robert white

Have been a customer for nearly 50 years and my most recent visit did not disappoint. I was born around here and my family moved away when I was pretty young, but I’ve never been back to Herkimer without at least grabbing a pizza at Yetty’s. Added some riggies and wings to the take-out order this time and everything was FANTASTIC! Great pepper flavor in the riggies and don’t sleep on the garlic bread. It was my wife’s first time here. She’s not easy to impress with pizza and pasta, but thought the food was great and really appreciated your extra-friendly service when picking up the order. Thanks for continuing to deliver the goods after so many years. See y’all again in a few years!

Brian “I'm BAK” K

Great service, great food! Tried to go to New Italian place around the corner, they closed early, they ran out of food!

+1

Ivan Hinkle

Excellent food, good service and very clean. Can't wait to try other dishes.

La Nissa Dyman

We have pretty good Italian Restaurants in our town but nothing like this. Hands down the best sauce we've had a long time. The service was incredible. Clean environment. Plenty of seating. Plenty of street parking. Very reasonable prices. Plenty of food options to pick from no matter what mood you're in.

Mo W

Yettys chicken tenders are so good. If you're not into upside-down pizza, visit for the other menu items. I had tendies, pizza, & Cinnamon sugar fried dough bites. All were so yummy. The dining room is lovely. OH! They sell shirts & hoodies with a clever slogan!

Mark Lovato

2nd time visiting better than the first time. I got the shrimp riggies and my wife got the cheese pizza. The pizza she said was fine but lacked cheese as seen in the pictures The riggies were a bit tasteless mild shouldn't mean no heat.(normally I go hot but the last time it was not edible the amount of peppers they added.) The sauce was broken and had chunks of curdled heavy cream in it. The bread hasn't changed its just heated no flavor and a little wirl added on tip with parm cheese.

The names TP

Bought from here 4 times so far and every time my order gets messed up. food is decent but wow cant get orders right if their life depended on it. this time i asked for Swiss cheese on my sub and i get absolutely no cheese, like if u have questions about an order whats so hard about re calling the person and double checking or double checking b4 u hang up??? every time its something new with this place

Lourdes Fumarola

To whom every owns yettys in herkiner I want to start by that I've never in my life time have heard a story like what my husband experienced at you estabishment yesterday. I've been in sales and customer service for over 45 years and I would never dream of treating someone like you did. He came in for something to eat you took his order and his money and after 45 or so mins still he was waiting for a cold sub I mean I cold have maded him a cold some in 5 mins with my eyes closed. People were coming in and out with there orders and he stayed there as patiently as possible and being ignored. He finally ask the young lady how much long and all she said Is well we are very busy. Really!! He asked for his money back and she told him I have to go ask. WHAT!! Here appears a so call manager whom had an attitude toward me husband and said they are wrapping it up she swings the door and yells wrap it up and he asked again all I want is my money back she was do rude he told her to keep the sandwich and his 12.00 which I hope she needed more then him and walked out. So I ask if anyone reads this what are your thoughts about the place and before I decided to write I looked at the reviews and saw that my husband has not been the only person with this kind of experience and as they say sorry we are working on our customers service and obviously nothing has changed. I wish her a merry Christmas and hopes that the $12.00 that she kept from my husband brings her what she needs. I will let everyone I know about this experience unfortunately my husband will never forget that experience. I don't wish for anyone to lose there job just for whom ever owns the place to revisit customer service because with out your customers you would not be in business. Wishing you all a Merry Christmas and Happy New Year!

M G

I dont understand what has happened here recently. Dining in took hours a couple weeks ago and maybe saw a server 2 times. Last night I waited 40 minutes after pick up time at the restaurant for a sub. Meanwhile feeling sorry for the girl whom was taking care of take outs as everyone else seemed to push her around and bully her out of the way to use the card machine. She was the only nice thing about the place and it didnt feel like she actually works there. Have been regularly ordering for years but I dont think we will be back.

Don Bombace

After seeing them Saturday and Sunday morning infomercials by Forever Leather Charlie and Felicia Netti in the past, finally decided to take a ride from Utica to Yetty's and give it a try Sat. Oct 4th at 4pm. When we arrived, went in, there is a small dining area across from the bar with several booths and tables which were full (I would say 12 guests) After standing there and not one employee saying a word to us, I asked one of the two bartenders who were just standing there, how long a wait? One said I have no idea. I offered: "30, 45 minutes?" She said probably unless you want to go outside. So we did and sat in one of the two tables offered. A young employee came out and took our drink order, iced tea and Coke, saying a server will be right out. A full 20 minutes(no lie) passes with zero acknowledgement. Out comes a group of 4 diners looked at us and said, " how long have have you been waiting? We've been here over two hours!" The drink employee came out and said, we are very busy, it's going to be awhile. I went inside, told the bartender we could not wait any longer, just to even place an order. (it wasn't busy, 3/4 of the diners had food) Apparently there was zero leadership, the staff had no idea what they were doing, totally lost. So I went to pay for our drinks and she told us it was all set. We then went to PKs restaurant, it was busy, yet we were in and out in an hour, wonderful service and food.