Menu
Old Cove Pub
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Water Mill

Old Cove Pub

★★★★ 3.9 · 0 reseñas

En Old Cove Pub, te damos la bienvenida a un ambiente familiar y acogedor, donde podrás disfrutar de platos clásicos de mariscos y bistró. Nuestra decoración rústica y nuestra terraza te invitan a relajarte mientras saboreas la frescura del mar. Ven a descubrir un rincón especial...

Old Cove Pub

Bar · Water Mill

3.9 · 1,086 reviews Google

About Old Cove Pub

En Old Cove Pub, te damos la bienvenida a un ambiente familiar y acogedor, donde podrás disfrutar de platos clásicos de mariscos y bistró. Nuestra decoración rústica y nuestra terraza te invitan a relajarte mientras saboreas la frescura del mar. Ven a descubrir un rincón especial en Water Mill, dond...

En Old Cove Pub, te damos la bienvenida a un ambiente familiar y acogedor, donde podrás disfrutar de platos clásicos de mariscos y bistró. Nuestra decoración rústica y nuestra terraza te invitan a relajarte mientras saboreas la frescura del mar. Ven a descubrir un rincón especial en Water Mill, donde la buena comida y el buen ambiente se unen.

What Customers Say About Old Cove Pub

Old Cove Pub is known for its beautiful waterfront location, decor, and lively atmosphere, making it a great spot for summer outings. Many reviewers praise the service, especially mentioning Moses and Lisette. While some find the food exceptional, others find it bland or inconsistent.

Popular Dishes

calamari (3) olive oil cake lobster fettuccine octopus Cove Burger bronzino oysters buffalo brussel sprouts

Best For

Couples Groups Celebrations Tourists Late Night

Tip: Enjoy the outdoor dining for the views, and consider trying the calamari. Be aware that music can be loud, especially in the evening.

Features

🌳 Outdoor 🅿️ Parking 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner Coffee
🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy 💕 Romantic Trendy 👔 Upscale 👨‍👩‍👧 Family 👥 Groups

What to see nearby

Garvies Point Preserve
A 586m

Garvies Point Preserve

parque

View details
Pratt Park
A 782m

Pratt Park

parque

View details
Plaza Park
A 886m

Plaza Park

parque

View details
Reservoir Park
A 957m

Reservoir Park

parque

View details

Data from Wikidata

Explore the area around Old Cove Pub

Old Cove Pub is located in Water Mill, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.

Parks & Gardens

  • Garvies Point Preserve (A 586m) — park in Nassau County, New York, United States of America
  • Pratt Park (A 782m) — park in Nassau County, New York, United States of America
  • Plaza Park (A 886m) — park in Nassau County, New York, United States of America
  • Reservoir Park (A 957m) — park in the Nassau County, New York, United States of America

Data from Wikidata

Frequently asked questions about Old Cove Pub

Old Cove Pub is located at 74 Shore Rd #3427, Glen Cove, NY 11542, Water Mill.
Near Old Cove Pub you can find points of interest such as Garvies Point Preserve, Pratt Park, Plaza Park, Reservoir Park.
Old Cove Pub offers bar cuisine.
Old Cove Pub has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.
Old Cove Pub offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway.
The most recommended dishes at Old Cove Pub based on customer reviews are: calamari, olive oil cake, lobster fettuccine, octopus, Cove Burger.
Old Cove Pub is ideal for couples, groups, celebrations, tourists, late night.
Old Cove Pub is known for its beautiful waterfront location, decor, and lively atmosphere, making it a great spot for summer outings. Many reviewers praise the service, especially mentioning Moses and Lisette. While some find the food exceptional, others find it bland or inconsistent.
Enjoy the outdoor dining for the views, and consider trying the calamari. Be aware that music can be loud, especially in the evening.
1,086
Reviews

Old Cove Pub Water Mill Reviews

3.9
1,086
5★
52%
4★
19%
3★
10%
2★
5%
1★
13%
Reviews (21)
SHAUN BEAUREGARD
SHAUN BEAUREGARD

Always a great spot for a post game dinner. Even better when the Sharks win!! Moses took great care of us and made some excellent suggestions!!! That olive oil cake was delish

Jamie Pavlou
Jamie Pavlou

Just threw a wonderful surprise party for my moms 60th! The DJ was fantastic and played disco all night so she could dance. Setting up the party was easy, Katherine and Phillip were a joy to work with. The food is delicious especially the keftethes (meatballs) and Mac and cheese on a spoon. The spicy margarita is a favorite and delicious martinis (espresso & dirty). Will be back soon for regular dinner!!

Johan Chabrel
Johan Chabrel

We had an enjoyable experience outside dining with views of sailboats and sunshine. Food isn't exceptional but for that view it's worth it. Great service. Try the whole fish 🐟

Britney Hernandez
Britney Hernandez

Such great customer service from Lawrence. He was very attentive and gave great recommendations. I would recommend the calamari. The steak and lamb chops could use some flavor and to be of temperature. The view outside is amazing and well worth it!

Rayhana Fazily
Rayhana Fazily

Happened to be in the area on a Saturday afternoon and decided to try The Cove- our server Lisette was so helpful and kind and made some amazing recommendations. The octopus, bronzino and the oysters were to dieeee for! We ended the meal with a delicious olive oil cake with fig gelato! We can’t wait to come back, 10/10 :)

Eligio M. Peralta
Eligio M. Peralta

We absolutely enjoyed our dining experience at this restaurant! The staff was friendly and welcoming from the moment we arrived. Their grilled octopus is an absolute must-try 10/10! We also loved the seared salmon and their Cove Burger, which were delicious and cooked to perfection. The spicy salmon roll also stood out. For drinks, you can't go wrong with their Classic Margarita on the rocks or the Old Fashioned. The service was truly exceptional. We have to give a special thanks to Hector, Manuel, and Jennifer, who made our dinner experience great. We loved the cleanliness, music, and the overall vibe of the place. We strongly recommend making a reservation, as we didn't have to wait at all. For the best view, try to go when the sun is setting! We finished with the lava cake for dessert, and while it was good, it wasn't the best we have ever tried. Overall, this was a fantastic experience with great food and excellent taff. We will definitely be visiting again!

Jill Fratkin
Jill Fratkin

Wonderful place to enjoy their location on the water. Food and service top notch. We had shorts and t-shirts on from the day of boating. They have outside and inside seating and was no problem to seat us inside with the more formally dressed customers. Service was above and beyond and warranted above standard tipping.

Citlalli Tapia
Citlalli Tapia

I loved my experience at The Cove The food was absolutely delicious — the calamari, the rolls, and the lobster fettuccine were my favorites. I also loved the dessert and the cocktails. Everything has that fresh, summery touch, from the decor to the vibe at the bar. I really liked that they have live music too! It's the kind of place that instantly puts you in a good mood. Perfect for a relaxed outing with great food, good vibes, and excellent service. Highly recommended!

meli
meli

The perfect place to enjoy the summer! From the moment you arrive, the decor and atmosphere wrap you in a super fresh and relaxed vibe. We had the calamari (so delicious!!!), some super fresh and tasty rolls, the lobster fettuccine which was incredible, and we finished with a delicious dessert and a perfect espresso martini. The cocktails overall were really refreshing and thoughtfully made. I started off at the bar and had such a great time — the music, the ambiance, everything gives off that summer mood we all love. I’m definitely coming back! My server Miguel was very friendly

Clarissa C
Clarissa C

I would give The Cove 6 stars if I could! First of all, the waterfront location is beautiful. They have so many seating options, including outdoor (heated in some areas if it's cool), indoor and bar. They have an outdoor bar and lounge area which is perfect for a night out in the summer. They offer live music on the weekends. They also have docking space available! The food is impeccable with a Mediterranean influence. Everything is delicious and I love the selection of menu items. The cocktails are also carefully crafted and fresh. The service is really nice! This place is great for a date night, a night out with friends or even a special occasion like birthdays or graduations.

Kelli Packman
Kelli Packman

This restaurant is gorgeous!! Right on the water and the decor is just as beautiful. We tried their tapas special first and everything was really yummy - the buffalo brussel sprouts are a must try! Moses was our bartender and he was so kind & knowledgeable. Drinks were pretty and tasty. We also tried the Naruto sushi roll which was fresh & delicious and their seafood spaghetti which was served in a fantastic spicy sauce - another must try! We will be back on a sunny day and sit outside!

Nafeesa Awan
Nafeesa Awan

We had an incredible dining experience at The Cove in Glen Cove. From the ambiance to the service, everything felt upscale yet inviting. We started with a round of mocktails, which were thoughtfully crafted—balanced, refreshing, and beautifully presented. A great non-alcoholic option that didn’t feel like an afterthought. The sushi was fresh and clean, with a nice variety of textures and flavors. The calamari was lightly crispy on the outside and tender inside, with just the right amount of seasoning. For mains, we shared the lobster roll and lobster fettuccine. The roll was generously filled and buttery, served with a perfectly toasted bun. The fettuccine was rich, creamy, and packed with lobster—comfort food elevated to something special. We ended on a high note with the lava cake. It was warm, decadent, and paired wonderfully with the ice cream—an indulgent, satisfying finish. Highly recommend for a date night, a nice evening out with friends, or any time you want a quality seafood experience with a bit of flair. We’ll definitely be back.

Hope Savvides
Hope Savvides

The views were so beautiful we took so many beautiful photos. The food was yummy. Just wished the village Greek salad was a bit more it was a lot smaller than other Greek restaurants. The dessert was very nice . Overall we loved it.

Chris Tina
Chris Tina

Wow! Make sure to get here on a Friday night. Beautiful ambiance. Feels like you're in Mykonos and not in a city. Food is great and the drinks are very tasty. Great music and decor. The lack of 5-stars is just that the temperature inside on an 80 degree night was not comfortable for my guests and some couldn't eat due to feeling ill. Be sure to choose outdoors on a nice night anyway. It is an absolute cool place!

Ellen Holland
Ellen Holland

The food was very good, the decor was beautiful, seats comfortable, great view. However, my husband never got the drink he asked for, the music from the club outside was too loud in the dining room, and probably could use more staff.

A
Amy C

The setting for the restaurant is lovely… views of the water….pretty lighting….and the dishes were good but its a false front for what the restaurant becomes once the clock strikes about 8pm. Thots… the line for the restroom….just ruins everything nice about it. The restaurant also may be understaffed or poorly managed because initially there’s good attention to the table but after 2 drinks the server just stops coming around and so we ended up not ordering another round of drinks and we flagged down the server for our bill.

Stephanie Charles
Stephanie Charles

I enjoyed the outdoor dining by the dock, and the decor was nice. However, the food left much to be desired. I ordered the steak and eggs, while my son had chicken fingers and fries. Unfortunately, the steak and eggs were bland, even though I requested chimichurri sauce to go with the steak. On a positive note, the margarita was quite good. I ordered a margarita on the rocks, but the menu only listed frozen margaritas. Because I asked for it on the rocks, they charged me an extra $4. I didn't appreciate that, as there was no indication on the menu that there would be an additional fee for this request. The server should have mentioned it, or it should have been clearly noted on the menu.

Chandra Pitamber
Chandra Pitamber

The Cove is definitely an aesthetic spot – perfect for drinks and pictures with its stylish setup and lively vibe. If you’re looking for a cute backdrop for Instagram and a fun cocktail or two, it’s worth a visit. But when it comes to the food, it was a huge letdown. Everything we ordered was bland, lacked seasoning, and felt like a total waste of money. For a place that puts so much effort into the ambiance, it’s disappointing that the food doesn’t match up. I’d only recommend going for the vibes and drinks – definitely not for the meal.

Joseph Miner
Joseph Miner

Came here last weekend for dinner with my family, including our newborn, for a 7:45 reservation. Though it's billed as such in the description, I wouldn't exactly call this a family-friendly restaurant, not in the evening at least. We were seated inside and it was like dining at a nightclub. Loud edm music you need to shout over to be heard, club type patrons, long lines for the bathroom. Loud drunk conversations. I know, we live in a society and all that, but family friendly was the expectation. The parking lot kid at the gate with the Gen Z mop haircut is rude and dismissive, playing on his phone without a care for hospitality. The duo of bouncers were very cool and welcoming, although a bit of a red flag in itself (bouncers at a restaurant?) Waiter was professional and efficient, although extremely busy so we were a bit neglected. Food took a while, which made enduring the loud party atmosphere difficult, but it was excellent when it arrived. I got the lobster fettucine and enjoyed it. This is a great place for singles or a date or a fun night with friends, but not for the wife, kids and in laws. Not dinner at least.

Suzie Singh
Suzie Singh

Service was horrible. We had an 8.45 reservation and got seated 940p. I had to leave my table several times to look for a waiter for a refill on our beverages . Kudos to the bartender he made a dynamic dirty martini. I was so disappointed with the food I didnt touch my dinner . Looks like my 10 yrs old plated it . The music is very loud you have to shout to hear each other . However the restaurant is beautiful. We reserved a table for 10 for my husband 55th birthday . This restaurant is more of younger individuals early 20s . Drinks fantastic . Food not good . Service was horrible . Ambiance its beautiful

Gustavo Avila
Gustavo Avila

Was sat at table 73 I asked the kid who took us to the table if we can move by the water since it was our anniversary. He said no because the tables are only for 4 people.. server took our order and never returned. The food was amazing and saved the night. I finally found the waiter texting in the rest room . To top it off the hostess sat 2 parties of 2 by the water. We will try again because of the food. Hope you make the changes needed. If you spend 200 with a tip you shouldn’t have to track your server down.

Sign in to leave a review

Sign in
👑 Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Explore Your Area

More restaurants in Water Mill →
📸

91 Photos

Explore Old Cove Pub's photos

Old Cove Pub
Old Cove Pub
Old Cove Pub
Old Cove Pub
Old Cove Pub
+86 More
📍

About Old Cove Pub

How to get there

74 Shore Rd #3427, Glen Cove, NY 11542

Water Mill, NY 11542

Loading map...
Old Cove Pub
Tap for directions

Highlights

💬
Many Reviews
1086 reviews
💰
Moderate Price
Price level
👨‍🍳
bar
Cuisine type

Services

🥐 Brunch
🍽️ Lunch
🍾 Dinner
Coffee
🥡 Takeout
🍴 Dine-in

Dining Options

🍽️ Dine In
🥡 Takeout

Restaurant Info

Status
Verified by owner
🕐 Hours Today
12-11PM
Rating
3.9/5
💬 Reviews
1,086
💰 Price Level
$$
📞 Phone
+1 516-676-1211
🌐 Website
www.thecoveny.com

Amenities

🅿️ Parking
🌿 Outdoor Seating
🚻 Restroom
💳 Credit Cards
🏘️

The Neighborhood

Location

74 Shore Rd #3427, Glen Cove, NY 11542

Water Mill, NY 11542

📍 Explore the Neighborhood

Weather
11°
Weather updated hourly · Jobs and events refreshed daily
Garvies Point Preserve

park in Nassau County, New York, United States of America

A 586m
Pratt Park

park in Nassau County, New York, United States of America

A 782m
Plaza Park

park in Nassau County, New York, United States of America

A 886m
Reservoir Park

park in the Nassau County, New York, United States of America

A 957m
🎮

Gaming

🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!

Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Old Cove Pub and other restaurants

🎮

Earn Points at Old Cove Pub!

Play Find Me and redeem rewards here

Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Old Cove Pub

🏆 Rewards at Old Cove Pub

💰

10% Discount

At Old Cove Pub

1000 pts
Available
🍽️

Free Appetizer

On your next visit

2500 pts
Limited
👑

VIP Table

Premium experience

5000 pts
Exclusive

to redeem rewards and earn points

📋 How Do Rewards Work?

1

Play Find Me

Every 100 score points = 1 reward point

2

Collect Points

Workers earn 2x points per game

3

Redeem Rewards

Discounts, free food and VIP experiences

Call
Leave a Review on Google
👑

Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Sign in & Play

Check your email!

No password needed — we'll email you a link

We sent you an access link

Check your spam folder if you don't see it