Lyndsey Massey

Nice cafe for lunch. Inside a shopping plaza. Reminds me of a panara bread, maybe a little more pricey. Staff was kind to me not so much to each other. Plenty of seating inside I got the panzanella and pasta. Was delicious!

Sanjiv Talwar

Soup and sandwiches for us. Jamaican jerk soup was bountiful pun intended with chicken beans celery. Very flavorful too. Ham & cheese was nothing really to write home about. Cranberry chicken sandwich was Right amount of condiments and the grilled sandwich tasted amazing. Linzer tart was supposed to be icing for the brunch was kind of soggy. All in all a bit underwhelming…..

jamie k

EDIT: Although I had the issue described below I was incredibly impressed with the integrity of this business - they made it right. They refunded the cost of my salad, and went the extra mile to send me a gift card so we could both try again. In a day were customer service is virtually non existent, this is everything. Bountiful Bread, I thank you! Got a Cobb salad and for $17 I expect more than just a tiny bowl filled with excess tomato and cucumber. Very disappointed, and I feel ripped off and hungry. This place used to be great and had phenomenal salads, but now not so much. The quality and care is severely lacking.

L C

I’m a frequent customer of bountiful bread. This is the second time I’ve picked up an order and returned to work to have things missing. Today I was given no salad dressing for my order which ultimately makes my meal inedible until I can get home and get some. And the chicken and rice soup I ordered today had no rice and was basically just meat. The attention to detail has really gone down which is unfortunate since I enjoy the soup and salad combo. I called to notify an employee today of this error and she said to me “I’ll notify our manager thanks” and hung up. Not impressed at all, especially for a $20 lunch combo.

Emily Lilly

This was a nice place to stop off for lunch. We took home some rolls that were delicious and we stayed for lunch as well. The sandwich was alright but I think it just wasn't to my taste. The pasta salad was really good and also the tomato pesto soup. I'll definitely come back and try another order!

Lauren Cole

Sadly the sandwich I get every time I come has changed. The bread changes. Smaller and stale. Not like their old baguettes that were large and soft. Three slices of tomato and some mozzarella for $15. I paid $2 for prosciutto which they didn’t add which was a bummer. I did to go so I didn’t notice until I got to my office. Will not return. Quality went WAY down

Meaghan Hurley

I've been going to Bountiful Bread for years and always loved it! But have been disappointed in the past few months. Prices have gone up but quality has gone down. Purchased a Caesar salad with chicken (see photos) and charging $14 for a salad that doesn't even fill the container and has brown lettuce. Also purchased a chicken pesto sandwich recently and noticed a premade one was taken out of the fridge. I requested it to be grilled but it was still cold when I bit into it! I understand refrigerating for efficiency, but a grilled sandwich shouldn't be cold.

Another disgusting capital area eatery. Why are you serving sad, wilted, improperly washed lettuce? Nasty. Easily the worst salad I’ve had in NY. Their house dressing is a thick gloopy nightmare, not a dressing. The chicken that’s included is 3 measly, rubbery, dry, nearly frozen nubs. I’d rather chew on a catheter bag. Now, I don’t normally complain about a piece of bread, but seeing as how this is “bountiful bread”, it should be mentioned. And wow, the baguette was day old, stale, and tasteless. So maybe their supply is not bountiful enough, or even well made. Whoever managed today 2/10/26 should be ashamed. I wish I could have my money back. Thanks for reading.

Anna Jansor

Love love love the tomato pesto soup and the rocky mountain muffins. They used to be worth a trip out to Stuyvesant plaza just to get some. Unfortunately, they've been hit hard by inflation. While sick at home and craving their soup badly a few years ago, I planned an order of it on door dash until I was sticker shocked to see that one bowl of soup costs nearly as much as a sit down meal! Out of curiosity, I looked at the menu prices for the fine dining, full service restaurant next door to them and found the pricing to be nearly the same as Bountiful Bread, where you have to order, pick up your food and bus your own table for the same cost. I would definitely return if the prices could be more reasonable!

Suzanne Smith

I ordered 2 6" cakes: 1 lemon, and 1 strawberry and cream. Both were VERY disappointing. About 75% of each cake was a heavy frosting. There was very little filling and it was only in the center of the cakes (rather than spread across each layer). And neither cake had much taste due, I think, to the overpowering sweetness of the frosting. I will not order from this bakery again.

Kyle Potter

Unfortunately was so disappointed. Spent 50 dollars on avacado toast, power bowl and soup. Soup was room temp, the power bowl everything on it was ice cold including the cold eggs. The beans and corn seemed like they were just straight out of a can. The avacado did not seem like real fresh avacado and was spread in a thin paste

Alex C

I typically don’t go out of my way to write bad reviews, but I ordered a caesar salad wrap, with chicken. Got a grilled chicken wrap with about 3 pieces of lettuce throughout the whole thing. Point being it needs more lettuce and less chicken. Entire wrap was smaller than my fists and it was $16.

Alex Sardo

Went to the bountiful bread location in Stuyvesant plaza just to get tomato soup for dinner. I showed up 20 minutes prior to closing and was told that the soup was put away for the night. I guess the full menu isn’t available if they are closing soon.