Greg Whipple

Really enjoyed Roberta's next to MSG. Great location, great atmosphere. Want to come back and check out the outdoor patio are. Downstairs included grab and go slices and upstairs is the restaurant. Food was excellent from each of the pizzas we ordered, perfectly cooked burger, salads, meatballs and the bread with ricotta was real highlight. Overall impressed. Servers were very helpful with our birthday celebration but one in particular seemed a bit brash for no reason, maybe just a bad day so the knock for minus 1 Service star. Otherwise 5 star experience and excited to go back.

LoreKataoka

Roberta’s Pizza at Penny Station is such a hidden gem in New York! The location is super convenient, and the pizza… oh, the pizza is absolutely delicious — perfectly made, full of flavor, and with that authentic taste that wins you over right away. What I really love is the little details: they have a bathroom (which is rare around here!), and right outside there’s a lovely square where you can sit and enjoy your slice in the open air. It makes the whole experience even more charming, with that laid-back city vibe. It’s the kind of spot that combines convenience, amazing food, and a touch of charm in the atmosphere. A place I truly loved discovering and one that’s already on my list of must-stops! 🌿🍕

+4

Suriane Teddies

Roberta’s Penn Station is my go-to pizza stop. Crust always perfect, toppings 🔥, and the vibe just right even in the middle of the Penn rush. Big love to Chef Kayzer, Ossie & Hadji — you guys make it feel like home every time. If you’re passing through, this is the pizza you need in your life! The Tuna Carpaccio and the Heirloom Tomato just meltsz in your mouth. And don’t sleep on the cheeseburger — tender, juicy, cooked to perfection . Pasta? Absolutely AMAZING !

Alena Augustine

Very much enjoyed my experience here. The servers were all kind and friendly. We had a little bit of a wait for the food, but the atmosphere was very very enjoyable. The rooftop vibes were perfect for a relaxing post-work hang. And the pizza was DELICIOUS.

Christopher Enright

Jema is quite possibly, nay, is INDEED the finest host in NYC. This is not hyperbole. She was so gracious and welcoming. Helped us all relax and enjoy our time together. Service was excellent. Regret not getting our server's name but they were so kind and listened and accomodated all of our requests. Food rocked as we expected, just want to highlight how unexpectedly beyond the service and attention we received was! We had the Little Stinker Pizza, the Rosso(Vegan option), and the classic MARGHERITA! Didn't get pics of the greens salad, cucumbers or olives, but all beautifully presented and excellent taste, texture and so satisfying!

Michael Damato

Solid thin crust pizza and some great bread. Everything was super fresh and right out of the oven, so much so even tapping the bread with a knife caused to it steam. Very much worth your time to stop in. Either for a slice to go or sit down.

+11

Andrea DiCastro

Great location especially if you are going to an event near MSG. Forgot pictures of the pizzas but they were really good. They are not huge pizzas but definitely big enough for the 2 of us. Salads are quite large to share and the grilled bread with the cheese is delicious Definitely a solid place to eat. They have an outdoor patio, indoor seating and a take out/ slice counter. It’s a bit pricey for a pizza/ pasta place but I guess it’s the location.

Malcolm Rouse - West

Tucked right next to Madison Square Garden and Penn Station. Robeta's offers pies and single slices. I was the first customer as they had just opened. I got two slices one pepperoni and one Margarita from the first bite the dough was cooked perfectly, the right amount of cheese and was super fresh. Definitely the best slice I had on my trip and will be my first trip on my next trip. The mural on the wall really elevated the place and gave it that Brooklyn Edge.

+1

Abby Rivera

The service and the food was amazing. Very flavourful. We ordered 2 pizzas and drinks. Now, let’s talk about the vibe. The entrance is a quirky surprise; it looks like a small takeout pizza joint, so I almost thought I was lost. Turns out, the full restaurant is upstairs. You can take the elevator (which is decked out in fun decorations), or, if you’re up for some colorful chaos, walk up the staircase. The painted walls are an artistic riot, as shown in the photos I took and is seriously Instagram-worthy! The ambiance upstairs is perfect for a lively get-together with friends or family. Even the bathrooms are clean and thoughtfully decorated. Amazing service and atmosphere. If you’re near Penn Station and craving something special, make your way to Roberta’s.

+2

Abilash Reddy

Great place to hang out with some cocktails and great Pizzas, not very crowded, but music was way too loud 😁, watch out for large steak portions on the brunch menu..

+2

Allan tackore

The food was delicious except the salad was missing something and should have other options for salad dressings and added vegetables! 😉Desert was yummy 😋 Music was Awesome!! some of it took me back to the 80s🕺

Vincent Altieri

Apps... marinated cucumbers are a staple. Olives were very good. Pizza was perfectly cooked, crumbled sausage was a little light but the pie was very tasty. Lite and fluffy crust. Highly recommend the straciatella with the house bread. The bread was warm and tasted amazing. Straciatella was perfectly prepared and like butter. Drinks were very good. Server took a long time to get the 2nd round but he comped it as a result. Would definitely recommend, great before an event at MSG.

Jenny D (Citybird_Adventures)

We came in pretty early to take a break and figure out our plans before check-in. It was too early for a full meal (and I’m lactose intolerant), so we ordered coffees and drinks instead. It turned into a nice, relaxing time to catch up. The manager was very pleasant and didn’t mind us taking over a small section with our luggage, which made things so much easier.

Vee .x

This was my second time here because the first time I liked it, but this time I waited a long time for someone to take my order & for the food to arrive. Ordered a drink when my food arrived, I finished eating and I never got the drink. I asked for the check and told them to just cancel the drink. They had the nerve to question me if I was actually telling the truth about not receiving the drink. Not even an apology for the wait. I think their customer service could improve. I still left 20% tip but I definitely won’t recommend this place and sadly won’t come back.