Michael

The best bagels in not only Brooklyn, but NYC as a whole. The bagel options are abundant and every flavor I’ve tried is has been 10/10. Recommend the everything, cheese bagel, and blueberry bagel. Cream cheese options follow suit and the scallion cream cheese is my favorite. Atmosphere is lively and service is always pleasant.

Kevin A.

I’m from LA, and it’s hard to find a truly good bagel back home. Took a quick trip to New York and stopped by this spot. It was so worth the morning detour. I tried the Big Breakfast Bagel, and it was delicious! They have tons of bagel varieties, and the staff was super friendly and attentive. Definitely recommend checking it out if you’re in the area!

Lauren Schubert

Some of the best bagels I’ve ever had. They have a great variety and the jalapeño cheddar cream cheese is the best!

Kat K

My company ordered these bagels for the office, and there are so many varieties of both bagels and cream cheeses—the combinations are endless! You truly cannot go wrong; they’re all fantastic.

Giuseppe

I think I've had the best bagels of my life! And what about the croissants? Simply delicious!!! Impeccable service and very attentive and friendly staff. I'll definitely be back and will recommend them to all my friends.

Eddie Gordon

growing up in NY, i have had many bagels in my lifetime .. and this was one of my favorites .. but, for me, it was about more than the bagel itself (which was, indeed, delish), it was the entire experience. you walk in and are greeted by this incredible mural on the wall .. which would make any NYer or visitor smile instantly! from that moment, it is clear that you are in for a serious NYC treat. the day i was there , so were the new owners, who make you feel like you’ve just entered their home — very welcoming, engaging and super helpful! i will definitely be back again and have no doubt that i will have an equally great experience. to the owners - and Clinton - whatever you are doing, keep it up, you’re crushing it!

Antonio Strazzullo

I can’t say enough good things about this bagel shop! The bagels are always fresh, just the way a real bagel should be. The staff is friendly, quick and welcoming, even during the busy morning rush. The shop is cozy, and has a great neighborhood vibe. it’s a great experience every time. Highly recommend this place to any bagel lover, you won’t be disappointed ❤️

Jessica Wilkins

Myrtle Bagel is my everyday “go to” spot for breakfast! They have a wide range of food which is always fresh and properly prepared. The guys are super cool, friendly, and they NEVER mess up the orders. Dining in is a chill vibe with great music! You’ll be very satisfied with everything!

Willow

Cute little bagel place with a couple small tables inside. The bagels are soft and chewy but dont have much of a hard crusty outside. Great for breakfast sandwiches but I wouldn't get just bagels here.

+1

Christopher Alexis

This bagel shop is hands down one of the best food discoveries I’ve made in a long time. From the moment you walk in, there’s an energy that makes you feel both welcomed and excited. The warm aroma of freshly baked bagels fills the air, and the space itself feels cozy and inviting, with bright lights that give it a cheerful, welcoming glow. It’s the kind of place that instantly makes you feel at home, whether you’re grabbing something to go or settling in for a quiet bite. What sets this shop apart is the craftsmanship. The bagels have that elusive balance that only true bagel masters can achieve: a beautiful glossy crust that crackles ever so slightly when you bite in, and a soft, chewy interior that’s both hearty and satisfying. You can tell immediately these are made with care and pride. The variety is outstanding — they’ve mastered the classics like sesame, everything, and plain, but also offer creative options that make you want to come back and try them all. And while every bagel here is worth ordering, I have to rave about my personal favorite: the pastrami lox with scallion cream cheese. It’s an absolute game-changer. The lox itself is smoky, rich, and layered with incredible pastrami spices that elevate it far beyond the traditional. Paired with the cool, tangy scallion cream cheese, it’s the perfect marriage of flavors — indulgent yet balanced, and unforgettable. I even placed a catering order recently, and it was a huge hit. Everything was beautifully packaged, fresh, and delivered with the same care you get in-store. My guests couldn’t stop talking about the quality of the bagels and spreads — it made the entire event feel extra special. Beyond the food, the staff make the experience even better. They’re genuinely friendly, attentive, and passionate about what they serve. They’ll chat with you about their favorite combos, make great recommendations, and always make you feel like a valued guest — whether it’s your first visit or your fiftieth. In a city full of bagels, this place stands out as something truly exceptional. Between the cozy, light-filled atmosphere, the unforgettable flavors, and the welcoming team, it’s the kind of spot that reminds you why a great bagel is more than just breakfast — it’s comfort, community, and craft all rolled into one. I’ve already started recommending it to friends, and I’ll be back again (and again) for that pastrami lox with scallion cream cheese.