Outstanding Pizza and Chicken wings. If you love pizza and wings come to Ye Olde Pizza Pub. Always great service.

Always love getting pizza from here a real classic for our family we go very often

Great place rather go there than New York Pizzeria in Morrisville New York Pizzeria Morrisville sucks Pizza Pub is the best you will never find a better Pizza

I ordered here as a first time customer and was told to try it and they were right. The pizza was made the way I wanted it the wings were good as well I have really no complaints and will definitely go again

I love their mountain taters! I always get pizza and wings as well, never disappointed! 😁 I have been eating here for 40 years and I hope for 40 more! So yum! 😁

I think the food there tastes great. Yea it is a little soggy but i like it. Pizza is great. Everyone has there own opinion on things and thats fine. For me i like it there

I love their pizza! I've been coming here ever since I was a kid. I moved to Florida 34 years ago, but I still make it a point to eat here (multiple dinners) each time I visit Hamilton. There's a couple of video games and a huge projector screen playing cartoons to keep the kids occupied.

The "Pub" as it is known, has the best pizza in the area...not kidding. I have been going since I was a young kid and now I am near 60. The open seating at large old picnic tables reveals the generations of teens that have etched their names in history. The Pub offers a large screen projection tv, that plays family friendly movies. Aside from the pizza favorites, the Pub is famous for the "tators"and the beautiful salad bar. Yes Olde Pizza Pub is perfect for birthday parties and impromptu gatherings.

Great food and pleasant staff.

Great place for pizza and tiny wings. It’s been 30 years since the last time I was here. The place hasn’t changed, it is still a great place to go to.

The Pizza Pub is a great family meal in a wonderful setting. A slice of time is yours when you carve your name in a table then come back years later to reminisce. Amazing food

Legit, best pizza place in Hamilton. This place is in my top 2 favorite pizza places. Staff is amazing..we called for a pizza like 10 minutes before they were supposed to close not even knowing it & they were so nice about it.

This place has a rustic atmosphere with a family friendly vibe..The pizza is great and the staff even better. Good service and a great attitude always makes the food taste better.😎👍

Large selection of tasty pizza served hot. Wings were meaty and tasty. Service is friendly and accommodating. Great place to eat with a family!

This is a long time standing tradition for camp hunt staff. On men's retreat we go every year. Great food friendly staff very accommodating.

This is one of my favorite places for great pizza. The atmosphere is relaxed and family friendly, with long tables and benches. Nice salad bar.

Very good!! Only complaint I have is I reserved all the tables by the buffet when got there there were people sitting in our seats and got mad when we sat down.. I think when a table is reserved a last name should be taken...

For a consistently delicious pizza, and a great salad bar at very reasonable pricing, you can't go wrong choosing Ye Olde Pizza Pub. Casual, come as you are - a relaxed place for sure.

Got some wings n taters to go. Glad to see the place hasn't changed a. It in 30 years. Best Buffalo wings on earth are made here

Great pizza and wings. I have tried most pizzas in the area and this is the best - the crust is the difference - fluffy not chewy. Takeout only during pandemic - unique, rustic bench seating is cozy and fun. Low lighting great for my sensitive eyes

I have made going to the pizza pub a yearly thing. Thoroughly enjoy their wings, and they're pizza I'd always phenomenal. Good atmosphere. They have Boomerang playing on a projector so you get all your favorite classic cartoons. Not to mention they serve alcohol. My only complaint about the place is that it isn't very well heated. So if you go during the cold season be sure to wear a coat! Other 100% satisfied.

I moved to the area 2 yrs ago and this is an amazing place for pizza, salad, and taters... especially love their homemade dressing 😍

This place smells amazing as soon as you walk in. I've never been in a place like it and the food was fantastic. I drive an hour and a half every few weeks to get food here.

Was an excellent visit. They have a very nice salad bar and their pizza is the best around. I grew up in Jersey and Ye Olde Pizza Pub is the only place with pizza like home. Delicious crust and the sauce and toppings are the best. Have been there many times and will continue to go back.

While the food isn't amazing, the memories and camaraderie can't be beat. The taters are simple, but legendary.

My Great Grandfather helped build this place and any time I travel home to visit it is a must. The food has never let me down and is a great place for all ages. I am so glad that they have started to allow eating in again and I look forward to returning.

This review makes no pretence at objectivity. The Pub is my idea of comfort food, pizza style. From the cheese mix on the pizza, to the sausage, to the taters and blu cheese the Pub offers a superior pizza experience. The pizza isn't foo-foo and the darkish dining area and bench seating may not appeal to everyone but, for nearly half a century people have come for miles to get their Pub food. Enjoy!!

This place used to be a favorite for many people. In the last 3 or 4 years, it has taken a turn. The food is definitely not as good as it used to be. The whole place is run by teenagers. You'll never see anyone older than 18 or 19 there. We used to LOVE the pizza, taters, and chicken wings. Now, every time we get food from there, we talk about not wanting to get it again. The quality of the food has just decreased. I got a fish fry there today that was so gross. The fish had to have been frozen. Typically, if you get a fish fry at any local pizzerias on a Friday, it's fresh, and they either beer battered it or breaded it themselves. This was 100% not done at the pizza pub. It's very sad to lose this once treasured restaurant. I have been eating there for more than 20 years. But I really don't recommend it anymore.

Sandy Abbott

Awesome pizza,wings salad bar.Fountain sodas,with free refills.

Bhailis

Amazing Pizza&Wings. I always get the highest and consistent quality orders from the pizza pub! I’ll pop service to 3 stars only because getting charged 40.03 for a medium and 15 wings is highly overpriced. If the app worked and I did not have to call-in the order it would have been around 25-30$ so that makes 0 sense.

GINA MORALES

I was up here for my niece’s wedding at Camp Fiver,they ordered pizzas Thursday evening,2 pepperoni 1 vegetable pizza and 2 cheese pizzas. I’m gonna tell you right now…THAT PIZZA WAS THE BEST I’VE EATEN IN YEARSSSSSS!!!! Thank you for putting your heart and soul and foot into making that pizza. The crust was amazing,now you know if the crust is good,the pizza is good. It reminded me of my youth growing up on the city in Queens NY. I’m telling everyone that decides to come your way or passing by,please stop and this business and get their pizza. It will not disappoint!! Thank you again guys for making pizza the correct way💯❤️

Travis Westcott

Ye Olde Pizza Pub has remained a family favorite since I was a child. Now I take my kids there. The food is excellent and they play movies on a big screen while you eat. You'll never find a place with the unique taste of the pizza and breaded wings, not to mention their potato wedges. The owner and the employees are super humble, kind, and friendly. They care about their customers' experience. I highly recommend Ye Olde Pizza Pub.

Jay Warner

I've eaten there for years and have known the family that owns it for years. Great food Great friends and a nice place to hang out.

Gray atmosphere. I love the Boss and Garlic wings, as well as the potato wedges. Pizza is ok. Fun family environment with large t.v. for children.

Specialty pizza was all we had when visiting from Michigan. Very good taste and crust was perfectly crisp.

The tators with ranch dressing are amazing!!!! The movie screen and csrtoons have a nostalgic feel and it helps my little kiddos stay focused on sitting and eating....

Great pizza for Central New York! Rough but fun atmosphere. Enjoyed our visit.

Wings tasted awesome! Pizza was good too. Pub atmosphere but kids were welcome

Nice rustic look remind me of the old Shakey's of years ago. Enjoyed everything, just what we needed, can accommodate lots of people

Only had one occasion with poor service from this place. The rest of the time not much of a wait or most times next to no wait. I never dine in, so can't comment there. I love that they still have the big screen playing kids movies!

The pizza wasn't FANTASTIC but the wait staff and atmosphere were a lot of fun

Great food! I love this place! It's a lot more expensive than the average pizza place, but they do have really food. Every time I've been here it is always very busy; so I would definitely recommend calling ahead of time and ordering your food. Otherwise you may have to wait a while. It's also lot pricier than your average pizza place. Overall I really enjoy the place and would recommend it to others!

Pizza was 7/10 the wingd are over priced for how small they are dollar a wing more so should be 50 cent a pop

The interior is dim and clean, although dated. The pizza was greasy and doughy, and the wings were adequate. It's certainly an experience. The menu is limited.

They have a salad bar, just, many long tables, and fairly good pizza, local place, good for large groups. Serve yourself soda.

Normally I'm all for it, love the pub, great food. But I didn't order much this time, 2 Large pizzas, 15 wings and a large tater.. One pizza was burnt on top in the middle, and the other wasn't cut so it got ruined.. And the wings had no sauce or anything on them. You have like 10 workers usually, how??

I used to go here a lot 10 years ago, and the pizza was awesome. Now the food was not as good, and it took a long time to get our order. I stopped in because of nastalgia, but I don't think I'll make the trip again.

The Hamilton Pizza Pub is not that great anymore. The quality if the food is declining and the very small menu leaves a lot to be desired. The vibe is weird inside- very dark and unwelcoming. Drive to Oneida if you want Pizza Pub.

Not what it used to be. I remember when you had to wait outside because the line was out the door to get a table. Now it looks like someone did a half professional makeover that's not even finished. The staff is a whole bunch of little kids telling other Little kids what to do. It sucks because this place was an awesome place and experience.

The food I'd rate 3 out of 5 for taste. The portions were pretty good though. And it wasnt too expensive. The interior design took my breath away (in a good way). You know those pubs/racers in movies? It looks just like that. They have a couple video game things to keep kids busy which is great.

Long wait on pizza. Undercooked crust. For new customer they do not tell or say anything..you best ask questions. Pizza flavor was good. Best thing is to call pizza order in if you want their pizza. May still take time, they have a lot of call in business.

Bill Klein

Fun atmosphere, family friendly. Wings were different and on the small side. Never had breaded wings before but I'd eat them again. Pizza was ok. Fun place for the family

Heather Brzostoski

Our experience wasn't the best. We got a large garlic pizza and 2 salad bars. Before we got there, we looked at the menu on-line. The pizza was the same price, but to our shock salad par was 4x the amount. As we were getting our salad, the waitress was dismantling the salad bar. It was almost 8pm. They close at 10pm on Friday. The table & bench were sticky. This was not our favorite dining experience.

Andrew Kirsch

Service staff was attentive and fast. Unfortunately on our visit the kid making pizza was new burnt our pizzas and it took over an hour to get our food. The atmosphere needs to change I think lack of management and training is to blame not the staff. Food was good. A little heavy on sauce with wings other then that everything was good. I would give them a second chance.

I've been 3 times, first time, they forgot my food in the back for an hour and a half, second time, they didn't make our food for an hour, third time, the forgot to make our food again, and waited an hour

I would give 3 stars if I had only ordered pizza. Pizza is OK, decent for the area. Wings were a travesty. They are mini wings, like they fried up baby chickens or cornish hens.

Kids working billed me for chili, I ordered chili, said chili was in the bag. Didn't check, lo and behold, no chili.

Great pizza. There were more employees than customers, someone should have been cleaning the bathrooms (they smelled really bad_ like cat pee!)employees were friendly, all young without direction .

Still don't serve beer. Pizza was under cooked and even after sending it back to have it cooked more, middle of pizza was raw! Wings weren't crispy, soggy and prices were expensive.

I had a pizza there last Saturday...NOT impressed!! The pizza had barely any sauce on it, and was under cooked! $17.50 for a 3 topping medium pizza?? WOW! $2.60 for a 20 ounce bottled soda?? WOW! No salad bar!! No refills on fountain soda!! I won't be back! FOLKS...go to the Oneida YOPP location, instead of Hamilton...you'll be much happier!

We visited this place before and had subs that were amazing! We decided to make the hour long trip to go back tonight and try their pizza and wings. The girl behind the counter seemed new and was not very confident when answering questions. Their menu lists a 'spicy sauce' and when we asked about it another lady (colored highlights in her hair) in the kitchen said it was the marinara sauce. Not sure how a marinara sauce can be consider spicy or why it would be listed as a separate topping but whatever. The pizza was good but when we got the wings some spots on them were ice cold and the meat was nearly mush. When I asked for a refund they did give it to me but defended the wings saying they air fry them to make them soft. Then as we were leaving the gentlemen who gave me the refund was saying goodbye and have a nice night (typical good customer service) when the lady in the kitchen told him "Don't tell them that". For that reason alone we will never be returning to this place and I highly advise against anyone else going.

Dennis Carney

Used to love this place, last few pizzas have been off. Ordered a normal medium chicken wing pizza and got this. I’m not even sure what this is, it’s loaded in cheese and super soggy. It’s disappointing considering the prices there.

Got pizza from here bc everyone in the area raves about how good it is....unfortunately it is not very good. Specifically, the pizza sauce is bland and the toppings taste as though they are from a can.

Food is not good portions are too small wings are tiny prices are way too high better off going down road to pizza hut! Pizza sucks as well

Wings are frozen, like you get from the grocery store. Awful. Pizza like cardboard. Staff, bored and inattentive. Hard to believe its in business.

The food took an hour to come out, and it was mediocre at best. The wings were very small, and incredibly soggy. It was very meh food for $40, and it took way too long to come out.

Lucky to get one star. Horrible service by one of the waitresses. Salad bar was empty said wasn't her job. She just had a snotty attitude all night while we were there

We ordered subs thinking it would be quicker than hot food because we were in a hurry to be elsewhere.It took about half an hour to get two subs(there were about ten people in the place).My Italian sub consisted of a couple slices of boiled ham with two slices of pepperoni on a roll that was definitely 'Ye Olde'.Place sucks.I would have given zero stars but it would not let me

Absolutely horrible old pizza dough, hard cardboard like, barely any sauce, watery big dipper, just not the same!!! Ewww for the price not worth it I've been going here for 30 years and I've never had horrible pizza from there before what happened!!!!

The attitude and unprofessional. The people working are teenagers that seemed untrained lacking in hospitality. Was told 45 minutes waited another 25 for food. We asked why it was taking so long gave us the run around of excuses. Asked to talk to manager there on working with the staff had to wait for the owner to get there. Owner acted like he didn't like he cared at all. I think monkey at the zoo would be better service and hospitality.

Place is dirty. Carvings/ graffiti on tables can’t be cleaned and crevices were full of old food etc. Tables were sticky and floor by walls is unclean and disgusting. No ice in soda machine, got pizza which was okay at best. Ordered wings that never showed. Also, apparently we’re supposed to know that you get your own plates when you walk in. Server never said a word. Never coming here again.

got there at 4pm they didn't open til 4:15 then no pizza for an hour while ovens heat up. salad bat was not set up yet. we ordered wings sold by 5s, never heard of that. we ordered 20 wings, 4 salad bars, 3 drinks cost 54 dollars. we were brought 3 salad bowls. they made us pay for another and I KNOW I told her FOUR! so now it's a 60 dollar meal. 5 wings each and a salad. salad bar was very sparse, 3 containers of cucumbers. very basic ingrediants and containers barely had anything in them. NOT WORTH 60 DOLLARS!

Check your order! Place an order for a medium pizza and 20 wings. Pick the order up, and arrive at home with order. I was not given wings. I was given mushy potatoes. Tried to call them back immediately. However, they know your phone number and know they missed your order so won't answer the phone. So I paid $40 for a cheese pizza. I'll stick with Sherrill location.

For $56 we got a one topping pizza and 20 Tiny Soggy wings. The menu online was 10 years old so we were really surprised when we got there to pick up the pizza and wings and found out that the bill came to $56. I'm not sure what was going on with the skin on the tiny tiny and I mean "tiny wings" but it seem to be disintegrating into the sauce.

We had a group of 8 people. We all ordered are for at different times .1 ordered a salad We got it they forgot tomatoes and they didn't give us silver ware and no dressing for our salads We had to keep running up there for our stuff and the workers had a real bad Attitude because they forgot to give our stuff to us ordered French fries and they sat on the counter for 10 minutes we had to go back up the girl like I for got to give them to you also our pizza we told her what we wanted when it came out to our table we said that's not what we ordered She had a bad attitude and was Argue with us.bad service all the way around the owners should be a shame of themselves for letting kids work on their own.

Did not like it! The staff is rude, The place is high, the movie you can’t hear, they give you paper snack plates to eat your whole meal off of! The wings are small and so is the pizza for the price! They should give you your drink and cups when they serve your food. They should give you your salad before your hot food! I love the Oneida location! They can handle washing plates so you can put an actual meal on it. The pizza is bigger for the same price. Will not be going back to the Hamilton location again!

The only saving grace was the staff. The pizza was super greasy without much flavor, and wings were a nightmare lol. They were breaded with what seemed like normal breadcrumbs and when they got to us they were soggy, no crunch. It was all very very bad.

Wow wow wow, I could give 0 stars if I could. I went with my best friend, her fiancé and another bridesmaid. We were in the area trying different pizzas for their wedding: Joey and Vinny's is our favorite, definitely recommend. Anywho, we went in and decided to try a buffalo chicken wing pizza! We expected the food to be amazing since it looked so beautiful inside, we were wrong. We got our pizza which looked like it had been drenched in water as a finishing touch but decided to not judge a book by its cover. We had taken a slice, my best friends fiancé went to go in for a bite and he found a hair in the food. He picked it out and tried for another, we all tried a bite and were not impressed. We brought it back up saying there was a hair in it and that it didn't taste very good (did not even ask for a refund). They brought it back and dug into it looking for a hair and we heard another say, "this doesn't look good either". A very nice blonde woman said that she was sorry and would have another coworker call the manager to see what to do in the situation. A different girl, very unexperienced to say the least, very rudely said "the only thing I can do for you is give you store credit or make you another pizza" and we politely said that we live an hour away so no need for a store credit and we do not want another pizza. She told us there was nothing else they could do and we reminded the girl that there was a hair in the pizza. She replies, "Oh now there's a HAIR in the pizza?" And we replied with, yes there is a hair in the pizza. She did not believe us and was quite rude. She then proceeded to swear at us and we asked for the managers number and she refused to give it to us. Note: no worker there had their hair up, no gloves and some of the women there were playing with their hair on the front desk area. Not impressed.

I am a long long long time customer of the sherrill location. I recently went to Hamilton as sherrill was closed for memorial day. I asked for them to cook my pizza so the cheese was crispy , and to cook my potato wedges until crispy . The staff at the counter said "we arent allowed to cook anything crispy here" .. the cheese on the pizza was almost raw , and the potato wedges weren't even cooked through let alone crispy. They should change thier name to something else , when you visit a chain (even one with only 2 locations ) you expect comparable food at all locations and the food here was just terrible I won't be back..

Melody Seaton

Waited over an hour and half for a pizza, wings and taters kept being told 10 more minutes. Run by teenagers no manager. People actually left before getting their food requesting money back. Worst experience will not return.asked for a refund and was totally ignored

Warren Perry

Pizza isn’t half bad. The service, specifically the wait, is ridiculous. Told 30 mins and you’re waiting almost an hour. If this had happened one time, fine! But everytime…every single time.

A

Crusty, dusty, dingy and sticky. We ended up being the only ones that came in and sat down to eat the whole time we were there. When we looked around you can see the cobwebs swinging from the ceiling, the water damage marks and all the dust. I dare you to take a nice hard look at the self serve soft drink machine 🧐 You seat yourselves, order at the front, pour your own drinks. They did bring our food to us though then we cleared our own table. Wings are itty bitty things with decent flavor. No crispiness and have some sort of coating under the sauce that adds to the sogginess. It is the same thing with their "taters"- just sad wet sliced potatoes begging and crying for two more minutes in the hot oil bath. The pizza is just alright. Crust is decent but it's not that homemade deliciousness. The garlic pizza was missing the garlic flavor. It fed us but definitely wouldn't recommend this place to anyone and will definitely not be back.

Deborah Edick

Not sure where the AI came up with overall review of amazing pizza and wings and consistency in quality after reading other reviews. The wings are over priced, at least 1/2 the size of wings at other establishments, and the coating is mealy. I strongly recommend not ordering takeout especially close to opening time as the wings are usually left over from the previous days business . Since they are closed on Monday you’re just getting Sundays leftovers if ordering Tuesday between 4-6. Loaded taters are greasy and nasty. If you’re looking for a laxative this is the place to go, if you’re able to keep it down long enough without regurgitating. This place has gone way downhill over the years. Really should have a dress code for the girls on the front end as well as training in customer service. Will definitely not be back anytime soon.

The Happy Magic Co Brush Hour Studios

Shitty service, rude kids, young girls that are half clothed. Sticky tables, if you ask for a cloth to wash the tables you get snubbed. Bathrooms are a mess

Heather Colley

My parents and I went there today, 4/25/2025. We put an order in for 3 salads, 1 draft, 2 sodas, and a large pizza. Well, the dark haired girl with the septum nose ring tried charging us $132!!! We said we don’t think that’s right and she insisted she was correct and she didn’t even think to check where she might have made the mistake. On that, we just walked out. We did the math and the most it would’ve cost us was about $50. I don’t know what that girl was trying to pull, but we weren’t going to fall victim to her scam!! Makes you wonder who else might have gotten ripped off by her!

brienna

I’ve ate here my entire life and this past year has been bad, decided to get a pizza after awhile and they put paper underneath the pizza in box which then ruined my pizza by attaching to the crust they’ve never used paper before so why start now and ruin things.

Haley Schladebeck

The chicken wings tasted like fish and were a third the size of a regular wing, but full price. Ordered a 16" pizza and received a 12" instead. Concerned for the freshness of the food, also poor customer service. Will not eat here again. $50 wasted and regret leaving a tip.

Laura Lee

We reserved a large table for a large party (25 people). We were told to call ahead and place orders ahead of time so our food would be ready at the desired time - each family in our group did just that. We arrived about 10-15 minutes early, paid for our food, got our drinks and waited. Within the next half hour literally everyone in our party had their food except us. We had a large cheese pizza, 10 boss wings, 10 medium wings and a Big Dipper of bleu cheese. My husband went to the counter to inquire and was rudely told by some girl that his pizza was fresh (she took it out of a box that had been sitting out) and he called her out on it. She and the other young girls then proceeded to argue and tell us they didn’t know it was for eat in and they didn’t know we were there (at this point we had paid over a half hour ago and had our number ticket). They literally pushed plates of food at us. Their ability (or should I say lack thereof) to treat customers respectfully was non existent. Thankfully there seemed to be one girl who took charge and was kind and did what she could to rectify the situation. We are long time customers/supporters of the pizza pub but we will not be back for a long time based on our experience last night.

David Brutsky

I ordered mild wings and when I came there to pick them up and pay, it ended up being 34% more than they said it would be saying our prices have gone up. The wings had no flavor and were small. I asked the girl at the counter for napkins. She pretended like she looked for them for half a second and then said we don’t have any napkins. How does a restaurant not have any napkins? Would not recommend this place to anyone, not honest and sassy staff, food not good, dark and unwelcoming atmosphere.

brittney jorgensen

Ordered for the first time Paid 80$ for garbage! Wings were suppose to be garlic, I don’t know what they were but they were not! Wings were soggy left in an inch of oil. Not a single one was cooked properly not even a crunchy outside! Ordered two pizzas as well one wasn’t cooked all the way dough in the crust was raw and the other was burnt. I would never recommend to anyone, I’d rather buy frozen at least I know it will be done and it won’t cost me 80$.