Ny Pizza Baby

Dria Lovely (Dria Drip)

One of my favorite pizza spots. Love the deals!

Christine Lewis

I was having a rough day when I place my order. The cashier asked me if I would like fries and maybe onion rings I said, sure fries I could use some comfort food. When I went to pick up my order, the cashier as always was pleasant and she said she threw some cheesecake in for me because she knew I was having a bad time and wanted to make me feel better. And it worked. I told her she was an angel because honestly I thought about ordering a whole one only for lunch so I got my wrap which was delicious. My fries were crispy and hot and my God the cheesecake superb. I could eat at New York pizza baby every day good food great people just a wonderful family run establishment.

Jose Cruz

NY Pizza Baby offers a delightful dining experience. The employees are friendly and attentive, creating a welcoming atmosphere. The food is exceptional, especially their calzone with fresh, high-quality ingredients. I highly recommend trying their Meat Lovers or Pepperoni calzone for an authentic taste.

Marcus Downes

NY Pizza baby is definitely a nice clean spot with great customer service. First time I was there they took there time with me and the food came right out

Richard Stanley III

This was our first trip... It was way above my expectations! The pizza is amazing.. but the garlic knots.. I says a HOT DAMN! These bad boys will surprise ya! They'll brighten your day.. Only issue I had, was that I ate entirely too much!

I came to Ny pizza baby, the pizza is delicious the service is friendly and efficient.I had an amazing experience. I will be coming back . The pizza make your mouth water. Good Pizza.

My go-to pizza place whenever I’m craving a great calzone or pizza. I’m also a big fan of their sides & desserts. Especially the garlic knots, pepperoni rolls, & Zeppoles. I typically order online pickup, but the atmosphere inside the store is always cozy & welcoming!

They have consistently good customer service and their alfredo sauce is magnificently bussin 10/10 chicken alfredo pasta and pizza and their garlic knots are bussin

We found a new place. There is nothing better than a great hole in the wall NY pizza place with great food and great service. It's all in the name It's NY pizza Baby

I typically order delivery from this restaurant, but today was my first time dining in—and the experience exceeded my expectations. The customer service was outstanding; the cashier provided excellent recommendations and was very knowledgeable about the menu. The restaurant itself was exceptionally clean, and my food was served hot and fresh. I will definitely be returning.

I went in at almost closing time, the place was clean and quiet. I love the cozy vibe. The Steak and cheese Stromboli was delicious! I had that with a side of fries and a pepsi. 5 stars all around! I can't wait to go try multiple other menu items.

Yair

My go-to pizza place whenever I’m craving a great calzone or pizza. I’m also a big fan of their sides & desserts. Especially the garlic knots, pepperoni rolls, & Zeppoles. I typically order online pickup, but the atmosphere inside the store is always cozy & welcoming!

GORDON MENTORE

Food delicious, lots of beautiful flavors ,service was greattttttttt no complaints wish I didn’t live so far I would back every other day lol

judith fenelus

I typically order delivery from this restaurant, but today was my first time dining in—and the experience exceeded my expectations. The customer service was outstanding; the cashier provided excellent recommendations and was very knowledgeable about the menu. The restaurant itself was exceptionally clean, and my food was served hot and fresh. I will definitely be returning.

Shanay Ulett

The pizza was great and the service was great. I love coming here other than other pizza places because you get more for your money

jay veli

This is hands down the best pizza in town. The flavor, the crust, the sauce — everything hits just right. You can tell they take pride in what they do. The staff is always cool and welcoming, and the vibe in there makes you feel like you’re in a real New York pizzeria. If you haven’t tried NY Pizza Baby yet, you’re seriously missing out. 🔥🍕 – Jonathan Velez

My family and I came here to get pizza and garlic knots. I ordered mushroom and onion and ½ pepperoni. I wish there was more mushrooms on it for what you pay for. I wish I would have taken a picture to show the lack of toppings. There might have been maybe 2 mushrooms slices on each slice of pizza. The flavor was just bland. I did like the garlic knots. They were soft on the inside and slightly crispy on the outside. Its a cute little place to sit and eat. Small and decorated in a NY style decor. My favorite thing about this little place was the staff. They were so nice and friendly. They were very eager to please and made sure we had all we needed to enjoy our dinner. They have all kinds of other things to eat so maybe you'll find something you like. Wings, Italian dishes, and salads. It wasn't my favorite pizza but it wasn't the worst.

Shannon Lufcy

My family and I came here to get pizza and garlic knots. I ordered mushroom and onion and ½ pepperoni. I wish there was more mushrooms on it for what you pay for. I wish I would have taken a picture to show the lack of toppings. There might have been maybe 2 mushrooms slices on each slice of pizza. The flavor was just bland. I did like the garlic knots. They were soft on the inside and slightly crispy on the outside. Its a cute little place to sit and eat. Small and decorated in a NY style decor. My favorite thing about this little place was the staff. They were so nice and friendly. They were very eager to please and made sure we had all we needed to enjoy our dinner. They have all kinds of other things to eat so maybe you'll find something you like. Wings, Italian dishes, and salads. It wasn't my favorite pizza but it wasn't the worst.

Akira Sora

Antipasto salad was awful. It was missing the pepperoni, only 2 small slices plum tomato and onion. The lettuce was limp, the ham, salami and cheese were skimpy and tasteless. The price in google maps was 6.95 which was wrong, with tax it was close to $10. Apparently I should’ve ordered pizza but I was really looking forward to a good salad. 2 stars for the young lady who waited on me. Zero stars for the antipasto.

This was an Uber Eats order from NY Pizza Baby. We ordered a large deluxe pizza and a garden salad. Sadly the pizza only looked good in the picture. What we received had no cheese and was very bad. I had ordered no green peppers and they did get that part right. I didn't complain, I just won't order from them anymore.

Whoever is running NY pizza baby is not doing it well. We’ve eaten here as a family for the last decade but recently it’s been going down the drain. I ordered a cheese pizza with light sauce. Open it and it’s soggy, you can see the sauce oozing out from under the cheese and the slices are simply falling apart and mushy. It’s so sad to see an Apopka staple pizzeria going down the hole like this.

It my first time going there and honestly, it sounded really good, but they unfortunately got my order wrong. I asked for a New York cheeseburger, but instead got an original cheeseburger with toppings I cannot eat and on top of that for the price. I thought I was going to get a little more for my value that was very little fries. The burger itself was a decent size but was very thin.

I've been to New York hundreds of times. I have family there. I can say with absolute certainly that nowhere in New York city will you find an Italian coldcut/hoagie that is served like this. This poor sandwich is absolutely embarrassing to send out to any customer. My FIRST time ever eating here. Just by looking at this poor sandwich tells me you guys have no pride in making food with a New York themed pizza, pasta, subs, and side dishes. I will try one more time to see if this was a one time mess-up. 2nd.....My cheese steak sub was absolutely horrible. I got bread, the meat, cheese, and tons of mayo. No onions, no lettuce, no other types of condiments. It was so not worth taking a picture of it.

Who ever is running this place, you starting to suck. The quality is trash, pizza not fully cook and crispy crush, this is not a pizza. You suck. My side is cooked better than the pizza. Have a bad day. I had to cook it in the oven.

Horrible customer service and the quality was garbage. I used to order from here often and the food was good. It's definitely went severely down hill over the last few years. The Sicilian pizza was less then disappointing. The slices on the edges had almost no toppings/cheese/sauce. When I called to let them know I was told to take it up with Uber becAuse he gave it to him out of the oven. Really?!? Lol. It's just a pizza so not a huge deal but this place and the attitude of the "manager" I spoke to left me wondering what will take there spot in the plaza when they close, no way they stay open if this is the product they are putting out and bad Customer service.

William Warnke

It my first time going there and honestly, it sounded really good, but they unfortunately got my order wrong. I asked for a New York cheeseburger, but instead got an original cheeseburger with toppings I cannot eat and on top of that for the price. I thought I was going to get a little more for my value that was very little fries. The burger itself was a decent size but was very thin.

Thomas Ferrari

I've been to New York hundreds of times. I have family there. I can say with absolute certainly that nowhere in New York city will you find an Italian coldcut/hoagie that is served like this. This poor sandwich is absolutely embarrassing to send out to any customer. My FIRST time ever eating here. Just by looking at this poor sandwich tells me you guys have no pride in making food with a New York themed pizza, pasta, subs, and side dishes. I will try one more time to see if this was a one time mess-up. 2nd.....My cheese steak sub was absolutely horrible. I got bread, the meat, cheese, and tons of mayo. No onions, no lettuce, no other types of condiments. It was so not worth taking a picture of it.

T

Who ever is running this place, you starting to suck. The quality is trash, pizza not fully cook and crispy crush, this is not a pizza. You suck. My side is cooked better than the pizza. Have a bad day. I had to cook it in the oven.

Michael Gazzo

Horrible customer service and the quality was garbage. I used to order from here often and the food was good. It's definitely went severely down hill over the last few years. The Sicilian pizza was less then disappointing. The slices on the edges had almost no toppings/cheese/sauce. When I called to let them know I was told to take it up with Uber becAuse he gave it to him out of the oven. Really?!? Lol. It's just a pizza so not a huge deal but this place and the attitude of the "manager" I spoke to left me wondering what will take there spot in the plaza when they close, no way they stay open if this is the product they are putting out and bad Customer service.

JT Locations

Never ordering from them again. I’ve ordered their chicken tenders once prior and it was great! 5 large pieces of crispy chicken. Everything I’ve order from here has been great. However… they must have changed the size and recipe of their chicken tenders. I called to make a complaint but the manager was too busy to speak with me. He calls me back, and says ‘it’s the same size tenders they have always had’. Nice try man but I know what I’ve ordered before, and it wasn’t this (see pic). This look like $10 worth of chicken tenders to you?