Rob Louis

I've been here several times over the years (I thankfully live close enough to where I typically don't need to go here after I've been partying at the nearby Alligator Lounge. But, each and every time that I've gone there I've been met with great food and incredible service. 5 stars all day!!!

mike m

I went there this later afternoon (Xmas Eve) couldn’t believe they were open. The bagels were still coming out of the oven extremely fresh and still hot. Not many places where you can get a bacon egg and cheese and coffee for little over 11 bucks can’t beat it! I highly recommend this place top notch service and quality.

Elizabeth Huh

Just discovered this bagel place and it’s definitely the best in Williamsburg. We went on Xmas Eve where it was quite busy, but the owner (I think) and his young son were there working and slinging bagels with the best of them. Though our order took a bit long to come out (they were jammed and it’s a holiday), the bagels were as good as ever and we got an entire bag of cookies on the house for our wait. That’s the kind of hospitality that can’t be beaten. 100% recommend and I know we will become regulars here!! Thank you to the team for working on Xmas Eve and keeping us hungry impatient New Yorkers fed with bagels and cookies!! PS, the bagels here are So much better than Leon’s or Apollo’s that are more social media favored / trendy it’s not even comparable. This is coming from two New Yorkers. Bagelsmith is a true New York bagel institution the kind that doesn’t exist anymore!

Denise Lopez

Absolutely LOVE the sesame roll with cream cheese from here. The cream cheese is so nice and fluffy! I always look forward to grabbing one of these when I’m in the area!

Ben Adams

Our go-to spot in the neighbourhood. Fast. Quality food. Amazing range of options. Gluten free if you need. You really can’t go wrong here!

Jade Roberts

The food was great but above that, very impressed with the service. They were extremely patient with a customer who was clearly struggling. Really felt like a neighborhood place where many knew and helped each other. Great experience to start the day during my visit.

Aarushi Agni

I can't believe how amazing this bagel is. it's a chipotle cheddar cream cheese on a whole wheat everything, I was waiting for an Uber and got it in perfect time and also while I was standing in the store I started singing along to the song playing ("I Dont Wanna Miss A Thing") and then the bagel guy started singing too!! 🥹🥹🥹 Also there's like pimento or something in this cream cheese?? it's so good idk like there's something magical in it. It's also the everything is on both sides of the bagel, like there's less of it on the bottom but there's still a significant amount at the crease! i'm sorry about this picture because I'm like literally Almost done with it but I wanted you to see!!

Kellyn Kory

The man taking orders was incredibly pleasant. My bagel was exactly what I wanted - I added cream cheese to my bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich for exactly the rich texture and flavor I was hoping for. Bagels are high quality and there’s a variety of beverages available. Prices are fair.

Jess Nogan

I went pretty early so there wasn’t too long of a wait. It’s New York and a bagel shop….there’s usually going to be a wait especially if yours going on a morning during the weekend. I think the reviews talking about having to wait for a long time just need to learn to order online instead. $6.75 for a bagel with scallion cream cheese is a little steep in my opinion. Bagels are always fresh and they don’t overdo it with the cream cheese. There’s plenty to have extra but they’re not putting 1/4 pound of spread on the sandwich thankfully. I’ve only had good experiences here.

AJ F.

Absolutely love this place - hands down one of the best gluten free bagels in Brooklyn! Deducting one star only because the gluten free bagel costs more but is significantly smaller than a regular bagel :/ (see picture) lots of vegan/vegetarian cream cheese options available as well! i would recommend the tofu scallion cream cheese