Thomas Acunia

Excellent pizza! Hands down one of the best pizzas we’ve ever had in the city. Grandma pie with extra cheese, pepperoni and sausage. We can’t wait to return!

Jacob Brown

Great pizza close to Wall St and the Ferry Port if coming from uptown. The pizza smelled so good walking in. The staff was very friendly to our family. Recommend the Sicilian slice with all 3 pizza sauces. Good amount of seating for NYC and the lunch special gave us 2 slices and a drink for $10.50.

Swati B

You get a pizza by a slice and it's so delicious. Have vegetarian options, and it's pocket-friendly. Loved it !

Karlin Anderson

We are on a Keto Therapy diet for medical reasons and a visit to New York wouldn’t be complete without pizza. These guys do an amazing cauliflower crust pizza with no sugar sauce - it is to die for!!! Thank you so much for making our trip complete!!

William Archer

I was staying at a nearby hotel and was researching where to get a good slice. The two that ended up being tops were underground pizza and joes so I did a pizza taste off between them. Spoiler alert: Underground Pizza won. I got 3 slices: pepperoni, mushroom, and buffalo chicken. Underground pizza has slices that are thin but not floppy, high quality toppings (beautiful pepperoni cups), and cheese that truly compliments the whole experience. Joes slices were slightly larger and had a slightly better topping distribution but Underground was the winner in a big way. Also appreciated talking with the owner when I told him what I was doing. Excellent guy and hope he reads this because I told him I’d come back and tell him who won!

Andrea Garcia

Found this pizza shop after a quick google search of what was next to me in NYC. I’m so glad that this little gem of a pizza shop came up. It’s a walk up counter and they have a variety of slices to choose from. We choose pepperoni/ sausage, pepperoni, and white. Once you choose they put it in a big oven and it comes out nice and toasty. You can choose to sit at the bar on the first floor. Or you can go up a small slight of stairs to sit down and eat. They is also a bathroom here if you should need it. Definitely give it a try you won’t be disappointed.

Caroline Rose

The experience was amazing! They are very nice to kids and the pizza was absolutely delicious. It was some of the best pizza I have ever tasted and there was no downsides.

Max Robertson

The vodka slice at underground pizza was my favourite slice in New York and came as recommendation from my partners father. In my short stay I tried many places but this took the top spot, not my usual Neapolitan pizza but I wish I could have another slice. Amazing depth of flavour, proper amounts of sauce and cheese with a super crisp and airy base. The “soda” as the yanks call it was very sweet just to my taste. The only discrepancy was the garlic knots weren’t very flavoursome. Iv had more garlic taste from a Frenchman’s breath. However that Vodka slice pushed the 5star 👍🏻 Highly recommend.

Jonathan Zapata

I was staying in the Financial District when I got the craving for a slice of Margherita Pizza. I really enjoyed this slice: it's ultra-thin, yet saucy. If you like a thin profile with the perfect sauce, this is the place for you. The only thing I wish it had was a little more basil. Thank you, Underground Pizza!

Rando Calrissian

I reserve 5 pizza stars for only the holy grail pizzerias, but was visiting back home in NYC from Florida and took the ferry to FiDi, which is something of a pizza desert. We were with our little one and needed something quick and close and found Underground Pizza and it absolutely did not disappoint. The pizza was really good, and the owner was super cool. God how I wish I could stumble upon random pizzerias in Florida that have been there for decades and have pizza that can knock your socks off. Almost makes me want to move back! Not quite, but almost 🍕