Lisa Werst

This recent rebrand has definitely reinvigorated this location! Easy to access for a comfy meal, with hands down the friendliest, most helpful staff I've came across in my year of food delivery!! Everything here looks and smells positively divine and it was a test of God to not order a to go for myself while I was here. Inviting, down to earth, cozy, but with a great menu of finer offerings and a good pizza if you're inclined. Great job to the crew!!

Madelyn Abeyta

We had a great experience! We ordered pasta and pizza to share. The corn ravioli was a little too weird and out there but it still tasted good. Uncle Carmen’s pizza was fabulous! Awesome flavors and a crust that’s both crispy and soft. The vibe is amazing and unique. The keyboardist is a nice touch and we loved the overall atmosphere. Service was also wonderful. Jonathan was our server and he was charming and funny as well as helpful and kind. I can’t wait to come back!

Tom Shook

Fried Calamari was inventive and enjoyable! Their pizza was well crafted…attention to detail. The crust was most satisfying. Thoroughly enjoyed our evening!

Andrew

Went for the new pasta dishes and they were delicious! The spaghetti, while it sounds boring, was PERFECTLY al dente and delicious! Tasting the pasta took me right back to Italy! The flavors were FULL! The pictures don’t do it justice, but this food is worth eating!!

Kaitlyn Nicholson

Staff were so nice and very attentive! The food was amazing. We had a Padre Island pizza, cheese bread and a Nutella pizza for dessert. Had plenty left over for later between the two of us. Will be back to try another pizza, since they all looked so amazing!

Brandy White

Oh my goodness. This was such a great experience. Stellar service, incredible food, fun vibe. 10/10 Looking forward to going back and trying more! Entry is in the back, meaning not towards the road.

+46

Bill Curci

Great to see Earl’s come back! Food and service were excellent. Caesar, lasagna and pizza were all great quality and good value.

Cristopher Womack

Exceptional Customer Service and Gluten Free Pizza!! We enjoyed Earl's 377 Pizza tonight with some exquisite take out. Our visit started with the delightful Riley who met us at our vehicle to offer assistance. As we had not yet ordered she walked us inside and provided exceptional service throughout. During our order there was a complication with the gift card we were applying to our meal. The manager came over and personally helped to sort the whole thing out. The service and atmosphere alone were impressive and we hadn't even eaten our food yet. We enjoyed the delicious and filling Nonna's Meatballs. The family favorite was the GLUTEN FREE BBQ Arezzo pizza. Phenomenal. The service alone is enough to give this charming restaurant a try, but the food will make you go back!

Bob Kim

Cross-posted from my Yelp review: SUMMARY: Hits all the marks for a solid dining experience: great food, fun atmosphere, and Outstanding service! VISIT We were first time visitors but not the first time we tried to dine here. Finally we made another attempt and glad we did. We were impressed by the country type atmosphere and by the cleanliness of the place. Big plus for this. FOOD We ordered a small margherita pizza as well as a small Caesar salad. We were really impressed by how well the crust came out. Nice and crispy without being burnt and still held its shape even with the ingredients soaking in. The sauce was outstanding too and the balance of the ingredients vs the ratio of pizza dough was perfect for us. Now the star of the show in my opinion was the Caesar salad. Boy, I gladly polished off what my wife couldn't! Perfectly sauced without drowning in the Caesar dressing and the right amount of ingredients. I especially liked the grape tomatoes. Nice n sweet and firm fresh skin, not old by any means. SERVICE: Can we say how much we loved our waitress Leanna? Hopefully I spelled her name correctly. She was absolutely the best and the restaurant should be happy that she represents the restaurant with her awesome service, demeanor, and service. She checked up on us enough at the right times and not too often so as to be intrusive. As a former waiter, I can tel she's experienced and good at what she does and she made our first experience at Earl's a memorable one. RETURN VISIT? We've decided Earl's is our go-to pizza place going forward!

Giut

Earl’s Pizza offers not only delicious pizza but also exceptional customer service that truly stands out. The staff is attentive, friendly, and eager to make your experience enjoyable. From taking your order to ensuring everything is perfect, they go above and beyond. It’s a great place to grab a bite and feel well taken care of.

+2

Anthony (Beer Chronicle) Gorrity

Great pizza, decent beer selection, and really cool atmosphere. The highlight was easily our server, Kaelyn. Kind and quick, knowledgeable and attentive without hovering. She really made the experience! I love the menus too. Such a cool spot.

+6

David Hume (David H)

Earl & Isabella's Taverna, formerly Earl's on 377, is a very unique restaurant with plenty of character, following the current trend of converted industrial buildings. This having been a Fire Station I believe. Well Done. The menu, aside from Pizza, is very limited, however the spaghetti & meatballs, has a more Italian name on the menu, is spectacular and very flavorful with generous portions. We would frequent this hidden gem more often if it had more menu selections of this caliber. The servers, mostly very young, are inexperienced but helpful & enthusiastic. Our server this last visit was young, but Extraordinary in his skills, thus double the standard tip. You absolutely must try this place if you live nearby. Being in Argyle, there are always interesting vehicles in the parking lot, like this McClaren Hyper-Car Hybrid last time we visited

BM FONZ

Where is the cheese? I always loved this place as Earls 377. When I saw the new version of a name I was really hoping that Earl wasn’t going to continue to be so stingy with his cheese. We got a cheese pizza tonight and still the same…amazing crust, incredible sauce, and very little cheese. Cheese it up more Earl and I’ll hand out another star.

Cheryl Oberkrieser

We thought the flavor of the food was good. Nothing exciting but it was decent and you could tell the quality of the ingredients was good however nothing made such an impression that I'd go out of my way to go back. 2 of our dishes came out cold - spaghetti and meatballs, and the brisket ravioli. The pasta and sauce were hot but the meatballs had a cold center. The ravioli were luke warm throughout and cold in some spots. When we mentioned the issue to the waitress she said we should have told her when the food first came out which was off putting because we actually did mention it the first time she came by which was significantly after the food arrived. They brought out new meatballs, which were hot, so I appreciated their effort to address it. Given the choice though I'd go to Bella Italia, Giro's, Rustico or Alforno's if you want good pizza or pasta in the area.

Noah Ray

The pizza tastes good. BUT As in a JLO But: A proper pizza should not flop over when folded as you pock it up, but this one immediately flops like Lebron James , the crust is too soft and the ingredients are too concentrated into the middle and almost nothing near the edges Unfortunately this is my last attempt to eat here after years of bragging how great they were The crust used to be more authentic NY style, now its closer to a raw dough sopapilla pillow fluff with honey- not a real italian pizza Ingredients are still good quality but rather sparse Also not sure when Earl transitioned Please go back to how you used to do it

Stefanie Doyle

Do not recommend, went here for my birthday, first time ever coming here, service was good until it wasn't. I bit into my pasta and there was a rock that almost broke my brand new veneers. I bit into a ROCK in my Riggatoni, and manager came over pretended to be kind, and said it's probably the grinding of the meat. Promised to take off my meal from the bill, waitress said we'll get that off for you. My birthday & didn't even get a dinner, had to share with my daughter. Go to check out and OF COURSE THEY LEFT the meal on the ticket! Literally took 2 bites and tried to charge us! Extremely disrespectful! I was super kind about it until they tried to trick us into to paying for it. The $15 salad wasn't good either, the pizza was mediocre, & the pasta wasn't edible. very disappointed in their deceitfulness by the manager, & was very disappointed in how they handled the situation in the end.

DSI Properties, LLC

Not worth the time and money! Very limited Menu and overpriced. They want to be an authentic Italian Restaurant? Table cloth alone will NOT do that. No Bread is served ( a must in an Italien restaurant)! Wine glasses are a joke. We spent $110.00 for two poeple, had Spaghetti and Regatoni, Calamari and two glasses of basic red vine. Food was okay, Spaghetti were undercooked. The Pizza selection, like the entire Menü is very limited and nothing there we liked. Service was horrible. Very little attention and had get up to call for someone to get the check. We would not recommend this place, and will not come back. So many other places who have much better Italian food.