Yaghi's New York Pizzeria

Best pizza. Owner know how to treat his customers. Very impressive.

Probably the best, affordable and non-chain pizza in Georgetown. Staff is always friendly and some of the best vegetarian (not vegan) pizza I've had.

Phenomenal pizza! The roasted garlic chicken pizza was so so tasty. Definitely found our new go to pizzeria. ❤️

Came here and got the lunch special. Two slices of pizza or a slice of pizza and a salad plus a drink for $5.99. So many choices of pizza. The greek salads looked amazing. Employees were friendly and helpful.

Walk in and the place smell good pizza. Great variety and display of the pizza.good special. The pizza tasted great and the crust has a nice crunch to it.keep up the good work

here is what you need to know about this location before you come here it's a local Central Texas franchise that has some locations throughout the nation but mainly is known for beef pepperoni and for people like me who stay away from poor product they have beef substitute for everything you can imagine and it comes out to my taste buds even better did not take long to have two fresh heated slices under lunch special complete with drink and plenty of dining in space despite it looking like a little hole in the wall they're open July 4th with two friendly gentlemen there to greet me and make me feel like family with super clean restroom with plenty of soap hand towels plenty of utensils and he even had fresh garlic and fresh spices to put on my pizza too plenty of napkins and a simple drink lineup no alcoholic beverages but at least that I noticed lots and lots of meat options especially to go as well The challenging part even though it's handicap accessible is finding parking in this super extremely busy HEB shopping center area and safely and patiently getting out of there is probably the trickiest thing with this location I would also say the tables were clean everything was kept clean and organized with a peaceful ambience to the whole location which just added to the overall quality and value of the lunch special which was just after tax under $9 for two slices and a drink which was enough to fill me up highly recommend them especially if you need a good amount of pizza to go I saw a couple people come in and out quick and easy to get there pizzas that they called ahead and paid for in advance

Best lunch deal in town. Two big NY style slices and a drink for $5. Amazing pizza and never crowded.

Delicious! Kids had pepperoni, adults had the Popeye pizza. On point!

LUIS PLAZA

Walk in and the place smell good pizza. Great variety and display of the pizza.good special. The pizza tasted great and the crust has a nice crunch to it.keep up the good work

Shane Anciso

here is what you need to know about this location before you come here it's a local Central Texas franchise that has some locations throughout the nation but mainly is known for beef pepperoni and for people like me who stay away from poor product they have beef substitute for everything you can imagine and it comes out to my taste buds even better did not take long to have two fresh heated slices under lunch special complete with drink and plenty of dining in space despite it looking like a little hole in the wall they're open July 4th with two friendly gentlemen there to greet me and make me feel like family with super clean restroom with plenty of soap hand towels plenty of utensils and he even had fresh garlic and fresh spices to put on my pizza too plenty of napkins and a simple drink lineup no alcoholic beverages but at least that I noticed lots and lots of meat options especially to go as well The challenging part even though it's handicap accessible is finding parking in this super extremely busy HEB shopping center area and safely and patiently getting out of there is probably the trickiest thing with this location I would also say the tables were clean everything was kept clean and organized with a peaceful ambience to the whole location which just added to the overall quality and value of the lunch special which was just after tax under $9 for two slices and a drink which was enough to fill me up highly recommend them especially if you need a good amount of pizza to go I saw a couple people come in and out quick and easy to get there pizzas that they called ahead and paid for in advance

BMF

Best lunch deal in town. Two big NY style slices and a drink for $5. Amazing pizza and never crowded.

Stopped in for dinner Friday night and we were surprised pizza was very good. Thin crust and pizza had good flavor. There could have been more sauce on pizza but we know that for next time. If looking for a good pie stop by.

My family had a Pepsi pizza, calzone, and two different salads. We all very much enjoyed the food. Everything was very tasty and great quality. The Cesar salad has tiny little garlic knots instead of croutons; very creative and delicious! We order pizza here from time to time it always comes out fantastic.

Took my kids and myself there during the holidays. Very nice taste and great food. Prices are to high though

Great option for a quick lunch. Good crust: little crispy, little chewy. Good ratio of sauce to cheese to toppings. Good deal with the lunch special. Will stop by again.

First time and we ordered a gyro pizza. Ready on time and fast pick up. My wife and I really enjoyed it. Great taste and plenty of good quality toppings. Crust was just right, tasty and crisp. Planning to get another pizza soon.

My husband and I just stopped by for the first time to grab a quick lunch snack. I had a slice of Margherita Pizza and my husband tried the Pepperoni with Jalapeños. Wow!!!! One of the best pizzas we've ever had! Hot, great flavor and the crust was incredible! Service was very friendly, too! Highly recommend!

For a small storefront in a strip center, Yahgi's Pizza is consistently as good as I've ever had. And their salads are just as good. The service is always great. Most of the time, we get takeout and the people there couldn't be nicer or more accommodating. You're in for a treat, enjoy!

This has become our toddlers favorite pizza. I love the chicken with spinach and garlic pizza. The chicken is seasoned to perfection.

Great pizza rolls and pizza. On time with orders. Decently priced for better pizza than big chains.

Gym Floor

Great pizza rolls and pizza. On time with orders. Decently priced for better pizza than big chains.

Food lover of all cuisines

This has become our toddlers favorite pizza. I love the chicken with spinach and garlic pizza. The chicken is seasoned to perfection.

Susan Crawford

Took my kids and myself there during the holidays. Very nice taste and great food. Prices are to high though

Mark Warren

For a small storefront in a strip center, Yahgi's Pizza is consistently as good as I've ever had. And their salads are just as good. The service is always great. Most of the time, we get takeout and the people there couldn't be nicer or more accommodating. You're in for a treat, enjoy!

Alan Olson

We ordered the works pizza and a chef salad. The pizza was so loaded with toppings. The salad had more toppings than lettuce.

Alcoholic Insight

Great option for a quick lunch. Good crust: little crispy, little chewy. Good ratio of sauce to cheese to toppings. Good deal with the lunch special. Will stop by again.

Scott Karcher

Stopped in for dinner Friday night and we were surprised pizza was very good. Thin crust and pizza had good flavor. There could have been more sauce on pizza but we know that for next time. If looking for a good pie stop by.

Leuyen Do

My family had a Pepsi pizza, calzone, and two different salads. We all very much enjoyed the food. Everything was very tasty and great quality. The Cesar salad has tiny little garlic knots instead of croutons; very creative and delicious! We order pizza here from time to time it always comes out fantastic.

Martina D.

My husband and I just stopped by for the first time to grab a quick lunch snack. I had a slice of Margherita Pizza and my husband tried the Pepperoni with Jalapeños. Wow!!!! One of the best pizzas we've ever had! Hot, great flavor and the crust was incredible! Service was very friendly, too! Highly recommend!

Jeep Oldie (89YJ)

First time and we ordered a gyro pizza. Ready on time and fast pick up. My wife and I really enjoyed it. Great taste and plenty of good quality toppings. Crust was just right, tasty and crisp. Planning to get another pizza soon.

Pizza was better than it looked. The owner was very pleasant and service was quick . I would recommend this place to others.

Some of the best NY style pizza you will find in the area. Yaghi's is in my Top 5 for favorite pizza's in North Austin. All the locations are pretty consistent. A little pricey and the other items besides the pizza are nothing to write about. Definitely a must try you like NY style pizza.

Had lunch special. Pizza pretty good. Guy at counter was ok. Hard to understand he spoke so softly. There was nobody else in the place. When our pizza was ready, he was too lazy to walk 19 feet to bring it to us and made me get up and come get it. If the place had been busy, that's fine. But empty? Great customer service (sarcasm). While we were eating, a large group came in. The guy stood there hoping the manager would help them. The manager literally had to push him to go help them.

Drew Stephens

Had lunch special. Pizza pretty good. Guy at counter was ok. Hard to understand he spoke so softly. There was nobody else in the place. When our pizza was ready, he was too lazy to walk 19 feet to bring it to us and made me get up and come get it. If the place had been busy, that's fine. But empty? Great customer service (sarcasm). While we were eating, a large group came in. The guy stood there hoping the manager would help them. The manager literally had to push him to go help them.

UPDATE: Gave them another shot. Needed a place close by prior to the Super Bowl. Same old story. Meatball sub still full of sauce and cheese, and a bit of meatballs. This time I also got spaghetti and meatballs. Pasta had obviously been prepared long before - it was so overcooked it was almost mush. Meatballs have decent flavor, but they've been quartered to make it seem like more. Not sure if they are house made - if so, they need to roll them more loosely; very dense, and need some moisture. Tried this place for the first time. Went with the meatball sub. So close, but missed the mark. Bread was great, sauce was tasty, but just not enough meatballs. For a 14" sub, you're gonna need more than one quartered meatball in each half. Half the bites (or less) had meat.

This is the best pizza that I've found in Texas, and coming from Boston my bar for good pizza is set pretty high. However I cannot give them a five-star review because how much they upcharge for their menu items if you order delivery. Especially during a pandemic when so many people are rightly staying home is unexcusable, depending on the delivery service the upcharge could be anywhere from $2 to $3 an item. This restaurant already has borderline overpriced menu items to begin with (18.99 for a large pizza is a bit much) so this makes it so ordering a large specialty pizza, two orders of wings and cheese sticks can cost you $80 or more. That's ridiculous. No thank you

I have been order n from this place for years, (at least twice a week) have always been happy with them, food is amazing! Recently my ordering has gone down a lot because the night crew seems to be quite rude! I will now only order now during the day, and if David is working. Those teenagers with their fancy cars, need to learn manners and how to use common sense!

Gave us the incorrect toppings 2 family dinners in a row. Line cook sneezed in his hands with no gloves and continued working. Buuuut its some of the best pizza I've had.

The pizza was below average in taste. And their salads are not very good either. I had the Caesar salad, it was just lettuce with bits of rolled up pizza crust, and parmesan cheese sprinkled on it l. Friendly and fast service but not so good food. However the prices are great, they have a lunch special 2 slices of pizza and a drink for $9, good value. Small location with limited seating.

Nice folks, clean place, decent assortment of pizzas to get something by the slice. My two slices came out but were nowhere near as hat as they should have been. Of course I had taken a bit from one so they couldn't put that one back in the oven. Didn't think to cut that part off at the time. They ought to know how long it takes to heat pizza. No beer either.

My sister recommend this place saying it was rather good. However, perhaps it was the staff on hand but our pepperoni pizza was very oily (I feel a bit ill from it honestly) and relatively lack luster--Costco pizza was a few bars ahead of their game. Perhaps it was a fluke.. my advice to management is to have steady employees and to become consistent.

Meatball sub - terrible. Threw it away after trying the meatballs; dry, smelled weird, my guess is they were improperly stored or undercooked. Cheese pizza. Was ok at best. Crust was thinner than places like Marco's or Domino's and was NY-ish (former NYC resident); however, it wasn't significantly better than those places. Would not return.

We got a Buffalo chicken pizza today, and it looked and smelled great. Unfortunately there was no sauce on the pizza other than grease and the chicken was dry as can be, so the pizza was fairly disappointing.

Ivan Collier

We got a Buffalo chicken pizza today, and it looked and smelled great. Unfortunately there was no sauce on the pizza other than grease and the chicken was dry as can be, so the pizza was fairly disappointing.

Hugo

The pizza was below average in taste. And their salads are not very good either. I had the Caesar salad, it was just lettuce with bits of rolled up pizza crust, and parmesan cheese sprinkled on it l. Friendly and fast service but not so good food. However the prices are great, they have a lunch special 2 slices of pizza and a drink for $9, good value. Small location with limited seating.

My family and I ordered pizza the night before thanksgiving from Yaghi’s. We drove a bit of a ways as most places were busy and Yaghi’s had a 20 minute wait. By the time we picked up our order, and got back home… we realized half of the order was missing. We spoke with Anthony and he explained his apologizes however is unable to refund us… This order was placed for a large party therefor after that night we didn’t need the items remade for just 1-2 people. Anthony said he can’t refund us. Very disappointed in the customer care. Highly don’t recommend as there are plenty of other pizza joints with better customer service. If you do choose Yaghi’s…. check your order before leaving, otherwise you’ll be paying for nothing.

Called in and ordered a two pizza’s. Show up to the store and they gave my food to someone else and had no explanation as to how it happened. Worst customer service I’ve ever seen and refused to give a discount after screwing up. Great pizza but terrible service from the front counter.

If you want cold pizza that tastes like it sat there forever, this is for you. If you want wings that weren't even warm and tasted like pure oil, this is for you. Not sure how this place has so many good review. Won't find me returning here.

I went in to get a couple slices of pizza and wings. When I asked for the wings the guy that just spoke English to me no longer understood or coupe speak English. Then wanted to charge me for ranch so I said okay I want to order wings. I even flapped my arms like a chicken. When I pointed to the wings he still couldn’t understand my English. So he just didn’t want to make the wings. So instead he went with he only spoke Spanish. So I walked out. You’re losing business cause your employees can’t and don’t want to make the food on the menu! And just say they don’t speak English.

I ordered a pizza that is made with white sauce. When I got it home it was covered in red sauce. Rich the manager refused to look at the pizza or remake it. He says that's normal. I've ordered a margarita pizza from Yaghi's a 100 times and have never seen it covered in red sauce. Based on their poor customer service they have lost a customer for life. We all make mistakes but we acknowledge them and correct them. They wouldn't even look at the pizza let alone remake it.

I’m extreamly irrited with this place. Been ordering pizza from them at least 3 times a month for the last 6 years. There pizza is great there drivers and customer service is great. What I’m irritated about is this, Ordered a Large pizza double cheese, double pepp. Runs $25 bucks, I can get one from Pizza Hut for $14 but never mind that. They sell by the slice, so I Wanted 2 additional slices with pineapple, I was told “ They don’t do that “ Your coming to my house what can’t you do that ! The owner won’t let him is the response, Ok I said May Insoeak with him ? No he laughs and tells me he won’t speak to me... You won’t be getting anymore orders from me.

Ordered pepperoni and roasted garlic. Got pepperoni and burnt garlic. Also received hard time from employee about getting pizza replaced. Not worth the nearly $23 for a medium 2 topping. No plans to go back.

Rick DeKreek

Ordered pepperoni and roasted garlic. Got pepperoni and burnt garlic. Also received hard time from employee about getting pizza replaced. Not worth the nearly $23 for a medium 2 topping. No plans to go back.

Horrible customer service. I ordered an XL half cheese and half Hawaiian. When I got the pizza home we realized it had no sauce. Kids arent going to eat a sauce less cheese pizza. When I called them to try to get it made right all they offered me was to drive all the way back and get a medium cheese to replace it. The manager REFUSED to get on the phone with me, and they refused to tell me the managers name. I asked for a refund and they said I would have to bring the pizza back. It's a 20 minute drive. I asked if they could deliver me a replacement, they said no. I drove back, got my refund, and will NEVER go back. To be honest, the pizza is good. I don't think I've ever been treated worse by a restaurant. Dominoes would have made it right for me. But not Yaghis.

I Called in my order Friday for lunch. The gentleman put me on hold and another gentleman took my order.(I ordered the cheesesteak). Upon pick up The establishment itself was empty but was clean. Pizzas on display were old and did not look appetizing. I went to pay and although the menu says ALL hot subs are $7.25 It rang up at 15.67. I asked why as I showed the cashier the menu says $7.25 he says he want aware and refused to acknowledge the listed price so I declined to get the order altogether. Please update your pricing and menus. It is deceitful to false advertise. I work nearby and wasted my lunch break.

Do NOT order calzones from Yaghi’s!!! I just received one and thinner than a slice of pizza. Called store and all they could say is “sorry that’s the way they are made with out a lot of toppings stuffed in. Door dash can give you a credit. Do not order, so disappointing!

I’ve ordered from Yaghis before, but never again. I walked in to pick up a medium pizza, which is now $28! The guy behind the counter went and got my pizza and threw the box onto the counter. I paid and when the receipt printed, he just left it by the machine, when I asked him to hand it to me, he just left it there. I’ve read the negative reviews about this place before, but I can’t believe someone could think they’re going to stay in business by making a mediocre pizza and have ridiculously bad service. There are plenty of other options for pizza in Georgetown. Stay clear of Yaghis.

Brett Rajotte

I’ve ordered from Yaghis before, but never again. I walked in to pick up a medium pizza, which is now $28! The guy behind the counter went and got my pizza and threw the box onto the counter. I paid and when the receipt printed, he just left it by the machine, when I asked him to hand it to me, he just left it there. I’ve read the negative reviews about this place before, but I can’t believe someone could think they’re going to stay in business by making a mediocre pizza and have ridiculously bad service. There are plenty of other options for pizza in Georgetown. Stay clear of Yaghis.

Fluff DiditFirst

I Called in my order Friday for lunch. The gentleman put me on hold and another gentleman took my order.(I ordered the cheesesteak). Upon pick up The establishment itself was empty but was clean. Pizzas on display were old and did not look appetizing. I went to pay and although the menu says ALL hot subs are $7.25 It rang up at 15.67. I asked why as I showed the cashier the menu says $7.25 he says he want aware and refused to acknowledge the listed price so I declined to get the order altogether. Please update your pricing and menus. It is deceitful to false advertise. I work nearby and wasted my lunch break.

Lera Matthews

Do NOT order calzones from Yaghi’s!!! I just received one and thinner than a slice of pizza. Called store and all they could say is “sorry that’s the way they are made with out a lot of toppings stuffed in. Door dash can give you a credit. Do not order, so disappointing!