Jessica Loughran

The original Mr Mikes pizza Italian kitchen located on the corner of McKinley street and Main Street was phenomenal. The atmosphere was very comfortable and the service was excellent. The pizza was cooked to perfection I had a pizza with mushrooms and spinach made with a thin crust slightly crispy and the Caesar salad was great! I always feel very welcome by the owners David and Ben Nicola. I highly recommend this restaurant!!

Will L

Awesome food, so fresh and made from scratch. Service was very attentive and took their role very serious. Our server worked hard to stay on top of her assigned guests.

Dave King

Amazing staff and owners. We sprung a 60+ person party on them (Hockey Family) and in less than 24hrs they were staffed and ready to accommodate us. Not to mention the pizza is spot on. We will be back tomorrow for some pizza for just the immediate family...lol Thanks for the hospitality. Rochester ACES - 10u Annechino

Robert Gardner

Mr Mike’s is the best! We have been dining there for 15 -20 years. Everything is delicious but we especially love their white veggie pizza. David is always friendly as are all his wait staff. We look forward to dining there often.

Amber Mae

Such an amazing place to relax and eat! We got a medium pizza and I must say IT WAS BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA EVER! The crust just melts in your mouth!!! Ellla the sweetest waitress!!!!

Richard

100% the best pizza by far. Waitress was outstanding. Super friendly staff all the way around. Very easy to get to and well marked. Free street and free lot for parking. Not all pizza is the same, and once you come here, you will find out why. Wanted to try other dishes here, but pizza was on tab for us. Thank you so much for a great experience. When we visit again, we know where to go. Friends will here from us as well. 👍👍👍👍👍 Thank you.

David Caruso

This was a take-out order - salads (with chicken) and large pizza with multiple toppings. Ready on-time, nice service at counter, and very reasonable prices. Grilled chicken on the salad was cooked just right - many places over-do it. And the pizza was excellent, great crust. We could not finish it and left a few slices for breakfast the next day. Will return when we come back to Lake Placid. (Note: it is a large place and parking was very easy as it is just outside the busier downtown section.)

Joshua Massaro

STILL THE BEST PIZZA 🍕 ON THE PLANET! Full disclosure: I've been coming here since 1985 when I was just a kid, so I may be a bit biased. ☺️ That said, Mr. Mike's has always been THE go-to pizza place for birthdays, lunches, dinners, reunions, graduations, and any other celebration out there. Recently, I had a friends and family reunion there and David, Sarina, and Ella all welcomed us like family. It was a wonderful time! My personal favorite is the white pizza. It is simply the best I've ever had. It doesn't even need toppings. In the summer of '94, my buddy and I ordered one, with extra garlic, EVERY day for lunch while working our little job on Main Street. The best! No regrets! And even though I live on the other side of the country now, Mr. Mike's is still the first place I go whenever I'm back in Lake Placid. So, next time you come to town, stop by Mr. Mike's and say hi to David. You'll be glad you did.

Rob Zuber

Very nice place to get pizza! The dinning room is very spacious. The staff is very nice. The pizza is delicious. Loaded up with a generous amount of toppings. The garlic bread and fried mozzarella is also very good!

+7

Robert Shaw

Fantastic! Haven't been to Lake Placid in about 15 years. Ordered a large pepperoni and the pizza is wonderful. It's perfectly cooked, flavorful and the pepperoni under the cheese ensures that it stays in place when you take a bite. The owner is super friendly and checked me out himself. The place is huge, with dozens of tables. I hope Mr. Mike's is full to the brim with customers during the 'on' season, as he deserves it for the wonderful food and service.

Norah DeWolfe

Fantastically friendly staff and satisfying pizza. We ordered takeout and the pizza was ready in 50 minutes. When we arrived to pick it up, the staff opened the boxes to double check that they were true to the order. The pizza itself was perfectly balanced with sauce, cheese, and a fully crust. It could have used a few more toppings but at that point I would just be searching for criticism. Overall, I would highly recommend visiting Mr Mike’s. Thanks for the great experience!

Kristen Coakley

The best pizza and Mediterranean salads! I have been visiting the Lake Placid area for 35 years and have been going to Mr. Mike's every time I'm in the area. Their pizza is to die for-perfect sauce, cheese, crust and toppings ratio. The crust is perfect - thin but not paper thin and not overly thick so that it overwhelms the rest of the pizza. Now the Mediterranean salads - the dressing is the best salad dressing I've ever had. It is SO good that I will get random cravings for it which is unfortunate as I have not been able to replicate it with store bought or homemade dressing. The romaine is also fresh and the feta, tomatoes and kalamata olives generous. When I was a kid I remember being allowed by the chef to come back and sample the pizza dough - I've held that memory my whole life and it speaks to the wonderful environment and friendliness of the staff. We spoke to Dave on our latest visit who notice my platelet donor hat and shared his donation experience with me. Thank you Dave. If you are craving a pizza night while in Lake Placid, this is must visit.

Laura Sokolowski

Excellent place to stop after hiking in the Adirondacks. We were impressed by the Cesar salade anchovy dressing, very tasty and refreshing. The pizza itself was a real treat. The crust was just the right balance of crispy and chewy, and the toppings were generously applied. The service was rapid and the food was pretty cheap. It was exactly what we needed to refuel and satisfy our hunger.

Lock Nonuser (schizophanes)

Service was fast and friendly. Really nice crew. Spacious seating (it wasn’t busy but I liked the layout) and you can choose between tables or booths. Food was great and fresh. For pizza not made in Brooklyn, it was really good. I’d come here often if I lived in the area.

Desiree Whitney

UPDATE: In September 2025 I got a pie. It was terrible compared to 30 years ago. Also 20 years ago you did sell slices. 30 years ago you were owned by Italians. I literally had friends from Bloomingdale that worked there. Your response proves how downhill this location has gone. Should be ashamed of yourselves. It wasnt as good as I remember it :( When we lived here in the 90s this was the pizza joint to go to. My dad would splurge and it was great. Everytime I visit I stop in for a few slices or a whole pie if I’m sharing at wherever I’m staying. Even in 2020 when my grandma died it still tasted great. But something has changed. We loved going here because actual Italian immigrants owned the shop.

Amanda Gunning

Tried to order to-go here. They told us 20 minutes. I got there at 30 minutes and then it was an additional 25minutes. They had a party going on but the dining room was empty. I saw three pizzas go by to tables, even though they knew I was waiting. The pizza itself was mid. Crust was really doughy n sauce was very bland. While I was waiting forever for the pizza someone came up complaining the glasses weren’t clean at the table. I complained politely twice and then a little more obnoxiously once, to no avail. I do not recommend.