Menu
Cutillo's Restaurant
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Cutillo's Restaurant
Foto

Cutillo's Restaurant

American, european · Carmel

4.6 · 181 recensioni Google
cutillosrestaurant.com

Informazioni su Cutillo's Restaurant

Welcome to Cutillo's Restaurant, where exceptional dining experiences await in the heart of Carmel. Our restaurant offers a warm and inviting ambiance, perfect for intimate gatherings or special occasions. Our menu features a range of delicious dishes, including local specialties and creative twists...

Welcome to Cutillo's Restaurant, where exceptional dining experiences await in the heart of Carmel. Our restaurant offers a warm and inviting ambiance, perfect for intimate gatherings or special occasions. Our menu features a range of delicious dishes, including local specialties and creative twists on Italian classics. Our signature appetizers, such as the roasted red pepper and calamari, are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Pair your meal with one of our expertly crafted cocktails, great coffee, or an extensive selection of wine from around the world. For dessert, indulge in one of our decadent treats, carefully selected to satisfy any sweet tooth. What truly sets us apart is our exceptional service and attention to detail. Our friendly staff are passionate about providing a memorable experience for every guest, whether you're dining solo or with a large group. We also take pride in serving locally sourced ingredients and offer a convenient takeout option for those on-the-go. Whether you're looking for a romantic evening or a special celebration,

Cosa dicono i clienti di Cutillo's Restaurant

Cutillo's is a charming, cozy Italian restaurant known for its excellent service, friendly staff, and delicious food. Customers rave about the plentiful menu, accommodating special requests, and the warm, family-owned atmosphere. Reservations are highly recommended.

Piatti popolari

calamari duck with apricot sauce veal scallopini chicken with pecan, apple, cinnamon sauce roasted red pepper

Ideale per

Coppie Famiglie Celebrazioni

Tip: Reservations are recommended as the restaurant is often busy. Some find it pricey, but many feel the food is worth it.

Services

🅿️ Parking Accessible 🍽️ Déjeuner 🌙 Dîner 🥗 Vegetarian Coffee
🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy 💕 Romantic 👔 Upscale 👨‍👩‍👧 Family 👥 Groups

Domande frequenti su Cutillo's Restaurant

Cutillo's Restaurant si trova in 1196 Farmers Mills Rd, Carmel Hamlet, NY 10512, Carmel.
Cutillo's Restaurant offre cucina american;european.
Cutillo's Restaurant ha orari di apertura regolari. Consulta il profilo per gli orari aggiornati.
Cutillo's Restaurant offre i seguenti servizi: mangiare sul posto, da asporto.
I piatti più consigliati di Cutillo's Restaurant secondo le recensioni dei clienti sono: calamari, duck with apricot sauce, veal scallopini, chicken with pecan, apple, cinnamon sauce, roasted red pepper.
Cutillo's Restaurant è ideale per coppie, famiglie, celebrazioni.
Cutillo's is a charming, cozy Italian restaurant known for its excellent service, friendly staff, and delicious food. Customers rave about the plentiful menu, accommodating special requests, and the warm, family-owned atmosphere. Reservations are highly recommended.
Reservations are recommended as the restaurant is often busy. Some find it pricey, but many feel the food is worth it.
181
Recensioni

Recensioni di Cutillo's Restaurant Carmel

4.6
181
5★
78%
4★
12%
3★
4%
2★
1%
1★
4%
Recensioni (120)
P
Paul Zenir

everybody is great there, the food is exellent. the atmosphere is incredible!!

T
Tim Spahn

This is the best food ever. The owners really care about you and the food they make.

J
Jack Mosel

Cool spot. Great food! Special place.

D
Diane Lee

Staff is wonderful! The atmosphere is homey and the food is superd!!

D
Debbie C

This place, food, wait staff, atmosphere, always makes me happy!

C
Christina Tanzman

Both the server and the food are awesome!

A
Anthony Civitillo

First class! Great food, great staff, great ambiance.

C
Carol Lang

They make good cosmo's and have delish food

F
Frank Gildea

Great place..... home feeling..... great food ... hospitality ...

T
Tom Thogersen

An excellent combination of great food, service and ambience

N
Nelson Davis

Amazing "everything" at very, very reasonable prices.

S
Shaun Favuzza

Excellent food, great atmosphere, great workers.

R
Robert Casabianca

Just elegant

R
R lynn

the best food ever such a chill atmosphere loved will be back!!!!!!!!!!!

T
Terry Galligan

Always a great meal and service.

J
Joseph Schallock

Good food friendly staff nice

K
Kenneth Wathey

Always great food and great service 👍

M
Marisa Crowley-Ortiz

Cute and cozy, food was good.

H
Here Today Gone 2 morrow RVing

Amazing!!!! Had the Veal fungi omg. I'm going there again in 2 days.

I
Ibrahim Barazi

One of the best meals I've had in a long time! Fantastic food and friendly service.

D
David Munk

Super enjoyable dinner. If you are the anxious type and like to plow through dinner go elsewhere.

J
Jill Karell

Beautiful restaurant, delicious food & fantastic service! Great for a special occasion as well.

W
Wendy

Fresh food, friendly staff and fun place to eat with or without the kids. Try Pat's stuffed portobello mushrooms, yum!

G
Glenn Kraeck

Food is always prepared to perfection. Friendly and attentive staff. The chef is a graduate of the CIA.

L
Lillian Cabrera

Celebrated my mother's 80th birthday. Great food and great service.

J
Joseph Faiella

Awesome food great service! An awesome family run place! Will keep coming back!

S
Sue Zasso

A great place! Fantastic food! Friendly staff!! Will definitely be back.

M
Michael Mullaney

Couldn't have been nicer! Like having dinner at a friend's home, but your friend is a gourmet chef!! Try this place soon.

T
Tfc Lavelle

Tops. Much thanks to Carol and Patrick and Lori and everyone else that makes this one of the great dining experiences

J
Jerry Stein

Great food and service from friendly people. I have been a patron and will continue to dine here.

P
Paul Schalkham

family owned business that will make things your way. They are great at everything try and you will see for yourself.

M
Melissa K

Wonderful family owned place! We had an amazing dinner.

A
Anthony Infantino

Fantastic Service! Fantastic Food! Would Definitely Dine there Again!

W
William Yellott

Everything is top notch at this restaurant. Cutillo's have gained customers for life from my wife and I.

W
William Noel

Great food in family run restaurant that is nice but not pretentious.

R
Ronald Gaedje

That at home feel and fine dinning taste all in one. Great place

R
Robert Rosit

Quaint restaurant nestled in the woods with great atmosphere

P
Peter Fiore

Very friendly and quite ambiance. Food was delicious and price right.

A
Alfonso Bastone

Very good food and service 👌 very attentive and polite nice atmosphere will visit again

t
trisha Pagliuca Johnson

So far this has been the best restaurant my book club/dinner club group has been to. Comfortable to have conversations around the room and great food. Great value.

D
Daniel Moran

Pat and family was amazing in having an absolute fabulous meal made for my whole family after my fathers funeral. Opened up their doors early and served delicious food. Great food and even better people.

L
Lorena Amador

We went this past weekend for dinner to celebrate my daughter's graduation when we were coming back from upstate NY. It is a very peaceful environment with delicious food and excellent service. Make a reservation! Food is really, really good!

C
Clara Alal-Bilyck

Delicious food and cozy atmosphere!

D
Diane Lee

Homey atmosphere, consistantly excellent food. Great and friendly service with unbeatable prices for the value of the meals. We have never been disappointed. Excellent chef Patrick!

A
Anthony Quattrone

This is one of those hidden secrets , they make you feel like family . Lori sees me coming in and has my martini ready , will make changes to menu without a problem . Food is always great and fresh bread is outstanding .

R
Richard Hazzard

A very special restaurant. Family friends for 50 years. Carol Cutillo welcomes you into what was once their home. Her son, Culinary Institute trained Patrick Cutillo prepares for you the finest of Italian specialties along with the many dessert offerings of his mother Carol...bringing forth a dining experience worthy of the Cutillo name. Enjoy!

Y
Yovanka Castellanos

Excellent environment and customer service. The food was outstanding in every single plate we ordered for our 14 people group. A must go in Carmel!

D
Diane Thomsen

Good food beautiful place, like going to Grandma's for dinner. Very well taken care of

R
Rick Reggio

Great place,Carol and staff are always welcoming ,food is great and Tim makes a great drink. It's a regular on our dine out circuit

m
matt ferrara

One hell of place. Our service was excellent and the food was way too good. Good portion amount. Had the Veal and Eggplant parm. All I can say is phenomenal!

N
Norma Scott

Great food & service all the time. I celebrated my husband's birthday this past weekend and Cutillo's did an awesome job for us.

P
Pedro Ortiz

Great location...antique home with new life and great food and service. Visit and enjoy!

C
Carol Vierra

The food is excellent. The Ambiance is great. The owners are terrific. I can't say anything more about this place you need to go.

S
Scoob Doo

Great atmosphere, superior food, fast, reliable service....a bit pricey, but, its not yer average chain style restaurant, and im willing to pay for that!

E
Eva Hecht

A gem! In every way. The food was flavorful, the staff was friendly and the atmosphere was charming.

R
Ray Weickel

Always a great place to dine. Catillo's has been our go to restaurant of choice to celebrate important occasions for years and never disappoints.

M
Michael Borrello

Here is an establishment which preserves a dining experience you can only find in a family run business. The menu is a selection of Italian classics with a homemade authenticity that can't be found in most other Italian restaurants. It's great for a couples night out or for a family gathering. The staff is very friendly and can ensure you are satisfied with your entire experience.

L
Liz Rice

We had a wonderful dinner last night at Cutillo's Restaurant. The food was excellent, service impeccable and atmosphere very enjoyable. This was our first-time dining here and plan to return soon.

G
Greg Jacobsen

I have never had the same dish twice, and every dish is better than the last! Tonight was the Chicken Pecan... delicious. Can't recommend this restaurant enough!!

P
Patti Bee

Absolutely delicious food .... to the last morsel !! I love the menu and specials, not your typical Italian food, it's a cut above. You can tell the chef, Pat was classically trained and trained by the best. Highly recommended. If I could give more stars I would.

J
John Ansbro

We had a family luncheon at cutillo's yesterday. The food was exceptional and the staff was incredible. The last time I had been here was when I was a child for my grandparents 50th wedding anniversary celebration. One of the same waitresses that was there yesterday was there 15 years ago. It was an overall incredible experience. I am very grateful for this staff and this amazing restaurant.

J
Joanne Tritto

Cutillo's restaurant is our favorite place to dine! The cozy, homelike dining rooms are very comfortable. The food is excellent. Chef Patrick prepares each dinner with his CIA expertise and will accommodate your wishes, when possible. Treat yourself to a lovely night out and make your reservation!

A
Archbishop Anthony Bondi

I totally enjoyed my experience at this restaurant. I ordered the veal valdostana which was cooked to perfection. My sister goes there regularly...we were celebrating her birthday yet they didn't mark her birthday with a piece of cake or a candle or anything.

E
Erin Minutello

I got something "off the menu".. it was delicious. Stuffed chicken!! Polenta app was yummy. Only complaint is expect to be there for a while. Food is a little slow to come out... but it's family owner local business and ill be a repeat customer.

N
Nancy Iankowitz

Sandy was a wonderful waitress. The service was outstanding & thetsteak was done to order. I would have ordered salmon, butb they don't offer wild caught. Would have preferred grass fed beef but for what we ordered, the price was reasonable and the ambiance fabulous.

J
Jonathan Moorehead

Great food, friendly staff. Reasonable prices, hearty portions. Inventive, adventurous menu, not just the standard Italian fare, but your favorites are there too. Plenty of parking. Family owned for over three decades. Nice warm vibe. Family pictures adorn the dining areas. You feel like you've been invited to an old friend's place for dinner.

L
Lisa B

Great little spot tucked out of the way. At 7p the parking lot was packed. Reservations recommended. Extensive menu & special white board made for a tough decision. We decided on veal scallopini (excellent choice) & chicken with pecan, apple, cinnamon sauce in a light cream sauce (to die for). Both dishes came with a house salad, warm bread (hot), risotto ( I’ve had better); the risotto was hot in temperature compared to our chicken & veal dishes. A nice accompaniment of root vegetables done exceptionally well. We were so hungry that I didn’t think to take pics till we were three-quarters done with our meal! The decor is reminiscent of being in someones living room with holiday décor abundant.

F
Fatima Skornjan

Everything pictured deliciously melted in your mouth. Nostalgic charming rustic setting. Excellent service. There’s a reason they have been around for a while. Highly recommend.

T
Tony

Pat the chef always has new delicious recipes and is an amazing chef! Carol is the most hard working, professional owner/waiter/bartender! Lori is the greatest waitress and always makes dinner fun and makes me feel like I’m having dinner home with family! The entire staff is always professional and pleasant. Prices are reasonable and atmosphere can’t be beat. Lori even holds up special menu when there’s nothing to place it on LOL !

Jonathan Moorehead
Jonathan Moorehead

Great food, friendly staff. Reasonable prices, hearty portions. Inventive, adventurous menu, not just the standard Italian fare, but your favorites are there too. Plenty of parking. Family owned for over three decades. Nice warm vibe. Family pictures adorn the dining areas. You feel like you've been invited to an old friend's place for dinner.

Lisa B
Lisa B

Great little spot tucked out of the way. At 7p the parking lot was packed. Reservations recommended. Extensive menu & special white board made for a tough decision. We decided on veal scallopini (excellent choice) & chicken with pecan, apple, cinnamon sauce in a light cream sauce (to die for). Both dishes came with a house salad, warm bread (hot), risotto ( I’ve had better); the risotto was hot in temperature compared to our chicken & veal dishes. A nice accompaniment of root vegetables done exceptionally well. We were so hungry that I didn’t think to take pics till we were three-quarters done with our meal! The decor is reminiscent of being in someones living room with holiday décor abundant.

Fatima Skornjan
Fatima Skornjan

Everything pictured deliciously melted in your mouth. Nostalgic charming rustic setting. Excellent service. There’s a reason they have been around for a while. Highly recommend.

M
Michael Valentine

I’ve been passing this place for years and we decided to try it last night. The food and service are wonderful. Really great with kids too. Drinks were excellent as well. Can’t wait to try this place during the summer. It’s on the tour and we will be back. Thank you!!

L
Lori Ringo

What a treasure! Sightseeing over the weekend and stumbled upon this gem. Luckily we arrived around 5:30. We were the only ones there - for about 5 minutes. Within 30 minutes the place was packed! The menu had a lot to offer and it all looked delicious. We had the calamari to start and it was fresh and tender. For our main, I had the veal fungi and I was so happy to see lots of fresh mushrooms! My spouse had the spicy hot scallops and he said they were amazing. Our waiter was very attentive even though the place was completely full. It was fun to see so many of the locals meeting up with their friends. The hostess recognized we weren’t locals and gave us some great ideas for places to visit while in the area. Either show up early or get a reservation. You won’t be sorry.

B
Barbara Tufano

First time for dinner it was fabulous. The service was excellent and the women serving us were terrific and very engaging. Will definitely be going back!

G
Glenn Jamieson

This is a great place, highly recommend. Menu is plentiful, food is fantastic, and the atmosphere was exceptional for our graduation celebration. The service was outstanding as well. Appreciated the pace of service that let our family enjoy our celebration and the wonderful food and drink together. Thank you for a great meal and a great evening with family!

e
emmet toner

Quaint little Italian place nestled inside a house off the beaten track. Been here a couple of times and have not had a bad experience. Everyone is very nice and the food is always good. You HAVE to make a reservation, they are always busy.

H
Hannah Pollack

Charming is truly the perfect description. The food was *delicious*. The waitstaff was very kind. It was a great meal and I hope to go back soon.

E
Eddie Soto

When entering this home turned restaurant, I was a bit skeptical on how good can this place really be. Parking was easily accessible. Now upon entering I was faced with what I can only describe as the decor something Gordan Ramsay would have a field day with. Putting that aside, the staff and food were AWESOME! Prices reasonable although portion sizes aren't that big but honestly do we really need giant portions. The flavors definitely made up for it. Please give this place a chance you won't regret it.

H
Henry Senno

My wife, brother and sister in law went for dinner the other night. It was my wife’s and mine 1st time there. The food was fantastic. We started with the roasted red pepper and calamari appetizers. Probably the best calamari I ever had. Roasted red pepper, cheese and olives were very tasty. For the main course I ordered the pork loin. It was very tender and juicy, had a great flavor with the seasoning they added. My wife had ravioli which was cooked just right and the cheese flavor was outstanding. My sister in law had veal that was so tender it melted in your mouth. My brother in-law had filet of sole franchise. I did not taste it but he said it was outstanding. We had coffee and dessert. Their cheesecake is to die for, so good. We had red wine (Montepulciano) throughout our meal which was very tasty and very generous pouring. I would give this restaurant a 10 out of 10. The portions of food were just right and the price was not expensive. Oh yes and the waiter (Tim) was very attentive and a pleasure to talk to. If you want to have a great relaxing meal where you are not rushed out the door try Cutillo’s you will be very happy you went there.

P
Paul Garcia

My wife and I recently found this place about a year ago. Have gone 4 times and have had nothing but exceptional service and food. I sort of want to keep this place a hidden gem. They recommend reservations, but walking in should be no issue for a small party of 2-4. However, every time I make a reservation, we are greeted and seated immediately with our table prepared and water already served, which is a nice touch. Not many restaurants actually prepare the table for the reservation that was made previously. Each time we have had the same waiter which has been great. He is always accommodating and polite and attentive. Other staff have also been friendly and kind. Soft butter is always served to go with the delicious bread. The fried calamari is great. The chicken parm is good. My favorite has been the NY Strip with Gorgonzola cheese melted on top. Cooked perfect each time. The cheese gives it a great flavor that just works well together. Had it twice and my wife also had it and it’s delicious each time. And for dessert the tartufo is probably the best I’ve had. Highly recommend. We have decided to make this a place for special occasions such as birthdays or anniversary’s. It’s a place that we truly enjoy and look forward to coming to for years to come. Highly suggest it. Prices are very reasonable. Much more expensive places with mediocre food. This place is worth every penny.

C
Chelsea S

Super cozy with high value food. I had the duck with apricot sauce and it was cooked to perfection. Their wait staff were knowledgeable about wine pairings, the methods of cooking, and were able to answer our questions smartly and professionally. A great place for anniversaries or special events, or just to have a really nice dinner.

A
Amanda Mauldin

Cute homey spot. They offered to take our coats and hang them upon arrival. The staff is older and oh so friendly, we noticed they recognized their regulars and engaged in friendly conversation with them and us and even took interest in the kids. They accommodated the requests of my picky daughter. The food was delicious, atmosphere was friendly. Would definitely go again and bring friends.

E
Eileen Young

Such a lovely restaurant. The food was excellent and they were very accomodating to special requests. Friendly atmosphere in a very quaint old building. While some dishes are a bit pricey, there is still so much to choose from in all price ranges. I will definitely go back because I thoroughly enjoyed myself. Check them out!!

D
Dana Walters

Wonderful! We so enjoy dining here. So many great menu items to choose from and they offer additional daily specials. They also offer a nice variety of GF options, that I require. They have been in business for 62 years and they are still busy. I would suggest Reservations. Great food.

P
Perry Guarracino

Neighborhood place that we go every week- food is amazing . Chef Pat Cutillo is always on his game. The specials are always terrific and there is not a bad thing on the menu. Veal is so tender you can cut it with a fork. Desserts are awesome- Carol and Lori make you feel welcome all the time- and the atmosphere is great in this old house- you must try it and the bread is always free and homemade- this place will rival nyc joints and I have been to many. Quality of food over quantity any day- if you want cheap big portions go to Olive Garden and get sick. Top choices- mussels, veal, Gnocchi and Penne Vodka is great- in Italy no one rushes thru dinner and this is a great place to eat and relax

Michael Valentine
Michael Valentine

I’ve been passing this place for years and we decided to try it last night. The food and service are wonderful. Really great with kids too. Drinks were excellent as well. Can’t wait to try this place during the summer. It’s on the tour and we will be back. Thank you!!

Lori Ringo
Lori Ringo

What a treasure! Sightseeing over the weekend and stumbled upon this gem. Luckily we arrived around 5:30. We were the only ones there - for about 5 minutes. Within 30 minutes the place was packed! The menu had a lot to offer and it all looked delicious. We had the calamari to start and it was fresh and tender. For our main, I had the veal fungi and I was so happy to see lots of fresh mushrooms! My spouse had the spicy hot scallops and he said they were amazing. Our waiter was very attentive even though the place was completely full. It was fun to see so many of the locals meeting up with their friends. The hostess recognized we weren’t locals and gave us some great ideas for places to visit while in the area. Either show up early or get a reservation. You won’t be sorry.

Barbara Tufano
Barbara Tufano

First time for dinner it was fabulous. The service was excellent and the women serving us were terrific and very engaging. Will definitely be going back!

emmet toner
emmet toner

Quaint little Italian place nestled inside a house off the beaten track. Been here a couple of times and have not had a bad experience. Everyone is very nice and the food is always good. You HAVE to make a reservation, they are always busy.

Hannah Pollack
Hannah Pollack

Charming is truly the perfect description. The food was *delicious*. The waitstaff was very kind. It was a great meal and I hope to go back soon.

Glenn Jamieson
Glenn Jamieson

This is a great place, highly recommend. Menu is plentiful, food is fantastic, and the atmosphere was exceptional for our graduation celebration. The service was outstanding as well. Appreciated the pace of service that let our family enjoy our celebration and the wonderful food and drink together. Thank you for a great meal and a great evening with family!

Henry Senno
Henry Senno

My wife, brother and sister in law went for dinner the other night. It was my wife’s and mine 1st time there. The food was fantastic. We started with the roasted red pepper and calamari appetizers. Probably the best calamari I ever had. Roasted red pepper, cheese and olives were very tasty. For the main course I ordered the pork loin. It was very tender and juicy, had a great flavor with the seasoning they added. My wife had ravioli which was cooked just right and the cheese flavor was outstanding. My sister in law had veal that was so tender it melted in your mouth. My brother in-law had filet of sole franchise. I did not taste it but he said it was outstanding. We had coffee and dessert. Their cheesecake is to die for, so good. We had red wine (Montepulciano) throughout our meal which was very tasty and very generous pouring. I would give this restaurant a 10 out of 10. The portions of food were just right and the price was not expensive. Oh yes and the waiter (Tim) was very attentive and a pleasure to talk to. If you want to have a great relaxing meal where you are not rushed out the door try Cutillo’s you will be very happy you went there.

Paul Garcia
Paul Garcia

My wife and I recently found this place about a year ago. Have gone 4 times and have had nothing but exceptional service and food. I sort of want to keep this place a hidden gem. They recommend reservations, but walking in should be no issue for a small party of 2-4. However, every time I make a reservation, we are greeted and seated immediately with our table prepared and water already served, which is a nice touch. Not many restaurants actually prepare the table for the reservation that was made previously. Each time we have had the same waiter which has been great. He is always accommodating and polite and attentive. Other staff have also been friendly and kind. Soft butter is always served to go with the delicious bread. The fried calamari is great. The chicken parm is good. My favorite has been the NY Strip with Gorgonzola cheese melted on top. Cooked perfect each time. The cheese gives it a great flavor that just works well together. Had it twice and my wife also had it and it’s delicious each time. And for dessert the tartufo is probably the best I’ve had. Highly recommend. We have decided to make this a place for special occasions such as birthdays or anniversary’s. It’s a place that we truly enjoy and look forward to coming to for years to come. Highly suggest it. Prices are very reasonable. Much more expensive places with mediocre food. This place is worth every penny.

Eddie Soto
Eddie Soto

When entering this home turned restaurant, I was a bit skeptical on how good can this place really be. Parking was easily accessible. Now upon entering I was faced with what I can only describe as the decor something Gordan Ramsay would have a field day with. Putting that aside, the staff and food were AWESOME! Prices reasonable although portion sizes aren't that big but honestly do we really need giant portions. The flavors definitely made up for it. Please give this place a chance you won't regret it.

Chelsea S
Chelsea S

Super cozy with high value food. I had the duck with apricot sauce and it was cooked to perfection. Their wait staff were knowledgeable about wine pairings, the methods of cooking, and were able to answer our questions smartly and professionally. A great place for anniversaries or special events, or just to have a really nice dinner.

Dana Walters
Dana Walters

Wonderful! We so enjoy dining here. So many great menu items to choose from and they offer additional daily specials. They also offer a nice variety of GF options, that I require. They have been in business for 62 years and they are still busy. I would suggest Reservations. Great food.

Amanda Mauldin
Amanda Mauldin

Cute homey spot. They offered to take our coats and hang them upon arrival. The staff is older and oh so friendly, we noticed they recognized their regulars and engaged in friendly conversation with them and us and even took interest in the kids. They accommodated the requests of my picky daughter. The food was delicious, atmosphere was friendly. Would definitely go again and bring friends.

Eileen Young
Eileen Young

Such a lovely restaurant. The food was excellent and they were very accomodating to special requests. Friendly atmosphere in a very quaint old building. While some dishes are a bit pricey, there is still so much to choose from in all price ranges. I will definitely go back because I thoroughly enjoyed myself. Check them out!!

M
Michael Cambeiro

Good food, nice atmosphere, friendly wait staff.

D
Dennis Zasso

The food and the experience was excellent staff were great

C
Charles Brown

Excellent food and excellent service

J
JAMES K BATTLE Sr.

Lunch and dinner with friends and a great staff will bring many good memories. Nice outside seating in warm weather. Try it.

J
Joyce Mitchell

Cutillo's is one of my favorite local restaurants. On the occasion of my last visit, it was for lunch and my meal was disappointing, but my companion enjoyed hers off the specialties menu; I, too, should have ordered from it. The kilbasa was excellent. Dinner menu splendid and my favorite entrée is quail.

W
William Griffiths Sr. (Bill)

Reservations only. White cloth dining & still informal. Great food fair pricing. Staff treats like family. Remembers our past visits. Multiple cuisines. First timers alwant to return

P
Paul Glenn

You really feel like family here Excellent food and excellent waitress. Look forward to going back.

D
David Pollack

"i wish there were a category between ""very good"" and ""excellent"". have to reserve excellent for the very best, but cutillo's is better than just very good. nice seasonal specialities, the chef cares about his food and his clients and it shows. "

F
Five-Star Fred

Let's take a step back in time, shall we? When things were simple, homemade food was served, prices were reasonable, and service was top notch. Welcome to Cutillos! Off the beaten path - which is a good thing. Probably the reason it's changed so little over the years. The food and service are the best. Great specials. Super affordable, which is so appreciated these days! Don't change a thing Cutillos!

Five-Star Fred
Five-Star Fred

Let's take a step back in time, shall we? When things were simple, homemade food was served, prices were reasonable, and service was top notch. Welcome to Cutillos! Off the beaten path - which is a good thing. Probably the reason it's changed so little over the years. The food and service are the best. Great specials. Super affordable, which is so appreciated these days! Don't change a thing Cutillos!

T
Thanassi Karageorgiou

If you really want fine Italian dining, don't come here. Take your significant other for a trip to NYC or another nearby metropolitan area and enjoy proper Italian food and ambiance. Heavily overpriced for the portions and quality. Our salad was $15 and looked like it was assembled by a child at a Roy Roger's Fixin's bar. The staff seems disinterested in being employed and catering to customer's needs. They got our drink order wrong twice in a span of 10 minutes. BREAD is extra money on the menu. Unheard of in ANY proper Italian restaurant, where the bread is (generally better and) treated like a water tap. Skip it and go to the nearby pizza joint to get more bang for your buck. This place is so depressing on the inside. Torn fabric on the chairs, mismatching chairs, and they have the nerve to charge what they charge. The positive was that the lasagna and the pasta fagioli were pretty good. Everything else about this place, not so much.

R
Rob R

I'm going to be as honest as I can be. The waitress was very nice, unfortunately service was incredibly slow, we waited 15 min to be acknowledged, 15-20 min for salad, another 15-20 min for the main course, which was very good, a bit pricey (I'm used to get much more )but comparable to other Italian restaurants in this area. The decor is like a grandmother's living room, which is fine, but far from classy. It is a great place for a date, where all you are interested in is the person sitting across the table from you. Meal and ambiance is secondary. You'll have plenty of time to converse. I'll recommend this place if you are fine with that. I'm accustomed (in an Italian restaurant setting) to be being treated like family, nice music, good conversation with staff, meeting the owner or chef, keeping your glasses and bread basket filled.

S
Susannah Straz

The service and atmosphere were excellent, but the food was just ok. w I had a half duck and even though it was 2 legs and no breast, I enjoyed it. But the "risotto rice" was bland, and the vegetable was one tiny piece of broccoli and 3 pieces of carrot with no seasoning at all.

Susannah Straz
Susannah Straz

The service and atmosphere were excellent, but the food was just ok. w I had a half duck and even though it was 2 legs and no breast, I enjoyed it. But the "risotto rice" was bland, and the vegetable was one tiny piece of broccoli and 3 pieces of carrot with no seasoning at all.

R
Rachel Nenner-Payton

Too expensive for a restaurant listed on an interstate road sign

E
Eileen Myers

Just had dinner...charged $21 for small side if broccoli..told waitress that bill was incorrect..she said chef sets prices and will not change price...so main course was $38 for linguini with clams and shrimp plus $21 for a very small side of broccoli total for main course $59...had appetizer oysters 6 for $12..the smallest oysters i ever saw..will not go back..would not recommend

G
Gerald Schiavo

Extremely disappointed with my meal. The veal in the veal parmigiana was sliced as thin as prosciutto so I basically ended up with fried breadcrumbs. The sauce was non description void of any species other than sauteed plum tomatoes. The penne was mealy and over cooked. I would not recommend this dish or restaurant. It is over priced and the quality of food is poor.

B
Bill Durkin

Pricey, cramped, and assertive staff are just a few of the detractors in this secluded eatery. Upon entry, staff insist on taking your coat and you have to stick to your guns should you want to keep it. The cramped conditions are exacerbated by the abundant knick knacks and attempts to make you think you went to Grand Mas House. The promised warmth of the tiny fire place will likely not reach you. Then there's the food. What little you get is flavorless. The chicken parm would have been outdone by a frozen Stouffers dinner. I made better with a can of Tuttorosso crushed in minutes at home. In fact I think straight from the can is better than what I was served. The chicken was pounded flat and still tough. I do also understand that garlic bread should be enjoyed with the meal, not before, and not be dried out sticks which render to breadcrumbs. Where is the warm garlic loaf to delight your senses? Dust. The portions are tiny and the prices exorbitant. Looking around you would see no private diners, you know a romantic couple, but tables of 8 or more and no kids. That is, corporate accounts only. The serving staff are knattily dressed and very attentive but boastful and sure to tell you how good your food is. I think they must add a hefty percentage to the prices. Do try somewhere else. I do cook well but I am no pro. I have experienced my match many times and then some when going out. Even from pizzerias. Actually some of them are great. Peace.

m
michelle bauer

The service was terrible. We didn’t get our salads for an hour after being seated.

michelle bauer
michelle bauer

The service was terrible. We didn’t get our salads for an hour after being seated.

Bill Durkin
Bill Durkin

Pricey, cramped, and assertive staff are just a few of the detractors in this secluded eatery. Upon entry, staff insist on taking your coat and you have to stick to your guns should you want to keep it. The cramped conditions are exacerbated by the abundant knick knacks and attempts to make you think you went to Grand Mas House. The promised warmth of the tiny fire place will likely not reach you. Then there's the food. What little you get is flavorless. The chicken parm would have been outdone by a frozen Stouffers dinner. I made better with a can of Tuttorosso crushed in minutes at home. In fact I think straight from the can is better than what I was served. The chicken was pounded flat and still tough. I do also understand that garlic bread should be enjoyed with the meal, not before, and not be dried out sticks which render to breadcrumbs. Where is the warm garlic loaf to delight your senses? Dust. The portions are tiny and the prices exorbitant. Looking around you would see no private diners, you know a romantic couple, but tables of 8 or more and no kids. That is, corporate accounts only. The serving staff are knattily dressed and very attentive but boastful and sure to tell you how good your food is. I think they must add a hefty percentage to the prices. Do try somewhere else. I do cook well but I am no pro. I have experienced my match many times and then some when going out. Even from pizzerias. Actually some of them are great. Peace.

Accedi per lasciare una recensione

Accedi
👑 È tuo? Rivendicalo GRATIS!

Rimuovi annunci e gestisci il menu

Esplora la tua zona

Più ristoranti a Carmel →
📸

8 Foto

Esplora le foto di Cutillo's Restaurant

Cutillo's Restaurant
Cutillo's Restaurant
Cutillo's Restaurant
Cutillo's Restaurant
Cutillo's Restaurant
+3 Altro
📍

Informazioni su Cutillo's Restaurant

Come arrivare

1196 Farmers Mills Rd, Carmel Hamlet, NY 10512

Caricamento mappa...
Cutillo's Restaurant
Tocca per le indicazioni

Punti salienti

Molto votato
4.6/5 stelle
💬
Molte recensioni
181 recensioni
💰
Prezzo moderato
Livello di prezzo
👨‍🍳
american;european
Tipo di cucina

Servizi

🍽️ Pranzo
🍾 Cena
Caffè
🍰 Dolci
🥗 Opzioni Vegetariane
🥡 Da Asporto
🍴 Mangiare sul Posto

Opzioni di ristorazione

🍽️ Mangiare sul Posto
🥡 Da Asporto

Info Ristorante

Stato
Verificato dal proprietario
🕐 Horario Hoy
Closed
Valutazione
4.6/5
💬 Recensioni
181
💰 Livello di prezzo
$$
⏱️ Visita tipica
People typically spend 2.5 hours here
📞 Telefono
+1 845-225-8903
🌐 Sito web
cutillosrestaurant.com
📋 Menu
Vedi Menu

Servizi

🅿️ Parcheggio
Accessibile in sedia a rotelle
🚻 Bagno
💳 Carte di credito
📱 Pagamenti mobili
🏘️

Il Quartiere

Posizione

1196 Farmers Mills Rd, Carmel Hamlet, NY 10512

📍 Esplora il Quartiere

Weather
15°
Meteo aggiornato ogni ora · Lavoro ed eventi aggiornati quotidianamente
🎮

Giochi

🎮 Guadagna Punti Mentre Esplori!

Gioca a Find Me e riscatta punti per sconti da Cutillo's Restaurant e altri ristoranti

🎮

Guadagna Punti da Cutillo's Restaurant!

Gioca a Find Me e riscatta ricompense qui

Guadagna punti extra e riscattali per ricompense da Cutillo's Restaurant

🏆 Ricompense di Cutillo's Restaurant

💰

Sconto 10%

Da Cutillo's Restaurant

1000 pts
Disponibile
🍽️

Antipasto Gratis

Alla tua prossima visita

2500 pts
Limitato
👑

Tavolo VIP

Esperienza premium

5000 pts
Esclusivo

per riscattare ricompense e guadagnare punti

📋 Come funzionano le ricompense?

1

Gioca a Find Me

Ogni 100 punti score = 1 punto ricompensa

2

Accumula Punti

I worker ottengono 2x punti per partita

3

Riscatta Ricompense

Sconti, cibo gratis ed esperienze VIP

Chiama
Lascia una recensione su Google
👑

È tuo? Rivendicalo GRATIS!

Rimuovi annunci e gestisci il menu

Accedi e gioca

Controlla la tua email!

Nessuna password — ti invieremo un link via email

Ti abbiamo inviato un link di accesso

Controlla la cartella spam se non lo vedi