Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

Excellent 19" pizza. Love that you guys have feta as a topping!

The epitome of New York style pizza. Hot, melted, good. Try the buffalo chicken pizza.

Fresh, hot, delicious pizza... Love the variety of wing sauces available!!

Guy who works during the best customer service I’ve seen since I was a kid

Food is always perfect! Highly recommend!

To expensive for me. For the same pizza I'll go to dominos next time.

Are favorite place, amazing owners.

100% improvement since new management took over.

Great pizza and food. Service A+

Good prices quality work and very nice professional staff.

Everything was amazing. Huge variety and great service.

Great daily specials.

Super friendly and receptive staff, manager especially. Gave us a free pie rather than seeing it go to waste due to an incorrect order… food was great too!

The delivery is awesome, always fast! Food is always great and what we ordered! Thank you Macedon Salvatore’s!

Typical salvatore's. Super nice guy working there. One of the only places that offer Pizza bowls. So in that regard, Best Pizza bowl bar none. 10/10 would recommend.

Hands down best pizza in Macedon. Thank you for serving the community with excellence. We love yall. #smichbros

5 Star. 2 Thumbs Up. Great Service, Great atmosphere. Great workers. First class establishment. Great Food. The owner is a class act. I Rēccomend it to all. Keep up the good work Salvatore’s Pizzeria

Subs were excellent, pre ordered and nearly picked up on arrival considering it was busy lunch time!

Stopped here with the family. Good pizza, pasta and wings. Owner was super friendly.

Great taste great customer service

I absolutely enjoy coming here. Great food, great service, clean atmosphere, very welcoming. These guys are absolutely the best!

Salvatore’s on Main Street in Macedon is open again! From the pizza and wings, to the subs, and the fish fry (available daily), the food is delicious and convenient. Eat in or take out, it’s a welcome addition to downtown Macedon!

always good food here and great service love their "no dough"s

Pizza was amazing and the gentleman who took our order was friendly, helpful and went above & beyond. Thank you!!

Had a cheese steak with provolone, mushrooms, peppers, onions and Cajun seasoning and it was good. Everything was grilled and assembled well even though it was off peak hours.

Food was excellent, owner was on site and very professional. Vast improvement over prior ownership

I normally get take out. The girl answering the phones is a sweetheart and the service/food seems better lately as well.

This place serves fantastic, hot food, quickly at a very reasonable cost with ample portions! Can't ask for more!

Decided to stop in for a slice of pizza. The pizza was great as was the service and the restaurant was nice and clean.

The quality of the food is always very good. The help at the Manson location was excellent. Can't complain about a thing!

Great sub! Amazing bread and shaved steak is awesome! I ordered delivery 30 min before closing which I understand is a pain in the butt. Delivery driver was very friendly and didn't act annoyed at all. Everytime I have gone in here at his been a pleasure! Very great people to do business with!

I don't often recommend a pizza place, but this small town place is outstanding. Generous portions, rotating $10 deals, quiet, clean establishment, and quite a variety. It is pizza from THIS area and Culture which I find is about halfway between thin crust of NYC and deep dish of Chicago. I grew up on this style pizza, and it's well cooked without being overdone, overoiley, or over cakey. They have the knack! Good teas, too! Lots of parking in the back. Great example of small business. Nice people, too.

I will never go anywhere else for pizza. Amazing owner who is beyond kind and cares for his customers! Great staff as well! I have never felt more welcomed!! My family loves the pizza! Thanks for caring about your customers and staff!! I will always order from here!! Thanks for your amazing service

I wish I remembered his name but the customer service here is amazing! and wonderful. They go above and beyond at this location. The man I talked to was so sweet. I called in for delivery for my father's bday and I live out of state and they offered to put a candle on his carrot cake for me. So sweet. I just had to leave an amazing review because he was so thoughtful and my dad really appreciated the candle on his carrot cake (Which he loved by the way) My thanks go out to him. Great food and great service!

Their pizza was superb. We did delivery which was quick.

We have become quite the regulars at our local Macedon Salvatore’s. The food is always fresh, fast, and ready. The new team that took over about a year ago is exceptional and truly appreciate their customers. Thank you for the wonderful service every time!

The Salvatore's-Macedon team was an absolute life-saver when our studio crew was filming in nearby Palmyra. The shoot was running late and a second meal was needed in a hurry for a crew of 30. We placed a large order of sub sandwiches in hopes they could accommodate. -- Not only did the restaurant crank out the order in 30 minutes, they threw in some desserts for the crew along with plates, plastic ware and everything else we needed to make the best out of a very long, tiring day...and they did it with a smile! They went above and beyond for us, and we could not be more grateful!

Great place to eat. Being from out of town for work, this place really stood out. Been eating there almost every day and not tired of the place. Food is good, nice portions, and their subs are huge. The staff is awesome, very professional. Definitely a great little spot in upstate NY.👍🏾

Ordered from Salvatores macedon last night for the 1st time in quite awhile and let me tell you the food was awesome. Wings were cooked perfectly and my calzone was a work of art. Thanks again

Adrianna who worked Thursday night was more than exceptional! We called last minute after our band practice and She was polite, asked the right questions(which NO ONE does at this location) and had a pleasant smile the entire time! She was 100% on top of things, coming from a manager myself at a food joint; it's rare to find workers like her! Keep up that positive attitude girl! Hope you see this!!! I'd hire you in a heart beat! Also she was able to multi task, clean while closing all while serving me with the utmost respect!!!

Glad there is pizza in Macedon. Stopped by for lunch on a Tuesday. There was a backlog of orders, but the people behind the counter got it done swiftly. Reasonable wait time. In and out in under 20 minutes. I ended up with a slice, wings, and a brew. Took it to a local park for better scenery. Macedon is great, but terrible infrastructure in the canal town by Lock 30. Salvatore's is located in a very desolate and empty part of town. Location not great, but the inside is clean and well maintained.

I came for lunch a couple of guys and tried the Eggplant Dish, waited a few minutes but it was worth the wait; delicious! Amazing food not just the delish pizza moreover, the guys that run the place are on top of their game and are super friendly, definitely recommended 👍🏾

So glad to see Salvatore's Pizza back in Macedon. Definitely the best Macedon Pizzeria! Love their steak subs and pizza with old fashioned pepperoni! Went there for lunch and dinner yesterday... yum!

Jacob Marrapese

Glad there is pizza in Macedon. Stopped by for lunch on a Tuesday. There was a backlog of orders, but the people behind the counter got it done swiftly. Reasonable wait time. In and out in under 20 minutes. I ended up with a slice, wings, and a brew. Took it to a local park for better scenery. Macedon is great, but terrible infrastructure in the canal town by Lock 30. Salvatore's is located in a very desolate and empty part of town. Location not great, but the inside is clean and well maintained.

Nelson Benitez

I came for lunch a couple of guys and tried the Eggplant Dish, waited a few minutes but it was worth the wait; delicious! Amazing food not just the delish pizza moreover, the guys that run the place are on top of their game and are super friendly, definitely recommended 👍🏾

Michael & Cindy Kaehler

So glad to see Salvatore's Pizza back in Macedon. Definitely the best Macedon Pizzeria! Love their steak subs and pizza with old fashioned pepperoni! Went there for lunch and dinner yesterday... yum!

I work down the street from here i come tleast 3 times a week and every time I show up it’s W customer service good food and smiles definitely one of the Salvatore’s you should come too if your in the area im here making the review waiting on a steak sub😂

Amazing service at Salvatore's! They stayed 30 minutes past closing to get an order ready for my son's birthday. Brendan was super friendly and went above and beyond. Truly appreciate the extra effort. Highly recommend 😊

Ordered a sheet and 2 dozen wings for a party last weekend. Every thing went very smooth, wings were perfectly crisp and saucey. Pizza was warm and had proper amount of toppings and tasted very good. Have earned repeated visits from our family.

The fish dinner here did not disappoint. I highly recommend anyone to try it for yourself. Don't forget to get a pizza or anything else on the menu, the food is always good. The other thing I want to mention is how nice the employees are and how they keep the store so clean, I was impressed. The dining area is comfortable with a TV and nice size booths.

I’ve had the pleasure of interacting with Jasmin multiple times, and every single experience has been excellent. His positive attitude, patience, and attention to detail make all the difference. The food has never disappointed!!

For the past year or so this has been our go to pizza shop, the staff is incredibly friendly and personable. The quality and consistency of the food is unmatched. Forever are go to spot, always welcoming!

I went to the Salvatore‘s in Macedon to pick up a slice on the way home as I do on a regular basis. And today they had one piece of the pizza I wanted, and he told me a new one is coming out of the oven. I told him that’s OK I’ll take the old piece because I’m not going eat it until later. When I took my money out, he said that’s OK and gave it to me for free!! It’s not the seven dollars, it was just somebody doing a nice thing. So I will go back again not for a free slice of pizza. To get a slice of pizza and return the favor! I have to say they are always very polite and nice to me when I go in there!

My experience at Salvatore’s is a blessing the whole crew is great especially Brendon and Sarah behind counter Jaz and the big Sanel but to some it all up they are great and wonderful people they always have a smile on their faces and treat you with respect

Salvatore’s in Macedon is a great spot offering more than just pizza. They have a solid selection—subs, salads, calzones, and a different daily special to keep things interesting. The place is consistently clean and the staff is always professional. Definitely worth a visit!

This restaurant has improved SO much in the past year or so ... the quality is consistently at a high standard, they work hard to be sure my order is exactly as I want it to be (and if for some reason it isn't, they ALWAYS quickly fix whatever the issue was). They aren't money hungry ... a number of times, they've suggested different options that would save me money and be equally more enjoyable. They are polite and professional.

They have the best pizza. I eat there most every day. I look forward to Wednesday for the calzone. The fish fry is great too.

Highly competent owners filled with enduring positive energy. Peak Salvatore’s quality and consistency. Staff is equally amazing.

THANK YOU FROM THE BOTTOM OF MY HEART I called in an order from work, knowing they would be closed by the time I got out but I had a hankering for a good slice ! My mother went to pick up the order for me and turned out that her vehicle died while she was in the store. The owner was very sweet, left the kitchen and came to help her, he even offered to drive her home if the jump didn’t fix the issue, thankfully it did. But to even go out of his way to offer meant so much to the both of us! Great food, from great people 🖤

We recently moved to Macedon and have found ourselves frequenting this Salvatore’s often. The food quality and customer experience truly are authentic and reminiscent of that small town feel. The owner Sanel is the most kind, and genuine person who truly cares about your experience. We plan to continue doing business with this location, thank you for handling all of our pizza cravings!!

After new ownership this year, this pizza shop has been completely amazing. They really turned things around and it's my go-to anytime I want some pizza. Great daily deals and coupons available. If you are entertaining a bunch of people the sheet pizza is a must!

The owner was great the staff was incredibly quick and gave me the friendliest service the gave a great atmosphere great place to get a good bite to eat

Crystal L

Amazing service at Salvatore's! They stayed 30 minutes past closing to get an order ready for my son's birthday. Brendan was super friendly and went above and beyond. Truly appreciate the extra effort. Highly recommend 😊

Thadeus dedee

The owner was great the staff was incredibly quick and gave me the friendliest service the gave a great atmosphere great place to get a good bite to eat

Morgan Halsey

I’ve had the pleasure of interacting with Jasmin multiple times, and every single experience has been excellent. His positive attitude, patience, and attention to detail make all the difference. The food has never disappointed!!

Robert Paro

Ordered a sheet and 2 dozen wings for a party last weekend. Every thing went very smooth, wings were perfectly crisp and saucey. Pizza was warm and had proper amount of toppings and tasted very good. Have earned repeated visits from our family.

Brandon Peters

My experience at Salvatore’s is a blessing the whole crew is great especially Brendon and Sarah behind counter Jaz and the big Sanel but to some it all up they are great and wonderful people they always have a smile on their faces and treat you with respect

Jeff Muncey

They have the best pizza. I eat there most every day. I look forward to Wednesday for the calzone. The fish fry is great too.

Brendan Mcintee

Highly competent owners filled with enduring positive energy. Peak Salvatore’s quality and consistency. Staff is equally amazing.

Maddie C

For the past year or so this has been our go to pizza shop, the staff is incredibly friendly and personable. The quality and consistency of the food is unmatched. Forever are go to spot, always welcoming!

Ben C

The fish dinner here did not disappoint. I highly recommend anyone to try it for yourself. Don't forget to get a pizza or anything else on the menu, the food is always good. The other thing I want to mention is how nice the employees are and how they keep the store so clean, I was impressed. The dining area is comfortable with a TV and nice size booths.

Kxngsquadgaming450

I work down the street from here i come tleast 3 times a week and every time I show up it’s W customer service good food and smiles definitely one of the Salvatore’s you should come too if your in the area im here making the review waiting on a steak sub😂

Mike Wiederhold

I went to the Salvatore‘s in Macedon to pick up a slice on the way home as I do on a regular basis. And today they had one piece of the pizza I wanted, and he told me a new one is coming out of the oven. I told him that’s OK I’ll take the old piece because I’m not going eat it until later. When I took my money out, he said that’s OK and gave it to me for free!! It’s not the seven dollars, it was just somebody doing a nice thing. So I will go back again not for a free slice of pizza. To get a slice of pizza and return the favor! I have to say they are always very polite and nice to me when I go in there!

Nick S

Salvatore’s in Macedon is a great spot offering more than just pizza. They have a solid selection—subs, salads, calzones, and a different daily special to keep things interesting. The place is consistently clean and the staff is always professional. Definitely worth a visit!

Valerie Aarne Grossman

This restaurant has improved SO much in the past year or so ... the quality is consistently at a high standard, they work hard to be sure my order is exactly as I want it to be (and if for some reason it isn't, they ALWAYS quickly fix whatever the issue was). They aren't money hungry ... a number of times, they've suggested different options that would save me money and be equally more enjoyable. They are polite and professional.

Alan Powell

We recently moved to Macedon and have found ourselves frequenting this Salvatore’s often. The food quality and customer experience truly are authentic and reminiscent of that small town feel. The owner Sanel is the most kind, and genuine person who truly cares about your experience. We plan to continue doing business with this location, thank you for handling all of our pizza cravings!!

Brent

After new ownership this year, this pizza shop has been completely amazing. They really turned things around and it's my go-to anytime I want some pizza. Great daily deals and coupons available. If you are entertaining a bunch of people the sheet pizza is a must!

Nicole Renee

THANK YOU FROM THE BOTTOM OF MY HEART I called in an order from work, knowing they would be closed by the time I got out but I had a hankering for a good slice ! My mother went to pick up the order for me and turned out that her vehicle died while she was in the store. The owner was very sweet, left the kitchen and came to help her, he even offered to drive her home if the jump didn’t fix the issue, thankfully it did. But to even go out of his way to offer meant so much to the both of us! Great food, from great people 🖤

Very good pizza!! Its a Must Try!!!

Excellent food, service and selection. Always seem to have trouble placing orders on-line

Decent food. Higher prices than the competition.

Was out fishing, got hungry, stopped, good service, good food, friendly people, Will go again.

Loved the mussels marinara! Great service too!

Good pizza every time. I recommend the meat pizza.

It was nice to have my birthday pizza with friends.

Salvatores pizza is about as good as it gets! Never had 1 problem. Crispy pizza great sauce and good deals! In this economy great idea for dinner.

One of the best around, just not that great.

Placed my order 40 minutes in advance. Was only a pizza and one order of wings. Was not ready when I arrived because they forgot the wings

The pizza here is more consistent than at Mark's. I like the sauce better here and some of the daily specials can't be beating anywhere, especially the Wednesday calzone special! They always have good deals and good service! I have had a few "well done" pizzas that were not replaced, so I have been going to the Newark location for a while now.

Person taking order was surly and not familiar with the pizza options. Pizza was decent.

Way overpriced for the quality. The pizza was alright but it definitely wasn't worth the money.

Service here always comes with an attitude

I ordered a eggplant parmesan sandwich. Got a dinner and paid a dollar for cheese. Top it off w very loud music not fit for any restaurant. Can't say that n word but blaring the music. Not one worker wearing a mask even. Bad bad bad.poor manager standing at counter on his phone. Not good business people at all.

Food is always great but, absolutely every time I order they never bring any of the sides I order and pay for them. Also nowhere on the menu does it state 1.95 charge for substituting white sauce for red on your pizza. I have spoken with the manager in the past and received my extra sauces only then. I'd hate to stop ordering because I really like the food but...

I ordered a fish fry and steak sandwich and by the time it finally got to me it was cold. The funny thing is the Mac salad was warm and everything else was cold. Not to mention, I was charged for steak sauce that I never received and a $5 delivery charge after waiting an hour and a half for delivery. Called to see if it was on the way and was told, " we only have 1 driver it should be there soon". Ok I get that alot of places are short-handed but if you can't provide the service due to that, then don't do it. Needless to say, very disappointed

Pizza was not great. Thi is an edited review after I just spoke to the shop. Paid for double mac salad and got the corporate answer that they weighed the pizza and gave me that. Sorry, no you didn't. If this is double, then I'm done. I don't care what you charge, but give me what I pay for

Stephen Ross

Pizza was not great. Thi is an edited review after I just spoke to the shop. Paid for double mac salad and got the corporate answer that they weighed the pizza and gave me that. Sorry, no you didn't. If this is double, then I'm done. I don't care what you charge, but give me what I pay for

Order was incorrect,pizza had incorrect toppings, completely wrong wing order,$50.00 order in my opinion was not worth that at all

They messed up my order. Not going back

Never again.. Ordered online. sheet pizza 40 wings ($112). Call to confirm they got it and everything was right.. Guy says 25-35 mins... Sweet. I leave Palmyra 20 mins later and head there. Walk in pizza is coming out of oven. Perfect.. guy checks on my wings. Comes back. Oh sorry sir the girl doing wings can't read and only dropped 20 instead of 40. So we sit there for almost 30mins. Pizza is cold 1st order of wings are getting cold. Guy comes up with other wings and says sir you're all set. I laughed and said I want the manager... He states he was. So his solution to the problem is give me $20 back on my card. Whatever I'll take it. The girl who can't read the ticket is standing there giving me dirty looks... Like I did something wrong. No no girly you did. Not me. So we get back home to my sons 2nd birthday party and we enjoyed cold pizza and wings. Never again macedon salvators. It'll close soon anyways they never last long there.

Don't order the taco pizza. For some reason it doesn't come with taco meat just chunks of burger for $30. I literally went to Taco Bell for something tasting like a taco

If I could do less than one star, I would. It shouldn’t take 80 minutes for a luke warm pizza, especially when you’re quoted for 40-60 minutes. This isn’t the first time we’ve been disappointed with Salvatore’s in Macedon, but it’s our last.

We ordered a pan pizza and 10 boneless wings for them to goto a wrong address and then leave and not say a thing so we call them and they were so rude about it and when we told them the right address they couldn’t even find our trailer which is sad because she barely looked for it. Everything was cold and we got sick from the food. Why hire people that don’t care!!

An hour and a half late,g a call that they're in the wrong town, then had to reorder $70 worth of food for our family gathering. Last time trusting this place. Good food but it's not worth the inconsistency

Called and ordered food and adter an hour went by called back and the manager said there was nothing they could do cuz they only had one driver. Not once did she apologize. She kept saying it would be here soon and the girl had taken 4 deliveries with her when she left at 755 and still at 835 still had no food. This is ridiculous and i will not order drom here again

It took the food 2 hours to get 5 miles, the pizza was burnt, and they forgot part of the order. They were short staffed and continued to make excuses. No refund, just credit. I will not be ordering from them again. If I could give less than 1 star I would.

$30 for a slice and a sub the sub is watered down package meat and $6 for delivery charge lol some companies soaked that covid up never go there again and food sucked

I do Salvatore often this was the wort meal yet frys were cold got wrong order fish over cooked will not be ordering anymore sorry macedon need a good pizza place

Pizza and wings might be ok but it's wayyyyy to expensive. Ordered a large pizza with 4 toppings and it's over 40.00! 5.95 delivery charge? And we still tip out the driver? Where does that go? I canceled my order tonight cuz I couldn't believe the price. The last time we ordered the food was mediocre, nothing to say anything good about. I might be old fashioned in many ways but not getting ripped off! I haven't ordered from other pizza places (marks pizza) because of their prices and low quality, guess I have to add you too. Come back to the family and your community. You've become too outrageous for the most of us!

I order from here all the time 1st time I've really had a problem. I ALWAYS ask for lite sauce on the pizza and this was the 1st time I've ordered and it wasn't when I call to see if they would just take notice to fix the response I got back was oh we put half the amount of sauce on there (which I will be posting a picture on the pizza to show the amount of sauce.). I worked in the food industry for 8 years all I wanted was a apology or something of that nature but instead they just fought me on it and I as the customer came up with a resolution which was 10 dollars off my next order mind you this is a sheet pizza which isn't cheep.