James Santos

Always a good spot! Pizza was great! Nice place to take the whole fam. Tons of different choice for a casual dinning experience. Great for the summer time and walking around the village. Service is usually quick too.

We got take out from John and Mary's tonight and the friend pickles were OK, but the dinner salad had nothing but onions and the sandwich sliced tomato. The fish sandwich had no flavor and was very thin and my royal sub was cold, not toasted and the sausage tasted bad and the Capicola was tasteless. The only good thing was the fried pickles because they came that way. Totally dissatisfied!

Brenton Fedele

Not sure what happened here, but the service is not at all tolerable. Ordered a pizza at 5:15pm, arrived at 5:45pm. Only one couple sitting at a table. As of 6:15pm, our single pizza isn’t ready yet. There is a group of people waiting for food, and about 4 people standing around in the kitchen. The quality of the pizza isn’t ideal either.

Aidan Brown

Chocolate milkshakes were the consistency of water. Very little taste and quite foamy texture. Not palatable. Calzones were not that great. Loaded with cheese but very little flavor and very pale in color. The red sauce was very bland. Very expensive for something I didn't really like. Waste of money, stick to the subs. Wouldn't recommend to a friend nor go back ever

Cold fries( they were still white), tomatoes on my sub when I asked them to not give me tomatoes, sub was cold, which was a pizza sub . And they ask for a tip before you even get food ! Then we sat and watched the kitchen touching food no gloves, changing trash bag then making a shake no gloves, then going from fried foods to bathroom to clean. Will never go here ever again horrible horrible staff and over priced for it for sure.

joe Ellis

The worker should have say nicely

Lori Crawford

On Sunday my mom ordered medium wings for the game. They were covered in oil so she called to complain and was told to call back when a manager was there. She asked me to return them after the game. I asked how we would be compensated and the front girl said she'd get the manager. That's when the fun began. She was rude and short with me. I said I just need to know whose name we would get the credit on. She said rudely, just call. Then she said, "ba bye!" And left to go in back. I got no resolution and was treated terribly. It's a shame, because my family has eaten there for decades, but we will not be back!!

Johnniepoo

Food is horrible! Place is so dirty, staff is rude owner is unbelievably RUDE! You run an establishment, you should be kind and CLEAN! I wouldn’t eat here again even if the food was free!

C B

Why on earth would you put soggy salad and chicken in a paper container that ended up soggy and falling apart in my salads? Any other time salads come in a plastic container. The chicken was disgusting, covered in a ton of spices. I order 2 times a week from this place but not anymore.

severin ryan

just wanted a slice, the ones in the rotator were clearly from when they opened. asked if they could possibly make a new pizza, got absolutely disrespected by the woman working. decided to still try the pizza, when i got it it was awful. so dry and burnt. the pepperoni was charcoal. and yet, the middle of the pizza had soggy dough. i couldn't chew through the crust it was so hard. had a hard time snapping it with my hands.

ZZZED

One Star - Avoid at All Costs My recent visit to John and Mary's was nothing short of a disaster. We waited over an hour for our food, and when it finally arrived, it was clear that the kitchen staff had completely phoned it in. My dish was bland and undercooked, while my companion's meal was overcooked and dry. The service was inattentive, and the overall atmosphere was depressing. Save yourself the time and money – there are far better dining options in town.

kate rose muscarella

Absolutely annoyed with the fact that I have allowed myself to order after missing items multiple times out of my order but this last one was the last time. Missing an entire order of fries and given maybe 5 fries in an order of single fingers. I'm sick of it. Do better for the price you charge this is sickening and ridiculous go ahead and explain to a kid with autism who literally only wanted the fries that they didn't get fries.

jasper jaworski

More cheese on the subs than turkey! worse sub I have ever experienced. Is a joke of a sandwich…. Will not be coming again… stay away unless you’re looking for a meal of bread and mayo