essential editor

Abitino’s serves really reliable New York-style pizza. The crust is thin and crisp, the sauce has good flavor, and everything is fresh. Being near midtown it’s consistent and convenient. Service is quick and the staff are polite. A good option if you’re in the area and want a classic slice without any fuss.

Fabio

I had a recent appointment at NYU. When I was done, I walked back to the subway and stumbled across a true gem of a pizzeria called Abitino's. I stopped in for a regular slice and a margherita slice. This place is as authentic as it gets when it comes to NY slice pizza. The pizza had the right amount of cheese and sauce and didn't flop down when I picked it up. Simply delicious. It was also nice to see how clean the place was. I can't recommend this place enough.

Max Gammons

It took less than 60 seconds to go in and get INCREDIBLE NY style pizza. A great selection of classic drinks and super nice workers and service. Would HIGHLY recommend if you’re near!

Baohuong Tran

The food here is absolutely delicious! We went here to get a quick lunch after a morning of activities, and this place hit the spot! They don’t have much seating, so be prepared to wait a bit. In general, my kids loved this place, and I definitely recommend this pizzeria!

$8.36 for Grandmama and Margherita pizza slice (both included). Good taste. Clean.

I like Abitino's for their pizza and buffalo chicken tenders. Served with Bleu cheese on top, so tender and packed with flavor. The pasta dishes are good but I usually only get the baked ziti so I cannot confirm more. Oh, they do sell Sangria, and yes it's the real thing. Red or white available.

Stinson Parks III

Great quick grab pizza spot with delicious pies and rolls. I had the pepperoni square pizza and it was quick and tasty. Just how it’s supposed to be done in NYC. Service was helpful as well.

Reza Rad

I was eager for a great pizza. Sadly, it fell short. To be fair, the pizza dough was crispy and had a decent texture, which was a positive. However, the overall quality was disappointing. The pizza and spinach roll had no real flavor. They were bland and unappealing. The ingredients seemed stale. It lacked seasoning. The meal felt incomplete. For the price, I expected much better taste and quality. Sadly, this was not the enjoyable meal I was hoping for.

+3

Thomas Buhl

I’ve lived above this pizza shop for about three years, and every once in a while I’ll grab a slice when I’m in a pinch. Unfortunately, it’s never really impressed me. The flavor often seems off, and the slices are frequently overcooked when reheated. I see their ingredients being delivered in the mornings when I leave for work, and it looks like they’re using good-quality stuff, which makes the end result more disappointing. There’s a newer spot that just opened around the corner that’s become my go-to instead.

Jake Hugues

Came here to grab a quick bite. Service there was rude and unprofessional. Didn't greet me. Just stared at me like I was a burden. Hmm hello I am giving you business lol?? Pricing felt outrageous. I got charged for extra marinara sauce. Two slices and a small drink ran me 16 usd. Take the congestion pricing out on goverment not the hard working customers trying to eat. I was not even told it would be extra i just saw him ring it up as extra on the machine. Of course no receipt was giving to me. Ok let's talk about the food. I got a hot chicken slice it was okay. I also got a margarita slice (not good) the cook made it so hot the cheese and sauce all melted off the slice. They are in a good spot I mean hey after all its a pizzeria in NYC. To the owner you got potential but tell your staff to be more friendly and more transparent with the customers on pricing. I was giving no receipt just rushed out. There was nobody even in line after me...you are not entitled to our money that is not how business works. I hope you read this and change your atmosphere.

Emma Rogers

Came here for a quick slice in between doctors. My dad got the grandma slice and rated it 5/10. He said it was very dry crust and wouldn’t come back. I got a mushroom and pepperoni slice. The mushroom was very bland and not enough sauce. I had to use ALOT of garlic and oregano to season it up. The pepperoni was better but still very sub par. The pepperoni added alot of flavor but still needed seasoning. It was also a bit oily to my liking. I wouldn’t go back again. It lacked a lot of flavor and was expensive for the quality.

Kevin Fisher

On August 19th around 9:40 PM, I left my wallet next to the register while buying a slice. A few minutes later I called the store, but I was yelled at that it wasn’t there and was asked not to call back. Later that night, my wallet’s AirTag still showed it at the store until 11pm, past closing time, and the next morning the AirTag was disabled. I reached out again the following day to ask if the cameras could be checked, but was told the owner was unavailable and haven’t received a reply to my email either. Unfortunately, this left me without answers and I’ve since had to involve my bank and file a report. This was a very disappointing and stressful experience. Edit: First of all you are already lying because I did in fact send you an email 3 days ago, check the picture I posted. Your response shows how disrespectful you are to your customers. Just read your other 1 star reviews, and quite frankly your 5 stars are pretty questionable. I have emailed you and gave you a few days to respond before leaving this review. The fact that you will only respond to me after leaving a review, and flat out lie to save face is disgusting. Let's clear this up once and for all, check your footage, and email me proof that they did not take it. And don't tell me that your footage magically disappeared. I am certain that they took it, but if you prove me wrong I will remove this review

other mail

This is one of the worst pizzas I ever tasted. They show a photo of what the upside down sicilian pizza looks like on ubereats - all sauce on top and cheese underneath, which is how it is in other pizza places. I even called to check this is what is. But When you get the square slice- it’s 99.5% all cheese on top w/ just a dot here, a dot there of literally a small drop of sauce here & there- NOTHING like an upside down square slice. It was awful!! Then their plain cheese and margherita slices looked so dry and stale as if it had been sitting on the counter for ten hours or was from the day before. The margherita was missing sauce on one side of it and looked so dry & stale. The plain cheese had an empty spot with no cheese or sauce on it and was so dry as if it had been sitting there since yesterday. Took a little bite. It was horrible. The grandma slice was advertised in ubereats as being on garlic bread. Nope, no garlic bread. And, did not taste good. Here’s the funniest part— they actually ask you on their ubereats page - would you like LESS SAUCE OR NO SAUCE!!!!! I’m not kidding!! I’ve been eating pizza for many years. It was awful!! One of the worst!!

Private Citizen

If I could give this restaurant zero stars I would. I walked in visibly disabled and the staff began with treating me like a child. There were two men working today. They acted like it was a bother to warm up a crappy slice of pizza. This is a tourist place, not an authentic NYC pizza place. I had ordered a slice of pizza and when they presented a slice at the counter warmed up, I started to grab for it and got spoken to like a child. I asked for my money back because I had not eaten anything. First the counter person refused and then I just said just keep it, nothing quite like stealing from customers. I am disabled, I don’t have the time and energy to deal with ableism. But I went back in and demanded my money back. The fact that one of the staff, any staff member, would be okay with keeping money from a customer when the customer are nothing and drank nothing, after horrific and condescending irrational behavior is beyond me. I should have checked the reviews before I went in.