Heather Evans

A few of us stopped in for lunch this past Friday. Our experience was nothing short of phenomenal from start to finish. The service was impeccable. Our server was knowledgeable about the menu and made excellent recommendations. As for the food, everything was absolutely fabulous. The fresh oysters we fantastic, the Ahi Tuna burger was 10/10 and the homemade desserts were the perfect small-bite amount as an after dinner treat. I cannot wait for my next visit. Highly recommended!

+1

Lift_Run_Eat_

Really good food being served up at Simeon’s. Although most dishes met my expectations for a place like this, some pleasantly surprised me. The Braised short Rib was by far the best dish we had. 9/10 Rib that just came apart and the flavour was great. It dried out quite quickly and was in need of the sauce by the end but it was excellent. They should shred some of it up and put it in a burger because that would be top. Second best dish and notable mention was their famous clam chowder. Definitely worth the claim to fame they put next to it on the menu. 9/10. It was really smooth and creamy but also had really fresh pieces of fish. The rest of the meal was very standard: - Oysters 8/10 - Prawns 7.5/10 - Half Lobster 8/10 - Spicy Clam Pot 7/10 - Burger 8/10

+6

Michael Delgado

Great spot! Great drinks! The grilled chicken sandwich and the burger were incredible. Tons of flavor and came out quick! Waitress was a sweetheart as well! Definitely plan a visit!

Laura Domic

We made sure to make a reservation in advance before our trip to Ithaca. From the moment we've got in everything was superb. Friendly, knowledgeable staff and amazing Bloody Mary cocktails made a great first impression. Our brunch experience started with amazing fresh oysters, cocktail shrimp and marinated olives followed by extraordinary mains: Eggs Benedict, Croque Madam and a Brunch Burger. They were all bursting in flavors. This is an extraordinary place!

+3

Jax Syms

Amazing restaurant. During weekend nights it can be very busy, and I would recommend setting up a reservation early in advance, otherwise it can be a 30-45 minute wait. The staff is very welcoming and friendly. Anything you try on the menu is guaranteed to be delicious. I had the oysters and salmon, and loved them. Desserts come in small sizes, which is welcome after such a filling meal, and are packed with flavor. Prices are a bit more than average, but it's absolutely worth it.

Ray

Cozy restaurant with friendly servers. Good beer and wine selections. We went with others recommendation and went for Chicken parmesan, lobster mac & cheese and Oysters. We also order the mussels. The oysters were fresh and the chicken was great. I didn’t think the lobster mac & cheese was good and the mussels were tiny. Overall food is average but the restaurant is nice and the servers were also nice.

+1

B. E.

Felt like my strip steak wasn't worth $52-not quite medium rare and the use of a grill lent a burnt taste to the steak. The quality of the meat was still excellent and tender, with the specials(a tomato soup with roasted red peppers and focaccia bread) being excellent. Mostly this means I should only have steak when I make it myself, since my standards are too exacting to what I like. Other people might rate this 5 stars. The rigatoni and sausage the other person in my group had was also excellent.

K Lap

We went here for dinner. It was pretty good. I had a burger and I have had better for less. The wife had the Lobster Mac & Cheese, which she really enjoyed. The prices are a little on the high side. The parking is not easy, although we got lucky and found an open metered space and it was cheap because it was close to 6 p.m. and they stop charging at 6. The drive in is not great either, as there is lots of construction. I am not a fan of Ithaca. We went to and through this town a few times and I was not impressed during any of my visits. If you're in the area to see the beautiful waterfalls, there are many other options without going into this city of commotion. Our server was nice. Overall, not a bad place to grab a bite to eat...

+6

Mushreka Afroze Khan

Honestly I had better lobster dishes. I was very disappointed by their lobster Mac and cheese, it's dry and the lobster was chewy. The only reason I'm rating them 4 is because of the shrimp Campanella pasta which was creamy and tasted decent. Highly recommend strawberry lemonade. Also I'm not sure if it's only me but we found the waitresses a little haughty, won't say they're non-hospitable but they're a bit snooty. I traveled from city for a short trip and had high expectation from the place as we're restaurant hopping and looking for the best food to try in Ithaca but I was severely upset. The desserts were also very average. We ordered the chocolate cheesecake and key lime tart. This place felt a little overpriced

Came in for my friends birthday. Good food and nice restaurant but server wasn’t around and when It came to splitting up the check she said she couldn’t do it and we should have told her at the beginning. She then told us she could split it five ways, but then handed us five of the exact same bill and was rude when I just asked For an explanation.

L C

Liked the atmosphere but wasnt my fav. They are trying to be "high class" We definitely under dress. The Waitresses definitely didn't want us there and treated us diffrently. I get it single mom with kids fresh from the commons but even with short stick drawing when we walked in. It was ok. Kids were happy. Excited about lobster it ended up.. bland and cold. Kids didnt eat it and The portions were smaller than I expected and waitress didnt refill our drinks an was short with us. For 3 dinners one appetizer with cokes as drinks with 3 desserts it was $155+ tip. So $205. Ps bathroom weridest location ever.. downstairs around 3 corners an past the boiler room lol we wont be returning much rather go else where to spend 200 an get higher quality an better food. Wish them well.