Downtown Deli
Sandwich · Seneca Falls
About Downtown Deli
En Downtown Deli, llevamos años sirviendo Seneca Falls con nuestros legendarios sándwiches deli, al más puro estilo neoyorquino, generosamente rellenos y elaborados con ingredientes de primera calidad. Somos un clásico local donde la tradición y el sabor se unen para ofrecerte una experiencia delici...
En Downtown Deli, llevamos años sirviendo Seneca Falls con nuestros legendarios sándwiches deli, al más puro estilo neoyorquino, generosamente rellenos y elaborados con ingredientes de primera calidad. Somos un clásico local donde la tradición y el sabor se unen para ofrecerte una experiencia deliciosa e inolvidable. ¡Te esperamos para disfrutar de un bocado auténtico!
What Customers Say About Downtown Deli
Downtown Deli is a beloved spot in Seneca Falls, known for its friendly staff and delicious sandwiches. Customers rave about the fast service and the welcoming atmosphere. Some recent complaints mention inconsistent food quality and unexpected early closures.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Try the 'Star Sandwiches' like 'Donna's A-Ok' for a terrific sub or sandwich.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Downtown Deli
Downtown Deli is located in Seneca Falls, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Religious Buildings
- Seneca Falls Trinity Episcopal Church (A 165m)
- First Presbyterian Church of Seneca Falls (A 171m)
- Memorial Congregational Church of Seneca Falls (A 291m)
- First United Methodist Church of Seneca Falls (A 410m)
Other Points of Interest
- Mynderse Library (A 97m)
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Downtown Deli
Downtown Deli Seneca Falls Reviews
I complained severely awhile about this place — then came back and help here now (2 pm Sept 16 ‘25) is exceedingly pleasant and friendly. My partner insisted you better post a good review to make up with the last one over a year ago. Sandwich’s are delicious.
Excellent deli. I was visiting for a few days and got a sandwich here every single day. The first day I placed an o line order, and they were switching Point of Sale software, and it didn’t go through. I offered to just reorder and I’d go through the company that runs the online portion, but they were really accommodating and didn’t charge me again for the same order. Their pickles are perfect, and the sandwhiches are just the right size and melody of flavor. I’ll be back when I’m up here again.
Fast delivery.i recommend the Bedford falls sandwich with chicken noodle soup.
I love going here for lunch. The staff is friendly. They build a sandwich that is like one I make for myself at home. A wide variety is offered on their menu. I always look forward to a stop a the Downtown Deli.
I love this deli. It literally screams 1950s. I got their breakfast sandwich and it blew me away. The staff are so friendly and I love the ambiance. The iced tea is great and I absolutely love their portrait of Times Square.
Great, delicious options. Friendly staff. Very clean. A great place to visit when in town.
I had a last-minute order for a sandwich platter. The ladies that took care of me were absolutely amazing. Taking my last-minute order thank you, Nicole.
Downtown Deli felt like home with a twist of ambiance including a whole crew of hostesses (every employee greets you); personal chefs, and barista's: I recommend everything on the menu. It was my first time visiting, a business meeting brought me to this area. I will be visiting for the beauty of your community and hospitality and kindness of those I met. An inspired day indeed - 5 stars ⭐🤩
Delicious beef barley soup. I love that individual wine🍷 bottles are available or at this deli. I don't usually like a mayo-based potato salad, but this is quite good. I didn't ask if the It's A Wonderful Life named menu items was a temporary thing or for the Festival, but it is clever.
I go here for lunch several times a month because it is a healthier choice. For the first time I ordered a lunch special scalloped potatoes a few weeks back and it was a hit, I will order every time it becomes a lunch special. They also have ziti lunch special also good (better than most locally). Love the lunch portions and soup and sandwich portions not on the heavy side.
Great service and great vibe. Sandwich really could be so much better. Make sure the pork fat is removed from the roast pork. Had a gross chunk of fat. And a good portion of my sandwich had nothing on it. Just spread it out more. It was also pretty lite on meat. I wanted to live it but it was pretty mediocre product. Love the staff and environment though.
Used to love them. they close unexpectedly before 6 on a Friday night when they are supposed to be open until 7. The sandwiches, especially focaccia have been going downhill now that they aren't wrapped (dry) but are in cardboard boxes. Won’t be ordering again.
Food definitely is overpriced for the quality, but holy cow is the customer service horrendous. Crazy how every employee seemingly hates their job, and the one lady that’s been there for years is the worst. Assuming it’s a management/ownership issue.
after 13 years of going here, the food has progressively gotten awful over the past few years to the point i no longer desire it, how you go from 5 stars to 1 star is crappy food now somehow. nothing tastes like it did when i started going there. Sauders still tastes the same after all these years.....what happened here?
The chicken in the gyro was similar to chicken in a McDonald's chicken nugget. Just mushy processed meat. No grill marks probably microwaved. Ordered a steak and cheese sub to get roast beef for a beef on weck as the steak for a steak sub. Idk if roast beef passes as steak for me. The roast beef sub was better than the gyro. Uses Costanzo rolls when they should be making a fresh roll as well. They could do better for sure.
I live in Seneca Falls. I have eaten here many times over the past 3 years. The food has progressively gotten worse, however the service has remained the same stale, unpleasant energy as my first time there. Recommended by other locals I was excited to try and being a Rochester native and overall foodie I was not impressed. I had a turkey sandwich with dry turkey and wet bread. I decided to try again, maybe a fluke. I went again unplanned with a coworker during lunch. Macaroni salad had went bad. Tables were sticky. Overall environment was uninviting.
Knowing we were approaching close time, we walked in at 6:40 and asked. Could we just get a sandwich to go? The lady turned her back on us and went and talk to another woman which didn’t even look at us and continue stocking the shelves so we walked out.
First, I order from here quite a bit. Never had a problem. Today, I ordered the lunch special- "Chicken Broccoli Alfredo". What arrived to me was definitely not that. More like chicken and dumplings on mushy mushy noodles. It was horrible. My coworker said the same thing but was somehow able to eat hers. I called to complain and ask if we had gotten the wrong thing only to be told that no, this is correct. It has carrots and little red peppers in it. Barely any chicken and the broccoli was incredibly mushy, though not quite as bad as the noodles. The only way they would refund (or I even volunteered to get put on a list for another lunch a different day) was by sending someone out to collect it. Gross. But since I didn't eat it, go for it. I ordered sandwiches also and didn't ask for a refund on those so I can't believe they thought I was lying but the fact that they're gonna pay someone to come all the way back and collect it is weird. And super off putting. I will never order again. Now both my coworker and I are not feeling great. Don't EVER order chicken and broccoli Alfredo. And just keep in mind the owner has crappy customer service skills if that's how she treats people who have ordered many times before and have never received a complaint.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Eddie O'Briens Grille and Bar
The Linden Social Club
Man Yuan
Portico at del Lago Resort and Casino
Blue Ribbon Smoke House & Restaurant
Little Italy
Ling Ling Chinese Buffet
Monaco's Coffee
Ciccino's
Wendy's
14 Photos
Explore Downtown Deli's photos
About Downtown Deli
How to get there
53 Fall St, Seneca Falls, NY 13148
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
53 Fall St, Seneca Falls, NY 13148
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Downtown Deli and other restaurants
Earn Points at Downtown Deli!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Downtown Deli
🏆 Rewards at Downtown Deli
10% Discount
At Downtown Deli
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu