Alicia Kluck

Such a good meal! I got the margarita pizza and added anchovies and it was delicious. We also got the homemade tiramisu and it was one of the best tiramisu’s I’ve had in my entire life. Our server was very nice and gave nice recommendations on the menu. Would definitely go again on our way through Amsterdam.

Kate

Best Italian place around. And for good reasonable prices!! You can taste the homemade and high quality ingredients. The pizza is to die for. It’s like it’s from Italy. And the pasta vodka sauce was one of the best I’ve ever had. First time here and service was amazing and the atmosphere was so nice too. Everyone seems to enjoy themselves here. Very big inside, bar, and patio outside. Highly recommend!!!

Nikki Garner

Our first time and everything was absolutely amazing!! 5 stars!! We had veal Parmesan and chicken Parmesan with homemade pasta and red sauce. Food was cooked perfectly and the pasta and sauce were my favorite!! Our waitress Gabriella was very friendly and attentive. Seriously the best service and food we’ve had in Amsterdam! Highly recommend! We will be back again!

Melanie Rotondi

Best Italian I've ever eaten! The stuffed Zucchini Flowers, a seasonal treat of Mozzarella and Ricotta stuffed flowers, in a light batter - delicious! The woodfired pizza crust like no other. Jordan, our server, made excellent recommendations and we were impressed by her allowing us time to enjoy each course. I encourage everyone to enjoy and read their website ABOUT. This is a truly remarkable and talented family with extraordinary culinary gifts.

Tami Schroeder

I just had one of the best meals ever at Lorenzo’s! The service was outstanding, with Cait making the experience even more enjoyable. She knew everyone who walked into the bar, and her lively banter added a fun touch for us out-of-towners. I ordered the American Italian with meatballs, and the hand-made pasta was absolutely delicious. To cap off the evening, I treated myself to a freshly filled cannoli, which was the perfect ending to a fantastic meal. Plus, the location is conveniently within walking distance from the Riverlink Marina. I highly recommend Lorenzo’s for an unforgettable dining experience!

Zee89!

The food amazing we had margarita pizza , linguine with meatballs , my favorite was the soup seafood bisque , fries and wings , the service amazing . We had Lilah as server . She was tentative and amazing . The price of food for 4 people I couldn’t be happier on the way out I noticed more different seating and I was like yes , I live an hour away so it was first time and wasn’t sure how it would go and now cannot wait to come back and enjoy again . My picky eater kids were obsessed with the bread . Thank you so much for a wonderful experience.

Jamie Sittner

One of the best dining experiences I've had in a long time. The food was perfection. Truly. The eggplant was sliced super thin and probably the best I've ever had. Italian American food is often overloaded with cheese and flavors fall flat...not here. Fresh, bold flavors and great presentation. The staff was also incredibly friendly and helpful. Highly recommend and looking forward to going back!

+3

iMacOfDeath

Grilled octopus? More like grilled kraken. Was feeling the urge for some sea food this week and luckily Lorenzo's had me covered with their new Feast of the Seven Fishes menu, I've never been here before as I was trying to hold out until I could actually eat at the location, but this menu was just too good to pass up. Ordered over the phone going with the Grilled Octopus and the Fritto Misto, coming to a total of $53 before tax and tip. I had heard that Lorenzo's is on the pricier side so I had expected as much, still, not as bad as I was expecting or have experienced before. Back home I found the two items I got also came with a side salad and a couple slices of bread, which really helped make everything feel like a complete meal. First up was the octopus which was huge! I have never seen octopus tendrils this big before, and they were so meaty! The suction cups adding a little crunch from how they cooked, and the flavor was so mild and unoffensive that the accompanying lemon, tomato dip, and small peppers were bursts of flavor. Then came the Fritto Misto, which is just a fancy was of saying fried dish, as it had fried jumbo shrimp, fried haddock, and french fries. Of course it was super, the fish was flaky and not greasy at all, the shrimp was impressively tough but not a chore to chew, and even the fries were so well seasoned I ate the lot of them. While I was not a fan of the cocktail sauce, being a fair bit too strong for me, I was loving the tartar sauce which was banging with the fish. And while small, the salad was refreshing and crispy. I did have to toast the bread a little as it was so plain and doughy alone, but once toasted it had a wonderful crunch to it. I think for future takeout they could look into toasting the bread a little with some garlic butter, and then wrapping it in tinfoil. I could see that working well. Overall I was very satisfied with my meal, even at the asking price, with nary a complaint to be made. Given how close they are I could totally see coming back, but, maybe only for special occasions and not a daily eatery.

Marvin Bernal

Appreciated this stop from a long drive from Maine! Lovely place where it seems all the locals come together to enjoy a good beer & pizza. Recommend the fried eggplant + mozzarella and the Napoletan pistachio pizza.

April Johnson

We were just out for a ride then decided we wanted to go out to dinner. We were in Amsterdam, so I pulled into a lot and started my Google search of places and they're menus. Just in the vicinity we were in there were 5 places to go . Decided on Lorenzo's but when I pulled up their page it said they were closed (not realizing the time, 9pm). We entered through their amazing deck. The greeter said the kitchen closes at 9 but she would see what she could do. Just then a man in a red jacket (I'm assuming owner, kitchen staff, etc). He said straight away to get us a table and we would be served. Every employee we had interactions with were such pleasant people. Our server was wonderful⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Prices are a bit steep, but then so is everything lately. The meals were absolutely delicious. Definitely going again ... You should too 😋 Forgot to add, there's a lot of parking!!

+14

Allan Robison

First time at Lorenzo's. The food was excellent. I went with a group of about 20 people. We all did a make your own pasta. I was impressed and will definitely go again when in Amsterdam, NY.

+2

Went for the first time last night for Restaurant week. Our waiter was excellent and the owner stopped by to say hello. The portions were very good the taste was great only thing I would say negative is it could have been hotter. I did send my pasta back and it came back perfect. Also do not charge $3 for a glass of ice with a little soda and no refills.

Eggplant Parm was undercooked. I'm sure it was frozen and that is fine as long as it's cooked. The sauce was nothing special. I had to ask for bread, twice before I received it. I was never offered dessert. Soda did not taste like Pepsi or Coke and if it was it was flat. The bathrooms were clean, the staff at the door was friendly. I will try it again and update.

Peter Huang (Pete)

Place was packed on Saturday evening and seems to be the it spot for the locals. Our expectation was high because of the crowd and good review on both Google and yelp. However the food is really just ok as one could expect from an American Italian restaurant despite the fancy menu using a lot of the Italian langue to try to make them look legit. The price also seems to be on the pricy side considering what’s offered. Might be a good place for family gathering but would not recommend for a foodie.