Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn

4.5 avg. rating 135 restaurants 90,258 reviews
Brooklyn, a borough renowned for its diverse culinary landscape, truly shines when it comes to Italian cuisine. From classic red-sauce joints that evoke a sense of nostalgia to innovative trattorias pushing the boundaries of traditional flavors, the options are as varied as the neighborhoods themselves. Whether you're strolling through the brownstone-lined streets of Carroll Gardens, exploring the vibrant energy of Williamsburg, or seeking a cozy spot in Bay Ridge, you're never far from an authentic Italian meal.

pos.do is your ultimate guide to navigating Brooklyn's rich Italian dining scene. We've meticulously curated a selection of the finest establishments, ensuring you find the perfect place for any occasion. Currently, our platform features an impressive 73 Italian restaurants across Brooklyn, each contributing to the borough's reputation as a prime destination for pasta, pizza, and everything in between.

Diners on pos.do have spoken, and the numbers tell a compelling story. These 73 restaurants collectively boast an outstanding average Google rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars, based on a staggering total of 51422 reviews. This high praise reflects the consistent quality, warm hospitality, and genuine passion found in Brooklyn's Italian eateries. It's clear that chefs and restaurateurs here are dedicated to delivering memorable experiences, whether through a perfectly al dente carbonara, a wood-fired Neapolitan pizza, or a decadent tiramisu.

For those seeking the absolute best, pos.do highlights several establishments that have achieved near-perfect scores. Cremini's, Terina, and Amuni all stand out with an exceptional rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars. These top-rated gems exemplify the pinnacle of Italian dining in Brooklyn, offering exquisite dishes, impeccable service, and an ambiance that transports you straight to Italy. From family-friendly trattorias to romantic, intimate settings, the perfect Italian meal awaits you in Brooklyn. Explore pos.do today and discover your next favorite spot.

What people say

Kateri Fischer

Decent place near the Barclays which was ideal since I came into the city for the Liberty game, the other night! The place was packed for a Taco Tuesday, the service was phenomenal! My only advice is having a happy hour menu for folks coming to see a basketball game or concert. The place would do re...

About Psta

Annedrea Coleman

Tiny’s Menu was cute! We visited during NYC Restaurant Week. The server, Frank, was a newbie. He did a great job! Very attentive and helpful. The manager also did a great checking in with him and our table to ensure all was well! I’ll definitely be back for another Margarita flight 🍹

About Psta

Hailey Kang

I loved this place!! I had tacos and enchilladas here and both were amazing. I went with 'green sauce' for enchilladas and it was a little spicy- i really enjoyed it. We also tried the nacho of the house and loved it too! With black beans and sauce, nachos were somewhere between crispy and soft. Ove...

About Psta

William Kucmierowski (Brimstone)

Adorable little authentic Mexican restaurant in the heart of Brooklyn. Everything is fresh, flavorful and well portioned - You can't go wrong with a single menu item! The unique Birria Tacos with Consume is levels above the rest, full of flavor, while the Carnitas Taco was moist and made to perfecti...

About Psta

Sorryimalwaysbooked

I never miss the opportunity to head over to Tiny’s Cantina on my self care days. Happy hour from 4-6:30pm SIGN ME UP! I always go on low key days because I’m one of those people who brings a book to the bar and I feel like you get better service when it’s not busy. The service is ALWAYS good when...

About Psta