shop, they are better.
They sold us freezer-burned, misshapen ice cream and overcharged us; the bill was corrected only after we pointed it out. The staff were completely unfriendly.
Staff standing around doing nothing. Eating with their hands but not washing before serving next customer. Hot as hell inside. Took forever to get a bagel with cream cheese. Not one person has read the back of their shirts - SERVICE.
Worst bacon egg and cheese I’ve ever had. They use a Starbucks heater to essentially microwave some form of eggs into plastic. Inedible food and it’ll cost you
They sold us freezer-burned, misshapen ice cream and overcharged us; the bill was corrected only after we pointed it out. The staff were completely unfriendly.
Worst bacon egg and cheese I’ve ever had. They use a Starbucks heater to essentially microwave some form of eggs into plastic. Inedible food and it’ll cost you
Staff standing around doing nothing. Eating with their hands but not washing before serving next customer. Hot as hell inside. Took forever to get a bagel with cream cheese. Not one person has read the back of their shirts - SERVICE.
I bought a salad and a slice of cheesecake here- the salad turned out to have rotted lettuce at the bottom and the cheesecake had a green mold spot on it :/ I didn’t see these until I got home and started eating because normally I’m not used to delis selling straight up rotted food off the shelves :/ the service was fine though.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Dos Toros Taqueria
The Campbell Bar
Joju
Strip House
Bobby Van's Steakhouse - Park Ave
Matto
Black Fox
The Clock
Palladino's Steak & Seafood
2 Bros Pizza
Gallery
No photos available
Photos will appear here when synced from Google Places
About New York Deli Cafe & Pizza
How to get there
369 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10017
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
369 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10017
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Upcoming Events
Banksy Museum NY - Monday Movie Day and Nights!
20 Jul. 2026, 14:00
Banksy Museum New York
Women of Americana
20 Jul. 2026, 17:30
Lucinda's
Vince Giordano and the Nighthawks
20 Jul. 2026, 17:30
Birdland Theater
Katie DeMartini
20 Jul. 2026, 18:00
Mercury Lounge
church building in Manhattan, United States of America
Church of Sweden Abroad denomination
former synagogue in New York City (1868-1927)
estación de ferrocarril de Nueva York
Episcopal church building in Yorkville, Manhattan, United States of America
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at New York Deli Cafe & Pizza and other restaurants
Earn Points at New York Deli Cafe & Pizza!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at New York Deli Cafe & Pizza
🏆 Rewards at New York Deli Cafe & Pizza
10% Discount
At New York Deli Cafe & Pizza
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu