Best Pizza I have ever had anywhere from NY to Texas, my Favorite is the Chicken Bacon Ranch, Literally Melts in Your Mouth, Oh my Goodness, & the service is excellent, a great Family of Christians, that are extremely nice, Like I said " The Best " if you are with in 50 miles of this place it Will be well worth your trip 👍👍👍👍👍

Best pizza I have had in a very long time. Thank y'all so much the food was AMAZING... BEST PIZZA IN THE 518 🥰

Best pizza around! We come here quite often because the food is great and the service is always quick and friendly!

Best pizza in New York State! Broadalbin would not be Broadalbin without it. Totally worth the trip of youe coming from far away. Has been my favorite for 25 years !

The food was delicious, the cooking and service areas were very clean and the customer service was very polite. It was truly a good place for lunch.

Pizza is very good. Bring your cash or check book as they don't use any card but do have an ATM. Kinda silly. Nice people.

Nice place, great pizza,order ahead ,seating inside ,owner friendly, good prices ,restroom.

Always amazing pizza is always 👌 and the wings are delicious! Best place around!

Always great friendly service. We love the garlic knots and the pizza is so good too.

Great pizza, friendly staff, comfortable environment I love this place

Owner is great. Pizza is as close to nyc pizza as you can get upstate.

Greatest pizzeria in the 518!!! Couldn’t get a better pizza anywhere else, awesome customer service and a friendly Family business.

Best pizza around and the everyone there is wonderful.

Awesome food & Awesome staff! I'm glad to call them my brothers! God Bless Pizza Supreme & their families!

The place was very nice and the customer service was excellent. Been a long time since I had a crust on a pizza that good. No grease. It was excellent. I'll definitely be ordering pizza from there again.

Absolutely incredible food!! Highly recommend to everyone!!

Food was excellent as usual. Ordered Mozzarella sticks, garlic knots, and a pineapple bacon pizza. Everything was delicious. Order took a little longer but it was expected since they were busy. 11/10 will dine again. Only able to rate 5 stars but would rate higher if I could.

Surprisingly good pizza in the little town of Broadalbin. Solid hot subs as well (can't comment on cold subs; never had). Appreciable amount of ingredients on a pizza or in a sub, very reasonable prices, friendly staff. The taco pizza is a notable family favorite, but their single topping or plain cheese have great flavor in their sauce and cheese. Try them and you won't be disappointed.

best pizza in upstate new york. i recommend trying the garlic knots they are out of this universe. they do not deliver. but their pizza is so good it is worth the drive. it a fun place to have a birthday party or just hangout and shoot some pool. if you don't trust my review go to pizza supreme on a Friday night and ask the 20 people in there waiting in line for pizza.

This is very possibly the best pizza I've ever eaten! 😋

Awesome as always. Grew up with their pizza and its always been a guilty pleasure. Great people their father was a good man and the sons who own the place are respectful, nice outgoing. Never been a disappointment. The best pizza ever by far. Rac h el Wood 🥰🥰🥰🥰

Huge shoutout to Pizza Supreme for honoring their hours unlike so many other businesses I’ve been to over the years. Called at 7:50 to order when they are advertised to close at 8 (Didn’t want to be that guy but got out of work early and really wanted their pizza lol). Told me it wasn’t too late and pickup would be around 8:15 which is obviously 15 minutes past advertised closing. I know to some this probably sounds like it should be automatic but I have experienced so many businesses that turn things off over 30-45 minutes before close, say they are no longer taking orders, etc. I’ve always been under the mindset that as a business you should be making food until your advertised closed time. If you want to be out at 8, then advertise until 7:30 so people know. Thanks again Pizza Supreme! Food was fantastic as usual!

Probably the friendliest group of people I have ever met. No matter if you spend 5 bucks or 50 they treat you like family. The owner is the nicest guy in the world. Always make me a my family feel super welcome and appreciated. A tad on the pricey side, but you pay for quality.

Amazing family owned pizza place. Super friendly. Clean store. Quick service and fast service. Their pizza is a great NY style thin crust that would rival any NYC pizzeria. A must stop when in the Broadalbin area!

THE BEST PIZZA PLACE IN FULTON COUNTY BROADALBIN NEW YORK.

I have came here since middle school, let's not count the years lol. Loved in different states and still the best pizza from around the country. Great job Tony and Frank, and of course y'all's parents for getting it going years back. As others said as well, great service with a smile every time

New York style, thin chewy crust. This is our favorite pizza place, even though it's at least 10 minutes farther than others we frequent. They don't take cards so make sure you have enough cash on hand.

Got a Sicilian pizza and an antipasto. Both were really good. The pizza was a lot bigger than anticipated, but since leftover pizza is really good, no worries. Friendly staff.

I love this place as a resident of Broadalbin NY for 12 years we have always been a parton and will continue as long as we live near to Pizza Supreme. The shop owners and staff are some of the best people in our community. The food is also truly top notch by any standard. The price is very fair as well. I urge you to stop in and say hello to Frank and or Tony and tell em I sent ya.

I received a piece of that was overdone to my taste. I called them and told them then they were going to drive a replacement pizza to my house for free. I told him that was not necessary and I I would call when I wanted the replacement Pizza. Great service great pizza great people.

As I said and the ability to write quickly was taken away from me by this microphone pizza supreme makes the very Best salad with lettuce tomatoes onions aloe's pepperoni East and and cheese for the price it is extremely affordable affordable and I recommend it to anybody to anybody I have compared this to at least 7 other places and they cannot even cannot even touch pizza supremes ability to make such a salad

Always great atmosphere with organist playing Christmas music. Always friendly

Hands down the best pizza and wings I’ve ever eaten! Not only that, but the customer service was fantastic I’ll give it an excellent 5 star rating!! Thanks again guys!

Best pizza around. We come from Galway for this pizza and I love supporting a Christian owned business. Highly recommend.

The best homestyle pizza I've ever had

Best pizza you can get in this area for a great price. A little greasy and a little chessier than I like it, perfect amount of sauce amd crust just the way I like it. I give it a 7.9

Great pizza. The chicken bacon ranch is amazing.

Excellent wings and newyork style pizza. Did takeout but the store appeared very clean. Friendly service. Good pricing. Be careful getting out of your car when parking on street....cars seem to fly thru there! Highly recommend.

This place was recommended to me. And it’s absolutely true!! Insanely good pizza! Crispy bottom, perfect sauce and cheese! Easily the best pizza place in Upstate NY!

The inside is what you would expect from a pizza shop. Nothing fancy or creatively decorated. However the pies themselves are the best in the area. In all fairness we have only used takeout so I can not speak to the in dining service.

Delicious!! Great service, perfectly made pizza! 🍕

One of the best places to get pizza in the state of New York

I love this restaurant. I know a lot of the reviews talk about it being greasy and yes, the pizza and calzones I have had here, were greasy but it was DELICIOUS. I've had their wings as well and they were just as good as the rest of the food I've had. Last I knew, they only took cash for payment, but they do have an atm in the restaurant, just in case.

Been coming here my whole life. Hands down the best pizza in the world!!!! Great Pizza made by a Great Family. Excellent service and always with a smile. You can tell when business owners love what they do and really appreciate their customers. Nothing better than grabbing one of their slice pies after it's been cooled up and reheating it. Hope they stay open for many generations.

I've been a frequent patron of this establishment for the last year and a half and the food has never disappointed. From succulent sides to substantial main courses, the food is spectacular and not to mention family run and owned. Aside from this aspect, the ethos of the restaurant (when it's opened to the public) has plenty to keep you busy and happy thereafter enjoying the sustenance.

Great pizza! (Although , my sister had to review the dough ingredients with the chef because they didn't know what "vegan" was when asked if it was ok. For the record... the regular dough is vegan and holds up perfectly to adding your own vegan cheese and throwing it under the broiler for a few minutes.)

The owner(s) put out a great product at a great price. Love their food. They are almost always looking to hire local professionals to help them do well also.

This pizza not only tasted good but the atmosphere of tbe inside seating and the customer service really is the cherry on top better then most places nearby couldn't compare

Michele Fox

Great family restaurant...always helpful..great pizza

Denis Fonda

As someone new to the area for the last 2 years this place is great.The food is great especially the pizza im most familiar with.

Karen M

We order two slices and two roast beef sandwiches. Delicious! Sweet people and clean environment! Definitely recommend.

Nancy Johnson

Today is the first time getting pizza from here and it's delicious. Enjoyed every bite. Bless you and thank you 🙏🥰

O. B.

Very good, classic pizzas. We moved to the area from pizza ground zero and have been struggling to find a good pie. This definitely hit the spot. Solid, tasty pizzas (crust not too thin or thick), very good gigantic calzones and buffalo wings.

Ashley B

picked up two pizzas to go, a supreme and a pepperoni. they were GREAT! very very tasty and fresh ingredients. would definitely recommend!

Rogue Guyver

I have been enjoying this restaurant since I was a teenager. So many wonderful memories with my family dining in and food was always delicious. Time hasn’t changed, it’s still my favorite pizza and Italian place upstate. Still owned by the same great family. Love the thin crispy crust and sauce on their pizza pies! Don’t forget a side of meatballs! A++

Kristin

Best pizza I've had in a long time!! Was feeding a big group- so five pizzas and two orders or garlic knots. Pizza was delicious and crust was just right. CASH ONLY! There is an ATM on site. I wish I lived closer- but the 45 mins drive might be worth it.

Jarod Price

My hometown pizza place! Customer service is always on point, they always go above and beyond and are such kind souls. And the food is absolutely DELICIOUS! 🤤 Don't have enough nice things to say about them! 10/10 Everytime!

Lenny Simone

Stopped by while out on Mother's Day. Had the Calzone with sausage. HUGE and perfectly baked giant calzone. Could not finish it, served 3 meals worth. The side sauce was much better than average, guy knows what he's doing there. Also had the house salad. Serving was very large, fresh greens, shredded mozzarella, olives and more. Didn't finish that either so took that home. Very friendly staff, recommended other places to visit for drinks in the area. Will definitely go back. Plenty of take out whizzed by while we ate inside.

Lisa Hathaway

We love the food here. Pizza, chicken tenders, & fries are usually our go-to. The taste is great. Sometimes we do onion rings. Also great. They sell by the slice as well, if you're just stopping in for something small...except the slices are definitely not small, and that's never a bad thing! There's a couple games inside to keep busy while you wait. As always, the people are friendly, and the food is great.

Kate

Pretty good pizza. A little greasy. Great prices but cash only. Big place lots of tables. Park on street

Frank Lockerman

Stopped in here on a whim and it didn’t disappoint. Pizza was fantastic, the service was excellent as well. Cash only wasn’t a problem as they have an ATM in the location. I will definitely be back again!

William Lewey

Homemade nice fresh spicy chicken wrap and my wife had a delicious burger the fries were amazing friendly workers coming back definitely

christine M

This is my first visit to Pizza Supreme, and it definitely won't be my last. The Buffalo chicken pizza is amazing! The crust was done just right and there was a perfect amount of sauce. The staff was very friendly and service was prompt. We opted for a dine in and our pizza was brought right to our table. The restaurant has the ambience of a small town, with a friendly atmosphere. Business was brisk and they were keeping right up with it. Such a delightful surprise.

JEM Ma

Pizza Supreme is the resident pizza place for our town! Pizza Supreme has been open for decades. The owners are great, the food and prices are great!

Great place to get pizza, wings, subs, garlic notts! All delicious. Prices are good. Never had a bad experience. Only downfall is they only take Cash.

Excellent pizza and their chef's salad is a meal and then some. Great value, and very friendly staff.

The pizza,was huge and good. However we were told,30 minutes for take out. We got there exactly 30minutes later. We then waited another 30 minutes for the food. We would of left but we had already paid for it. It tasted good though.

I would say this is one of the better places to buy pizza around this area. The staff is always nice to you when you place your order. The food is always made the way you order it. You tell them a time you would like to pick up your order it is ready for you when you get there. The garlic knots are made very well too.

Bought two pizzas on a busy Thursday night and they were excellent. Good sauce, crispy crust, quality toppings. Returned for a pizza on a slow Tuesday night, and it was so soggy that the box was saturated.

Disappointed. I've been enjoying the "" mom and pop shop" for 6yrs. Never a complaint. Tonight I got the "Saturday sh*t show". Ingredients were the same, but the the execution was sub par. The boneless garlic parm wings were overcooked in old oil and just garlic powder in possible butter. Great food when made by the proprietor, not so good when the kids are involved

My Husband and I Wanted a pizza well he wanted pizza I wanted a ham grinder (was craving it) We are from Ma. and come up to Amsterdam every year My husband loves trains so We rail fan I decided to look up a place for pizza this place had good reviews (which is what I go by usually but still with hesitation And I am so glad We drove a little further then We planned it was excellent so we'll worth it loved the bread they use for subs make sure your hungry I had a large sub and a slice of pizza see all the places around where We live give half the portions ( not worth it) My husband had to finish the sub for Me We will definitely being going back when We r in the area sorry so long Ya gotta try this place You won't be sorry👍

Friendly staff, fair prices, quality food. The pizza sauce was fresh and paired nicely with the pepperoni on the pizza.

Pizza and mild wings were ok. The pizza was soggy, and the wing sauce was not my favor. The staff was great and the dining area was great.

Shelley Brienza (Event Coordinator)

I really like it here because they have a good menu selection. The prices are reasonable in comparison to other similar places. It's a hometown kind of restaurant where everyone knows everyone else. It's a " hey, hello, how have you been" kind of greeting every time you walk in. That's nice. I particularly enjoy their subs. Fresh bread and a good amount of meat on the sub. I've also enjoyed the antipasto salad with their homemade Italian dressing. It really is like my grandmother used to make and that was a favorite too. The owner Frank is always there with a smile on his face and it is always busy in there. I would recommend trying this place if you haven't already.

Cutting back on a lot of topping

Staff was very friendly. No delivery. Doesn't accept credit card. They have an ATM which cost me $3.50 to use. Pizza tasted ok but was a little soggy.

The pizza here is really good and maybe last Friday was an exception on the service. We ordered a pizza and were told a time to pick it up. Got there and 10 people were standing on the sidewalk waiting for orders. Finally got into the place to pay and found out everything wasn't ready. If your kitchen is swamped don't keep telling everyone the same pickup time. If it's going to be over an hour to get food be upfront on the wait time.

Fairly slow service. They were very busy but if I'm told 40-45 mins to wait for 2 large pizzas and a salad, I expect it to be ready. It was over 10 mins late and then the salad came 10 mins after the pizzas were done (so 20 minutes late. The pizza was very greasy which resulted in extremely flimsy pizza. Flavor of the pizza was good, but very very greasy. Not in any rush to go back.

Was my favorite pizza even though I had issues with how they do lunch, however last time I ordered the same thing I always do, I got 2 square pizzas and the wings were off. Also, asked for ranch and only got blue cheese.

Drove 20min to pick up 2 pies. Was not as good as previous visits. Dough was chewy and dense. Too much sauce on the pie made it messy. Was just okay. Maybe they had an off day. Will try again.

It's alright/good food. IMO it's not the best pizza in the area, but it isn't bad. The sauce is too sweet for my taste. The main issue I have is two-fold: It's pickup only so no delivery, and cash only. I recognize that these two things might not be possible for their current business model, but when their competitors in the area (with better pizza IMO) do have delivery and credit-card, it makes it tough to recommend or order from here. Additionally, the lines to pick up are usually quite long, sometimes 10-15min of waiting in line. Its frustrating to stand there knowing your order is waiting. This is another area where allowing credit-cards would be hugely beneficial. Again, I do understand the business reason against this.

D K

I'm surprised by the excessively positive reviews. Our order took longer than estimated. Service was not rude, but not warm either. Pizza was average at best. IMO, great pizza often tastes better the next day - this did not. Antipasto salad was good. The garlic knots were the best part of our order - cheesy, garlic-y and buttery in all the best ways, and the dough was good. Perhaps we visited on an off night, but based on this one visit I wouldn't recommend their pizza.

Went here today for the first time. The women in the front is pretty miserable and angry that the other staff were chatting to loud for her liking and it didn't seem like she even wanted to take are order but on the plus side the place is very clean. I ordered pizza slices that were ok and garlic parm wings that were plain had no taste at all... 16 dollars for 12 tasteless wings

Julianna Carey

Food was okay, ordered a 6 cut cut half meat lovers got 16 cut half meat lovers, called back and she told they don’t offer 16 cut, and she just kept repeating that we ordered a thick crust 12 cut pizza, in no way did she try to resolve my issue horrible customer service on her end.

Therese Harper

Not sure about all the rave reviews. Staff was nice and pizza was ready on time but super greasy, so much so that it was leaking through the bottom of the box. Very salty and no ranch flavor or sauce on the chicken bacon ranch pizza. Was really looking forward to this based on the reviews. Feeling sick to the stomach after one slice of a $25 pizza.

Pizza was over cooked and salty. Felt sick after eating. Rude teenage cashiers will not return don't understand why they have such high reviews defintely not great pizza.

So tried to get pizza . Three people in line two have been waiting for long time already. No one came to the modified window so I called they said 45-60 minutes, really.... no . I would have gone to Fritz’s pizza which I like better but they were closed , now I am at Stewards ordering pizza . So you need to get better at making pizza it us your job .

Gave attitudes about them making our pizza wrong and us not taking the one they messed up

This place was recommended to me, and I can't tell you the level of shear disappointment. It was a Saturday evening around 5:30. I walked in to get a couple of slices. They didn't have much to offer, just 3 dried up old plain slices and nothing else. So I order a small cheese pie and a chicken parm hero. I was told 45 minutes. Waited in my truck for 40 minutes went back in, the lady took my money with the hero in hand, but told me it would be another 15 minutes for the pie. Finally pizza came out and I headed home. When I arrived the pizza was the worst I've ever had. To much sauce, and over cooked. The chicken parm hero you ask? Bread was soggy and when I opened it, there were chicken fingers covered in too much sauce again. I'll never go back, and the people that recommended it to me will get an ear full. I give it a 2.2 out of 10. In a word- disgusting.

Went here for the first time today. Asked for some pepperoni slices to find out they just add pepperoni to a cheese pizza already cooked. Went to pay with my debit card to be told they don’t accept cards but you can use their ATM and pay a fee. Never will I give my money to a place that makes you pay a fee to give them your hard earned money. Total joke! Walked right out.