Justino’s

This place pays attention to detail. Crispy crust, seasoning on top. And great customer service! Best pizza in Fidi

The best pizza on Fulton Street. Crispy crust (not burned), tasty sauce, and great price.

Pizza was heated properly. Sauce was tasty and crust was crunchy. 5🌟 for flavor.

Their margherita pizza was delicious! Great for a quick bite and affordable!

R Bod

I’m a few years late doing this review! We visited in December of 2021, after sampling a few Manhattan pizza spots. Justino’s was our fav! What a great experience! Recommend you try Justino’s ASAP!

Andrew Featherstone

Wow Thankyou amazing pizza and chicken wings tonight and such a friendly service! Thanks again From Michelle, Andy & Bobby from 🇬🇧 UK

LDM

Best pizza in Manhattan. I used to work down here and since moving to Houston 5+ years ago, I am always missing their chicken parm slice. It is DELICIOUS! Also the slices are HUGE. One will be enough unless you're training for an eating competition. The red hair/blonde hair manager is funny and a great time. Made us feel back at home

Sravani YK

Their margherita pizza was delicious! Great for a quick bite and affordable!

Lee Ann Porter

This place pays attention to detail. Crispy crust, seasoning on top. And great customer service! Best pizza in Fidi

Andrey Btw

This place is not meant to be perfect. Just inevitably unforgettable when it comes to their Margherita. And it keeps coming to it. A slice of heaven no food critic deserves. Impossible to discover by recommendation, only by chance.

Natalie Burg

Authentic NYC Pizza. Great value and really nice employees. + you can bring to picnic by the water!

Christian Kelly

One of the best pizza shops in Fidi. The crust is delicious, the sauce and fresh quality. Also, the price point is really good. Highly suggest! try the Vodka Sauce Slice!

Zubair Dawood

The best pizza on Fulton Street. Crispy crust (not burned), tasty sauce, and great price.

Honestly Name a better place if you have one

Pizza was heated properly. Sauce was tasty and crust was crunchy. 5🌟 for flavor.

Kylie Briggs

A cheap and solid slice! One of the best in the area, and you can take your pizza right across the street to the park!

CINDY ROBLES

Most definitely the better pizza shop in the area! The others do not even match the taste nor the size of the slice as Justino's. My favorite slice is the chicken bacon ranch and the one at this place will not disappoint. It is fulfilling and very enjoyable. Yes, there is quite a bit of wait but they encourage to call ahead (if you can) to avoid the lines they have because they're so good DUH!

Chalmers Barnes (toymachinary)

The pizza here is the best in the area, and there are quite a few good spots. The vodka sauce is great making the vodka slice my fave. The classic cheese is a delicious close second and should usually be the slice you judge a shop on imo. My friends get the chicken bacon slice and its huge with a lot of toppings - makes it well worth the price as its basically a meal. The staff has always been super friendly and even gave me a little history of the shop when they opened. I work in the area and this is my go-to spot from now on.

The lasagna was absolutely delicious and the veggie slice was also very good. The prices were reasonable. *A* rating for cleanliness. I would definitely recommend this pizza place and I would absolutely recommend their lasagna.

Justino's is a must have in Lower Manhattan. The prices are reasonable and there is a variety of choices. I'm always into eating something different when I'm in the area. This time I had: Penne a la Justinos ( broccoli rabe, sausage, garlic, oil & a touch of romano cheese). Simply amazing. It was well portioned and just delicious. 😋 My partner had the veal parmigiano but as it was really good, the veal was really tough to chew which is why they are losing one star. However, their wings, chicken and sausage parmigianos heros are superb. We were able to save them for lunch the next day. But on a side note we never knew garlic knots can be stuffed with meat. It's huge and so good. We will definitely have Justino's again.

Tara Noemi S

The lasagna was absolutely delicious and the veggie slice was also very good. The prices were reasonable. *A* rating for cleanliness. I would definitely recommend this pizza place and I would absolutely recommend their lasagna.

C D

Justino's is a must have in Lower Manhattan. The prices are reasonable and there is a variety of choices. I'm always into eating something different when I'm in the area. This time I had: Penne a la Justinos ( broccoli rabe, sausage, garlic, oil & a touch of romano cheese). Simply amazing. It was well portioned and just delicious. 😋 My partner had the veal parmigiano but as it was really good, the veal was really tough to chew which is why they are losing one star. However, their wings, chicken and sausage parmigianos heros are superb. We were able to save them for lunch the next day. But on a side note we never knew garlic knots can be stuffed with meat. It's huge and so good. We will definitely have Justino's again.

The slices are hefty with a lot of cheese. Unfortunately there’s just too much, and a lot of grease to go along with it. I would not recommend over other well known places in fidi. However the staff is nice and the store clean.

Christian Jefferies

The slices are hefty with a lot of cheese. Unfortunately there’s just too much, and a lot of grease to go along with it. I would not recommend over other well known places in fidi. However the staff is nice and the store clean.

I went to the Fulton street location when they first opened. Ordered two mushroom slices. Price - $9.00. Pretty large slices and pretty good pizza. But $4.50 a slice?

I ordered a plain slice at $3.75 and proceeded to add the seasonings (Garlic, oregano, etc;. The garlic seasoning had green things mixed in with it. I then asked for garlic at the counter, when the guy pointed back to the seasoning on the side. I informed him some green stuff was mixed in and his response was to tell me what he thought or expect it to be. (I did not allow him a chance to finish) I stated, I did not know 'what' that is and if his response is to try and explain, instead of accommodate me, then I won't be revisiting this place. The pizza taste ok.

MsKenya Marie

I ordered a plain slice at $3.75 and proceeded to add the seasonings (Garlic, oregano, etc;. The garlic seasoning had green things mixed in with it. I then asked for garlic at the counter, when the guy pointed back to the seasoning on the side. I informed him some green stuff was mixed in and his response was to tell me what he thought or expect it to be. (I did not allow him a chance to finish) I stated, I did not know 'what' that is and if his response is to try and explain, instead of accommodate me, then I won't be revisiting this place. The pizza taste ok.

Gary Alexander

I went to the Fulton street location when they first opened. Ordered two mushroom slices. Price - $9.00. Pretty large slices and pretty good pizza. But $4.50 a slice?

Rude and poor customer service. I asked the salesperson if they just have thin crust or there are others not on display yet. She said this is it, thin crust. I said Thank you and stepped out as I'm looking for thicker crust. A guy with a belly who claimed to be the owner yelled "thank you for wasting our time". I turned around and called him out on being rude and poor customer service. (I was the only person in the pizzashop at that time and I spent 30 seconds max in there). He and the girl working at the counter laughed. My fiance approached and called him out on being disrespectful. He comes outside and proceeds to get in a verbal fight with my fiance. Wow. This is the worst and most unprofessional service in NYC. I guess if you step into the store you are obligated to buy something? Your job as a owner or employee is to answer potential customer questions, not try to bully people into buying your product if it is not the specific product they are looking for.

64 Fulton is now seaport deli.

Roxana Guerra

Rude and poor customer service. I asked the salesperson if they just have thin crust or there are others not on display yet. She said this is it, thin crust. I said Thank you and stepped out as I'm looking for thicker crust. A guy with a belly who claimed to be the owner yelled "thank you for wasting our time". I turned around and called him out on being rude and poor customer service. (I was the only person in the pizzashop at that time and I spent 30 seconds max in there). He and the girl working at the counter laughed. My fiance approached and called him out on being disrespectful. He comes outside and proceeds to get in a verbal fight with my fiance. Wow. This is the worst and most unprofessional service in NYC. I guess if you step into the store you are obligated to buy something? Your job as a owner or employee is to answer potential customer questions, not try to bully people into buying your product if it is not the specific product they are looking for.