Papa Joe's Pizzeria

Bob Citizen

Took the family to Honeoye for dinner at Birdhouse but unfortunately they have winter hours and close the kitchen early. The only place nearby was Papa Joes so off we walked. The place was empty and no one was up front for a bit. Worried we were too late… Brett popped up and helped us decide (sheet pizza 1/2 veggie and a chicken parm sub). Food came out quickly and was delicious! Chatted with Brett and he made us some apple desserts! So good!!!

Aubrey Summers

★★★★★ I traveled from the faraway hills of Kentucky all the way to Honeoye, New York for one reason: PIZZA. Why? Because I am a self-proclaimed pizza critic with absolutely no credentials, zero certifications, and unlimited confidence. And let me tell you… this pizza didn’t just meet my expectations. It drop-kicked them through a flaming hoop. The crust? So good it made me reconsider every life decision I’ve made. The cheese? Stretchier than my willpower in front of a dessert table. The sauce? I swear it tried to convert me to a new religion. Now, about those recent bad reviews: clearly the work of a mysterious, disgruntled, possibly snack-deprived gremlin lurking somewhere with a keyboard and too much free time (makes sense, loser). A shadowy culinary saboteur who fears the raw power of good pizza. Tragic, really. To that anonymous chaos gremlin: may your microwave meals be forever lukewarm. To everyone else: go to this place. Go NOW. Cross state lines. Ignore responsibilities. Accept destiny. Five stars. No notes. This place is the final boss of pizza

brandon lewis

The food is always satisfying and delicious. The staff is friendly. My go to here is a buffalo chicken slice with country sweet. Highly recommend 👌

David Stagnitto

Frankly the best pizza in honeoye. Friendly staff, quick service, subs are great! I'm partial to the cheese steak.

Dave P

Pizza was delicious and service was great. Glad we stopped. Hope to again some day.

Bob Barker

Best pizza around! We drive from Naples quite often just for the excellent pizza and wings. The people are super friendly and the food is consistently amazing. Try the meaty pizza with cup and char pepperoni! The hot buffalo sauce is the best I’ve ever had! Thank you Papa Joes for the amazing food and friendly staff, you have a customer for life!!!!!

Amanda Kudzia

We Came into town on Monday and after a long drive from Michigan and we were looking for food. I have to say, they had the best wings in my opinion. We definitely be grabbing more before we go!

When they're open its my favorite pizza spot, and the only one in the area that delivers to my house. The only issue of late, is that they're not open, or delivering when they are open. Im sure it has something to do with reduced workforce, wages, etc. Sadly, the unreliable hours and service has basically removed them as an option. Good luck Papa Joe's!

Jared Walker

When they're open its my favorite pizza spot, and the only one in the area that delivers to my house. The only issue of late, is that they're not open, or delivering when they are open. Im sure it has something to do with reduced workforce, wages, etc. Sadly, the unreliable hours and service has basically removed them as an option. Good luck Papa Joe's!

We stopped in for a pizza tonight while passing though town. The pizza was just ok. The place definately needs an update. Its not the worst we have had but definately not the best.

$9.99 cold sub on the menu, but ended up paying over $16.00. I just asked for extra lettuce and banana peppers. I bit into a banana pepper stem, which sucked but hey, I'm a fat kid and was starving. I know reviews are important to local businesses but either update the menu or warn people of a $6.00 up charge.

Todd Burritt

We stopped in for a pizza tonight while passing though town. The pizza was just ok. The place definately needs an update. Its not the worst we have had but definately not the best.

KC Conti

$9.99 cold sub on the menu, but ended up paying over $16.00. I just asked for extra lettuce and banana peppers. I bit into a banana pepper stem, which sucked but hey, I'm a fat kid and was starving. I know reviews are important to local businesses but either update the menu or warn people of a $6.00 up charge.

My order has never once been ready on time. I specifically place my order in advance so I don't have to sit around and wait for it. It's at least 15 minutes late every time. I stopped going there because I was tired of waiting. Today, I made and exception hoping they would be better. I placed an order at 3:30 PM for pickup at 4:45. It's 5 PM and I'm still sitting here as I type this. The place is dead. There is no excuse for it not being ready on time.

I have been through this town a million times and never stopped here for pizza . We did yesterday , the staff was very pleasant we each had a slice and a soda prices not bad. The pizza had minimal flavor and enough grease on it to fill a soda bottle half way because I did it !! I have seen greasy oily pizza in my day but this was a show stopper !! If you like pizza like this god bless you I will not be returning unless my car needs some engine oil !

Mitchell Kantar

My order has never once been ready on time. I specifically place my order in advance so I don't have to sit around and wait for it. It's at least 15 minutes late every time. I stopped going there because I was tired of waiting. Today, I made and exception hoping they would be better. I placed an order at 3:30 PM for pickup at 4:45. It's 5 PM and I'm still sitting here as I type this. The place is dead. There is no excuse for it not being ready on time.

angeshift

I have been through this town a million times and never stopped here for pizza . We did yesterday , the staff was very pleasant we each had a slice and a soda prices not bad. The pizza had minimal flavor and enough grease on it to fill a soda bottle half way because I did it !! I have seen greasy oily pizza in my day but this was a show stopper !! If you like pizza like this god bless you I will not be returning unless my car needs some engine oil !

This place is a joke. Is this even pizza???? Ordered a pink sauce pie with chicken and broccoli. Well 10 small cubes of chicken later and 10 burnt dime size florets of broccoli is not called a pizza when a large 2 topping is $26.00!!!! Do not go here! Don’t waste your time!!! Let the picture tell it all. NASTY! Couldn’t pay me to order from here again lol!

Demyan Petryk

This place is a joke. Is this even pizza???? Ordered a pink sauce pie with chicken and broccoli. Well 10 small cubes of chicken later and 10 burnt dime size florets of broccoli is not called a pizza when a large 2 topping is $26.00!!!! Do not go here! Don’t waste your time!!! Let the picture tell it all. NASTY! Couldn’t pay me to order from here again lol!

Worst place I’ve traveled to in the upstate area if you want to go to a good pizza place this isn’t the one. There is obviously sanitary issues going on plus food not being cooked to a safe temperature. When I tried speaking my concerns I was met with a very rude attitude.

Pizza had no flavor. Sauce too bland and sausage was flavorless. Definitely not worth 25.50 for 2 toppings. Tried it once, that was enough. Threw it out to my skunks and raccoons.

Overpriced. Rude staff, stale/cold food and missing items even though we waited forever. Called to say missing things and refused both a refund and delivery items. Then girl on phone hung up on us. Don’t waste your money.

It’s a shame because the foods decent (sometimes). But it’s LITERALLY every time we order there it’s a catastrophe. Whether the credit card machines down and the guy says who doesn’t carry cash? The dough on calzones and pizza will be raw when you get your food. When you order fish fry and extra tartar sauces, you will get 0; and when you go back in to ask for what you ordered and paid for, you’ll be told he’ll have to charge you extra. And heaven forbid they give you someone else’s pizza but you don’t notice until you get home, so you call and let them know, and go back for the correct pizza. Only to be offered the one that’s now an hour and a half old and been on someone else table. And the staff is disgruntled when you say you’d like a fresh one of the one you ordered and continue to trash talk you while you’re standing right there… seriously, just go to Topshelf!

Asked for a blt with banana peppers and they didn’t give me any banana peppers. My tomatoes and lettuce were frozen. Bread was stale. Definitely won’t be back.

mystery mystery

Worst place I’ve traveled to in the upstate area if you want to go to a good pizza place this isn’t the one. There is obviously sanitary issues going on plus food not being cooked to a safe temperature. When I tried speaking my concerns I was met with a very rude attitude.

Eva Buchiere-Gee

Overpriced. Rude staff, stale/cold food and missing items even though we waited forever. Called to say missing things and refused both a refund and delivery items. Then girl on phone hung up on us. Don’t waste your money.

Marley Man (Marleysmom)

Pizza had no flavor. Sauce too bland and sausage was flavorless. Definitely not worth 25.50 for 2 toppings. Tried it once, that was enough. Threw it out to my skunks and raccoons.

Ella Christ

Asked for a blt with banana peppers and they didn’t give me any banana peppers. My tomatoes and lettuce were frozen. Bread was stale. Definitely won’t be back.

craig munson

Horrible food Horrible service don't waste your money. You wonder what they are selling to keep the lights on because it's not good pizza.

Will Lloyd

It’s a shame because the foods decent (sometimes). But it’s LITERALLY every time we order there it’s a catastrophe. Whether the credit card machines down and the guy says who doesn’t carry cash? The dough on calzones and pizza will be raw when you get your food. When you order fish fry and extra tartar sauces, you will get 0; and when you go back in to ask for what you ordered and paid for, you’ll be told he’ll have to charge you extra. And heaven forbid they give you someone else’s pizza but you don’t notice until you get home, so you call and let them know, and go back for the correct pizza. Only to be offered the one that’s now an hour and a half old and been on someone else table. And the staff is disgruntled when you say you’d like a fresh one of the one you ordered and continue to trash talk you while you’re standing right there… seriously, just go to Topshelf!