Jenna Gervasio

Pizza is awesome and never disappoints!!! But for the first time I tried the seafood and it was so fresh and delicious! We had the seafood salad and the mussels. The red sauce was sooo good and we also tried the artichokes. Dessert was phenomenal, the Spumoni ice cream and the tiramisu was delicious. We didn’t have one bad dish. I absolutely recommend. Dominic our waiter was the best!

+1

michael allen

I love the Sicilian slices from this place and it's what they're known for and they have been in this location for years. The sauce is amazing, The cheese is fresh and the crust is perfect. When I go I usually walk up to the window for my slices and there's a separate window to order if you want a whole pie. They have outdoor picnic tables and also have indoor seating but I've never used anything other than the outdoor seating. Overall this is an actual place of visit if you're a fan of pizza and you like Sicilian slices too like me

M Guyer

My first ever NY style pizza & I got to try both the thin slice & their square slice. I preferred the square slice, but both were very good. The whole pizza is the large round. Super friendly & funny staff. There wasn't a long wait when we arrived either.

+1

Bonnie Gleicher

This new spot in Dumbo and second location of the pizza institution is incredible! Everything about it is delicious, warm, and welcoming, with a big space that’s great for groups. Shoutout to the kindest, coolest server Rodney! Their Sicilian pizza is insane. Thick and doughy, unlike any crust I’ve had before, almost half-baked in the middle like a great cookie. Their sauce is sweet and comforting and their baked clams were delicious. Of course, you’ve gotta get the spumoni ice cream for dessert - its marzipan flavor and crunch is unlike any spumoni I’ve had. Can’t wait to come back to try their regular pizza, a salad, and more of that spumoni. 5 stars!!!!

+4

Urban Traveler

Came here for a late lunch with several people on a weekday. I was seated rapidly and the server came with the menus in no time. The size of the pasta dishes was big albeit a tad pricey. Fettucine alfredo was very good. Pizza was also good and full of flavor. I did not rank thrm 5 star due to 20% compulsory gratuity for parties over 6 persons

Ahmed

Recently visited Spumoni and loved the pizza- We were recommended Spumoni by a native New Yorker and were impressed. The pizza slices were exactly what we expected when we thought of a NY pizza. Rich, creamy, big in portion, and just filling. The slices did have a bit too much grease for our liking, but nothing that quick napkin pat down couldn’t fix. This restaurants location also makes it easy for you to get a box and sit along the river admiring the Manhattan skyline. Truly an unforgettable experience. Would highly recommend.

Sara

Family friendly casual dining. Service is always very friendly. Came with different friends on each experience and they enjoyed all the dishes, where I found them to be average, and red and pizza sauce was more on the heavy concentrated side, so not good for my sensitive stomach. They enjoyed the Sicilian pizza, baked clams, Caesars salad, malfade with sausage ragu special. The pistachios spumoni was refreshing!

+2

Omar A Morillo

Too much confusion between staff and online orders. Calamari was unseasoned. Mussels were ok. Pizza as always, and by pizza I mean the Sicilian square, was great which is why we keep coming back. But frankly, this place used to be better.

Nitiphum S.

I recently visited L&B Spumoni Gardens and ordered a few dishes to try. The Shrimp Oreganata with linguini ended up being served last, about 30 minutes after the first dishes arrived. I’m not sure if it was forgotten or if it just takes longer to prepare, but the wait felt too long, and by the time it came, I was already full. Unfortunately, the flavor was just average—nothing that really stood out. The fried calamari, on the other hand, had a nice texture and was cooked well. Lightly crisp on the outside and tender inside—an enjoyable appetizer. The highlight for me was definitely the World Famous L&B Sicilian Pie. It’s exactly what people rave about—thick crust, plenty of cheese, a nice crunch, and a rich, satisfying flavor. I tried the medium size, and if you’re visiting with two people, I’d recommend ordering one medium per person for a full experience. The ambience is casual and feels more like a takeout pizza joint, but there are tables if you want to dine in. If you prefer something quick, they also have a bar counter where you can enjoy your order right away. Service was okay—nothing bad, but nothing exceptional either. Overall, it’s worth visiting for the pizza, but be prepared for possible waits and manage expectations on some of the other dishes. I’d rate my experience 3 stars overall.

+8

Jia Sun

The OG location has been on my list forever, just didn't get the chance to go yet. After trying the Dumbo spot, might not happen any time soon. While the margherita slice is good, it is not worth the $7+ price. Still bit soggy after reheat, taste not that memorable and slice on the small side. Sitdown dining area was packed though.

+12