FarFalle
Pizza · Oceanside
About FarFalle
FarFalle is a Pizza restaurant in Oceanside, NY. Rated 4.1 out of 5 by guests. Check the opening hours and menu for the latest availability.
What Customers Say About FarFalle
FarFalle is praised for its pizza, especially the thin-crust New York style slices and personal pies. Frank and the crew are often mentioned positively. However, some customers report issues with inconsistent pricing, burnt or undercooked pizza, and occasional poor service.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: If you're a fan of thin-crust New York-style pizza, this place is worth a try. Be sure to check your bill and confirm pricing, as some customers have reported discrepancies.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around FarFalle
FarFalle is located in Oceanside, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Parks & Gardens
- Lotts Pond County Park (A 502m) — park in the United States of America
- Veterans Memorial Park (A 632m) — park in Nassau County, New York, United States of America; geonames ID = 6348663
- Silver Lake Park (A 825m) — park in Nassau County, New York, United States of America
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about FarFalle
FarFalle Oceanside Reviews
I have eaten here for years food has always been top notch. The service is great. The owner does a great job with catering they have done a bunch of party for me. We love there seafood and Sicilian pizza. if you love salads they make a great Farfalle salad
I have eaten here for years food has always been top notch. The service is great. The owner does a great job with catering they have done a bunch of party for me. We love there seafood and Sicilian pizza. if you love salads they make a great Farfalle salad
There plain slices are amazing loved the slices and time I spent there eating and drinking a great drink
Really nice people they make you feel Welcome and the food is very good
Pizza and wings were excellent! Thank you!!
deserves 6 stars!!! native lonGISLANDER and proud member of the 30k+ slice club. this is REAL. OLD. SCHOOL. THINNEST. POSSIBLE. SLICE. NEW YAWK PIZZA! and yet still very filling. it's magic!!! 9.99/10. sorry ... had to add to the review ... people who think this is bad pizza are NOT NEW YORKERS. it's ok. THEIR LOSS.
Hands down thee best Pizza Place around!! Their personal pies are unbelievable…regular slice on the go is to die for and the dinners are second to none. Frank and the crew are amazing…deliveries are always on time or earlier…..you can’t find a better pizza place. 5 🎉
Pizza and wings were excellent! Thank you!!
deserves 6 stars!!! native lonGISLANDER and proud member of the 30k+ slice club. this is REAL. OLD. SCHOOL. THINNEST. POSSIBLE. SLICE. NEW YAWK PIZZA! and yet still very filling. it's magic!!! 9.99/10. sorry ... had to add to the review ... people who think this is bad pizza are NOT NEW YORKERS. it's ok. THEIR LOSS.
There plain slices are amazing loved the slices and time I spent there eating and drinking a great drink
Very good food. Always on time and never an issue.
Really nice people they make you feel Welcome and the food is very good
Hands down thee best Pizza Place around!! Their personal pies are unbelievable…regular slice on the go is to die for and the dinners are second to none. Frank and the crew are amazing…deliveries are always on time or earlier…..you can’t find a better pizza place. 5 🎉
Neighborhood restaurant. Usually empty with no wait. Quick service. Food is very good.
Great place for pizza and heroes great assortment of all kinds of Italian dishes great place to grab a quick bite or dine in
Very tasty pizza ate 3 slices and a scillian would recommend the pizzeria !!!!!!
Neighborhood restaurant. Usually empty with no wait. Quick service. Food is very good.
Great place for pizza and heroes great assortment of all kinds of Italian dishes great place to grab a quick bite or dine in
Its good pizza, 100%, but they tend to forget that they put pizza in the oven. I've gotten burnt pizza one too many times. But their pies aren't so bad if you don't rush them. If you get there too early they are perfectly happy to give you an undercooked pizza.
Pizza is average. Pasta is okay with fine dining prices. Very expensive for what it is. Both and 1 beer and 2 glasses of wine. $85.00 + tip
Its good pizza, 100%, but they tend to forget that they put pizza in the oven. I've gotten burnt pizza one too many times. But their pies aren't so bad if you don't rush them. If you get there too early they are perfectly happy to give you an undercooked pizza.
Pizza is average. Pasta is okay with fine dining prices. Very expensive for what it is. Both and 1 beer and 2 glasses of wine. $85.00 + tip
Ordered Calzone with ham and chicken cutlet parmesan. Both were just okay. Wish it was better. 2 stars
Ordered Calzone with ham and chicken cutlet parmesan. Both were just okay. Wish it was better. 2 stars
Probably one of the worst slices I ever had. I should have known the place wasn’t that good; on a main road and no one was in there. All the slices looked old. Everything looked like an extra thin crust. The slices are smaller than the average slice. The sauce has no real taste. Larger crust so less pizza. Heated up and there is NO crunch to the slice. None. The adults were not friendly. One of the younger kids kept banging a pizza pan. Spanish music blaring. Nothing about this place is authentic and to charge $3 for this pitiful slice is a shame. Do not recommend.
Probably one of the worst slices I ever had. I should have known the place wasn’t that good; on a main road and no one was in there. All the slices looked old. Everything looked like an extra thin crust. The slices are smaller than the average slice. The sauce has no real taste. Larger crust so less pizza. Heated up and there is NO crunch to the slice. None. The adults were not friendly. One of the younger kids kept banging a pizza pan. Spanish music blaring. Nothing about this place is authentic and to charge $3 for this pitiful slice is a shame. Do not recommend.
Horrible horrible food. I've given it 2 chances and both times the pizza was nasty and thrown out.
They are very recist becus I speak español they charge me more for the pizza and we’re very mean when me
So my issue is pricing, which is what brought me here to let others know. I ordered a large house salad with grilled chicken, which is an average price around $14. They charged me $25, which blew my mind after seeing the bank statement for my debit card. When I asked the owner why so high, it’s because I order the “large”, which was a normal size everywhere else. When asked to hear the break down, it was $19 for the salad, a credit card charge and the tip. Didn’t seem like a valid explanation. Ask for prices before you order here, they lost my business.
I ordered a lasagna with meat sauce they brought me lasagna that had pork sausage chopped up on there and had the nerve to charge my card for $21 the delivery driver came and told me my card didn't cover the full amount and asked me for $7. So I paid $28 for something I couldn't even eat. when I called to discuss this they told me I was wrong and my card wasn't charged for $21. I'll never order anything from this place. Customer satisfaction is not important here. thumbs down 👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎 over charged for pork lasagna and a bunch of bread stuffed inside the bag. thanks I wouldn't give them a single star. The person I discussed the problem with was very nasty and unreasonable
I was next door waiting on my wife to finish her appt.. and found this pizzeria to have a bite to eat while I wait..and upon entering I was ignored looked at and continued to be ignored ...the spanish man with the salt and pepper hair didn't even acknowledge me and made me feel as if I was bothering him and he was doing me a favor ...I will never step foot in here again and will tell all my friends and family to avoid too
I called trying to speak to the manager or the owner, I received a message that they only come in once every four months. My purpose to speak to the manager is that I ordered a pie and the person behind the counter charge me $25 thinking that was a normal price as I’m new to the area I paid it I checked online and it was $19. The person behind the counter ripped me off will never go here again.
On 9/12/20, I pick up just a large pie which came out to be $8 and change, charged it on my credit card. Two weeks later when I saw my credit card bill, it stated Farfalle Pizzeria over charged me...it was billed for $19.24 Just for a pie.
They are very recist becus I speak español they charge me more for the pizza and we’re very mean when me
I was next door waiting on my wife to finish her appt.. and found this pizzeria to have a bite to eat while I wait..and upon entering I was ignored looked at and continued to be ignored ...the spanish man with the salt and pepper hair didn't even acknowledge me and made me feel as if I was bothering him and he was doing me a favor ...I will never step foot in here again and will tell all my friends and family to avoid too
So my issue is pricing, which is what brought me here to let others know. I ordered a large house salad with grilled chicken, which is an average price around $14. They charged me $25, which blew my mind after seeing the bank statement for my debit card. When I asked the owner why so high, it’s because I order the “large”, which was a normal size everywhere else. When asked to hear the break down, it was $19 for the salad, a credit card charge and the tip. Didn’t seem like a valid explanation. Ask for prices before you order here, they lost my business.
I called trying to speak to the manager or the owner, I received a message that they only come in once every four months. My purpose to speak to the manager is that I ordered a pie and the person behind the counter charge me $25 thinking that was a normal price as I’m new to the area I paid it I checked online and it was $19. The person behind the counter ripped me off will never go here again.
I ordered a lasagna with meat sauce they brought me lasagna that had pork sausage chopped up on there and had the nerve to charge my card for $21 the delivery driver came and told me my card didn't cover the full amount and asked me for $7. So I paid $28 for something I couldn't even eat. when I called to discuss this they told me I was wrong and my card wasn't charged for $21. I'll never order anything from this place. Customer satisfaction is not important here. thumbs down 👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎 over charged for pork lasagna and a bunch of bread stuffed inside the bag. thanks I wouldn't give them a single star. The person I discussed the problem with was very nasty and unreasonable
Horrible horrible food. I've given it 2 chances and both times the pizza was nasty and thrown out.
On 9/12/20, I pick up just a large pie which came out to be $8 and change, charged it on my credit card. Two weeks later when I saw my credit card bill, it stated Farfalle Pizzeria over charged me...it was billed for $19.24 Just for a pie.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
2 Photos
Explore FarFalle's photos
About FarFalle
How to get there
396 Merrick Rd, Oceanside, NY 11572
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
396 Merrick Rd, Oceanside, NY 11572
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Upcoming Events
San Diego Strike Force vs. Northern Arizona Wranglers
23 May 2026, 19:00
Frontwave Arena
Oceanside Bombers vs. Kentucky Barrels
24 May 2026, 17:00
Frontwave Arena
KSON's Leading Ladies... LIVE!
29 May 2026, 19:00
Frontwave Arena
Oceanside Bombers vs. Minnesota Monsters
07 Jun. 2026, 17:00
Frontwave Arena
park in the United States of America
park in Nassau County, New York, United States of America; geonames ID = 6348663
park in Nassau County, New York, United States of America
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at FarFalle and other restaurants
Earn Points at FarFalle!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at FarFalle
🏆 Rewards at FarFalle
10% Discount
At FarFalle
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu