Laura Lee

The gluten-free pizza was very good. The crust was the thinner type so I'm not sure they make it but it was actually very tasty. It wasn't a thick fluffy pan pizza Detroit style crust but it did taste very good. My partner got regular pizza and he loved it. I like their sauce it wasn't too sweet but it still had some sweetness. The wings or meaty. We got extra sauce and it definitely was very saucy what you really like. Definitely will be going back! The only sad thing I am one of those weirdos who likes ham pineapple and mild pepper rings on my pizza. They don't have pineapple and mild pepper rings.

Kyle Matesic

My first time having a Pesci pizza. I really really enjoyed it. Great flavor. Great crust. Great Cup N Char. Oregano I could take it or leave it. Sauce was sweet but not too sweet. Very good pizza

Salvatore Christopher

First time having there food pizza was good needed more sauce. Wings were done well. But working in a pizzeria and ordering for 50+ years this was the first time ever did not get celery or carrots in the wing order.

Mitchell Maciuba

Good hole in the wall pizza joint. Location has nothing special. But the food is good

The pizza was really pretty good. They didn't skimp on the cheese, but weren't exactly generous with the topping portions. I know it's not the staff's fault, but I knocked off a star because of their Toast pricing. They quote the price for a cheese only pizza, but show the picture of a cheese and pepperoni pizza. That's deceptive advertising. Classic bait and switch.

Rex Koeppen

Food is great every time. Past couple times the young cashiers have been quite rude. Once more and I’ll just go to Picassos instead. She’s gotta go.

Ivy Lindsey

The pizza is consistently okay here. But the wings we got last night were inedible unfortunately. We got the large pizza and 1 lb of wings combo for $43, and I didn’t realize I was ordering boneless wings so I got them charred. They were so burnt we threw them all out. We didn’t want to get sick eating ashes… So we basically had to throw away $20.

Goodorbad2025

I placed an order through Door Dash for us to pick up, and when my husband arrived they told him that a door dash driver already picked up my order. The girl was told to call the manager who was in Florida for the next Bills game, and he was arguing with her over the phone. A few minutes later, I received a phone call from this manager basically making me feel like a criminal, even though he saw I had ordered 19 times from them. As if I was going to steal one large pizza! He was rude and accusatorial, questioning me and basically telling me this has never happened before! I will never order from here again solely based on my unpleasant experience with the manager. I also felt terrible for the girl at the actual restaurant, because my husband said he was obviously being a jerk to her over the phone. All over one large pizza! I still cannot believe that there was no one that could have handled it at the restaurant, and that they had to call this manager in Florida and apparently ruin his night from the way he spoke to me! After reading other reviews on multiple sites, (including here where the owner called a customer's husband a lunatic), it appears to be a reoccurring problem. Customer service is seriously lacking.

Rachelle Cizdziel

We were die hard Pesci’s fans for years, but within the past year, every pizza we ordered is not cooked. The most recent one we ordered was RAW, I could literally pull the dough up like it was the cheese (it wasn’t). Pesci’s has really lost their quality control.

Andrii Dunaf

Horrendous customer service. I ordered a 1 slice of pizza with boneless wings combo and they only sent me wings. Arrived cold and no pizza slice. When I called lady answered. I kindly explained my situation then she hung up. Very upset w the experience won’t be coming back.

Carlos Pareja

So I called in at 2:10pm and asked to have a large cheese and pepperoni pizza ready for 5:15pm. I was told by the girl I spoke with that it will be ready at that time and how much to pay. My wife just left there to pick up pizza and the owner or manager ( not sure who he was) yelled at my wife stating she was lying. First of all, any man yelling at my wife, that's your first mistake. Trash establishment. Never had an issue until today. NEVER ORDERING FROM HERE AGAIN.

Kelly J

Ordered a large pizza today and the crust was burnt. The pizza was very chewy and the sauce was liquedy. Seems like it was old and left out. The pizza was very inedible, my kids couldn’t even eat it. We had to throw it away. My husband called and told them and they wouldn’t even give us a refund/credit. Not great customer service. We’ve never had an issue before and always loved their pizza but now we’ll go elsewhere.