Best pizza I’ve ever had! I’m from the Chicago area, lived in Arizona, traveled all over the United States and Canada in an RV for over ten years; and this is the best pizza I’ve had. I don’t write reviews but this is exceptional. We recently visited the Corning Glass Museum and stayed in Corning for two nights. Our first night we ate here and I was so amazed at the quality of your pizza. Bravo!!!’

My friend from Buffalo recommended Aniello's to us when he knew we were going to the Corning Glass museum. He knows we are pizza snobs, well my husband is, and said this is a must! And let me tell you he was not wrong! Tasted like we were in New York City having a proper slice! Great people working their pizza magic behind the counter and taking care of you immediately! Love these guys! And the price is right on too!

I was in Corning overnight and took a stroll down the wonderful Market street... taking note of the number of pizza places in a small stretch of street... I gravitated back towards Aniello's; busy place, seems like a lot of Locals (and you always want to eat where the Natives eat...); got two slices, good pizza... good price... nice person helping me... I decided to hang out and eat it there and just people watch. Better than the airport! Highly recommend.

Always very good pizza. Service was a bit slow but they were busy. One of the best pizza places in the area.

Great little family owned pizza shop. Pizza was delicious, had a lovely conversation with the owner. Highly recommend!

The atmosphere, the service, the thin and crispy crust … it all combines into the most perfect pizza experience! Your pizza is brought to your table whether you sit in a cute little 2-person table by the window, a booth, a long table perfect for groups, or at one of the outdoor tables with your dog. The slice varieties are incredible, with something for everyone! This was my first time at Aniello’s but I’ll be back!

Amazing pizza. One of the best doughs and crust we have had. The garlic knots came out fresh and we're toasted outside with nice soft inside. The pepperoni slice was great and the BLT specialty was one of the better specialty pizzas we have had, very crispy bacon. Very friendly staff, we will be back.

OMG!!! Growing up in NJ we had plenty of Italian pizza shops around some better than others. After moving to West Virginia, 10 years ago, we realized how bad pizza can get. Passing through Corning, New York, we were Hoping for the best. And let’s just say They didn’t disappoint! Brought us back to our roots, fantastic mozzarella. The sauce was perfect. The pizza was thin and firm. The crust was magnificent and crispy. You could pick up a slice and It held together With a Perfectly cooked undercarriage. I bet Dave P. Would love it….. Everybody knows the rules a solid 8.9 in my book. If passing through again, I will Most certainly stop in for another bite.

5/8/24 Came in tonight looking for a sub. Damn if Jasmine wasn't here. Usually do a salad. Tonight I was going to skip it. Asked if Jasmine who was taking my order would be makin' our salad. On the yes... We got salad. Yep! Kid has the touch! It was great... 05/21/23 Best Antipasto was just kicked up. Jasmine made it chopped, cut and mixed better! Making the best "better"! Wow... Greatest pizza and salad anywhere. Update: Tried something different this week. Monday and yesterday. Aniello's hot cheese steak! OMG!!! First try had mayo. I'm not a fan of mayo, but the hearing, well you might understand. It was incredible! So yesterday we were passing through Corning. Stopped in and tried it again, this time with the bbq sauce. Just incredible! So for decades it was the best pizza there is. Now, I have to try some other choices. Still the best pizza! Now with more choices. Wow.... Update: Just love Aniello's. Best of the best. Heading for Florida and it's the only thing bad. Aniello's South would be such a great addition. North Fort Myers! Yep, that's what we need! Please? What a great team here at Aniello's!!! We drive from 25 miles for Aniello's. Its so worth it! Best staff anywhere..... The best pizza restaurant anywhere. Try the artichoke and roasted red pepper white pizza. Its our favorite pizza. The antipasto salad is great. So much to love about this restaurant.

Absolutely the best Italian hoagie I've ever eaten

Best pizza I have ever had. I have traveled this country and the globe and not found any I enjoy more.

If you’re ever in the mood for a slice of heaven, look no further than Aniellos Pizzeria. This cozy eatery is a treasure trove of gourmet pizzas that range from classic white to vegetarian and even Sicilian1. The crust is perfectly crisp, the toppings are fresh, and the flavor is simply out of this world. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, their pizza is a must-try that will leave you craving more. And if you’re feeling adventurous, their extensive menu of salads, strombolis, calzones, and pasta dishes promises to delight. It’s not just a meal; it’s an experience that embodies the warmth and charm of a true Italian pizzeria1.

The only reason I moved to this peach of a town from the Outer Banks Of N.C. in 1979 is because I heard about Aniello's Pizza 😜 😉 🤣 😂 🍕. All the tourist come because they heard about Aniello's Pizza too, NOT TO SEE THE GLASS. If you've seen one piece of glass then you have seen them all 😂. Nobody comes here for Corning Inc. They come here for the PIZZA 🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕! So, when you arrive here from China, Taiwan, or wherever you come from, remember to walk right past the Museum of glass, across Centerway Bridge, take a left on Market St. where you will find Aniello's, and the world famous Hot Piece! 😋 🍕 Everyone love's a Hot Piece every once in awhile! 😜🤪😉 Take it from me, YOU WON'T FIND A BETTER PIZZA ANYWHERE ON THIS PLANET 🌍🌎......

Great pizza and quick service. They always have slices of many kinds available. They bring your order to your table which is nice. Located in the slightly slower part of Market Street so it's easy to get in.

My mother took me to her favorite childhood pizza place, and we were thrilled with our pie! Substantially gooey cheese, a nice touch of sauce and the crust was thin and crunchy!

Stopped on way back home from Niagara and had an amazing Pizza! We ordered vegetarian option and it came out quite well - piping hot from oven. Very friendly staff and awesome pizza!!

Absolutely amazing place!!! It was our first time this summer visiting Cape Cod. We stayed at the Dune Crest and this restaurant was just down the road. We fell in love with the food, atmosphere and super friendly staff. So much so that we started and ended our vacation at Aniellos. Highly recommend you try this place when you in the North Truro area. Also you can buy the olive oil they serve with bread right there. It is incredibly good. Best olive oil I've ever had.

I first started eating Aniello's pizza in the 70's. I was on my way to Webster, NY to visit my son Memorial day weekend and I wanted an exceptional NY pie. After many times giving Rochester pizzerias a shot but still to this day, haven't been able to find one. I took a little detour from my trip and drove to Aniello's. I tried to call an order in but my phone was acting up so I went in and order three plain NY pies to take some with me to my son's and to bring back to NC for a brother and my wife. I must say, it was well worth the detour and the wait. Pulled off in a rest stop about ten minutes away and I had to eat at least a couple. Very, very good.....hot and fresh, cold and warmed back up in a covered skillet. My hats off to that entire team. That place is a well oiled machine

We loved the specialty and grilled chicken pizza, it was absolutely delicious. We would come again, the location is perfect for travelers, the town is very pretty and there are a few coffee and gelato shops nearby.

What a delightful pizza stop. We loved the atmosphere and the hand tossed pizza. The medium was more than enough for the two of us. Plus we added a salad and garlic knots. It was a great road trip stop! Yum yum!

Best place ever for pizza, they never disappoint! Friendly atmosphere i live in bath and I would make the trip to corning every time I wanted a pizza. It worth the drive so if you never had there pizza your are truly are missing something special !

a place to go for Pizza. I went to up-state NY for a hike and picked this restaurant because it was closed to my hotel and it got lots of good reviews. They served pizza really quick. Their garlic knot was the best one I had so far. Tomato sauce is so smooth just like a heaven. They put cleaning stuff on each tables and there are clear wall in front of each in-door tables. There is a one-way in and one-way out in case the restaurant's busy

As good as pizza in New York City - and that's high praise! The pizza was excellent. The flavor was perfect; it had just the right mix of seasoning and I felt no need to add anything. The crust was just right - soft enough to fold, but not soggy. We ordered at the counter and then the pizza was brought to our table. The prices were totally reasonable as was the size of the slices - generous but not ridiculous. There was ample seating and everything was clean. Our overall experience was fantastic. Next time we will know that not only is there free parking on the street in front of the restaurant, but there is ample free parking in the lot behind the restaurant.

Consistently fantastic pizza. Their garlic knots are also out of this world delicious. Because their food is so good, they’re almost always very busy. They all work very hard to get people fed as soon as possible but because of their popularity, I don’t recommend here when you’re starving or short on time.

Market Street gem. Park out back if you can! Enjoy a nice dine in experience, or sit outside. It can get quite crowded in here! Food is great, made fresh. There seemed to be a lot of people working, and working as a team. It was nice to see that. Their prices are very good for what you get! They had sanitizer at each table, and other proper precautions which was nice to see. Everyone was helpful and friendly.

+2

Went here three times on my recent visit back home. We’ve been coming here since I was a kid. Really love the casual atmosphere, they represent Corning well. Even down to using Corelle wear plates. We also got the half buffalo half pickle pizza. Delicious combo!Can’t wait to go back again.

What a great find! Loved the thin crust NY style pizza. Ordered a medium Mediterranean. Wonderful mix of flavors.

Aniello's is always a good time. Whether you want a slice, a calzone, or a sub, all their food is amazing. The people who work there are the nicest as well. Super friendly and quick service.

Stopped for a quick bite while in Corning … what a delicious find! Cheesesteak, pizza and garlic knots were all wonderful. Staff was so helpful even though they were super super busy! 10/10 would recommend the pickle pizza.

Great service. Friendly and fast. Always very busy. But it's because it the best pizza in town...for decades. They do have gluten free crust, good! But they need to Not put flower on back of crust, that's the point of GF. Nice treat when in Corning.

Delicious Gluten Free pizza! Probably my favorite pizza yet. The ingredients taste fresh! Run, don't walk to Aniello's.

I can't stress how much we enjoyed this experience as a family! It was an amazing experience at every step of the way. The delivery guy helped us with parking! The cashier helped me pick a DELICIOUS Chicken Wing pizza. The servers have my son Basil and ketchup. The interior was beautiful. And best of all: the pizza and dipping sauce were KILLER. We are going to go out of our way to stop here again on our way home.

+1

My husband and I loooove the pizza at Aniello’s! We always make a point to stop whenever we’re driving anywhere close to Corning 🥰 our favorite order is a large pizza with pepperoni, broccoli, and ricotta, and we always get it extra well done. Crispy crust and pepp, melty cheese, and just all around a great pizza! Definitely stop by if you’re in the area!

This is an amazing pizzeria and the calzone they serve is the best ever had😍 Loved the cheesy calzone served with flavourful pasta (kinda) sauce! Visited this place after reading lots of positive reviews and it was worth the visit!!

They offer many varieties of pizza, including varieties of pizza by the slice. Their sandwiches are very good as well.

First time actually getting pizza while in NY. I must say it was great. Hot floppy foldable slices. Toppings were good and although I only ordered pepperoni and cheese, I couldn't take a bite without getting some pepperoni in it. 🥰. Delivery said 45 mins, but got here faster.

Great food. Great service. We live out of state but always stop in on our way through. The chicken wing and pickle slices are delicious.

First time Ive been here. Went during a nice evening that wasn't so busy. Had specialty slices thin crust ready fresh into the oven. The cheese slice I had was awesome plus a huge amount of drink options. They have an outdoor area which compliments it well.

Fantastic pizzeria! Family owned for multiple generations! They have the absolute best pizza you will ever have the opportunity to eat! If you don't make time to visit and dine here, you will be missing one of the best places Corning has to offer!

It was amazing, the best pizza I have ever tasted! The garlic knots were delicious they came with garlic sauce and marinara sauce! Lastly the sub it was perfect. Every thing is amazing at this restaurant!

Great NY pizza joint. We had the chicken wing pizza, which was very good and spicy. The garlic knots were terrific with lots of butter and marinara sauce. The staff is friendly and helpful.

It's a great pizza shop and more! Nice dining room and good service. The place is always busy. Cash is king here, but credit accepted. Nice atmosphere. Highly recommended! Whenever I'm in Corning, I stop here. Highly recommended!

+4

This place looks like a gold mine. Came in on a Friday night around 7:30 and there were 10 people in front of me waiting for their orders. I will say that for Upstate this pizza is pretty damn good. The crust might be top 5 I have ever had. The sauce and cheese were solid well above average. This is probably the closest you will get to an 8 in these parts.

Delicious pizza! Service was great!

What a great pizza place. Taste is awesome. They have slices at reasonable prices. We got 5 slices tonight for thirteen bucks. They just do cheese and then throw the toppings on top while it reheats but I'm not complaining.

+3

Pit stop on way to finger lakes. Great pizza. Friendly local and efficient service. Will be back. Cute little town too.

Absolutely 10/10 pizza. I live out of state and it's next to impossible to find a NY style pizza as good as this anywhere. Prices are also very reasonable. Definitely worth the stop and if I'm back in town I will absolutely be coming back for more.

We came with four adults and two kids who were served and seated right away. Ordered at the counter and then served at the table. All excellent. Pizza crust was very crispy and delicious. Supreme pizza was great!

This is an amazing pizza 🍕 place. The staff are awesome, the environment is nice and the pizza is by far the best in the area. I usually go for pepperoni but today I got Chicken Wing pizza with blue cheese. What an amazing choice that was. Spot on, a little heat in flavor, perfect amounts of chicken pieces, crust is thin and crunchy, and they top it off with chunky blue cheese on top. Just excellent. The drink choices are a good variety , ranging from beer to fountain drinks. Perfect for a family to eat in or take out. Definitely one of my favorite stops on Corning.

Maybe it's because I am new to this side of the country but I was not disappointed with real New York pizza! Not to mention the very outgoing staff! Already been back twice. Love you all there.

This establishment is a cozy, cafeteria style restaurant where you order and pay at the counter and they bring your food to your table. Our server was Rae, who was lovely, helpful and very patient (we were very indecisive because everything looked delicious). We ordered the chicken Caesar and the meatball Parmesan sub. Rae asked us if we had pickle pizza in 🇨🇦. We don’t so based on her recommendation, we decided to try one slice and split it three ways so we could all try it (the picture is 1/3 of a slice - we added the hot pepper 🌶️ flakes!). This was a white pizza (no tomato sauce) with a delicious crust with just the right amount of chew, plentiful cheese and yummy pickles which perfectly complemented the other flavors. It was a real standout! The chicken Caesar was also delicious. The dressing was lemony and light and not very garlicky (which is how I prefer it). The romaine lettuce was fresh and crunchy and cut small (large pieces of romaine are a pet peeve of mine). The pieces of real chicken were plentiful as well. The meatball sub was delicious with a generous portion of meatballs and ooey gooey cheese. The bread was soft and fresh. As an aside, the bathrooms were spotless which is always a huge sign that the restaurant is very clean. We loved our entire experience at Aniello’s and we will definitely be back when passing through Corning.

The best place to get pizza! The pizza sauce was bursting with flavor and the antipasti salad was fresh. We went the day after Thanksgiving and it was packed out and we didn’t have to wait long for our food. Very friendly too!

Nice pizzeria right in the gaffer district. Best pizza around with other menu items. Really nice that they are open until 11 pm so after many of the pubs or breweries close you can swing by and get a bite to eat or even have a drink with their sleep tion of beer.

Awesome New York pizza restaurant. So authentic. We ordered the Garlic knots, Sausage roll, Meatball Parmigiana and Sausage Parmigiana. Everything was perfectly cooked and Delicious. Everything we both hoped for. Great atmosphere too.

+1

Stopped in for a slice on my way back to Binghamton. I can never resist a nice thin slice that I half to fold in half. Love eating off the metal tray. Brings up nostalgic feelings of growing up near NYC and having a slice.

Thin crust typical NYC style pizza simple classic flavor bot overly fancy Good one😍

Jim Samuels

Brooklyn style pizza brought to Corning NY in 1972, with authentic thin crust, rich tomato sauce and fresh toppings.

Kathie Notarfonzo

What a sweet find in Corning. Can't wait to go back....such great staff, friendly atmosphere, and amazzzzing pizza!

Nathaniel Taylor

Really good pizza! And, it is available by the slice. They have a few other options like subs and salads. Their crust is old school NY style. Plenty of toppings and good pricing. Note, you order at the counter then sit down where you want and they will bring your order to you. They don't have any stands for the pizza, so 2 pies will quickly fill up the table with just a little wiggle room for plates, so keep that in mind. The staff is friendly and helpful. Overall, very pleased and will return!

Missing Winter

Absolutely phenomenal pizza! It was crispy, foldable slices with that perfect New York chew and char. The sauce is on point and the cheese is generous. It's the crust though what hits that classic thin but sturdy balance. It’s the closest thing to a NYC slice you’ll find outside the five boroughs. Plus, the staff is warm, fast and genuinely welcoming service that matches the quality of the pie.

Craig Kirk

visited the town of Corning first week in October 2025. It was around 9pm and not much open so we were forced to get a bite to eat here. Ordered a Calzone with ham and was shocked at the $11 price tag. I said wow what a bargain. Sat down in the welcoming restaurant decorating in family history. The old wooden floors were so cool to look at imagining their history. Received a round dough the size of a Kizer roll with cheese on top with some pieces of ham. Was not pleased at first because Im from Jersey and Calzones at home are a completely different beast. I took a bite and just stared at the food. Took another bite and amazed at the taste of their cheese. Tried another bite with the side sauce that was good but the sauce took away the cheese flavor. A worker came over and asked how our meal was. I explained the Jersey Calzone but I was amazed at the flavor of the cheese. He told me it was a blended cheese but did not know its contents. Once I finished this calzone in about 6 bites, I ordered a slice of pizza. BAM same great cheese flavor. I dont dont dont want to admit this because Jersey is known for its pizza, but Aniello's pizza and their blended cheese has ours beat. Nice clean place, historical feel and great tasting food with their cheese. Highly recommend great job gentlemen.

Sam Brannon

Everything was fresh and delicious, and it’s great you can get single slices of the specialities, too. So much food for a solid price and the whole crew was nice. And of course the pizza was to die for ☠️

Rosemarie

Here visiting from Florida!! OMG Amazing pizza for a great price, large Pizza 🍕 with Bacon and onion is our favorite!!! Every single person who works here is polite, friendly, professional great place overall!!

Mark

Went here after the Wine Glass Half Marathon. We got a Large pepperoni pizza and did not have to wait very long. Pizza was excellent and it was a good price.

Burcak Kurt

The best pizza ever! Perfectly thin crust, amazing sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. Can’t wait to go back!

Ron Randall

My wife and I had building supplies to obtain at Home Depot my gal is like let's try this place on market street I have never been here so our day has begun. We parked on the corner and wandered in, the atmosphere was very NYC type, everyone kind of rolled with the atmosphere, everyone seemed to enjoyed the food and people they are sharing with to me looked amazing. Our pizza arrived in about 15 minutes, it was delivered to our table, the gentleman brought us silverware, excellent. Everything looked clean and on point. The tables had a roll of paper towels and chemical cleanser, excellent we wiped the table down while chatting and enjoying the day. The pizza extra cheese / mushrooms and sausage was hot and amazing. My wife a real pizza GODDESS thought it amazing, she loves the whole scenario people chatting with other people the children just loved it being a country gal. I grew up in NYC so it was a time trip to my childhood. If you get to market street this place is worth a stop, it sent me back to the 1970s Queens NY Great food & atmosphere for sure.

Anne Alexander

I have literally never had a bad experience here. Sometimes I’ve had to wait a while when it’s busy, but this place is amazing. Always good food. The entire block smells like good pizza.

Amy Montondo

I just went here for the first time even though this place has been around for a long time. You order at the counter and either wait for takeout or eat in at a table or booth. We had the garlic pizza and it was very good. I love thin crust so this was a win for me. We'll def be back.

Jared Garrett

If you are looking for the absolute best Pizza, with the crispiest, most flavorful crust and delightful and fresh toppings, as well as magnificent garlic knots and a glorious salad and, finally, with the greatest fountain drink mix you'll find in this part of the state - you have found it in Aniello's Pizzeria. After a beautiful hike up Watkins Glen and back, we were extremely hungry, and this food absolutely hit the spot. The salad was big enough for 3 people to share, and the garlic knots were honestly an amazing surprise with how crispy and light and flavorful they were. We had the chicken wing on one side of a large and the Mediterranean on the other side of that large. It was glorious. Magnificent. And an aggressively reasonable price. To top it all off, the service was awesome and friendly and patient with us as we took forever to choose. My absolute highest recommendation.

Steve Delahunty

You normally wouldn't expect such great food from a pizza place but it's amazing. They also kept all our food warm in the pizza oven so that when they brought it out for the five of us it was all nice and hot. Traditional and Sicilian pizza. The bread on the sandwiches is fantastic.

+2

Ken Vastola

I grew up in the NYC area. This is the best Brooklyn style pizza I've had outside of NYC. The quality of the ingredients is excellent. The crust has that perfect balance of soft and crunchy with great flavor.

Wonderful food ( fish soup, Chardonnay), quiet acoustics despite a large party nearby, and lovely service. FYI: restrooms are on 2nd floor if accessibility is an issue.

Wonderful food ( fish soup, Chardonnay), quiet acoustics despite a large party nearby, and lovely service. FYI: restrooms are on 2nd floor if accessibility is an issue.

Wonderful food ( fish soup, Chardonnay), quiet acoustics despite a large party nearby, and lovely service. FYI: restrooms are on 2nd floor if accessibility is an issue.

Wonderful food ( fish soup, chardonnay), quiet acoustics despite a large party nearby, and lovely service. FYI: restrooms are on 2nd floor if accessibility is an issue.

Stopped in again on our way out of town. Have the buffalo wing pizza, the hot honey, pepperoni, pizza, garlic, knots and the Greek salad all equally as excellent as the first time we stop by this pla…

Stopped in again on our way out of town. Have the buffalo wing pizza, the hot honey, pepperoni, pizza, garlic, knots and the greek salad all equally as excellent as the first time we stop by …

Stopped in again on our way out of town. Have the buffalo wing pizza, the hot honey, pepperoni, pizza, garlic, knots and the Greek salad all equally as excellent as the first time we stop by this…

Absolutely the best pizza in the Corning area! Very busy because it's soooo good. Go during the week as weekends are chaos but it's worth it anyway.

Very good food and friendly staff. One of my favorite places for casual dining when I come to NY to visit family and shop on market street!

We stopped in for a quick bite. We ordered two pepperoni and plain slices. The pizza was good. The place was clean and staff was accommodating. If I had to say one con was that the pizza took a lon…

Food & service & ambiance are casual but amazing;)\nTry the antipasto salad , the Buffalo chicken pizza and any sub

Always an awesome experience in food, service and atmosphere. We make it a "must visit" every time our family visits the Corning area.

Pizza is the best I've ever had... and I've had a lot of pizza. Really great atmosphere and it's very clean

We went for slices, and they have Coke products! the pizza is perfect NY Style pie - it didn't disappoint us! Service was quick and the place is great for the pizza vibe!

We went for slices, and they have Coke products! the pizza is perfect NY Style pie - it didn't disappoint us! Service was quick and the place is great for the pizza vibe!

We went for slices, and they have Coke products! the pizza is perfect NY Style pie - it didn't disappoint us! service was quick and the place is great for the pizza vibe!

We went for slices, and they have coke products! the pizza is perfect NY Style pie - it didn't disappoint us! Service was quick and the place is great for the pizza vibe!

We went for slices, and they have Coke products! the pizza is perfect NY Style pie - it didn't disappoint us! Service was quick and the place is great for the pizza vibe!

Have stopped several time while traveling and it’s always great. This time had pizza slices and a great antipasto salad!! Great atmosphere and even had outside seating. We have ate outside several…

Have stopped several time while traveling and it’s always great. This time had pizza slices and a great antipasto salad!! Great atmosphere and even had outside seating. We have ate outside s…

Have stopped several time while traveling and it’s always great. This time had pizza slices and a great antipasto salad!! Great atmosphere and even had outside seating. We have ate outside sever…

Have stopped several time while traveling and it’s always great. This time had pizza slices and a great antipasto salad!! Great atmosphere and even had outside seating. We have ate outside sever…

Tasty slices, fairly priced. Very busy, service was robotic but efficient. A few tables outside to eat on a nice day is great. Pizza was fresh and hot. Smelled great from the parking lot and drew u…

Tasty slices, fairly priced. Very busy, service was robotic but efficient. A few tables outside to eat on a nice day is great. pizza was fresh and hot. Smelled great from the parking lot and drew u…

Tasty slices, fairly priced. Very busy, service was robotic but efficient. A few tables outside to eat on a nice day is great. Pizza was fresh and hot. Smelled great from the parking lot and drew u…

Tasty slices, fairly priced. Very busy, service was robotic but efficient. A few tables outside to eat on a nice day is great. Pizza was fresh and hot. Smelled great from the parking lot and drew u…

Fantastic fresh NY style pizza. It was perfectly made and delicious. It was served hot in 15 minutes. The prices were very good also. The fountain drinks were sweet and as most fountain drinks…

Fantastic fresh NY style pizza. It was perfectly made and delicious. It was served hot in 15 minutes. The prices were very good also. The fountain drinks were sweet and as most fountain drinks are.

Best calzone I've ever had! service was fast and the food was amazing. Brisk business, both dine-in and take-out. A definite must-try in Corning.

Biggg pizza! Huge! Us family with some friends went here after a day on the water and couldn’t be more happy. Thanks to the friendly staff!

Took my family of 8 from out of town for pizza. Service was good and the pizza was as well. For my liking I thought. price was fair.

Solid place to grab a slice. Loved the pizza and the environment. Cool downtown vibe. I had the Buffalo wings pizza and it was so good.

+5

Very unique spot to grab a slice. Great prices and options. Surprised there weren’t any TVs for a games. The pizza was great, the cheese pizza didn’t have much cheese. They have a selection of alcohol and plenty of seating.

Loved the delish pizza with tasty and crispy crust. Fabulous and friendly staff. Fun retro vibe - lights with red glass skirts and upholstered booths. Pretty sprays of fresh garden flowers on the tables - BRAVO!!

Good grab and go restaurant. Food is fresh and there is a lot of food for the price you pay. The salad is excellent and very fresh. Pizza is freshly made by hand. Just don't expect matching silverware and dishes. Beer mugs are dirty.

+2

We were passing by enroute to Buffalo and were hungry. When we googled we found this place and dropped in for a quick bite. The menu seemed quiet vast and I had a slice of pickled pizza slice and the others had the meat ball sub. Pizza was so fresh and the flavour of the pickle was just right not over powering and the base was just the way. Loved it. Very cute place and seemed very centrally located in the down town part. We parked at the back which had ample parking. This is situated in the city of Corning, NY

Renee VanGalder

My husband took me here for the first time recently. We ordered a large chicken wing pizza and a tossed salad. It really didn't take long to get our food. The pizza had an amazing taste (and a nice side of bleu cheese). The crust was perfectly thin but not hard. The salad had lots of toppings and it was a heaping portion. For me personally it had too much dressing. The decor was cool with old pictures and lighting. The staff were all very friendly and helpful even when they were getting their lunch rush. I would go back again if in the area for sure.

+2

leostation Fact

Ordered the sausage and pepperoni, Buffalo chicken, bacon chicken ranch and Aniello's special. From what we tried I'd stick to the basic pizzas like the sausage and pepperoni, though the sausage was shaved not in chunks. The specialties were not done nearly as well. I've had much better Buffalo chicken. The chicken itself was in tiny pieces and not very tasty, almost bland and the sauce used was disappointing. The crust on all the pizzas was excellent. Overall good pizza but definitely better with the basics. Atmosphere was loud and very busy/frenetic especially for a Tuesday early evening. I'd try again

MacKinsey M

My pizza was nice. I got a vegan custom pie, with no cheese and a bunch of toppings. They forgot the basil I ordered, so double check before you leave the restaurant. Boyfriend really liked the single cheese slice. Open late.

Honest Reviews

Atmosphere-4 stars- Aniello’s Pizzeria in Corning, NY, offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that blends the charm of a traditional New York-style pizzeria with the comfort of a family-friendly eatery. Located on East Market Street, or the strip that I call it. The interior features simple decor adorned with historical family photos, creating a nostalgic and cozy setting. The ambiance is relaxed, allowing patrons to enjoy It’s a place where you can feel at ease, whether you’re dining alone, with family, or in a group.  Plenty of seating inside (tables and booths) and few tables outside. Service- 4 stars- hard to rate since this is counter service however the staff were friendly and even though it was busy they didn’t rush you when ordering. When your food is ready they bring it to your table. Food- 4 stars- this is mainly a pizza place but I just felt like a hoagie on my visit. They recommend the Meatball Parmigiana Hoagie- saying it was their most popular choice in hoagies. With that saying I thought it was just ok- I have better- not saying it was bad but just not what I was hoping for especially if it was the most popular choice. We did get a few slices of pizza (Buffalo chicken and plain cheese) I tried the chicken buffalo and the pizza is great and I wish that is what I would have gotten. Should have known better- when going to a Pizza place get the Pizza lol. Highly recommend a stop for pizza!!

+7

Good pizza. Nice service. Clean location with character. Would go again if in Corning.

Good pizza. Nice service. Clean location with character. Would go again if in Corning.

Good pizza. Nice service. Clean location with character. Would go again if in Corning.

Good pizza. Nice service. clean location with character. Would go again if in Corning.

Very casual Italian pizzeria, both the servers and the patrons. Warm and cozy. I like the ambiance here. It's almost like having pizza in your living room without a couch and a TV. Feel free to hav…

We had the artichoke and red pepper pizza. A long wait was rewarded with an uncooked, chewy crust pizza and while the toppings were almost redeeming, getting any customer service was a challenge …

Best pie in town but always super busy be prepared to wait!! Still worth it forsure! Great sausage rolls although over the last few years the price has went up considerably for the size

I gave this a 3, I got a medium cheese pizza, which when I got it delivered, the cheese was all pretty much on 1 side, was not happy about that, also wasn't cut to well, Im not a fan of the taste of the pizza itself, I gave a tip as well, once I seen that pizza, I regret that, I do reviews in many places, as far as pizza places, this is at the bottom of the list, the workers were nice however.

Where's the Pepperoni on my pie, under the cheese. Thin pep, cheese, thin dough. Taste is good. True very thin crust NYC style.

Good pizza, GET THAT! Absolutely disgusting “cheese steak”… they put 2 slices of kraft on top of dry unseasoned cheap cut steak and throw it into an oven where the cheese burns onto the steak helping the sandwich become as flavorful as 400 grit sand paper. The cheese should be blended into the meat and melted into every bite, not a sad see thru curtain on top of pile of tough chewy “beef”. I swear these people have never eaten a cheesesteak if THIS is what they’re fronting. Take the 4 hour drive to Jersey and go and have a cheesesteak from any mom and shop pizzeria and come back and imitate that because this was offensive. Better yet save the money and take it off the menu because like I said the pizza is good, I’d give it a NY 8… maybe even a 9 if you get a fresh pie.

Scott Barnett

So ..I did not enjoy the pizza. HOWEVER, my dad loved the pizza. The sub, which was a chicken bacon ranch was very good! Easily a 10/10. So, I would say go here for the sub. Food took about 10 minutes longer than what they originally said. However it was packed so I won't take away points for that. Staff were friendly. Place is clean.

Ordered a cheese calzone for $9.75. Received a tiny calzone cut into 4 tiny triangles and put in a to go container that was drenched in butter/seasoning so by the time I went to eat it, it was soggy and soaking wet with oil/butter that did not enhance the flavor, only made it harder to eat without needing a million napkins. I've never had a calzone that was so small and so wet and covered with oil/butter. Completely disgusting to eat. Wonderful restaurant if you don't order calzones.

While our deliver order Pizza arrived on time, one of the pizzas was not good. The pizza had more sauce which made the pie soggy and all topping fell apart.

Normally we love this place. The food is always delicious. Tonight we wanted to try a new pizza so we ordered online. We chose a large pepperoni and onion pizza. When ordering online we are able to add toppings. We wanted some fresh basil on it and it was not an option so there was a place for notes and we put in there please add fresh basil after the pie was cooked. I quickly got a phone call from the shop stating that basil is a topping and it would be an additional $2.00 charge. I thought that was kind of odd as it is an herb but ok. Well, when I got the pie home and opened it, there were maybe 5-6 specks of green basil on the pie. Like I said, normally this is fantastic food bit to charge us an extra topping price for basil and then barely put anything on, Aniello's, please do better.

Edit July 2020: What happened to your suppliers? You changed your ingredients! Now you use a low quality cheese and the sauce is yucky (loaded with beet sugar). March 2020: THANK YOU for being open during the Coronavirus crisis. Yummy pizza. Sandwiches are meh. Pizza is so good that there is no time for pictures before it gets cold.

+1

Do not order ahead for pickup! Food looks good. BUT I ORDERED AHEAD for salad and garlic knots only. They told me 30 minutes. On arrival, I had to wait 15 additional minutes because they have only …

Tried calling for delivery after they were recommended by the hotel. They picked up & then hung up twice. Not even a “please hold we’re busy”. The food might taste good but their customer service is terrible.

So I just ordered for the first time and got a cheesesteak hero. Well it was downright disgusting. I got extra chz, mush,peppers n onions! The steak tasted like week old left out meat. Almost like a mixture of hamburger n something else. Grizzle pieces..no peppers..cheese was cooked...ugghh udderly disgusting!!