I Love NY Pizza

Captain McKay Random

Gusto’s always does a great job whenever I order food. It’s my go-to pizza place!

Matt Berard

You can't beat a good slice and a soda for $5.75. nice spot for a quick break.

Heidi Johnson

We ordered seven different extra large pizzas on a whim and they were delivered quickly, still hot, and tasty. I will always order my pizzas from Gusto's.

Mary Beth Amato

Best pizza I have had in a really long time. Excellent. Crust so good.

Kimberly Miller

Ordered online and my pizza was hot and ready at the time I requested. Very pleasant service - carried my pizza around the counter so I could slide them in my thermal carrier. Tasty as always.

Amelia Persico

We get Gustos every week and tried the buffalo chicken pizza for the first time tonight. It was great!

Charlene Lynch

There aren't a lot of places left anymore that you can get anchovies on pizza. The pizza was so good. I ate twice as much as I normally do i!

Kimberly M

THIS time I picked up hot pizza that was ready on time. (Not my experience always.). It was handed to me by a very polite young man who realized short people can’t always reach up and get it off a high counter.

Victoria Jones

Pizza was good but too much sauce for me I'll ask for 1/2 the sauce next time.

Shawon Roy

Good pizza — crisp and light; the sauce is the only thing that could use improvement. make it great

Shawn Ballard

I have to give this a 3 for food because it was a blah sausage sub and a 1 for service because I put in on my card a 20% tip before realizing the waitress (or whatever she was) wouldn’t even come 20 feet to deliver my sub when it was finished. She called out to me like 2 times to come to the counter to pick up my meal. What exactly is she there for? Just taking orders? Not bringing the orders to the table? Good to know beforehand because next time I’ll leave out the tip. If I go back.

Jamie Thompson

Pizza was floppy, too much sauce, and the crust was tasteless. The buffalo chicken bites were not edible.

Richard J Naylor

My update to the first take is not good. The second was the Veggie Lovers again but this time, the broccolui totally overpowered everything and the pizza was so soggy from something (I'm guessing lighidy tomato) that we could barely eat it. The main part of the crust was also too thin -- so with sogginess added it was yuck. Previous comments: The pizza was very good. The only problem was the notification that the pizza was ready came after i had picked it up. Also, while i ordered asap the acknowledgement email made no mention of when i should come or that there would be another email when it was ready.

Muhammad akram khan Alokozay

The order should be ready on 2:54 but they said it will take 30 more minutes just because they forgot to make the order like what the actual hack is that men, so unprofessional so lazy employees are they, hope the mangere take action against them

Jorge Cintron

First time ordering from gusto pizza and let me tell you ...'save ur money!!!" I ordered the meatball sub and what a disappointment no flavor what so ever... I can't believe y'all let food go out like this where's ur pride in serving ur customers! Shame on u. Head's up for anyone stupid enough to throw away ur money on this crap. SMH!!!

Liam

Very poor service. An order that should have taken 20 minutes somehow became 1.5 hours. When speaking with a woman on the phone, she offered no help nor apology. After an additional ten minutes I had to call back and ask for her to call the driver so I could know if I could finish a second movie before the food arrives. She was clearly exhausted and disgruntled. Sorry, lady, this is the service industry for a reason. Been there. Ya still have to do the job well. At least try. I’m not sure why she felt the right to be upset at me, but that was clearly the tone. I had to call several times just to reach anyone. But there is also no voicemail set-up. That’s not a good owner. Pretty basic stuff if you care about customer service. Anyway, after finally receiving the order 1 hour and 44 minutes after ordering, I got a tepid soda, sad and broken cookie, and this sad pizza. OH.. and I ordered pepperoni… so they can’t even be bothered to get a simple order correctly. I’d like a response, please.

Quinetta Rouse

My mother referred me to this place. She said this was the best pizza she had in years. She had ordered a pizza pie and had nothing but great things to say about the crust and how good the pizza was. So last night we decided to order from there but not a pie. We ordered their Sicilian pizza 24 cut Buffalo chicken with extra cheese with 20wings, 10 mango Habanero 10 honey barbecue. When it arrived this is what is looked like. Old pizza they just threw in the oven. I was going to call and get my money back but my 10 year old son wanted to try it soo bad and said he liked it but after barley one slice he didn’t want it anymore. By then I felt like it was too late to go get my money back and because he said he liked it in the beginning I made him eat another slice since I WASTED 61 dollars and tipped the driver. I will NEVER ORDER FROM this place again. Do better