Best Italian Restaurants in Rochester

4.5 avg. rating 22 restaurants 22,775 reviews
Looking for the best Italian restaurants in Rochester? Browse our curated list of 22 top-rated Italian spots. The average rating is 4.5/5 based on 22,775 real Google reviews. From casual eateries to fine dining, find the perfect Italian restaurant for any occasion.

What people say

Kyle Matesic

This a very cool little spot. I had been working on the area for 8/9 weeks driving by like 2-3 times a week. I finally stopped. I regret not stopping sooner. Food is great. I loved the almond cone. I got the steak sub. It’s HUGE and tasty. Thank you. They have all kinds of stuff in here. Deli. Some...

About Carabala's

Jes I

I used to live in Rochester in my earlier days. Graduated from high school. There went on to college in another state and of course I came back to visit family and friends and I'm telling you each and every time I came back you find me right there in the line getting my steak sub. This is the best s...

About Carabala's

Miss Alisha

What a gem this place is. Immediately greeted by all staff as soon as we walked in. Several options of Italian cuisine you don't typically find in the grocery store with fresh made baked goods. Stopped in for some subs and they were perfect you really get a good amount of meat on these subs which is...

About Carabala's

Ron Caruso

The Best of the Best ! No need to go anywhere else Dominick & Dina and the rest of the employees are the BEST !!! The food speaks for itself…. My only go to place for subs - cold cuts -and cheeses I live in California but originally from Rochester but I still order from there and have it shipped not...

About Carabala's

Kimmie Kim

One of the best Deli sandwiches I've eaten..I've traveled all over the US and even out of the country and nothing compares..The sandwich I had was the Dominator..fresh bread..turkey..lettuce, tomato choice of cheese and the sauce they add to kick up the flavor is absolutely delish..the portion size...

About Carabala's